Masechet Berachot, daf chaf zayin (page 27), amud alef (column one), four lines from the bottom: mesaye'a lei (it supports him) le-Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi, de'amar Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi, asur la'avor (to pass) keneged (in front of) ha-mitpalelim, the people while they are praying. He said it's asur to go in front of ha-mitpalelim. That's a side point from the story we had before about Rav, who was in the house of Geniva, with Salishel Shabbat, Be'elev Shabbat, and Amatzel HaMir Mia Baraba behind him. He was behind him. You're not allowed to walk in front of the people while they are praying.
The Gemara says: “Ah, Eni, Ve'ah, Rabbi Ami, Ve'rabi Asi, Chalfi, Rabbi Ami, Ve'rabi Asi, Chut, Le'alba Amotu, De Chalfi.” How do we read this? “Eni, Ve'ah, Rabbi Ami, Ve'rabi Asi, Chalfi, Rabbi Ami, Ve'rabi Asi, Chut, Le'alba Amotu, De Chalfi.” Ah, that's the answer. What's Chalfi? Rashi says—no Rashi? What's Chalfi? “They walk by?” So he says it was outside of Fuamot that they would cross in front.
How did Rabbi Yirmiya pray right behind Rav? It's the same line. Normally, the rabbi has to be in front. It also shows a little bit of yuhara, arrogance. Tosafot adds another reason: it's also a little weird. Why is it yuhara to be right behind the rabbi? It's still the same category. The rebbe is looked at by what the chassidim do. The rebbe is almost by himself in his corner. They're not close to him; they give him space in the yeshiva. In the old building, the first Beit Midrash (house of study) on Rav Aharon, there's a big heichal (hall) that goes up like this. It's the original Beit Midrash. There's a place he squared off, and that's where he used to sit. There's a rail there. I don't know whether they put the rail there after he passed away, or whether he used to sit there with the rail. Let's use that as a mashal: “the zoom i come for the rabbi,” give him space, but right behind him is not usually where people sit. There's a mizrach (eastern side), but people are not on top of them. They give them space.
So immediately, aharei Rabo, like adjacent to Rabo, that's really close. But this is not so much like that. Sephardim are not so much like that. I've seen many where the rabbi actually sits with the people; it depends which one. They also have the official seating on Shabbat, sitting in between the wheel, each place. The rabbi just sits in his freshman year and then eats at the front row or whatever. And then, by the Amidah (standing prayer), there's a system of the teivah (pulpit)—of the teivah.
It's not because the rabbi doesn't want to go to the rabbi. Tanya (it was taught): Rabbi Eliezer prays after the rabbi, gives peace to the rabbi, gives peace to the rabbi, goes back to his yeshiva, and says things that the rabbi doesn't hear—or causes the Shechinah, the Divine Presence, to be separated from Israel. That's a lot of things. What is each one of those? Rashi says: shalom l'Rabbi. It doesn't mean you don't say hello. Of course you have to say hello, but don't say it like everybody else: “Hey. Hi, Rabbi.” It's kavod. The point is how you greet him when you're passing by.
So what's the shayla? How did the be me pray right behind Rav when there are several sources indicating that you cannot do that? The first one is probably okay; it's probably a mark of kavod. It depends on the makom (place). What happened? He was different. He was a talmid chaver (fellow student). A talmid chaver is not the same level. It's like saying you have a chavruta with a talmid chacham who is a greater talmid chacham than yourself. Both are talmid chacham. Of course, talmid rabbo—the concept exists. A talmid chaver is also a rabbi, but not at the same level as the other rabbi. Both are talmidei chachamim, but one is in a higher category than the other. A talmid chaver is not his rabbi; he is somebody he learns from, but not like a... I don't know how you measure that.
One time I went to Parak Yosef to get “a bit of a half from review with that sadhka.” He told me, “Don't kiss my hand; kiss the rabbi's hand.” I said, “How do you know which one? Which one is bigger?” I don't know if we could quantify it. Which one is bigger, Raman? Which one has the gadut on there? All the gadut. Look, Rabbi Yirmiyah bar Abba is probably, you know.
That day, which was Friday night, he said to Rabbi Yirmiyah, “How do you speak to Rav? Did Rav, did Mor, in third person? Did Maul stop the Melachah? Did you stop the Melachah?” That's not how a talmid speaks to his rabbi. Therefore, we see from here that the relationship was talmid chaver, not talmid rabbo. He said to him in the second verse, “Mibadalt?”—“Ma li'in badilna, li'l-Romar li'in badil Maul.” So that was a way of showing that he was a talmid chaver, not talmid mamash.
Tosafot says, “That's interesting: how do we know that there is a halakhic proof that a person is not allowed to say shalom aleichem just like that? How do we know? Because the kedei dibbur, the v'toch kedei dibbur, is quantified, measured, calculated based on shalom aleicha Rabbi. That's the formula, right? And that's called because they say that tamiz larav ah.” So you see there is enough coming out. In halakha, shalom alecha would take less time than shalom alecha Rabbi. Therefore, you see that even in halakha, when quantifying the time that is betoch kedei dibbur, we count it with that.
That's the re'ayah—the halakhic re'ayah that there's a formula for how to say shalom. Tosafot is bringing a re'ayah that there is a re'ayah brura that, halachically, it's a formula, and it's quantified and calculated. The kedei dibbur of anything is calculated like this, based on shalom alecha Rabbi. If “Rabbi” were just a mark of kavod, an extra thing, then it would be shalom alecha. That formula is used as a template to know how long toch kedei dibbur is. It's not a standard concept. It is what it says: “Shalom Aleichem, Oli Rebi, Ateir Roshi.”
Actually, it says in the Rambam: how do you say hello to the Rav? If you say hello to the Rav, it's “Shalom Aleichem, Oli Rebi.” If he says “Shalom Alecha” to you first, then you answer, “Shalom Alecha Rabbi” or “Mori” (my teacher). He asks there why, when returning the she'elat shalom, you add Mori. I don't remember whether I read the answer, so I don't know. But “Shalom Alecha Rabbi” is the formula used for betoch kedei dibbur, so therefore it tells you...
Rabbi Yirmiyah bar Abba once prayed for Shabbat on Shabbat evening. It's surprising: one day the Rabbi went and did arvit (evening prayer), presumably after Palag HaMincha (halfway through the afternoon prayer), and after that he went to the bathroom, to take a shower. He went to take his Shabbat bath. He went to the hamam, the steam room, after praying. So maybe the prayer of the Kabbalat is not enough to be mekadesh Shabbat, to sanctify Shabbat. How do you know this? It's a little weird because, as we've said many times, you say, “Baruch Atah Hashem Mekadesh HaShabbat.” Rabbi Akiva Eiger famously says to have kavanah, the intention, not to be your tzitzit kiddush when you say that, so that when you go home and say Kiddush d'oraita (from the Torah) for everyone, you're doing that.
I always had a very difficult time understanding this concept. If you don't have kavanah for Kiddush, then you're not praying the right tefillah—the prayer. That tefillah is mekadesh Shabbat. What are you doing otherwise? It's not disassociated from the prayer. You're not just reading words. You are mekadesh Shabbat. It's like saying, “Have in mind while you pray Mincha that you're not praying Mincha.” Have in mind when you say, “Baruch Atah Hashem Mekadesh Shabbat,” that you're not mekadesh Shabbat. How is that supposed to make any sense?
It's not the same thing as not praying. He still prayed. He prayed, but he didn't mekadesh Shabbat? He is mekadesh Shabbat. What's the sense of that prayer? What is that prayer if it's not mekadesh Shabbat? This is the translation of the words, by the way. It's Kiddush. What is it, then? What are you saying? I'm not making a difference. So what did you say? Tell me. Any other shot? It's weird. It's like saying the same thing in the same country. You're the one saying it. Imagine you're the one saying it and I'm not making a difference. You could make a difference. You did. You could make a difference. It could be. It has to make sense.
When you're doing Mincha, you cannot say, “I'm not having kavanah for Mincha,” because the prayer is Mincha. Here, we're being mekadesh that Shabbat is something holy, but I'm not—in other words, I can dissociate myself from accepting Shabbat while saying that Shabbat itself is holy. I can say, “Shabbat is something that's mekadesh, that's holy and this and that, but I'm not accepting on myself the stringency of entering Shabbat.” I'm saying Shabbat is holy, as something that applies to the object, you understand? Mincha has nothing to do with that. Or the candle is to see no candles, right? Candles to see. But there are some people who say you accept Shabbat the moment people bag the shiitake.
So what do you want to do with that? This is a rocket. If you could make a scenario according to the—to the right—okay? Normally, you're going to make a shot through that, but you could understand that there's another way out to do it. Therefore, when you say it tonight, you're saying, “Master, I'm doing this for the light to have light on Shabbat.” Same way around: when I'm cooking on Shabbat, I'm not making Shabbat at the same time. So too, when I'm lighting on Shabbat, I'm not mekadesh Shabbat at the same time. You could understand that. But here, the words “Baruch Atah,” which happen to be the same words as the Kiddush, by the way, so it's not a coincidence. You are making Shabbat when you say that, unless you're saying not. So what are you doing? You're doing two things, shibbu. You're going to have something in mind when you pray, but you can have a different mindset about what the prayer is. I'm not even going there. Before that, even the akira: understand how you could be disassociating yourself from what you are saying. It makes no sense. It's the timing. Where are you doing that? It's just words. Like you said, make a declaration. But it makes more sense on the sebor. It makes more sense.
By the way, what's the point of making a declaration on Shabbat? Do we need your declaration on Shabbat? No. The point is not the reminder. You are making this Shabbat. That's why there's a mitzvah of Kiddush and you are sanctifying Shabbat. When I make a bell on Shabbat on myself and do this whole thing right now, I'm sanctifying Shabbat; in a few minutes, it's going to be Shabbat. I'm sanctifying that Shabbat. But I'm not mekabel all the stringencies. So again, you're saying words: “I'm sanctifying that.” What is that?
Like when you say the Shema, you're saying the prayer, but then no one says you're taking something on this month. So I'm saying the prayer, but this is what I'm going to take on this month. We asked those questions already, and she said, “kid a sheet paletta of the retora she see.” They gave a different definition. Shema could be a divinity also, and I'm going to use the divinity after that. Yes, right before Shabbat finishes, you say Tafon and Tano. So why isn't that the same thing? What do you mean? Well, no, but you don't have Shabbat. That's a good question. I think it's very good. There is a hiluk. You know what the hiluk is? You don't own that time. In other words, you can't transform Shabbat into Chol (weekday) unless it's already Chol. Over there, you could make Shabbat Shabbat although it's still Chol.
So when you make Kadesh Shabbat, especially when it's early—even worse when it's early—if it were Friday night, then your b'shat could work: “I'm not making Kadesh Shabbat. It is a Metsiutayit Shabbat.” But hold on: when it's early and you're saying “make Kadesh Shabbat,” then you don't have kavanah to make Kadesh Shabbat. So what are you doing exactly? It's the opposite. That's why I don't... Hehalah. But it's not halachically a problem.
Back to the story. It says this Rabbi went to pray Shabbat: “Be'elef Shabbat. V'yatsa v'shana. V'shana pirkin.” And he gave the lesson after that: “V'adayinu chashchai.” It was still not Shabbat. So you see, you could be praying in Amikabel.
Amar Rava—Rava said, “ha'ud v'nikhnas le'aziya.” He went into the steam room before the Gezerah. You see, there's a lot of kodem gezerah, achar gezerah.
Most of you were not here on Friday night of Hanukkah, but I'll tell you: a very big chidush. You're going to remember, hopefully. The ask on Hanukkah, she'ela on Hanukkah, is a famine. We know the nes ha-nerot, the miracle of the lights, has a little bit to do with this; that's why I'm bringing it up. We know the nes ha-nerot was because they couldn't find pach shemen (flask of oil) that was tahor (pure), so they had to... Rambam says it took eight days to go make it and bring it.
The question is: why? Not because of tumah. That's a classic answer, but this is a much stronger question. In the Torah there is no tumah on liquids. There is no tumah on liquids. It's only there that the Gemara says the liquids that go on the midbahaya, on the midbahaya, dachin—that tahor. Which are those liquids? Four: water, ya'in (wine), shemen (oil), and dam (blood). Shemen is shemen zayit (olive oil). In the compound of the Beit HaMikdash and within the context of Avodat HaMikdash, it doesn't exist. Chachamim lo gazru al shemen.
Start again: d'oraita is only on ochalim, not on liquids, period. Chachamim gazru, beautiful. But they didn't decree on a Mikdash, like many things, and tumat mashkin on the mashkin used in the Mikdash. So what's going on here? That's the bomb question. It's a question in the Acharonim. The Shoel UMesheev and the moruk Tziah ask the question. This is bombakashe. The whole nes, nothing.
Al pi hashkafa, you finances, whatever. In halakha, Hashem is not going to do a nes if you don't need one, never. So the Yabetz asks the question and gives a very interesting answer. He brings re'ayot; it's complex, but he brings re'ayot that—first, as an introduction—many times we look at gezerot Chazal as people who are at least 1,500 years later. But it could have taken 1,000 years, from the time of the Nevi'im until the sealing of the Gemara. During those 1,000 years, there was a lot of back and forth in some gezerot.
We see this in muktze, for example. Nehemiah is the one—remember when he talked about the kelim? There was no muktze, any kelim. Afterwards they made “kol ha-kelim asurim”—all utensils were forbidden—because everybody... ad shibaban, they said no, the keli achilah were not included. Then they were mechalak between keli shemelachto le-issur (utensil used for prohibited work) and keli shemelachto le-heter (utensil used for permitted work). So there are three levels: keli shemelachto le-issur, keli shemelachto le-heter—you still have to find a usage; it's not just playing—and those kelim that were never included in a gezerah because they were keli achilah.
A cup you could play with; a fork you could play with. But with something that is keli shemelachto le-heter, you still have to find a usage for it. That's why mehamal etzel is enough for keli shemelachto le-heter, not for keli shemelachto le-issur. And the Shulchan Aruch says that if you just want to play, playing is not a function. Therefore, there's a big machloket about whether you're allowed to use a bowl on Shabbat. That's the famous one. There was a lot of back and forth with gezerot. You see a lot of this throughout Shas. There's a lot of sugyot to talk about. First it was one way, then chazru v'nimnu, and they did that, et cetera.
The Yabetz proves that indeed it started like this. It was mutar min ha-Torah; there was no gezerah at all. Mashkin were permitted. Afterwards, Chachamim of that time around the Beit HaMikdash made a decree. They would go there, and the mashkin were used by Klal Yisrael for everything. Then chazru v'nimnu, and they decided to remove it only in the Beit HaMikdash. More specifically, inside the Beit HaMikdash there was no reason to apply it to mashkin used for the avodah. So it went from nothing, to everything, and then to an adjustment. The story of Hanukkah happens right there, between the first gezerah and the adjustment.
The point I was making is that the whole story of Hanukkah happened for the kavod: Borei Olam was forced to make a nes galuy for the purpose of the kavod of the gezerah, which was—I don't know if that's the right word—wronged. It was proven to be too much. It didn't stay. For most of the history of liquids being tamei, they were either completely permitted before that or forbidden outside of the Beit HaMikdash. That means that for most of history, except for a very, very small sliver of halakhic history, it was always permitted in the Mikdash. Always, Adai Hamazen, from the beginning. There was just one period of time when they had started with the gezerah. They hadn't completely readjusted where the gezerah would apply and where it wouldn't. That's when the story of Hanukkah happened, and because of that you have the whole nes. Otherwise you wouldn't need a nes. Zero. Gezerot come with time. Sometimes they're removed, sometimes they're added. It's adashas, adashas seals everything, Gamal, right? But it takes time to establish; sometimes it takes time to restate it.
So here is a side point: this was before the gazillion of Zia. Zia, it goes, it shema, you're not gonna have enough. Are you gonna show my heart a big a highly? You can't even cut the big a human Shabbat. So take Zia. Don't be before the gazillion; that's why that B was able to go after he was from Kabbalah to the Beit HaMarchatz.
If you believe there is no Urdin Dechor, there is nothing there with the hamam, before the gezerah of not having a problem with Shema Yechate Begiharim, what would be the Urdin Dechor? I guess people went on Shabbat afternoon to the hamam, if there was any. Think about it: Maim Shehu Hamu, it's the same gezerah, right? Why can't you use Maim Shehu Hamu? You have a boiler; you turn off the cold water coming in and take a hot shower on Shabbat. It's not a very big issue. It would be like this, then it wouldn't be a non-Shabbat activity to take a shower after. It would go to there's no get a little today. It's even worse today. Cold water is getting in. If you have a tank and it doesn't even work at home energy, if you're boiling your water right away, so it's much, much more direct. It's a big tank. The cold water is getting in, so club the grandma.
Grama (indirect causation) is not there? It's a far removed grama. Ah, you have grama plus something else. So there is what doesn't reach. And it's not a hundred percent. It's a hundred thousand percent. I don't know. How do you get another... See no evil, hear no evil. You have to do something before. Shemayish. You don't have to be too...
So if you have a big tank and you close the influx of water into the tank... Only the Lebanon. So you could take... Don't forget, one of the biggest problems is that people don't understand. It's hard to talk to an Am ha'aretz sometimes. There's some Talafini, Am ha'aretz. All American.
A lot of people ask whether you can use a swimming pool on Shabbat. This is classic in Miami, especially with kids. Parents may disagree about it. I would say it's the number three question that comes my way. The only real problem that there is in the swimming pool today—even sechitah, it's synthetic; there's no sechitah in that, there's nothing, sechitat se'ar—is not what people usually think.
Ashkenazim, yes. Ashkenazim are more stringent: even a cold shower in Al Haba. Sepharadim, you can take a cold shower. So all the gezerot you're talking about, they're made up. If it were a gezerah of Shema Yisra, then you couldn't take a shower. Number two, the sechitah of se'ar is a huge sugya. It's not bichal Fashud Seh, it's bichal. Every point you want to look at, there's an answer. There's only one point that's very hard to make ayah. I'm not even getting there. I'm not touching that one. This one is not debatable, and nobody understands it. Nobody adheres to it.
When you say Maim Shehu Hamu, you're talking about the heater? No, the sun. Maim Shehu Hamu me-Erev Shabbat. Between you and me, buildings don't shut off the heater on Shabbat. So they have another problem: Maim Shehu Hamu b'Shabbat. Bichal, out the window. But you're using the hot water. I don't care who did it. Now you're confusing it with a goy doing a melachah for you. It's no goy doing a melachah, or mar'it ayin, anyways; that's not going to work here. Can you in Maim Shehu Hamu me-Erev Shabbat by the Pope? Who cares who did it? Let's not confuse the two. The problem is, lu yetzuyar you have your own pool and you say right before Shabbat, “I'm shutting off the heater.” It's not Maim Shehu Hamu b'Shabbat. You still have the same gezerah: Maim Shehu Hamu me-Erev Shabbat. It's still hotter than water that wouldn't be heated at all. It's called Maim Shehu Hamu; it's asur.
The only pool that would work is a non-heated pool that is mutar. I don't have a way to say it, but when people are in buildings and have their own pools, it's not common. They say, “The kids are getting in the pool and it's cold. It's horrible to get into a cold pool.” Okay, that's the only way you can do it. It's such a side point that they don't even think about. Women often ask me about this, and when I tell them that's the only problem, they want to laugh at me. If you could chill the water, then it should not be heated at all.
But isn't Maim Shechmo supposed to be at a certain temperature? I see the teshuvot say that if it's more than room temperature—meaning outside temperature—it's considered Maim Shechmo. Rav Moshe's a fan, is an example, or we could look it up.
The same problem applies to the mikveh. For a mikveh there's a whole debate about how they let women's mikvaot that you shalit before Shabbat use it for that. It seems that for mikveh there was a special thing that was done for mitzvah and for... boropak, boiling nut. How many times do you go to the boropak mikveh on Shabbat morning? For mikveh, they made special dispensations. No, it's really hot water in the mikveh. And there are some mikvaot that they might put on that, by the way, just so you understand. I remember in Lakewood there was a pool that was heated and a pool that was not heated, for those who didn't want to use that kula.
What's the big deal? The new sign says it's the new thing in America. There was never a hamam in America. Any spa has it. It's a little more than a steam room. In Morocco I went to a hamam. It was an experience; it was interesting. You sit down, take your own bucket, and sit over there in the middle of the room.
It's an addition to the gezerah. The gezerah would be if you do the zeah. I'm afraid you're going to take a shower, right? A shower with water that was heated before Shabbat. Exactly, but that's not the gezerah. They're adding the zeah to the shower, which means if you take the zeah, they're afraid you're going to warm up the cold. That's one gezerah, right? No, I know, but here the gezerah would be, “I'm afraid”—but that's what he said. Has he formulated it? But why? That's why. The zeah seems to be—I mean, unless you're saying that they were going to lie about the lying and going all the way back, so that's what I'm saying. It's like a... So you mean how much the Rauh is more concerned that you're going to lie about something, and then in other things you don't talk about that? It's the mystery of the gezerat Chazal.
But going into Metteveria is allowed. Why are you worried about this and not worried about that? You're going to Metteveria? They let you because they said that it's natural. Nobody's making it up. There's no Chashash you're going to warm it up. So you go, if you want, to the hot springs in Arizona, and he allowed it at the end because natural is better water. Now it's allowed in Hamei Tiberi: Heteerot Hamei Tiberi. It's only mitzvah. There's another thing that you have to keep in consideration: there's another Yisroel going into a body of water that doesn't have banks. That's another gezerah. So if there are banks—there's another thing, if it's very shallow water. There are other things that get you saying about going to the springs. It depends; there are other things that you could satisfy. If it was that much, it wouldn't be a problem.
I don't believe it has to be hot, hot, hot, hot to arrive; it's more than this. If you're allowed to go into Khamiti Beria, a swimming pool is 100% good. If you're allowed to go into Khamiti Beria, then a swimming pool—there is absolutely... Why? A cold swimming pool. No, no, you said cold. I have no answer, but definitely you have no answer. If Khamiti Beria is allowed, a cold swimming pool is 100% correct.
But that's what I'm saying. No, you don't know the other problems they had. Maybe they were wearing nothing when they went, JCH. You know the other side problems, which we have answers to. It's not that we're right; those we have answers to. Cold swimming pool, I call swimming pool 100 correct. Be careful with the hair; you can fool all that stuff, no problem. The same is true of the whole shower lip; it's not an issue. But you have the swimming pool as well. You have a site if it's flat. This is what they talk about with an infinity pool. Would it be okay? That's just for a gift, you know, discuss that. But even the infinity pool has a—yeah, you have something. The water doesn't get recycled again; it goes out.