A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Are there fruits that aren’t available all year?

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
August 30, 2024
Duration
5:22
Lecture code
RGK-1332

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Does Shehecheyanu (Who has kept us alive) apply also to peri adamah, so vegetables, or only to peri ha'etz, only fruits? Although the Shulchan Aruch uses the language peri chadash, a new fruit, which sounds like a fruit from a tree, the great majority of Poskim (halachic authorities) say: What would be the difference? He didn't use the word yerakot (vegetables). Peri is also both. Peri adamah, you say, what is peri adamah on yerakot? But I would like to take this a little bit further and explain why I believe it's very rare for people not to say the Beracha (blessing) Shehecheyanu on vegetables.

The reason is really that the Beracha Shehecheyanu became very scarce. It's almost impossible to say the Beracha Shehecheyanu these days. Why? I would like to discuss the difference between before and today. Seasons are less respected today because of technology. Vegetables are less subject to seasonal changes than fruits from a tree. They're also easier to grow, and they're usually smaller. So today, because of technology, with certain temperatures maintained indoors and certain humidity levels set, etc., it's a perfect climate for growing any vegetable all year round. Really, there's no more mitchadesh mi-shanah le-shanah (renewed from year to year). There's no more respect for the seasons because of that. So clearly, that would be the case. That is the case. The Beracha would not be said because the vegetables are now available all year round, regardless of whether they're natural or not natural. It just happens to be that they're available. That's one thing.

What happens is that in the world of trees, it's more difficult. It's more difficult to do that. However, with imports and exports from one country to the next, and the Northern Hemisphere and the Southern Hemisphere having opposite seasons, you really... I don't know. When is the last time you couldn't see blueberries? I don't know. Do we see blueberries all year round? I remember growing up, there was a season for blueberries and there was a season for certain things. So how do we deal with it? Is it mitchadesh (renewed) or is it not mitchadesh? It is mitchadesh. On a local level, there's a certain hitchadshut (renewal), but when you bring it from somewhere else, it is now available, but it is also because of hitchadshut that comes from somewhere else. So it could get a little bit technical very quickly. The hitchadshut is 30 days. If for 30 days it's not available and then it comes for the next 30 days, there is a certain hitchadshut that is enough to say the Beracha Shehecheyanu. So let's say this fruit grows for three months in a certain place, and then there are three months when it doesn't grow anywhere. Then three months later it grows in the Southern Hemisphere and is available. In that case, you would be able to say Shehecheyanu twice in a year. However, even that is not the case today.

But correct me if I'm wrong: I'm sure there are some fruits that I'm not aware of or that I don't pay attention to. I'm sure there are fruits that are not always available; I understand that. But to have 30 days when you cannot get your hand on the fruit like this would be difficult. I don't have examples off the top of my head, but what I see in the past few years is that everything is available all the time. If that's not the case, then Shehecheyanu is doable. But if the fruits come from somewhere else, then the answer would be that you don't say Shehecheyanu because it's available all year round. So maybe fresh figs, for example, are not available all the time. Maybe I'm wrong, but I think they're one example of the rare fruits that are not available all year round. The fact that there are dried figs does not change the halakha (Jewish law).

The Poskim discuss: What about frozen fruits? You have frozen fruits that are available all the time. If the taste is exactly the same and the freshness is the same, then you wouldn't be able to say Shehecheyanu, but usually that's not the case. Usually it is a different presentation. Usually they use frozen fruits for smoothies and things like this, but not for consumption. Therefore, there is enough of a difference to be able to say Shehecheyanu. In the case that the only availability was frozen, you would have to say Shehecheyanu when they come fresh. But again, it would be limited to a very small number of fruits. Maybe cherries have a season when you can't find them. I'm not sure anymore. Yellow cherries. Yellow cherries. Oh, okay. That's another she'eilah (halachic question): If you have red cherries available, but now they change the color, do you say Shehecheyanu? Is it a different fruit? I don't know. For that, you would have to consult with Guillermo for more details on the fruits, et cetera. I don't know whether there are so many fruits that are really not available. But if they aren't available and they come in new, then we believe the blessing of Shehecheyanu would be said. It's just very few cases today where you would be able to say the blessing of Shehecheyanu on new fruits.