A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Amazing Story How Mayim Aharonim saved these soldiers

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
October 14, 2024
Duration
5:57
Lecture code
RGK-1395

Mayim Acharonim

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says Mayim Acharonim is a difficult halacha to understand. The Shas discusses Melach Sedomit, a type of salt that might get into a person’s eyes and cause blindness.
  • Tosafot says that this salt is no longer present, and that without it there is no need for Mayim Acharonim. Other reasons are also given: respect for Birkat Hamazon, zuhama (filth), and Kabbalistic considerations.
  • Rabbi Koskas notes that some people are less careful about the practice and have a basis on which to rely, but emphasizes that the Shulchan Aruch says, “Mayim Acharonim chovah” (washing after meals is obligatory). He concludes that the practice is to do Mayim Acharonim.

The soldiers’ account

  • Rabbi Koskas recounts a message from a worldwide Semichat Chaver Program chat of about 200 rabbis. A rabbi in Israel, who knew the events firsthand, said that a drone struck a dining room where people were sitting; many people died and some were badly injured.
  • Before the strike, one man asked another to do Zimun with him. The other agreed and said he was going to do Mayim Acharonim. After a brief discussion, others agreed to go do Mayim Acharonim with him.
  • They got up and left the table while doing Mayim Acharonim. The drone struck that table and place. Rabbi Koskas says the rabbi who sent the account gave him the names of the three men who got up, though he does not state their names in the lecture.

Taking inspiration from the story

  • Rabbi Koskas cautions that it is difficult to interpret stories like this and says listeners may draw their own conclusions; he presents the account as something that happened, not as a definitive explanation of why it happened.
  • He connects the story to a choice people face after Yom Kippur: at a party or at home, they may choose between bread requiring Hamotzi and bread that is mezonot.
  • He says people often choose mezonot because Hamotzi takes time and effort: getting up, washing, drying, saying the blessing, sitting down, and then reciting Birkat Hamazon, which takes a few minutes.
  • Rabbi Koskas urges a change in mindset: if people are looking to do mitzvot, they should consider the mitzvah d’oraita available in this choice. He says that nobody is obligated to choose one bread over the other, but one can still ask why one did not choose the option that offers the mitzvah.
  • He compares this with choosing a home: if a beautiful two-storey house is only a little more expensive than a less attractive flat and one can afford it, it is natural to ask why the better option was not chosen. He also compares it to choosing between two investments of equal risk, one returning 10% and the other 7%.
  • He says people do not usually evaluate mitzvot as they evaluate investments. Although no one had to choose the more involved option, he asks why not use one’s judgment and chochmah (wisdom) to choose it. He contrasts four berachot with one, calls one option the d’oraita, and says the other is a machloket.
  • He encourages listeners to learn from the story and try to take on more mitzvot during the year ahead. If the story inspires them, he says, that connection establishes a zechut (merit) for the injured soldiers.
Words in this lecture1
Shasהש"ס
Terms The whole Talmud (from the initials of the six orders).
Also written: HaShas, Ha-Shas