A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi

Torah Lecture

Teffilah - Tatzileinu Me’chaver Ra 54– When the Wrong Friend Holds You Back

Lectured by Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi

Published
November 26, 2025
Duration
11:56
Lecture code
REF-PRAY-54

Tatzileinu Me’chaver Ra: The Risks of a Bad Friend

  • While learning Birkot HaShachar (morning blessings) and Tefillah (prayer), Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi focuses on the request that Hashem save us from various dangers, including a bad friend.
  • A Chaver Ra (bad friend) differs from an Adam Ra (bad person): because someone is a friend, it may be hard to recognize that the relationship is harmful. A close friend has access to personal information, and people may later find themselves in serious or even legal conflicts with someone they once trusted.
  • In a close relationship, people often share information without considering what might happen if the relationship changes. For example, a man in love may tell his wife about his property and business dealings, without imagining that years later they might fight and divorce. A person may not know whether someone will remain a friend in the future.
  • We therefore ask Hashem to protect us from relationships that seem friendly but may ultimately cause us harm.

Yaakov’s Solitude and the Value of Friendship

  • Yaakov leaves his parents’ home for many years and, while dealing with Lavan, has nobody to consult as Lavan repeatedly takes advantage of him.
  • A friend can be invaluable as someone to talk things through with, whether or not one follows the friend’s advice. In business, for example, a person can discuss a real-estate purchase or a deal with someone else and benefit from having another perspective.
  • The Gemara’s saying, “O Chavruta, O Mituta” (“Either a study partner or death”), expresses how essential companionship is.

Choosing a Chavruta

  • In a Yeshiva or Kolel, students often choose their Chavruta during the first Seder of the Zman, or semester. The Beit Midrash can seem like “speed dating”: students talk with one another, hear about each other’s learning ability and reliability, and try to find a suitable partner.
  • After a week or two, a pairing may prove less suitable than expected. By then, the other students may already have partners, leaving someone feeling stuck for the semester.
  • Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi recalls thinking that a bad Chavruta could make “O Chavruta or Mituta” feel literal: sometimes learning with an unsuitable partner can seem worse than death.

Choni HaMe’agel and the Need for Someone to Talk To

  • Yaakov’s isolation leads him to recognize that Hashem has not abandoned him, and to use the experience to deepen his connection with God.
  • The Gemara tells of Choni HaMe’agel, who drew a circle in the ground during a drought and declared that he would not leave it until rain came. The Gemara says that Hashem sent rain and discusses whether Choni was right to speak to Hashem in that way.
  • At the end of the story, Choni is put to sleep for about 70 years. When he awakens, people do not recognize him; they believe Choni lived 80 years and died 70 years earlier.
  • Unable to find anyone who acknowledges him or with whom he can connect, Choni says that without anyone to talk to, it would be better to be dead.

How a Friend Helps a Person Grow

  • A friend can offer feedback that reveals when one’s own understanding of a situation is inaccurate. Decisions based only on one’s personal perspective can often be mistaken; talking with someone else can provide crucial insight.
  • But a friend can also pull a person down by introducing harmful activities, places, or ideas. Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi recalls young adults asking whether they should keep spending time with a friend who uses drugs because they want to help him. He says there comes a point when one must consider the effect of the relationship on one’s own life and development.
  • Relationships can become like a ball and chain, holding a person back spiritually, in business, in success, or in developing character. The people one spends time with have a significant influence.

Relationships That Limit Growth

  • When Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi was 18 or 19 and in Israel, some Yeshiva students with girlfriends back in America struggled to grow. They spoke with their girlfriends every night, and he describes the relationship as keeping them on a leash: the girlfriend brought them back to their familiar identity and limited how far they could develop in Yeshiva.
  • During his first year in Israel, Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi was friends with one young man through the first half of the year. Rabbi Eliyahu was becoming more religious and connected to Hashem, while his friend was not breaking through in the same way.
  • During midwinter break, the friend returned to New York or Aruba, where he and his girlfriend broke up. After he came back to Israel, he began praying, learning, and connecting in a much more focused way. Rabbi Eliyahu says this taught him how relationships can anchor a person.

Choosing Friends Who Encourage Growth

  • If a person is the most religious member of his friend group, he may not be as developed as he could be because he feels he is already doing best. A person should have friends who are more developed in areas he values, whether religious connection and observance, finances, or business success.
  • Conversely, having friends who are weaker in those areas or have negative character traits may limit one’s own growth. This is not a judgment of those people; each person must assess whether a relationship is helpful to him.
  • If a friend is holding a person back, he may need to find a way to let go of the relationship. This can be especially difficult after 20–30 years of friendship, but a person may recognize that they want different things and that spending time together repeatedly brings him to a place he does not want to be.
  • Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi concludes that people sometimes face hard choices that bring great value. He asks Hashem to give them clarity to recognize a Chaver Ra and a Chaver Tov (good friend) and to make the right choices.