A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Eytan Aviv

Torah Lecture

Shiur on Wine -Halachic difference between Mevushal and Non Mevushal - Part 2

Lectured by Rabbi Eytan Aviv

Published
October 10, 2021
Duration
8:09
Lecture code
REA-03

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

In the last shiur (lecture), we spoke about the machloket Rishonim (dispute among the early authorities): whether yayin mevushal is kasher (fit) for kiddush (sanctification over wine), or whether it is not kasher for kiddush. Today, in this shiur, we’ll see what the halacha lemaaseh (practical halacha) is. The Shulchan Aruch, in siman (section) reish ayin bet (section 272), se'if chet (subsection eight), says, “yayin mevushal kasher for kiddush” (cooked wine is valid for Kiddush), like the shita (opinion) of the Rosh. Then he says, “v'yesh omrim, she'en mekadshim alehem” (and some say that one does not make Kiddush over them). He brings “v'yesh omrim” (some say that you’re not mekadshim alehem). What is the halacha lemaaseh when the Shulchan Aruch gives the stam (anonymous ruling) and then says yesh (there are those who say)? We know the klal (principle): many poskim (halachic authorities), Yad Malachi, and many klalim say that when he has stam v'yesh, halacha k'stam (the halacha follows the anonymous ruling). And therefore, yayin (wine) that is mevushal is kasher for kiddush. That is what the Shulchan Aruch says. However, if you look in the Mishnah Berurah, he says that a person should be choshesh (be concerned) for the shita of the yesh omrim, the shita of the Rambam, that yayin mevushal is not kasher for kiddush. If a person has that option—two wines, one mevushal and one non-mevushal (uncooked)—which should he take? The Mishnah Berurah says that v'vadai (and certainly), it is better to be yotzeh (fulfill) the shita of the Rambam and take the non-mevushal wine for kiddush. The Kaf Hachayim says the same thing, and they are in the same siman: if you have two wines, or you’re going to the store and want to know which wine to buy, the non-mevushal one is better for kiddush, because you want to be yotzeh the shita of the Rambam.

Now, everything we’re talking about is mevushal, cooked wine, as we had in the time of the Gemara and in the time of the Shulchan Aruch. What does that mean, cooked wine? You take the wine, put it in a pot, put it on the fire, and cook it. As a result, the wine bubbles and its taste really changes. The Rambam says that this wine is pasul (invalid) for kiddush and pasul for nesachim (libation offerings). According to the Rambam, you should not use it for kiddush.

The question is that in our days, the process is different. The process for mevushal wine is very different from the process in the times of the Gemara and the Shulchan Aruch. What changed in our days? What they do to make yayin mevushal is pasteurization—flash pasteurization. The way it works is that the wine goes through pipes, and in the middle there’s a pipe with a coil. It gets very hot. It’s cold on one side and cold on the other side. The wine goes through the hot pipe for about 30 seconds, and right away it cools off on the other side. That is what we call today yayin mevushal. We see mevushal on the bottle; that’s what it means. It is pasteurized in that hot pipe, and it reaches a pretty high temperature—about 180, 190, even 200 degrees—and then it cools off right away. The reason they do it so quickly and cool it off right away is that they don’t want the wine to be affected by the bishul (cooking). Really, if you ask, most people cannot tell the difference between wine that is mevushal and wine that is non-mevushal.

Joe, you wanted to ask something? You’re saying, “Most people can’t tell the difference between mevushal and non-mevushal. Is there anybody out there who can tell the difference?” Okay, that is a good question. That’s a very good question, and I was wondering about that for a while. I’ll tell you a story that happened to me. One day, I went to a wine store called the Wine Cellar in Lakewood. I walked in and spoke to the owner. I always have questions about wine, different questions, so I asked him this question: “You are a big mevin (expert), a big mumcheh (expert). Tell me, do you know anybody who could tell the difference between yayin mevushal and non-mevushal today? Does the mevushal really affect the taste of the wine? Did something happen to it?” He said, “You know what? I have big people who are big professionals in wine, and we’ll do a wine tasting with them, a blind wine tasting. We’ll see the answer to your question. Come one day, and we’ll do it.”

So we actually did it a few weeks ago. For the wine tasting, we brought real professional wine tasters. In the wine business, there are different levels. It goes from 1 to 10, with 10 being the highest. That night, we had two certified wine tasters, one level 3 and one level 5. Plus, we brought other people who officially really understand wine. These guys told me they don’t drink any wine, any bottle of wine less than $100, and it has to be 10 years old, too. We got wines from the same vineyard and the same year. One was mevushal, one was non-mevushal, and we gave them to the tasters. We did this with three different wines. Everyone there was able to identify the difference between the two cups of wine. They were able to tell the difference. The real professional certified guys were even able to tell us which one was mevushal and which one was non-mevushal. So that is the metziyut (reality) we have. It’s true, most people cannot tell the difference, but the real mumchim (experts), the real professionals, are able to tell the difference.

And therefore, back to the Rambam and his shita on wine: the Rambam holds that wine mevushal is pasul. Let’s go back to understand the sevara, what’s the reason the Rambam holds that wine mevushal is pasul, and then we’ll be able to apply it to pasteurized wine. If you look in the Rambam, it is mashma (implied) there in the perek (chapter), and he says that the reason wine mevushal is pasul is that its taste changes. The Rambam is mashma that the change in the taste of the wine is what makes it wine for nesachim. If that is the case, here, with wine mevushal, even though many people don’t taste the difference, there is a difference in the taste; you’re just not a mumcheh to taste it.

Now, if we know that the taste of the wine has to remain unchanged if you want to be menasech (offer as a libation) the wine on the mizbeach (altar), this is considered a shinui (change), a ta'am (taste). Even though most people can’t taste it, there is a shinui here in the taste. And therefore, according to the Rambam, even pasteurized wine would be pasul for nesachim, and therefore pasul for kiddush.

So, again, to conclude the halacha: what we’re coming out with is that the Shulchan Aruch brings two shittot (opinions), and halacha is k'stam. If you have yayin mevushal, you could make kiddush on yayin mevushal. That’s not a problem. However, if a person has an option between mevushal and non-mevushal, it’s kedai (worthwhile) to be machmir (stringent) and take wine that is not mevushal for kiddush, in order to be yotzeh shitat haRambam, even with wine that is pasteurized today. And still, the non-mevushal, which is non-pasteurized, overrides the one that is pasteurized. Ad kan hashiur (that’s the end of the lecture) for today.