Good morning, Rabotai (gentlemen). Continuing with the Beracha (blessing), we say, “Hashem chose us from all the nations, v'natan lanu et Torato, Hashem gave us His Torah.” Baruch ata Hashem. Hashem, You're the source of all blessing. Noten haTorah, the One who gives the Torah.
I want to highlight the context or tense in which the words are said: Hashem v'natan lanu, v'natan lanu, versus Noten haTorah. In the middle of the Beracha, we say, Hashem gave us the Torah. In the closing of the Beracha, we say, Hashem Noten haTorah; He's the giver of Torah. But it's also said in a way, in a present/future tense: Noten haTorah. Noten haTorah. Noten haTorah. Noten, someone to be a noten, is a giver. But He's Noten haTorah; He's giving the Torah. Natan lanu means He gave the Torah. The difference between those two things is tremendous. Does Hashem continue to give? Does Hashem continue to create?
Our rabbis say this with regard to Maaseh Bereshit, with regard to the creation of the world: every single day, Hashem is renewing creation. In fact, not only every single day, but every single moment, Hashem is renewing. What does that mean? Effectively, it means that at any moment in which Hashem decided not to continue powering the world, the world would cease to exist. We say, Hashem is renewing with His goodness every day, constantly, constantly, Maaseh Bereshit, the action or the creation of the world. So, not just 5,700 and whatever years ago, but right now, today, Hashem in this moment is renewing Maaseh Bereshit. He's renewing trees, He's renewing the life of animals, and everything that's happening is being constantly powered by Hashem.
Similarly, we could use that to explain this concept of the giving of Torah. One could say, Hashem gave the Torah in the year 2000, 448; Hashem gave the Torah, and then it was given to us one time at Har Sinai, and then from there it's all just whatever we can make of it. But the Beracha is Noten haTorah: Hashem is the giver; He's giving it now. That means right now, this moment, a person is receiving the Torah. I think the difference between those two perspectives is how fresh a person feels these experiences are and how that powers his relationship.
Let me explain what I'm saying. Do I feel like this was a once-in-a-lifetime event that happened? Maybe I don't even feel like it was in my lifetime: Hashem gave the Torah at Har Sinai and said the Ten Commandments; Hashem gave the Torah to Moshe. Is that a one-time event? And then today, I'm just connecting to that old event? Or is there an actual, consistent re-giving of the Torah that Hashem does, and I'm connecting to that? Today, Hashem is giving me the Torah, and He's commanding me, and He's giving me this mission of living a life of the Torah. So that makes a big difference, right?
Let's give another example for a minute, just to give clarity. Imagine a person was in a terrible financial situation, and someone came in and took care of her, right? At that moment, do you feel full of gratitude? What happens as a person goes down the path away from that event? They become desensitized to what happened, and they feel their appreciation less and less and less. They feel the obligation to show gratitude less and less and less.
Keeping it fresh is very important, right? Keeping this concept fresh, with Hashem giving us the Torah, with Hashem saying, “I'm charging you with the mission of living a life the way I know you need to live, which is the lifestyle of Torah,” is something that Hashem is doing today. And asking myself that question—if I were to experience Maamad Har Sinai today, what would I be doing differently?—isn't something I necessarily live with personally, but it's a question that would make me think a little bit. If I had just come out of Har Sinai's giving of the Torah, what would I do? And you say, “Well, you didn't just come out of Har Sinai; it was a long time ago.” But now you did: Noten haTorah, Hashem is giving the Torah today. It's consistently being given. So what do I do with that?
It's a funny kind of expression they say with regard to rabbis and speeches. A very good rabbi can hold his crowd while he's speaking. If he's really excellent and speaking in shul on Shabbat morning, in the synagogue, he can hold his people until Musaf (additional prayer) starts. If he's excellent and he blew everybody away, he can hold them through the Chazarat (cantor's repetition), until Kaveh, almost to the end of prayers. Once the people hit the door to go out to Kiddush (sanctification over wine), you've lost everybody, right? They're not really carrying it out with them.
That freshness of the inspiration requires work. It's not like, “Oh, you got inspired,” and then, even if you had Har Sinai happen a minute ago, we would still start to lose that sensitivity every moment. And it's our obligation or job to figure out ways to creatively make it fresh, so that when we feel that freshness, we feel that drive, that obligation and that commitment to go ahead and do and live life the way Hashem wants us to live it today.