A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi

Torah Lecture

Teffilah - Shelo Asani Isha (She’asah Kirtzono) 44 - Accepting the Role Hashem Designed for You

Lectured by Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi

Published
October 28, 2025
Duration
10:23
Lecture code
REF-PRAY-44

The Beracha of Shelo Asani Isha

  • Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi discusses the beracha of Shelo Asani Isha (“who did not make me a woman”) and the beracha women say, Baruch She'asani Kirtzono (“Blessed is He who made me according to His will”). He notes the apparent contrast: men thank Hashem for not making them women, while women thank Hashem for making them as He chose, without saying the full usual beracha beginning “Baruch Atah Hashem.”
  • This wording can give the impression that Judaism views women as inferior, so Rabbi Farhi asks how to understand it in a healthy, grounded way.
  • He shares an explanation he heard: men and women have different roles, aligned with different spiritual makeups. In general, he says, women are more naturally connected to Hashem and more readily absorb spiritual teaching.
  • Men, by contrast, are given more mitzvot. Rabbi Farhi explains that this is because men are less naturally likely to keep Hashem in mind; without structure, they can become absorbed in daily life. The mitzvot provide a detailed schedule and recurring opportunities to connect with Hashem, while women’s spiritual plan is more “freestyle.”
  • On this account, men can be grateful for the opportunities their challenges provide: because they need more help maintaining connection, they have more chances to build it. The beracha can also suggest that a woman’s spiritual makeup reflects a way of being connected to Hashem that is especially aligned with His will, while men must work harder toward that connection.

Accepting One’s Role and Circumstances

  • Rabbi Farhi says the broader lesson is that everyone needs to accept their role and position in life. This does not mean remaining stuck in misery or giving up on improving one’s circumstances.
  • A person should work hard, but matters such as income, power, influence, and status ultimately depend on what Hashem has decided to give. Women may struggle with having different opportunities from men; men may struggle when colleagues have greater wealth, status, or influence. Each person has their own challenge of acceptance.
  • Acceptance does not mean abandoning effort and leaving everything to Hashem. A person must put in Hishtadlut (effort), using the tools available to grow and improve. At the same time, even after making that effort, one may need to accept the place and results one has today, while remaining open to what Hashem wants for one’s life.
  • Rabbi Farhi presents “Hashem, You made me a man” as a focus for recognizing that one’s role brings both challenges and advantages. Seeing Hashem as the one who directs and places each person can bring relief: like a choir member who wonders why he is not performing the solo, he can accept that the director knows where each person belongs.

The Role One Was Given

  • Rabbi Farhi recounts walking in a mall with his children, when one asked why a man was wearing a skirt and a girl was wearing shorts. He says his children were accustomed to women covering their knees and wearing skirts or dresses.
  • He told them that, as he described it, non-Jews may believe that someone born a girl can decide to change and be a man; he said this is not in keeping with the Torah and that the Torah view is that a person is meant to be as created. He presented this as a basic example of accepting one’s given identity.
  • He extends the same principle to other circumstances: a person was born to particular parents and into a particular financial situation, rather than a different one. One should do the best one can with the tools Hashem gave, while recognizing that the results one has at the end of the day are what Hashem wants for that person today.
  • Rabbi Farhi says that accepting this can bring freedom from anxiety and pressure about where one ought to be, what one ought to be doing, and what one ought to have achieved by a certain point in life.