A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Gemara Berachot #312 daf 30a Why can’t we say Havinenu during the winter? (Bet Yosef & Bach)

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
March 20, 2023
Duration
33:35
Lecture code
RGK-824

Havinenu and tefilah ketzarah

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas contrasts havinenu with tefilah ketzarah. Havinenu is an abbreviated amidah: it condenses the 13 middle berachot into one, while retaining the three opening and three closing berachot. Because it is still an amidah, someone who prayed havinenu does not need to repeat the prayer on getting home.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas illustrates this with a soldier traveling on a mission: if he prayed havinenu because he could not pray the full amidah, he has fulfilled his obligation and need not pray again when he returns. He clarifies that havinenu is only for when one cannot pray the full amidah; otherwise, one prays the full amidah.
  • Tefilah ketzarah is not an abbreviated amidah. It omits the first three and last three berachot and serves in place of the amidah. Once the person can pray the full amidah—for example, on reaching home or a settled place—he must pray it.
  • Havinenu must be said me'omed (standing). Tefilah ketzarah may be said standing or while walking. The distinction is also that havinenu remains a form of the amidah, while tefilah ketzarah substitutes for it.

When each prayer is used

  • The Mishnah says that someone walking in a dangerous place prays tefilah ketzarah. Rabbi Yehoshua gives its wording: “Hosha Hashem et amcha” (“Save Your people, Hashem”). The Mishnah mentions danger in connection with tefilah ketzarah; havinenu is discussed later.
  • The Mishnah also mentions Rabbi Yehoshua’s “me'ein shemoneh esreh.” The Gemara asks what this means: Rav says an abridgment of each berachah, while Shmuel identifies it as havinenu. The passage does not specify when havinenu should be used.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas recalls the case of someone unable to pray a full Shemoneh Esreh because of his work, such as a person up in a tree who is not given reshut (permission) to stop and pray.
  • The Ridvaz distinguishes the prayer options: havinenu may replace Shemoneh Esreh in an emergency, such as while traveling, and is said standing; in dangerous territory, one says tefilah ketzarah. Tefilat Haderech is another of the forms discussed. Tefilah ketzarah is the shortest option, since havinenu still requires the opening and closing three berachot.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas recalls tefilah ketzarah as a one-line prayer: “Baruch Atah Hashem, shome'a tefilah.” He also mentions additional wording found in the Gemara, including “Yehi ratzon milefanecha: Shema shav'at amcha Yisrael va'aseh meherah bakashatam,” followed by “Baruch Atah Hashem, shome'a tefilah,” and another version beginning “Aseh retzoncha bashamayim mima'al.” “Oseh shalom bimromav uverachamav ya'aseh shalom aleinu” is mentioned as something one may add if machmir; Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says he is not machmir.
  • The Mishnah Berurah note distinguishes the circumstances: tefilah ketzarah is for dangerous situations, whereas havinenu is for any situation in which saying the long Shemoneh Esreh is difficult. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas asks what “difficult” means and points to the text’s examples: traveling, being preoccupied and afraid of interruption, or being unable to pray a lengthy prayer with kavanah (concentration).
  • The cited halachah says that havinenu is said after the first three berachot, followed by the last three, and must be said standing. When the person gets home, he need not repeat the prayer. It also says not to pray havinenu during the rainy season or at the close of Shabbat or a festival.
  • A separate halachah addresses wage-earners, who pray havinenu. For someone traveling where bands of wild animals and bandits are found, it prescribes tefilah ketzarah—“Tzarchei amcha merubim”—without the first or last three berachot, said on the road while walking. If he can stand, he stands; when he reaches a settled place and can concentrate, he repeats the full tefilat yud-chet.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that Rav’s version, an abridgment of each berachah, is much longer and comes close to saying the whole Shemoneh Esreh. The lecture says that this is not the practice followed, while havinenu is included in a prayer book for chayalim (soldiers) to use in the field, not on base.

Why havinenu is not said in the rainy season

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas asks why havinenu cannot be used during the rainy season, when one must add veten tal umatar. He notes that Ashkenazim use the same barech aleinu and add the words “veten tal umatar livrachah,” and asks why those words cannot simply be added to havinenu.
  • The Mishnah Berurah says that veten tal umatar must be said in birkat hashanim. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas suggests that perhaps the Chachamim instituted the entire berachah as the place for this request, but continues to question why the words cannot be included in the abbreviated prayer.
  • The text also says that at the close of Shabbat or a festival one must say havdalah, and may not include it in havinenu; it refers the reader to the Beit Yosef and Magen Avraham. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas uses this as a parallel question: if havinenu includes a few words for each berachah, why not add the relevant words there?
  • The Gemara discusses whether veten tal umatar could be included with “vedashenenu bene'ot artzecha.” Mar Zutra raises the possibility, and the answer is “atei le'itrudei”—the person may become confused.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas questions this explanation, especially for a request said throughout the rainy season. He asks why a person would be more likely to get confused in havinenu than in the regular amidah, and notes the Rabbi Schottenstein note’s broad statement that havinenu is available in any difficult situation.

The Beit Yosef and Bach on the risk of confusion

  • The Beit Yosef explains that a person is more likely to err in short passages: it is easy to skip or add two or three words. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas presents this as the reason a short havinenu may be more prone to mistakes than the full amidah.
  • The Bach questions whether the concern can simply be skipping words: even without veten tal umatar, a person might omit two or three words, leaving havinenu short one of its middle berachot.
  • The Bach instead understands the concern to be uncertainty about where to insert veten tal umatar alongside “vedashenenu bene'ot artzecha.” In the full Shemoneh Esreh, the request’s place in birkat hashanim is known; in the short text, a person might put it before or after the intended phrase.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas emphasizes that the Bach’s explanation differs from the Beit Yosef’s: the issue is not simply that short wording invites omissions, but that the abbreviated prayer makes the correct placement of the rain request less clear.
  • He finds the explanation difficult to apply to a request repeated for six months. For Ashkenazim, who add the words in birkat hashanim, the placement is familiar and clear; he contrasts this with additions such as Aneinu, which are said only on a fast day. He also notes that Ashkenazim have a different nusach, and that in havinenu the first and last three berachot are not said.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas does not resolve why a person who says the request for six months would be especially likely to misplace it in havinenu. He notes that the Days of Awe have their own additions, such as Zochrenu, but says this is a separate issue.

Havinenu at the close of Shabbat

  • Rabbi Akiva Eiger raises a question about motza'ei Shabbat: havinenu is not normally said then because of Atah Chonantanu. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas considers someone who missed Arvit, then wakes before alot hashachar with too little time for the full amidah and decides to say havinenu, omitting Atah Chonantanu.
  • Rabbi Akiva Eiger’s novellae suggest that when time is running out, it may be better to pray havinenu without mentioning havdalah than not to pray at all, since after the fact one has fulfilled the prayer obligation without havdalah.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that this appears to allow havinenu without Atah Chonantanu in that situation, possibly relying on havdalah over the kos. He says some poskim disagree and does not present this as the accepted practice. He also observes that if one begins the amidah before the deadline, it may not matter if one finishes afterward.

The unresolved question for workers

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas returns to the practical difficulty for wage-earners: if havinenu is meant for any situation in which the person is too preoccupied to pray at length, why is it unavailable for six months of the year? During that time, the person must pray the full amidah or tefilah ketzarah.
  • He wonders whether havinenu is actually intended only for exceptional situations, despite the wording “any situation,” and asks what workers who cannot stop to pray are supposed to do during the rainy season.
  • He suggests that it may seem more sensible to permit havinenu with an added line, rather than risk workers not praying at all. He also raises the possibility that veten tal umatar is treated as an especially important part of its berachah: unlike other berachot, one may need to include this specific request to fulfill the obligation. He presents this as a possibility, not a resolution.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas concludes that he still finds the issue difficult: havinenu seems useful for people who cannot pray at length, yet the restriction leaves workers with the same difficulty during the rainy season.