
Torah Lecture
Cleaning and rinsing the mouth between dairy and meat
Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas
- Lecture code
- RGK-735
This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.
Good morning, gentlemen. Continuing from yesterday's halakha, we refer to the Gemara in Chulin, Daf Kuf Hey. The Gemara discusses Tavshil Shel Basar. We mentioned that the Maaseh, based on the Mordechai and most of the later Poskim, indicates that there is no difference between Tavshil Shel Basar and Basar Mamash. Therefore, if someone has a soup and did not actually eat the meat, it makes no difference.
To simplify things, if someone eats something dairy and then intends to eat something meat, how should they proceed? We know that between meat and dairy, there is a waiting period of six hours. However, between dairy and meat, it is immediate. So, how does one navigate this? The Shulchan Aruch in Beit Yosef quotes a Machloket among the Rishonim. Since it is late, I will not delve into the entire Machloket but will go straight to the point.
He cites the Rambam, the Rif, and the Rosh. When you have the Rambam, the Rif, and the Rosh, the halakha will follow this guideline. The language of the Rosh is as follows: "Bil Basar Akhar Gevina, Mutar Miyad." If you ate cheese, you can have meat immediately, provided there are three conditions: Kinuach, Verda Hat Piv, and Netilat Yadayim.
Kinuach is not washing; Hadakha is washing. Kinuach means to clean. Rinsing is Hadakha. To wipe is acceptable. So, we can say it is either to wipe or to clean. Hadakha is rinsing with liquid, and then there is Netilat Yadayim. You have these three elements for cleaning your hands.
The Rosh states that if it is daytime and he sees that his hands are clean, then Tzadik Netilat, he does not need to wash his hands. Today, Baruch Hashem, we use utensils more than in the past; we use forks and knives. Therefore, one might argue that if they did not touch the dairy at all, why should they perform Netilat Yadayim? Indeed, that is Hadakha. This is logical; it is not merely spiritual but factual. If you did not touch the dairy or if your hands are clean, you can inspect them and see that you do not need Netilat.
What is Kinuach, according to the Rosh? You must chew something else. He provides the case of bread as the best example; chewing bread will clean the mouth. However, if the item is not an effective cleaning agent, it will not suffice. For instance, just eating a fruit, like a date, or a vegetable would not be enough. In that case, you would need to rinse your mouth with liquid.
Thus, you have these three elements. Netilat Yadayim is optional. The two middle steps pertain to the mouth: one is for cleaning, and one is for rinsing. Chacham Ovadia, based on the Roshash's comments on this Gemara, states that if you only had a dairy beverage, you do not need to perform Kinuach; you only need to do Hadakha, as the liquid will remove the residue. If you ate a solid, then you would need to perform both steps: Kinuach and Hadakha. This is indeed the halakha al-Maaseh.
Therefore, depending on what exactly the person ate, whether it touched the dairy directly, and whether it was solid or liquid, the halakha may vary from three steps to perhaps only requiring Hadakha. We will continue from here.
