A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Gemara Berachot #220 21b Saying Modim or just bowing is enough (Tur&Bet Yosef)

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
May 11, 2022
Duration
45:06
Lecture code
RGK-529

Shome'a Ke'oneh and listening during the Amidah

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas continues Tosafot’s discussion of listening to the shaliach tzibbur: the listener should pay attention to the words, and the prayer leader must have the listener in mind.
  • Rabeinu Tam argues that if shome'a ke'oneh means that hearing counts as though the listener himself answered, it must also count as an interruption during the Amidah. That creates a problem, and suggests a machloket Rishonim about how shome'a ke'oneh works.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas explains two possible readings: it may mean that it is as if the listener himself said the words, as Rabeinu Tam understands it; or it may mean that listening gives him the status of the person answering—the Chazan—without making him the one who spoke. On the first reading, there is a hefsek.
  • He recounts a Moroccan custom, followed al pi Kabbalah, of saying “LeMoshe tzivita” instead of “Tikanta Shabbat.” A Spanish saying joked that when the dafina came out well-cooked, one said “LeMoshe tzivita,” because of the pleasure; if it was burned or spoiled, one could let the prayer leader say “Tikanta Shabbat.” The joke also prompted discussion of whether the custom had a makor in the Tur, and of the wording “al pi haKabbalah” versus “Kabbalah beyadam,” including where a comma belongs.
  • In any case, the people adopted the custom of remaining silent and listening during the Amidah when the prayer leader reaches a passage from which they could be yotzei, such as Kaddish or Kedushah; Tosafot brings this view, and the custom is described as great. Chacham Ovadia says this applies only when the prayer leader knows what he is doing, since it depends on his having the listener in mind.

The Yerushalmi: when to begin if the congregation is praying

  • In Perek Tefilat HaShachar, the Yerushalmi discusses someone who has not prayed and arrives while the congregation is praying Musaf. If he can pray and finish before the prayer leader reaches the relevant point, so that he can answer amen, he should pray; otherwise, he should not.
  • Tosafot asks which amen the passage means. It is not an amen to Kedushah, but an amen during the prayer leader’s repetition. Two amoraim identify it differently: one says Ha'El HaKadosh, and the other says Shome'a Tefilah.
  • Since Musaf does not include Shome'a Tefilah, the two views can be reconciled as referring to different settings: Shome'a Tefilah concerns a regular weekday prayer, while Ha'El HaKadosh concerns Shabbat Musaf. A person may begin if he can finish by the time the prayer leader reaches Shome'a Tefilah; otherwise he must wait. This is shortly before Modim.
  • The Bavli discusses Modim and Kedushah, while this Yerushalmi passage also discusses Shome'a Tefilah and, for Shabbat Musaf, Ha'El HaKadosh. The question remains why Rav Huna discussed Modim rather than Shome'a Tefilah; Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says the halachah will become clearer when the views are considered together.
  • The Yerushalmi’s conclusion is that Ha'El HaKadosh applies in both settings, while Shome'a Tefilah applies only on a weekday.

The practical tension of arriving late

  • If all the views are combined, a latecomer may need to finish before Kedushah, Ha'El HaKadosh, Shome'a Tefilah, and Modim. Waiting for the repetition to end, however, means missing tefilah bi-tzibur.
  • A person who arrives late, or starts late while six people are still praying the Amidah, may find that the prayer leader has already begun the repetition rather than prolonging the wait for him. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas raises the practical question of what to prioritize and says that one may have to compromise somewhere.
  • He notes the idea that being in the synagogue connects one to the congregation, and contrasts someone who arrives just before Modim with someone arriving just after it.
  • On Shabbat, Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says he supports the Ashkenazi practice of starting the Amidah with the congregation, even if one skips the preceding prayer and returns to it afterward. Sefaradim do not practice this way. The Rema permits not joining ge'ulah to tefilah on Shabbat, whereas Sefaradim must join them.

Weekday Musaf and the Yerushalmi’s text

  • The Yerushalmi’s reference to Shome'a Tefilah in a Musaf setting raises the possibility that weekday Musaf on Rosh Chodesh or Chol HaMo'ed included all eighteen blessings. The Bavli does not follow that practice; we do not follow it either.
  • The discussion also raises the count of blessings. The passage in Perek Tefilat HaShachar says, “Eighteen were established; nineteen were not established.” Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that Aneinu does not make an Amidah of twenty blessings: the individual includes it in Shome'a Tefilah, while the prayer leader says it between Go'el and Rofeh. The passage must therefore be discussing the congregation rather than an individual prayer leader.
  • The Yerushalmi’s discussion of Rosh Chodesh and Tish'ah B'Av raises the same issue; Nachem is in place of Tishkon. The Gemara speaks of eighteen and nineteen, while the familiar count is nineteen and twenty, but Shemoneh Esreh does not go beyond the established count.
  • Rabeinu Chaim argues that the Tosefta explicitly reflects our practice: on days with a Musaf offering, such as Rosh Chodesh and Chol HaMo'ed, the evening and morning prayers have all eighteen blessings, with Ya'aleh V'yavo in Avodah; if it is omitted, the person repeats the prayer, even at night. Musaf itself has seven blessings, with the sanctification of the day in the middle.
  • Tosafot suggests that the Yerushalmi may contain a scribal error: perhaps it says only that someone arrived and found the congregation praying, without specifying Musaf, since the particular prayer would make no difference.
  • A different reading of the Yerushalmi would mean that weekday Musaf did include the full Amidah. This would affect someone who mistakenly began Atah Chonen in Musaf on Rosh Chodesh: the Bavli says not to continue, though after the fact it would not be a blessing in vain; under that Yerushalmi reading, the full Amidah was the practice. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that this would be a significant disagreement with the Bavli’s position that there cannot be twenty blessings in the Amidah.

The Tur’s rules for beginning late

  • The Tur’s first case is someone who enters while the congregation is praying: if he can begin and finish before the prayer leader reaches Kedushah, he should pray; otherwise he should not, because he needs to say Kedushah with the congregation. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that someone beginning at a normal pace while the congregation is already at laminim velamalshinim in Shacharit will not make it.
  • If he enters after Kedushah, he should pray if he can finish before the prayer leader reaches Modim. Otherwise he should not, because he needs to bow with the congregation so that he does not appear to deny the One to whom they are bowing.
  • The Tur also allows him to reach Modim with the prayer leader, or to be at another blessing where people bow, such as hatov shimcha ulecha na'eh lehodot. The key is to bow with the others.
  • If he is in the middle of a blessing when the prayer leader reaches Modim, he can bow with him. He does not bow at the beginning or end of an arbitrary blessing, since bowing at a blessing’s beginning or end is limited to Avot and Hoda'ah. The Tur says this option should not be used initially unless he needs to begin in order to join ge'ulah to tefilah.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas remarks that waiting is not always the only solution: one may continue, join ge'ulah to tefilah, and rely after the fact on the option of bowing. He compares the interruption caused by waiting to the way pauses of 35 seconds, 1 minute, or 2 minutes can disrupt the rhythm of prayer.

Kedushah during the Amidah and the views of the Rishonim

  • The Tur does not mention Ha'El HaKadosh or Shome'a Tefilah in this timing rule. It separately says that if the prayer leader reaches Na'aritzach while someone is praying, the person should say the prayer leader’s words; this is not an interruption. This raises the question of whether he says the whole Nakdishach or only “Kadosh, kadosh, kadosh,” which the Beit Yosef will address.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas raises a related question: if one may answer Kedushah during the Amidah, why may one not answer amen to the kohanim’s blessings during Birkat Kohanim? The discussion does not resolve the question; the participants say they need to check the sources and may also be mistaken about the rule concerning the kohanim.
  • The Beit Yosef cites Perek Mi Shemeto: Rav Huna says to pray if one can finish before the prayer leader reaches Modim; Rav Yehoshua ben Levi says to pray if one can finish before Kedushah. They disagree about whether an individual may say Kedushah. Rava also says an individual does not say Kedushah, citing Venikdashti betoch benei Yisrael, and the decisors rule like Rav Yehoshua ben Levi.
  • At first glance, Rav Yehoshua ben Levi does not address Modim. The Rambam likewise says to finish before Kedushah and does not mention Modim; the Beit Yosef confirms that the Rambam’s text is correct.
  • Tosafot and Rashi understand Rav Yehoshua ben Levi differently: he agrees about Modim and adds Kedushah. Rav Huna does not mention Kedushah because, on this reading, he holds that an individual may say it. The Rambam instead treats the disagreement as applying across the issues: he holds that one can say Kedushah alone, while the other opinion does not require waiting for Modim.
  • One possible explanation of the Rambam’s position is that the Modim concern is about bowing, which the person can do while the congregation bows. On that view, someone arriving just before Modim may begin without waiting; if he is concerned about appearing to deny the congregation, he can bow while in the middle of a blessing.
  • Tosafot and the Rosh indicate that one must also finish before the prayer leader reaches Modim. The Tur therefore brings both views: after Kedushah, one should finish before Modim. Rashi explains the concern as appearance: although an individual says Modim, not saying it with the congregation while they bow may make him look as if he denies the One to whom they bow.
  • The Tur’s additional allowance to reach Modim or another bowing point together with the prayer leader is also found in Tosafot and the Rosh.

When the time for prayer is passing; Modim and bowing

  • The Semag and Hagahot Maimoniyot say that one should finish before Modim, but if the time for prayer is passing, it is fine to pray anyway. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas emphasizes that praying on time takes priority over meeting the timing condition.
  • The Darkei Moshe reports that the Maharil would begin even when he could not finish before Modim, perhaps because the time for prayer was passing; the Maharil did so in that circumstance.
  • Or Zaru'a takes a stricter view: even if one will reach Modim together with the prayer leader, he may not begin, because he will not be able to say Modim Derabbanan. This is different from Rashi’s concern about appearing to deny the congregation: for Or Zaru'a, bowing in the middle of the Amidah is not enough; one must say the text.
  • Tosafot explains that the congregation’s wording differs from the prayer leader’s, so that no one thinks he is yotzei through the prayer leader: thanksgiving must be personal. The order of the wording does not seem essential, since Modim expresses thanksgiving. The congregation bows specifically at Modim, which explains why the concern about appearing to deny them arises there.
  • The Beit Yosef says that Tosafot and the Rosh attribute the practice to Rabeinu Tam, and Rabbeinu Yonah also mentions it. Rabbeinu Yonah appears to say that one bows whether in the middle, at the beginning, or at the end of a blessing, to avoid appearing to deny the congregation or separate oneself from it; he says to bow only, without saying anything.
  • The Beit Yosef agrees with the Tur that this should not be done initially: if one who cannot finish before Modim should not pray, all the more so he should not rely on bowing in the middle of a blessing. Tosafot and the Rosh also say this, though the Beit Yosef does not explain their reason. Or Zaru'a’s reason is clear; on Rashi’s approach, saying the wording may be preferable initially, while bowing may work after the fact. The Beit Yosef says he will discuss the matter further in siman kuf-chaf-gimmel.

Saying Kedushah during the Amidah; amen to other blessings

  • The Rif, in the name of Rabbeinu Hai, and the Rambam in the tenth chapter of the Laws of Prayer say that someone praying may say Kedushah at the corresponding point in the Amidah, after Mechayeh HaMetim.
  • Tosafot says that when the prayer leader reaches Kedushah, the person should say Nakdish with him, including the entire Kedushah, and may answer with the congregation because this is not considered an individual. Rabbeinu Yonah, the Rosh, the Mordechai, and the Hagahot Maimoniyot write similarly. Ashkenazim say “Nekadesh.”
  • The Beit Yosef says he found a statement in the name of the Geonim. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that the Anshei Knesset HaGedolah were between the First Beit HaMikdash and the middle of the Second Beit HaMikdash, whereas the Geonim were around the year 700, about a thousand years later.
  • This leads to the question of whether someone praying the Amidah together with the prayer leader should be exactly in sync with him. If so, perhaps he need not answer amen to Ha'El HaKadosh, since he is saying that blessing at the same time. But answering amen to the prayer leader’s blessings while saying one’s own silent Amidah would be a hefsek.

Amen to Ga'al Yisrael

  • The Tur brings a custom of answering amen to Ga'al Yisrael; some answer it only on Shabbat. The question is why one might answer amen to the prayer leader’s blessing, or even to one’s own Ga'al Yisrael, without treating it as answering amen to oneself. At night, interruptions such as Kaddish may occur, and they are not a hefsek because that is how the berachah is concluded.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that according to sod, one does not answer because of the seventh sha'ar one enters. He leaves open the question of how answering amen to Ga'al Yisrael differs from answering amen to the prayer leader while praying the Amidah together with him, which is not done.
Words in this lecture1
Talmud Bavliבבלי
Terms Talmud Bavli, the Babylonian Talmud.
Also written: Bavli