A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Ezra Zafrani

Torah Lecture

Michtav Me'eliyahu- the secret to revealing the illusion of the yetzer p 50

Lectured by Rabbi Ezra Zafrani

Published
February 25, 2023
Duration
40:02
Lecture code
REZ-289

Recognizing the Yetzer Hara

  • Rabbi Ezra Zafrani opens with the practical aim of conquering the Yetzer Hara: not to be drawn into gashmiyut and the worldly pleasures people treat as the purpose of life. Recognizing that the Yetzer Hara is trying to pull a person away from Torah and into Olam Hazeh gives a person a chance to resist it.

Achashverosh, Haman, and the reversed decree

  • After Haman’s downfall and Mordechai’s identity was made known to Achashverosh, the king honored Mordechai. Esther asked that the decrees against the Jews be overturned, and Achashverosh gave Mordechai his signet ring and permission to write a new decree in the king’s name. Since the original decree could not be revoked, the new decree had to address its effects.
  • Rabbi Ezra Zafrani presents a novel reading attributed to Ibn Ezra. The familiar explanation is that Achashverosh wanted to get rid of the Jews but did not know how, and Haman offered to do it for him. Ibn Ezra’s reading, as presented in the lecture, reverses that understanding: Achashverosh’s original intention was for the Jews to destroy the enemies of the king, while Haman wrote a decree targeting the Jews instead—acting against the king’s will.
  • On this reading, Achashverosh’s aim was not to kill all his subjects. The intended targets were those opposed to him, identified in the discussion as Haman’s henchmen and supporters. The king had reason to regard Haman as a political threat seeking power, and the decree could serve to expose his allies. The targets were not clearly named at first; the decree’s later wording would reveal who they were. A source the lecture names as the Ba’al Sevin, Barod HaGurim, is cited as saying that Haman wrote his intention clearly, whereas Achashverosh’s decree indicated that Haman’s henchmen should be destroyed.
  • Rabbi Ezra Zafrani compares this political reading to the reports surrounding a coup against Turkey’s president Erdogan: after Erdogan returned to power three days later, some said the coup had been staged so he could identify and imprison his enemies. The lecturer presents it as a similar scenario in which a ruler uses events to discover who is against him.
  • The lecture then draws a spiritual parallel. Achashverosh’s plan represents Hashem’s plan, and Haman represents the sitra achra, which continually works against it. Haman tries to destroy the Jews and draw them into the Yetzer Hara’s territory, but Hashem’s plan will prevail; Mordechai is the Yehudi on earth through whom it is carried out. The lecture says the Ibn Ezra’s chiddush is a striking interpretation, while acknowledging that the story can be learned in more than one way.
  • The king might have issued a decree himself, but the lecture emphasizes that the reversal comes through Mordechai and the Torah of Bnei Yisrael. The Jews—not an army—then act against Haman’s people. Achashverosh, from his own political perspective, could think that he had manipulated events for his own benefit: Esther disclosed that Haman threatened her people, and Mordechai’s decree served the king’s interests. He does not see Hashem’s plan as Rabbi Ezra Zafrani describes it.
  • The practical lesson is that kedushah and service lashem shamayim, including tefilot and Torah learning, can withstand decrees and opposition. Rabbi Ezra Zafrani says people mistakenly attribute power to armies and weapons, which he describes as a mirage, rather than recognizing the power of Torah.
  • He recounts a story involving Ramban, who was asked what he was doing and replied that he was learning about the korbanot. The challenge was how that learning could diminish an opposing power; the answer given is that learning Zevachim and Kodashim mevatel the gezerot. He also describes people continuing to learn and pray when their lives were at stake, saying they would remain with their rabbi even if they had to die.

The “opposite” as a way to resist the Yetzer Hara

  • Rabbi Ezra Zafrani explains that Haman’s acting against the king’s intention illustrates how the sitra achra operates: it insists on doing what it wants, not what Hashem wants. The point is not that Mordechai himself simply imitated Haman by acting oppositely; rather, Hashem turns the opposition around, and the Torah and actions of Bnei Yisrael bring about the reversal.
  • Asked how a person should deal with the Yetzer Hara, Rabbi Ezra Zafrani answers that one must not follow it away from Torah and mitzvot. When one sees oneself being drawn toward the Yetzer Hara, one should turn the other way and follow Torah.
  • He extends this into a broad rule about advice: advice that is not Torah’s emet is sheker, and he tells listeners to treat its opposite as the right direction. He applies this to advice promoted in newspapers and in the name of health, education, or other causes, and to advice from friends, neighbors, therapists, psychologists, and even people who sound religious but lack daas Torah.
  • As an example, he suggests asking an irreligious friend whether a child should go to university for a degree or to a yeshiva. If the friend insists that college is obviously best, the answer, in the lecturer’s example, indicates what to do. He similarly describes a businessman advising someone to get a degree to earn money to support Torah; the listener should thank him while taking the advice as a cue to do the opposite.
  • Rabbi Ezra Zafrani distinguishes this from practical expertise. He acknowledges Chochmah b'goyim in matters of Teva, such as gravity, electricity, physics, construction, roads, kitchens, and technology. People can build buildings and highways and achieve technological feats, but that expertise does not make them authorities on Torah or on how to live by Hashem’s will.
  • He says that people’s reliance on friends and other non-Torah authorities, rather than Hachamim, has contributed to turmoil, and calls this an olam hafuch. He refers to a mashal in which people share a code: they say “yes” but mean “no.” He also invokes the idea that the words of the rabim are hefekh ha-emet, so the truth may be found by turning their words around.
  • He warns that Torah’s assurances and the onashim written in the Torah remain in force. When a person acts wrongly, consequences may follow; he mentions a building collapsing, a house decaying, and other things going wrong. He also refers to corona while describing a world of sheker in which people believe falsehoods.

Torah before Matan Torah: the Avot and the soul

  • Rabbi Ezra Zafrani then turns to limud haTorah and introduces the difference between the Torah of the Avot and the Torah of Klal Yisrael. He asks how there could be Torah before Matan Torah, and how Yaakov learned by Shem v'Ever, and raises the question of where the earlier generations received their Torah. He says there are two different ways of growing in Torah.
  • Before Matan Torah, the soul had to purify itself in order to attain Torah; in that period, Torah was not yet the means by which the soul became purified. He refers to a Midrash and a pasuk in Tehillim in connection with the soul’s purification and its capacity to receive Torah.
  • Citing Likutei Torah of the Baal HaTanya, Rabbi Ezra Zafrani explains that Avraham and the Avot established the work of Torah before the Torah was given. Their spiritual understanding enabled them to perform mitzvot and draw down the higher lights that come through a mitzvah. Avraham’s neshamah could rise to the highest spheres in Shamayim.
  • He explains that aliyot neshamot, such as those associated with Rabbi Akiva and Ben Azzai, are not physical journeys upward. The soul mezakechet et atzmo and ascends spiritually. He says that before Hashem began speaking to Avraham, when Avraham was 75, Avraham had spent years contemplating Hashem and Kedushat Hashem and concentrating on what Hashem wanted of him.
  • Through his sevarot and hashkafot, Avraham came to understand Yichud Hashem and the Borei Olam, and that life required mitzvot and a mission beyond the seven mitzvot. Rabbi Ezra Zafrani describes Avraham’s neshamah as rising and seeing what Moshe Rabbeinu would later see in Shamayim. Unlike Moshe Rabbeinu, who had to bring the Torah down to the people, Avraham attained this Torah through his own soul.
  • The lecture describes the whole Torah as being present in the neshamah before birth, though people forget it. Rabbi Ezra Zafrani gives an example of a child prodigy in Israel, about 300 years ago, who spoke about sodot, kabbalot, and Torah. Sages came to hear him, and they prayed that he should forget what he knew; he died at a very young age. The point is that Torah is within a person and must be brought out, as Avraham did.
  • Rabbi Ezra Zafrani cites Rashi in connection with Moshe hearing from Hashem. Moshe received the halacha of action—the Torah revealed in the world of action—whereas Avraham’s attainment was of a different, higher, soul-based kind. The lecture says that a person today cannot attain the Torah of Avraham Avinu in the same way; one must begin with the Torah as it was given.
  • He explains alpayim shanah tohu as a period in which the work was to repair middot and purify the self. Avraham’s avodah was chesed: doing acts of kindness, performing mitzvot, and becoming an ish kadosh. By perfecting himself and understanding Hashem, Avraham could elevate his neshamah; this was the avodah available before the Torah, and everyone had that opportunity.
  • The order changed because derech eretz kadma laTorah. Having Torah today does not remove the need for derech eretz, which Rabbi Ezra Zafrani says will be developed further in the next piece. The Avot’s learning and ours belong to different worlds; Torah should penetrate each person’s neshamah, but the neshamah’s purification is not yet there. The lecture ends by leaving this difference—and what is needed to reach the Torah Hashem gave us—for continuation.
Words in this lecture1
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem