A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Birkat hamazon, keriat shema, sefirat haomer. In what order?

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
May 22, 2023
Duration
3:53
Lecture code
RGK-883

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

It is an evening during Sefirat HaOmer (counting of the Omer). You are finishing your meal, and now you have three mitzvot (commandments) in front of you: Birkat HaMazon, Keriat Shema, and Sefirat HaOmer. In what order are you supposed to do these three mitzvot? On the one hand, in the middle of the meal, it would seem that you should finish Birkat HaMazon first, then say Keriat Shema, which is De'oraita (from the Torah), and then Sefirat HaOmer, which we hold is Derabbanan (rabbinic). Most Poskim (halachic authorities) hold that it is Derabbanan. If you hold that it is De'oraita, good luck figuring out which one goes first. But we could address that too.

Sha'agat Aryeh asked a question and said the following. We of course know the concept of Tadir: what's more frequent? But the She'eilah (question) here is: What is more frequent? For somebody who eats bread at every meal, you could have Birkat HaMazon two or three times a day, while Keriat Shema would be two times a day. So what is more frequent? Does it depend on the person? If somebody eats bread only once a day or rarely eats bread, then for this person it is not Tadir like Keriat Shema. Does it go by number? Does it go by person? Sha'agat Aryeh says no: it does not go by person or by the number of times; it goes by the frequency of the Chiyuv (obligation). There is no Chiyuv to eat bread, no Chiyuv to eat bread every day on a regular day, but there is a Chiyuv to say Keriat Shema two times a day. So even if a person ate bread ten times in a day, it does not make it more Tadir, because he eats bread ten times every day. It has to first be a Chiyuv, not elective. I know Yom Tov (holiday) could be different, but then you look at the whole picture and say that Keriat Shema is steadily two times a day, and Birkat HaMazon is not.

The first thing Sha'agat Aryeh says is that Keriat Shema has to be said before Birkat HaMazon. This is very Shayach (relevant): many times at the Shabbat meal, the Friday night meal, you go well into the night, and you have to say Keriat Shema before Birkat HaMazon. That's the halacha (Jewish law). So first Keriat Shema, and the second one would be Birkat HaMazon, because, again, if you go by frequency and compare Sefirat HaOmer—even if you hold it is min HaTorah (from the Torah)—with Birkat HaMazon, Birkat HaMazon is more frequent than Sefirat HaOmer. Sefirat HaOmer is learning the Omer.

Number two, we hold that Sefirat HaOmer is Derabbanan. But Sha'agat Aryeh says there is another problem: really, it depends on the person. Sefirat HaOmer is much more likely to say Birkat HaMazon than Sefirat HaOmer. It is more likely to be forgotten than the other mitzvot, because we are more Tadir in Keriat Shema and Birkat HaMazon, which are everyday occurrences, while with the other one there is a Chashash (concern) that you are going to forget. That Chashash is strong enough, and it may depend on the person. If a person is worried that, if he says Keriat Shema and then Birkat HaMazon, there will be a lot of distraction, by the time he is done with that, there is a very high chance that he will completely forget about Sefirat HaOmer, unless he has a way to remember Sha'agat Aryeh. Because of that, you first do Sefirat HaOmer, then Keriat Shema, and then Birkat HaMazon.

So we thought at the beginning there was going to be Birkat HaMazon, Keriat Shema, Sefirat HaOmer, and it is exactly the opposite. First Sefirat HaOmer because you may forget, then Keriat Shema because it is Tadir, and then Birkat HaMazon because it is the last one. Bichvod.