A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Gemara Berachot #293 daf 27b Timing in the gezerot of Hachamim

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
January 2, 2023
Duration
42:39
Lecture code
RGK-763

Passing in Front of People Who Are Praying

  • The Gemara’s wording supports Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi, who says it is asur to pass in front of people who are praying. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas connects this to the earlier story about Rav at Geniva’s house: Rav was praying while others were behind him, and the discussion raises the rule against walking in front of those praying.
  • The Gemara’s phrase about Rabbi Ami and Rabbi Asi crossing is examined, especially the meaning of chalfi. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas reads it as indicating that they passed outside the relevant area, though the precise wording is unclear in the lecture.

Rabbi Yirmiyah Praying Behind Rav

  • The apparent difficulty is that Rabbi Yirmiyah prayed immediately behind Rav, although sources indicate that one should not pray directly behind one’s rabbi. Tosafot adds that doing so may also look like yuhara (arrogance) or be an awkward, overly close arrangement.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas illustrates the usual distance given to a rabbi with the old Beit Midrash of Rav Aharon: Rav Aharon had a designated place, and people gave him space. The lecturer is unsure whether the rail there was put in after Rav Aharon passed away or was present when he sat there. He contrasts this with some Sephardic communities where the rabbi may sit among the people; arrangements vary. He also mentions formal Shabbat seating and the separate arrangement around the teivah for the Amidah.
  • The proposed answer is that Rabbi Yirmiyah was a talmid chaver, not a talmid rabbo. Both he and Rav were talmidei chachamim, but Rav was in a higher category; Rabbi Yirmiyah was not Rav’s student in the full sense. The lecturer notes that it is difficult to quantify which scholar is “greater,” recalling an occasion when a rabbi told him to kiss the rabbi’s hand rather than his own.
  • Rabbi Yirmiyah’s way of addressing Rav supports this distinction. On Friday night, he spoke to Rav in the second person, asking, “Mibadalt?” The lecturer says this is not how a talmid normally speaks to his rabbi, and takes it as evidence that their relationship was that of talmid chaver, not talmid mamash.

Greeting One’s Rabbi and K’dei Dibbur

  • A teaching about Rabbi Eliezer’s conduct after praying after his rabbi is cited: he gives his rabbi shalom and returns to the yeshiva. The discussion also mentions the concern of speaking so that the rabbi cannot hear, or causing the Shechinah to be separated from Israel.
  • Rashi explains shalom l’Rabbi as a matter of showing kavod: it does not mean one should not greet the rabbi, but that one should greet him respectfully rather than casually, as one would greet anyone.
  • Tosafot brings a halakhic proof concerning the proper greeting: the time measured as toch k’dei dibbur is based on saying “Shalom alecha Rabbi.” The lecturer explains that this makes “Rabbi” part of the formula used to measure the interval; if it were merely an optional extra, the measure would be based on “Shalom alecha.”
  • The Rambam gives a formula for greeting a rabbi: “Shalom Aleichem, Oli Rebi.” If the rabbi first says “Shalom Alecha,” one answers “Shalom Alecha Rabbi” or “Mori.” The lecturer notes that the Rambam’s addition of Mori in the reply raises a question he does not recall the answer to.

Early Friday-Night Prayer and the Timing of a Gezerah

  • Rabbi Yirmiyah bar Abba once prayed the Shabbat evening prayer, apparently after Palag HaMincha, and then went to the hamam (steam room) to bathe. This raises the question whether praying Kabbalat Shabbat necessarily makes a person mekadesh Shabbat and obligates him in Shabbat’s restrictions.
  • Rabbi Akiva Eiger famously says to have kavanah not to fulfill one’s obligation of Kiddush through the words “Mekadesh HaShabbat” in the prayer, so that one can fulfill the Torah obligation of Kiddush at home. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas finds this difficult: if the prayer says that Hashem sanctifies Shabbat, how can one pray it without sanctifying Shabbat?
  • The discussion considers whether one can affirm that Shabbat itself is holy without personally accepting Shabbat’s restrictions yet. The lecturer distinguishes this from Mincha: one cannot pray Mincha while intending not to pray Mincha, but perhaps one can describe Shabbat as holy while postponing one’s personal acceptance of Shabbat.
  • He also raises the comparison with lighting candles, which some people treat as accepting Shabbat, and with declarations such as Shema. The distinction offered is that one cannot turn Shabbat into Chol before it is already Chol, whereas one can accept Shabbat while it is still technically Chol. The lecturer says the issue remains difficult to understand, though he says it is not a halachic problem.
  • Returning to the story, Rabbi Yirmiyah prayed for Shabbat, taught afterward, and it was still not night. Rava says he entered the bathhouse before the relevant gezerah. The episode therefore illustrates the importance of whether an act occurred before or after a decree.

The Hanukkah Oil Question and the Development of Gezerot

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas connects the timing of gezerot to the Hanukkah oil miracle. The familiar explanation is that no pach shemen that was tahor could be found, and the Rambam says it took eight days to make and bring more oil.
  • He asks why the oil needed to be pure if the issue was tumah: according to the lecture, Torah law applies impurity to food, not liquids. The Gemara identifies four liquids used on the altar—water, ya’in, shemen, and *dam*—as tahor. Moreover, the Chachamim did not decree impurity on liquids used for avodah in the Beit HaMikdash. If so, why was a miracle needed?
  • The Shoel UMesheev and the moruk Tziah are cited as asking this question. The Yabetz offers an answer based on the fact that gezerot can change over time. A decree may begin broadly and later be narrowed or removed.
  • The lecturer illustrates this with muktze. He describes a progression associated with Nehemiah: first there was no restriction on the kelim; then “kol ha-kelim asurim” was decreed; later, keli achilah were excluded; and distinctions were made between keli shemelachto le-issur and keli shemelachto le-heter. He says a keli shemelachto le-heter still needs a use, and that playing with an object does not count as a function according to the Shulchan Aruch. He notes the resulting dispute about using a bowl on Shabbat and says that Shas contains many examples of gezerot being reconsidered, including cases of chazru v’nimnu.
  • According to the Yabetz, liquids were initially permitted; Chachamim then decreed impurity broadly, and later adjusted the decree so that it did not apply to liquids used for avodah inside the Beit HaMikdash. The Hanukkah events occurred in the interval after the broad decree but before that adjustment.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas presents the miracle as occurring for the kavod of the gezerah, which was later shown to have been too broad. For most of the relevant halachic history, liquids were either permitted altogether or forbidden outside the Beit HaMikdash but permitted there. Only during a narrow period did the decree apply even in the Mikdash. In that interval, a miracle was needed. His broader point is that gezerot may be added, narrowed, or removed, and that establishing or restating them can take time.

Shabbat Bathing, Hot Water, and Pools

Heated Water and Showers

  • The lecture returns to the bathhouse and the timing of the decree. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas distinguishes water heated before Shabbat from water heated on Shabbat. He says that even if a person shuts off a heater before Shabbat, water warmed before Shabbat remains Maim Shehu Hamu and is asur; it is not enough simply to say that the heater was turned off.
  • He notes that buildings may continue heating water on Shabbat, raising the separate issue of Maim Shehu Hamu b’Shabbat. He distinguishes this from a non-Jew performing a melachah for someone, and from mar’it ayin.
  • The lecturer discusses tanks in which cold water enters as hot water is used, and raises questions about grama (indirect causation) and how directly the incoming water is heated. He does not give a definitive resolution to every version of that scenario.
  • He says Ashkenazim are more stringent about showers, including cold showers, while Sepharadim may take a cold shower. He distinguishes these practices from the question of hot water and from the separate sechitah discussion concerning hair. He says synthetic pool materials do not present the usual sechitah concern, while acknowledging a difficult point in the hair discussion that he does not address.

Swimming Pools and Mikvaot

  • Asked about swimming pools on Shabbat, a common question in Miami, Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says the central issue is not usually what people assume: a heated pool. In his view, a non-heated pool is the kind that could be mutar; a pool heated before Shabbat still raises the Maim Shehu Hamu issue.
  • He says that some responsa treat water warmer than room temperature—or the outside temperature—as Maim Shehu Hamu, mentioning Rav Moshe as an example, though he suggests the source should be checked.
  • The same issue arises with mikvaot. There is a broader debate about women’s mikvaot heated before Shabbat, and the lecturer says special arrangements or dispensations have been made for mikvaot used for a mitzvah. He recalls that in Lakewood there was both a heated and an unheated pool for those who did not want to rely on that kula.
  • He describes the hamam as a steam room, noting that such facilities were not common in America historically but are found in spas. He recounts visiting a hamam in Morocco, where people sat with their own buckets.
  • The discussion asks whether the steam or zeah restriction is an additional gezerah: perhaps the concern is that entering the steam room will lead someone to shower or to heat cold water. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says the rationale is difficult to formulate, calling this part of the mystery of gezerat Chazal.

Hamei Tiberi and Other Pool Questions

  • The lecture contrasts heated water with Hamei Tiberi, the natural hot springs. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says they were permitted because the water is naturally hot and there is no concern that someone heated it. He also mentions that the permission is connected with mitzvah, and that other gezerot can matter depending on the body of water, including whether it has banks or is very shallow.
  • He says that if Hamei Tiberi are permitted, a cold swimming pool would seem permissible as well, provided the other concerns are addressed. He acknowledges that there are additional issues people raise, but says those have answers; he also cautions about hair.
  • An infinity pool raises a further question about its arrangement and the water flowing out rather than being recycled. The lecturer does not settle that case.
Words in this lecture2
Hanukkahחנוכה
Terms Chanukah, the eight-day festival of lights celebrating the Maccabees' victory and the miracle of the oil. English: Festival of dedication
Also written: Chanukah, Hanukah
Shasהש"ס
Terms The whole Talmud (from the initials of the six orders).
Also written: HaShas, Ha-Shas