A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Can a woman schedule a delivery on a Thursday?

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
July 15, 2025
Duration
3:51
Lecture code
RGK-1594

Delayed brit milah and the Thursday–Friday principle

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas recalls the previous day’s discussion: a postponed brit milah may not be performed on Thursday or Friday, so it must be delayed until Sunday.
  • He derives a broader rule: a person should not initiate on Thursday or Friday an activity that may lead to chilul Shabbat. The concern is not unique to brit milah; the example underlying the rule is someone traveling on Thursday or Friday. The lecture also describes the relevant period as the three days before Shabbat.

Scheduling elective surgery

  • Hacham Ovadia applies this principle to non-emergency surgery. Since surgery can lead to infection or other complications requiring treatment, he says it is assur to schedule an elective procedure on Thursday or Friday.
  • Emergency surgery is different, as is a case with a strong reason to choose that date, such as having a better doctor available then.
  • If the procedure is entirely elective and can wait until Sunday, Monday, or Tuesday, one should choose another day rather than schedule surgery before Shabbat.

Scheduling a delivery or C-section

  • Hacham Ovadia gives two reasons not to schedule a C-section or delivery for Thursday. First, although a woman’s post-birth condition may allow Shabbat to be violated if complications arise, a Thursday C-section for a boy would lead to a brit milah the following Thursday.
  • He distinguishes a brit milah performed on its proper, eighth day from a postponed brit milah: an on-time brit milah may be performed on Thursday, including when it falls on Shabbat. He nevertheless questions arranging a birth so that the brit milah falls in the period before Shabbat.
  • The lecture says at this point that “it’s better if you do it on Thursday,” but then states that a scheduled delivery should be set for a different day, not Thursday or Friday. The stated reasons are concern for the woman’s health and avoiding the arrangement that brings about a brit milah before Shabbat.