A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Gemara Berachot daf 37a #391 Do women need to cover their heads when praying?

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
December 18, 2023
Duration
36:11
Lecture code
RGK-1076

The question about women and uncovered heads

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas opens with a question about young, unmarried women who are accustomed to going without kisui rosh: may they pray, make berachot, say other matters of sanctity, and study in school with their heads uncovered? Is there a prohibition against mentioning Shem Shamayim with an uncovered head?
  • The question is raised but not resolved in this lecture; Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says that the discussion of women’s hair covering has only just begun.

Masechet Soferim and the early rulings

  • Masechet Soferim records two opinions about reciting Kriyat Shema when poorly clothed or bareheaded. One reading appears to allow it even with an uncovered head; another allows exposed legs or torn clothing, but not an uncovered head, because the person may not utter an azkarah in that state.
  • Maran haBeit Yosef, citing haKolbo in the name of Maharam, writes that walking with an uncovered head is not prohibited. The Gemara in Shabbat describes avoiding four amot bareheaded as a midat chasidut, not as a legal prohibition.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas recalls the pidyon haben episode involving Rav Kahana: a man offered him the five coins, and Rav Kahana asked for an item worth that amount, apparently the man’s turban, so he would not walk four amot bareheaded. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says this is not proof of a prohibition, since it reflects a midat chasidut.
  • Rabbenu Peretz says one should object to someone entering a beit kneset with an uncovered head. Rabbenu Yerucham says it is prohibited to recite a berachah bareheaded because of azkarat Shem Hashem.
  • The discussion in Berachot about a naked person covering certain parts of his body while reciting Kriyat Shema raises a question: the head is covered there, but that is a different sugya, and it is unclear how the two discussions fit together. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas suggests that the person might have had a kippah nearby, but stresses that this is only a possibility.
  • Both discussions appear in Shulchan Aruch, siman Tzadi-Alef, and in siman Reish-Vav in Hilchot Berachot. The passage about a woman directs her to sit so that her body is not exposed and also discusses covering her hair; Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that it is striking that it does not discuss head covering in the same way.
  • Maran haBeit Yosef quotes Rabbenu Yerucham’s conclusion that reciting a berachah bareheaded is prohibited. Since Rabbenu Yerucham rules in accordance with the restrictive view in Masechet Soferim, that is the ruling Maran haBeit Yosef presents.
  • Shulchan Aruch, siman Tzadi-Alef, se'if gimmel, gives two separate “there are those who say” rulings: one about uttering God’s name with an uncovered head, and another about objecting to someone entering a synagogue bareheaded. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas explains that the second is an additional ruling from a different sugya, not a disagreement with the first.
  • The Or Zarua discusses the teaching that everyone is included in the minyan shiv'ah, even a katan and an ishah. He says a minor should be kept from reading with an uncovered head, since Masechet Soferim may prohibit reciting Shema bareheaded.
  • The Or Zarua further says that, in either case, the person may translate but may not read baTorah, serve as sheli'ach tzibbur, or perform Birkat Kohanim. He questions whether the person may recite Kriyat Shema, noting that the Tanna Kamma’s wording seems to make reading from the Torah prohibited in either case.
  • The Or Zarua cites Kiddushin, where a man was asked why he did not wear a sudar and answered that he was unmarried. The other person told him not to return until he was married. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says this shows that the man was particular about uncovered heads, while also indicating that the unmarried man was not expected to cover his head. This is a separate discussion about a man.
  • The Or Zarua argues all the more strongly against reading from the Torah bareheaded, especially for an adult, and says he does not believe the rabbis of France recited berachot with their heads uncovered. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that the Ba'alei ha-Tosafot evidently relied on the lenient opinion in Masechet Soferim; the Or Zarua does not accept their practice and says he can uphold it only if it follows the Tanna Kamma.
  • In a brief exchange, a participant recalls a source connecting wearing a kippah with being in the presence of a talmid chacham or rabbi; Rabbi Gabriel Koskas acknowledges the point, but it is not developed.

Terumat ha-Deshen and an oath with an uncovered head

  • Maharai, the Terumat ha-Deshen, was asked about decrees made by the authorities in Breslau, which Rabbi Gabriel Koskas identifies as a city in Ukraine. Jews required to take an oath would have to swear by the Shem ha-Meyuchad with their heads uncovered.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas explains the question as whether the Jews would have to choose between swearing by avodah zarah and swearing by Hashem’s name bareheaded.
  • The Terumat ha-Deshen distinguishes between an order intended to make Jews violate their religion and one intended to make the oath more binding for the authorities’ own benefit. If the non-Jews require an uncovered head because they regard it as a sign of respect and believe it will make the oath more serious, that is not an intention to make the Jews violate religion. In that case, one should ve-ya'avor ve-al yehareg.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas recalls the general discussion of yehareg ve-al ya'avor: it applies to three prohibitions, while a decree imposed by a government or non-Jews against the Jews can require neherag ve-al ya'avor for any mitzvah. Here, the key question is whether the order to uncover the head is aimed at making Jews violate a religious prohibition.
  • The Terumat ha-Deshen says he knows of no explicit prohibition against mentioning Hashem’s name bareheaded. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that the restriction is sourced in Masechet Soferim, among the masechtot ketanot, rather than in Shas. Mentioning Shem Shamayim in vain is prohibited, but a truthful oath is not in vain.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas suggests that the Terumat ha-Deshen may have known the passage in Masechet Soferim but followed its lenient opinion, along with the reasoning of the rabbis in France. He emphasizes that this should not be taken to mean the Terumat ha-Deshen was unaware of the earlier rishonim; he was a great gaon, and the authorities held him in great esteem. Avodat HaGershuni says, “Who is greater for us than Maharai, from whose waters we drink and whose rulings sustain us?”
  • Maharashdam reports that his teacher, the great Mahari Teitzik—Rabbi Yosef Teitzik—regarded the words of Maharai, author of Terumat ha-Deshen, as the words of the Rosh. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas also refers to Yeri'ot Shlomo and Melamed Leho'il.

The order of birkot hashachar

  • The Gemara’s account of waking includes saying Elokai neshamah shenatata bi tehorah. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas explains that the earlier practice was to say birkot hashachar as each event occurred while a person woke and got dressed; that is not the practice followed now, though a person may choose to follow it.
  • He distinguishes birkot hashevach from birkat hamitzvot and birkat hanehenin: a blessing of praise need not precede the event it describes. For example, the blessing associated with hearing the rooster follows hearing it. The requirement to bless before an act applies to birkat hamitzvot and birkat hanehenin.
  • The sequence raises questions about Oter Yisrael betif'arah, which concerns covering the head: if the blessings are said as events occur, how can someone reach that blessing before covering his head? And why is she-lo asani goy said later, rather than first, since a non-Jew does not say berachot?
  • Berachot, daf samech, lists the sequence: on waking, Elokai neshamah shenatata bi tehorah; on hearing the rooster, Baruch hanoten lasechvi vinah; when putting on clothes, Baruch malbish arumim; when placing a sudara over the head, Baruch Oter Yisrael betif'arah; and when washing hands, al netilat yadayim.
  • The Rosh says the order in Shas indicates that these berachot may be recited before netilat yadayim: the person is beside his bed, gets dressed, and only afterward goes to the bathroom. This supports the view that netilat yadayim was instituted for Kriyat Shema and tefilah. The Rashba says similarly in his responsa.
  • The Rambam likewise places Elokai neshamah while the person is still in bed, malbish arumim when he dresses, Oter Yisrael betif'arah when he covers his head, and al netilat yadayim when he washes. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says the Riaz and the author of haMichtam also understand the blessings to be said in the Gemara’s order, when the relevant actions occur, even before netilat yadayim.
  • The geonim, by contrast, were stringent and instituted saying all the blessings after morning netilat yadayim, so that they would be recited in purity and cleanliness. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that this arrangement loses the connection between each blessing and its corresponding action.
  • Orchot Chayim reports the same contrast: the Talmud’s wording indicates that the blessings are said while the person is still in bed, but the geonim instituted saying them after netilat yadayim. The Tosfot Rid explains that the people of the Rambam’s time were holy and careful about washing, so they could say the blessings cleanly in the order of the Gemara. Rabbeinu Asher, citing Rabbi Chayim in Sefer haPardes as quoted in Birkei Yosef, Shiyurei Berachah, also explains that the Rambam’s practice was for a different, more careful generation.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas summarizes that the rishonim cited above understand the Gemara’s order plainly. This means that, before saying Oter Yisrael betif'arah, the earlier blessings were said while the head was uncovered. He explains that birkot hashachar are blessings of praise connected to an action, not blessings that must be said beforehand; a person says the blessing alongside the event.
  • He mentions related questions: how quickly one must bless upon hearing thunder; whether a blind person says pokeiach ivrim as praise for himself or for the world according to darko shel olam; whether, as the Rema discusses, women say it for everyone or only for themselves; and whether someone who does not wear shoes says sheasah li kol tzorki for that day or as a general statement.

What the blessing order implies about head covering

  • The order of the blessings poses a challenge for those who prohibit mentioning God’s name with an uncovered head. Shouldn’t a person cover his head and say Oter Yisrael betif'arah before saying the other blessings?
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas considers whether the person might have slept wearing a small cap and then put on a larger hat or mitznefet before saying Oter Yisrael betif'arah. He does not accept this as a clear answer: Tosafot explains that the sudara means any kind of hat or head covering, suggesting that the head was uncovered before that blessing. He also notes that Tosafot represents the Rabbanei HaTzarfatim, whose approach was lenient about berachot without a kippah.
  • The issue matters for people who do not wear a kippah during the day and find themselves at a business meeting or elsewhere without an easy way to put one on. Some put on another item for the berachah and then remove it; others do not. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says the order of the Gemara suggests that they can say the berachah, rather than omit it.
  • Maran haBeit Yosef explains that Oter Yisrael betif'arah relates to the practice of walking with the head covered. Even someone who does not consider uncovered walking prohibited agrees that covering the head is a midat chasidut. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that this means a berachah can be said for a midat chasidut.
  • The Zohar, Parashat Naso, says that a person must not walk bareheaded because life departs from him. Since the Jewish people are commanded in this practice so that mora Shamayim will be upon them, they recite Oter Yisrael betif'arah. The Zohar’s explanation is that this consequence applies to Jews. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says that Maran haBeit Yosef’s explanation indicates the head was entirely uncovered before this blessing, in keeping with the plain reading of the Gemara.
  • This understanding accords with the Tanna Kamma in Masechet Soferim and with the lenient position of the rabbis in France. The Ra'ah and Shitah Mekubetzet say the Gemara’s order is not necessarily exact because the person had not yet washed his hands; Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that they do not raise uncovered head as a reason for changing the order.
  • The Gra says that refraining from mentioning God’s name with an uncovered head is only a midat chasidut, since the Gemara in Berachot permits it according to the law. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas presents the Gemara’s order as a proof for the Gra’s position.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas also considers the possibility that people slept with a small cap and then put on a larger covering. Maharsha explains Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak’s instruction to “cover your head” as a way to acquire yir'at Shamayim; Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak may have covered his head more than other people out of awe. The sages would spread a sudara over their heads, and the practice of wearing a tallit over a smaller head covering is associated with them. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says this could be an answer to the difficulty, though the Gra does not use it.
  • Eliyah Rabbah, quoting the Shelah, describes covering the head at night as a midat chasidut. Leket Yosher quotes Maharai as saying there is no concern about sleeping with one’s head uncovered. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas distinguishes sleeping from walking four amot bareheaded: a person who is asleep is not walking, unless he sleepwalks.

The lottery in the lishkat hagazit

  • In Yoma, daf kaf-heh, the person conducting the payas takes the mitznefet from one of the kohanim to determine where the lottery begins. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says this appears to indicate that the kohanim could stand with uncovered heads, even on Har Habayit.
  • The Magen Avraham cites this as evidence that there is no prohibition against sitting or standing bareheaded. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas asks how this fits with the fact that the lottery was conducted in a holy place, and whether the selected kohen only covered his head after the lottery.
  • The Beit Me'ir discusses the matter similarly. Ta'am Megadim rejects the proof by suggesting that the kohen wore a small cap under the mitznefet; Sdei Chemed also discusses the issue.
  • Tosafot asks why the lottery was not held in the holier azarah. Rabbeinu Tam answers that after the mitznefet was removed, it would have been disgraceful to stand in the azarah without it. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas responds that even if there were a small cap beneath it, that cap might itself have been considered disgraceful.
  • The proposed proof is that a head covering was not required on Har Habayit, outside the azarah. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas cautions that the passage is not directly about mentioning Hashem’s name, but it is being used to support the view that there was no general chiyuv to cover the head.
Words in this lecture1
Shasהש"ס
Terms The whole Talmud (from the initials of the six orders).
Also written: HaShas, Ha-Shas