Yayin (wine) and Shemen (oil) have different Berachot (blessings). Why? Ela (rather), the reason yayin has a special Beracha is: Chamra sa'id (wine satiates), umishcha lo sa'id (and oil does not satiate). Rashi says this is because satiating is a higher category than nourishment: sa'id chashiv tefei mimazon (satiating is more significant than nourishment). Once you talk about sa'id, it is a higher category than mazon. Mazon is zan; it gives you nutrients. Therefore, wine would require its own Beracha.
Vechamra mi sa'id (and does wine satiate?), asks the Gemara. Does wine satiate people? If you drink enough of it, you will be full. The Gemara says, “Veha Rava havah shati chamra kol ma'alei yoma dePesach ki heichi denigrerei lelibei venichol matzah (unleavened bread) tefei” (Rava drank wine all day to increase his appetite). Rava was drinking wine on Erev Pesach (Passover eve) to open his appetite, so that he could eat more matzah with Te'avon (appetite). It was not a Cheshbon (consideration). For the purpose of opening the appetite, clearly wine is not satiating; it does the opposite. It makes you hungry.
The Gemara says, Tuva garir, purta sa'id (a lot draws on the appetite; a little satiates). If you drink a lot, it opens the appetite. If you drink a little, it satiates. Tosafot says, “Tuva garir” (a lot draws on the appetite). Mikan mashma she'asur lishtot yayin be'Erev Pesach min haminchah ulema'lah (from here, a prohibition is implied). If that is the case, it should be Asur (forbidden) to drink wine on Erev Pesach from the afternoon onward. Tosafot continues, “Ve'im rotzeh lishtot, tzarich lishtot harbeh” (if drinking, drink a lot). If you want to drink, you would have to drink a lot. We just said that a lot of wine opens the appetite, so you would not be allowed to have, let’s say, a cup of wine; you would be allowed to have two or three cups. That seems crazy. I do not understand what it means: if you drink a little, you are full, but if you drink a lot, you get hungry. Is that a Chok (statute), or is it a Halachah leMoshe miSinai (law given to Moses at Sinai)? A person who is tipsy might get hungrier and want to eat.
The Gemara asks, Umi sa'id kelal (and does it satiate at all)? Are you sure that sa'id is the right terminology, the right etymology, for this situation? Umi sa'id kelal, vehachtiv Veyayin yesamach levav enosh (and wine gladdens the heart of man). However, Velechem levav enosh yis'ad (and bread sustains the heart of man). So sa'id has to do with lechem (bread), and yayin has to do with Simchah (joy), not with sa'id. They are two different things. Nahama hu desa'id, chamra lo sa'id (The bread is what fills a person, not wine).
Rashi explains: “Veseifa dekra velechem levav enosh yis'ad mashma aval yayin eino ela mesame'ach” (the end of the verse implies that bread sustains the heart of man, but wine only gladdens). The Gemara says, “Ela chamra it bei tartei, sa'id umesame'ach” (rather, wine has two qualities: it satiates and gladdens). Bread satiates; joy does not gladden. Wine has the particularity of both. The Rambam discusses this in Hilchot De'ot. Wine is mesame'ach (gladdening) and also sa'id, although the Pasuk (verse) does not seem to support that, because it says, “yayin yesamach velechem yis'ad.” It seems that they are not the same. If the Pasuk had said, “velechem levav enosh yis'ad veyayin yesamach levav enosh,” you could say that wine adds gladdening to the bread’s satiating quality. But when it says first that wine gladdens and then that bread sustains, it sounds like two different things. How do you know that wine also satiates? It is strange.
Rashi explains: “Mishum deshani leih kidei amaran, de'ilu lechem yis'ad velo yesamach, aval yayin so'ed umesame'ach” (because it differs as we said: bread sustains but does not gladden, while wine satiates and gladdens).
The Gemara asks, “I hachi, nevrich aleih shalosh berachot” (if so, let us recite three blessings over it). Why do we not say Birkat Hamazon (Grace after Meals) on wine, if it is mesame'ach and sa'id like bread? The answer is, “Lo kav'ei inshei se'udateihu ilaveih” (people do not establish their meal upon it). People do not Kove'a se'udah (establish a meal) on wine.
Rashi asks, “I hachi desa'id vesa'id mazon hu, venevrich aleih shalosh berachot acharav” (if so, why not recite three blessings afterward)? “Va'anan tenan lekaman” (and we learned below): “Kol shehu mishiv'at haminim velav min dagan, acharav mevarchim Beracha achat” (anything from the seven species that is not grain has one blessing recited afterward). You never have Birkat Hamazon on anything that is not from the five grains. Why not? If it is sa'id, it is sa'id. It is interesting, because the rule about the five grains is not universal; it is just that it is Misa'ad (satiates). If we find a grain that is Misa'ad, would you consider Birkat Hamazon if people are Kove'a se'udah on it?
A lot of gluten-free people eat rice. They do not say Birkat Hamazon on it, though. The Gemara did not say that the reason is because it is not from the five grains; it said that people are not Kove'a se'udah on it. The world is changing. Bread is clearly less popular, and people establish meals on things that are not bread anymore. Should that change, then? Technically, you can make a Mezonot (food blessing for certain grain foods) wrap and have three of them, but that is something else. I am talking about changing completely from the five grains to something else. The Sevara (reasoning) here is, “Lo kav'ei inshei se'udateihu ilaveih.” If people are now Kove'a se'udah on it, would that change things? I do not know. We will see what the Rishonim say.
Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak said to Rava: “Amar leih Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak leRava: i kava ilaveih se'udateih, mai?” (Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak said to Rava: if he established his meal upon it, what is the ruling?) He is asking our question: what happens if he did Kove'a se'udah on it? Rava answered, “Lechsheyavo Eliyahu veyomar, i havya kevi'uta” (when Elijah comes, he will say whether it is an established meal). “Hashta miha batlah da'ato etzel kol adam” (for now, his opinion is nullified before everyone). For now, it is certainly not the Derech (custom), and therefore his Da'at (opinion) is Batel (nullified).
Perhaps this whole gluten-free movement is the Derech now. There are a lot of people who are not eating gluten, and oat bread is very hard to eat, so they Kove'a se'udah on other things. How much would you have to drink to Kove'a se'udah on wine? There is a Rambam who tells you how much wine; I do not know who could actually drink that. I think the Rambam discusses it in Hilchot De'ot. Mada is the first section.
The Rambam says, “Yesh ma'achalim shehem ra'im” (there are foods that are harmful). There are foods that are extremely unhealthy. “Yesh ma'achalim shehem ra'im beyoter ad me'od, vera'ui la'adam shelo le'ochlam le'olam” (there are very harmful foods that a person should never eat). For example: Hadagim hagedolim (the large fish)—tuna and swordfish. Hameluchim hayeshanim (the old salted fish). The large fish are full of mercury, he says. The text also mentions old, salted fish, and he mentions Barbunias, which are small.
He also lists Ve-hagevinah ha-meluchah ha-yeshanah (the old salted cheese): aged salted cheese, such as Camembert, Gouda, or Brie. I hate every one of them; I do not eat them. When they open the refrigerator, the smell is too much for me. Lechatchilah (ideally), I sit outside; I cannot sit inside.
“Ve-hakeme'in” (truffles) “ve-hapetriyot” (mushrooms). What is keme'in? He first says it is a kind of mushroom, then identifies it as truffles. The ones pigs dig out are truffles. “Ve-habasar hamaliach hayashan” (the old salted meat)—salami and jerky. “Ve-yayin migito” (wine from its vat); he describes it as wine from its barrel. The Gemara says “yayin yashan” (old wine). “Ve-tavshil she-shahah ad shenadaf reicho” (and a cooked dish left until its smell dissipated). “Ve-chen kol ma'achal she-reicho ra” (and so, any food with a bad smell). Or “mar beyoter” (extremely bitter). Mar means bitter, not sour. “Harei elu laguf kemo sam hamavet” (these are like poison to the body).
“Ve-yesh ma'achalot shehem ra'im, aval einam kemo harishonot leroa” (there are foods that are harmful, but not as harmful as the first ones). They are not as bad as the first ones. “Lefichach ra'uy la'adam shelo le'echol mehem ela me'at” (therefore, it is proper for a person to eat only a little of them), “ve-le'achar yamim harbeh” (and only after many days). Only occasionally, a little bit. “Ve-lo yargil atzmo lihiyot mezono mehem o le'ochlam im mezono tamid” (and he should not accustom himself to make them his food or eat them constantly with his food), for example, large fish. Once in a while. “Livyatan” (Leviathan).
“Ve-chalav she-shahah achar shenechlav arba ve-esrim sha'ah” (and milk that stood for twenty-four hours after being milked). That is old milk, milk that is not fresh for 24 hours. That is raw milk, not pasteurized. In general, we know that Chalav (milk) is not healthy either. “U-vesar shevarim gedolim u-teyashim gedolim” (and meat from large oxen and large goats). Teyashim are old goats, or something like that. “Pilim” (elephants). “Shelavim” (quail).
“Ve-hapul” (the fava bean)—pul is a fava bean. “Ha'adashim” (lentils). “Hasapir” (chickpeas): “Sapir makers cuts it. is chickpeas.” “Lechem se'orim” (barley bread). Not because of the safety, not because of the airplane. “Lechem matzot” (unleavened bread). “Hakruv” (cabbage), which gives a lot of gas; some say it restores intestinal flora. “Ve-hachatzir” (leeks), “ve-habetzalim” (onions), “ve-hashumim” (garlic), “ve-hachardal” (mustard), and “hatznon” (radish). “Kol elu ma'achalot ra'im hen” (all these are harmful foods).
“Ve-ein ra'ui la'adam le'echol me'elu ela me'at ad me'od uvimot hageshamim” (it is proper for a person to eat very little of these in the rainy season). “Aval shelo bimot hageshamim, lo yochal mehen kelal” (but outside the rainy season, he should not eat any of them). In the summer, none. “Ve-hapul ve-ha'adashim bilvad ein ra'ui le'ochlam lo bimot hachamah velo bimot hageshamim” (the beans and lentils alone should not be eaten in either season). “Ve-hadilu'in” (and gourds)—dilu'in is Dla'at (gourd). Gourds are eaten a little in the hot season.
“Ve-yesh ma'achalot shehen ra'im ve'einan kemo elu” (there are foods that are harmful, but not like these). Some are bad, but not as bad as those. So you have the very bad, the bad, and the less bad. We have not got to the good yet.
“Vehem of hamayim” (and they are waterfowl), such as duck. “U-vnei yonah ketanim” (and young pigeons). “Ve-hatemarim” (and dates). “Ve-lechem kalui beshemen” (and bread roasted in oil), or “o lechem shenilosh beshemen” (or bread kneaded with oil). That is focaccia or bread kneaded with oil in the dough. “Ve-hasolet shenafo otah kol tzorkah ad shenish'ar bo re'ach mursan” (and fine flour sifted until the smell of bran remains). “Ve-hatzir ve-hamuryas” (and fish brine and fish sauce). Tzir (fish brine); Muryas (fish sauce), which he describes as pickled fish oil.
“Ein ra'ui leharbot me'achilat elu” (it is not proper to eat much of these). “Ve-adam shehu chacham ve-chovesh et yitzro” (and a wise person restrains his inclination), “ve-lo yimashech achar ta'avato” (and does not follow his desire), “lo yochal mikol hanizkarim kelum” (he should eat none of those mentioned), “ela im nitzrach lahem lirefu'ah” (unless he needs them for healing). “Harei zeh gibor” (that person is mighty).
“Hadvash vehayayin ra laketanim veyafeh lazekenim” (honey and wine are bad for children and good for the elderly). Wine is included, but he does not give the amount.

