A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi

Torah Lecture

Teffilah - Tatzileinu Me'Dina Shel Gehinam 61 – When Judgment Is a Gift

Lectured by Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi

Published
December 30, 2025
Duration
7:38
Lecture code
REF-PRAY-61

“Tatzileinu Me’Dinah Shel Gehinnom”

  • The tefillah concludes with “Hashem shetatzilenu midinah shel Gehinnom”—asking Hashem to save us from the judgment of Gehinnom.
  • Rabbi Eliyahu Farhi explains that dinah, with a mappik hei, refers to din: the judgment of Gehinnom.
  • Rabbi Dessler writes that we will be fortunate if we merit entering Gehinnom. Rabbi Farhi asks how Gehinnom could be considered fortunate, since people often understand it through a Western idea of hell as a permanent punishment for those who did wrong.

Gehinnom as a gift of purification

  • Rabbi Farhi explains that Gehinnom is a gift from Hashem: it allows someone whose sins have created distance from Hashem to be cleansed and restored to closeness with Him.
  • He compares this to a dentist cleaning a tooth before placing a bonding or crown. The painful scraping removes plaque and dirt so the adhesive can make a proper connection.
  • Likewise, a person can accumulate spiritual “plaque” over a lifetime, limiting how close they can come to Hashem.
  • The analogy also highlights the value of regular spiritual maintenance. Fasting and other practices are not necessarily bad, but Rabbi Farhi says they do not replace a steady routine of doing what is right, just as special tooth-whitening practices do not replace proper dental care.
  • Hashem could have left a person with whatever spiritual condition they had at the end of life. The reward of the world to come is being connected with the Creator and experiencing the pleasure of that connection; without cleansing, a person could be unable to enjoy it.
  • Gehinnom is very painful, but it is a temporary process. Rabbi Farhi says it lasts a maximum of 12 months even for the worst rasha, while allowing that there may be an exception.
  • This is why Kaddish is said for someone for 12 months. There is a one-week pause so people will not infer from a full 12 months of Kaddish that the deceased was a rasha.
  • Gehinnom’s painful cleansing enables a person to attain connection and clarity. Rabbi Farhi compares being unable to enjoy the world to come without it to having cavities and being unable to enjoy ice cream: the cleansing is something one would not want, but, when needed, it is a gift.

Other possible outcomes

  • Rabbi Farhi also mentions other outcomes discussed by the rabbis: a soul may float between worlds without finding a place of rest, or be flung between one world and another in what he calls the “slingshot” (also referred to as “the where”).
  • A person may instead have to return to this world because they did not succeed, rather than going to Gehinnom.
  • He compares this to losing a game: after the game is over, there is no chance to play again, and the person has not won. By contrast, someone who goes to Gehinnom has, so to speak, won, but still needs cleansing before attaining the ultimate relationship with Hashem.

Judgment is ultimately for our benefit

  • Gehinnom is din and therefore painful, but Rabbi Farhi describes it as a tremendous gift that enables a person’s ultimate closeness to Hashem.
  • We pray not to experience the judgment of Gehinnom, while recognizing that all of Hashem’s ways are good: even when Hashem’s din is upon us, it is ultimately for our benefit.