A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Eliyahu Ben-Haim

Torah Lecture

The Shiniver Rav & the Rich Lady

Lectured by Rabbi Eliyahu Ben-Haim

Published
June 29, 2025
Duration
6:42
Lecture code
REB-HS-48

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Welcome to the Daily Holy Story.

In the town of Shinova, there was a very wealthy Jewish lady who employed a girl from a poor family as her servant. The girl was an orphan. The lady paid her a little money and let her sleep in her house, with room and board. One day, the rich lady and the poor orphan girl went for a walk outside. They passed a little stand selling lottery tickets. The lottery was for $5 million, a great amount of money, unusual in those days. Even though she was rich, the lady decided to invest a little money for a chance to win $5 million, and she bought a ticket. When the orphan girl saw that the lottery was for $5 million, she also bought a ticket with the little money she had. They took their tickets home and gave the person selling them at the stand their address.

Sure enough, about a week or two later, the lottery messenger knocked on the door at 7 o’clock in the morning. The rich lady opened the door, and the man told her, “You won the lottery—not the big lottery, not the $5 million lottery, but the lottery for $50,000.” The rich lady got very excited. She had won $50,000. But unfortunately, it wasn’t her ticket; it was the poor orphan girl’s ticket. The poor orphan girl was still sleeping, so the rich lady went into the poor orphan girl’s bedroom. Her Yetzer Hara (evil inclination) started working on her and said, “You know, lady, you’re the rich lady; you’re the master, she’s your servant, and whatever the servant gets belongs to the master.” So the rich lady decided to switch the tickets. She went into the poor orphan girl’s drawer, took her ticket, put her own ticket in the drawer, and collected the $50,000.

A few hours later, the lottery guy came back and told the rich lady, “You won the big lottery with the second ticket, for $5 million.” The rich lady almost fainted. What was she going to do now? The poor orphan girl was awake, and the ticket the rich lady had switched was in the girl’s drawer. That was the $5 million ticket. That was her original ticket. The rich lady went into the bedroom and told the girl, “You won $5 million.” The poor orphan girl was so excited. Now she could buy her own house, find a husband, and get married. But the rich woman was beside herself. What was she going to do now? Was she going to admit to the poor orphan girl that she had switched the tickets? She started thinking to herself, then went to the poor orphan girl, stuttering as she told her, “You know, sometimes people don’t do the right things.” She started confessing that she had switched the tickets. “What’s really correct is: what’s mine is mine, and what’s yours is yours. Your ticket was the one that really won the $50,000, and my ticket was the one that won $5 million. So give me the $5 million, I’ll give you the $50,000, and we’ll call it even.”

The poor orphan girl looked at the rich lady, her master, and told her, “No way, Jose. You decided to take my ticket. You took the $50,000 and put your ticket in my drawer. The $5 million belongs to me.” Well, let’s go to the Rebbe (rabbi). At the time, the Shiniver Rav was the head of the town in Shinova. They went to the Rebbe and told him the whole story. The Rebbe said, “I have to think. Come back to me in a couple of days.” Sure enough, after two days, the rich lady and the poor orphan girl went back to the Shiniver Rav. He told them, “The $5 million and the $50,000 both belong to the poor orphan girl.” They were both shocked. “Why is that?” they asked the Rebbe.

He said to them, “Very simple. On the day the lottery was drawn, HaKadosh Baruch Hu (the Holy One, blessed be He) decided that the mazal (fortune) of the poor orphan girl was high and that she was going to be the winner of the lottery. She won the $50,000, but the rich lady decided she was going to take it. So when the second drawing came for the $5 million, and Hashem decided that the mazal of the poor orphan girl was high that day, the second ticket also won because of the poor orphan girl’s mazal. However, if the rich lady hadn’t switched the ticket and the poor orphan girl had gotten the $50,000, then the second ticket would not have won the $5 million. It only won because of the poor girl’s mazal.”

That was the psak (ruling) of the Shiniver Rav. The mazal of the poor girl in Shamayim (Heaven) was high. Therefore, she gets the $5 million and the $50,000. This teaches us that when a person does the right thing, he can even be sleeping and become wealthy. If a person does the wrong thing, he can end up with nothing.

Thank you for listening and have a lovely, lovely day.