That is why sushi is very complicated. I think we can agree that there are only two possibilities when it comes to sushi. Maybe. You have the chashivut (importance), which is the fish, and the mas'id, the mazin (nourishing) aspect of the rice. But the Shulchan Aruch says you need the rov (majority). For vegetable sushi, the question would be adamah (ground) versus mezonot (foods made from the five grains), but there is also the avocado, which is ha'etz (the tree).
I would look at the rov as everything against the rice. Then what berachah (blessing) do you make? You look at what is chaviv (beloved), what is chashuv (important), or whatever the relevant factor is. But when it comes to rov, I do not think the question is rice versus fish or rice versus another ingredient. It is everything versus the rice. Someone asked whether a thin layer of rice would count as the majority because there is more rice than avocado, fish, or cucumber individually. No. I look at the whole thing and ask what makes up the greatest amount. You can have several mi'utim (minority) together. The rov is the ingredient you have the most of. But in Yoreh De'ah, when you speak about a majority, it means 51%. You need 51%; you do not have 51% of the food. For example, you have 30% rice, 20% adamah, 20%—You want to call that rov? That's not rov. All mi'ut! Within the mi'ut, you say one has more than the other. All mi'ut! That's rov? No, all mi'ut.
Here, though, you are trying to find one staple so that you can make one berachah for the whole thing. It has to be the majority of the whole thing, not the majority of some other component. If nothing makes up a majority, then you look at other possibilities, such as chavivut (fondness) or chashivut. I am not saying what the berachah would be; we can discuss that. But the rov would no longer play that role.
Many kinds of sushi have fish on top, and there may be 51% fish. If that is the case, there are two ingredients, and it is definitely not mezonot; it is definitely shehakol (everything came to be through His word). The ikar (primary) is definitely the fish. What about the fact that there is this inyan (matter) that you can see each one, so it is not like a bitul (nullification)? A lot of Ashkenazi rabbis separate the ingredients and make the berachot on everything, certainly on the fish. But tafel (secondary) and ikar have nothing to do with whether you can identify the ingredients. One ingredient accompanies the other; you have to determine which is the rosh (head).
With nigiri, the little ball of rice has a piece of fish on top. Even if the rice is bigger, I would think the fish is primary. But on a sushi roll, it is more difficult; it is a mixed experience, and the rice is eaten on its own too. That raises the she'elah (question) of what the word ikar means and how to define it. Is it based on the more expensive ingredient? That is a good guess, but it is only an idea, not a final answer. And protein is always going to win, and it's always going to be shehakol. If that's what you go for, I'm throwing out an idea. I'm throwing out an idea. I'm not saying this—It's not a final thing. You always have such a tiny amount of truffle, which is today not real, except for the actual truffle, which is always such a small sliver. It's going always going to be cents versus the fish, always. The truffle oil is chemical, but the actual truffle is a small sliver compared with the fish or whatever else you are eating. So what is the definition of ikar vetafel (primary and secondary foods)?
With nigiri, you want to eat the fish with a base of rice, but you want the fish. Someone objected that you also want to be full, but the reply was, “Definitely you don't want to be full eating nigiris. That's not your objective.” Two nights ago, at Havana Grill, the meat was not good, so I ate a little and was still hungry. I asked them to bring me sushi because I wanted to get full. Someone replied that sushi is different from sashimi; they serve one or two pieces. Rice has an element of making you feel full; that is not complicated. You eat sushi for the experience and the flavor, and for both reasons. Mazin? Also rice. You see how difficult it is to pinpoint ikar? If you are really hungry, you might say, “Give me bread,” but that is not what you are eating sushi for. You are eating it for the sushi experience, led by the fish in combination with the rice.
A roll is more difficult because it is like arroz con pollo: everything is mixed together, like chicken fried rice. With nigiri, you see a big piece of fish on a bed of rice. Alon has a good point: if you go on price, the expensive thing is the rice.
There is another safek (doubt) that we did not study enough: what is the definition of rice? Is rice really orez (rice) or not? We assumed it was, and kind of slogged off the issue. There is a machloket rishonim (dispute among the early authorities) of equal standing between Rashi and Tosafot; Rashi was earlier. The Tur has a very controversial lashon (expression), saying that Rashi was a mefaresh (commentator), not a posek (halachic decisor). Rav Ovadia cites that often: Rashi says this, but he is a commentator, not a halachic decisor. Still, in halachah (Jewish law), lema'aseh (in practice), the Beit Yosef quotes Rashi all the time as an opinion, not merely as a commentator. That is hard to swallow.
A reference was made to Halichot Shabbat, Mishu Zham, and Rav Shmuel Wosner. The Magen Avraham, in se'if katan (small section) tet, writes, “hevi bitchilat da'at haShelah vehaBach dena'asu orez vedochan sfika dedina” (the Shelah and Bach initially considered rice and millet a legal doubt). The Magen Avraham says there is a safek. One can berachah lehakeil (rule leniently in a blessing doubt) because it is a sfika dedina.
There is also a good question: if there is a doubt whether the food is mezonot or adamah, which should you say? Because both would work. Either way, right? Bedi'avad (after the fact), both would work. Which one is preferable? It says nowhere Berachot. Yes, it does. No, here, siman (section) kuf-nun-chet ad reish-lamed-tet. So reish-chet is before reish-lamed-tet, right?
There is a distinction in halachah between shiv'ah ziknei ha'ir (seven elders of the city) and shiv'at tuvei ha'ir (seven leading men of the city). Shiv'at tuvei ha'ir is discussed in connection with selling a beit kneset (synagogue), in section kuf-nun, kuf-nun-alef.
The text says: “Ha'ochel tavshil o orez” (one who eats a cooked dish or rice), with a piece of chicken placed before him on a plate, or schnitzel or meat. Tavshil means cooked food, stew. The examples include Adafina and cholent. We learn in the afternoon what? Eiruv tavshilin (joining cooked dishes). Eiruv tavshilin, so we're in the sugya (Talmudic discussion) of tavshil. If the meat is mixed with the rice, “gam keshe'ochlo levado ein mevarech al habasar” (even when he eats it alone, he does not bless over the meat), because it is secondary to the rice. Even if you take a piece of meat by itself, you do not say shehakol; it is secondary to the rice, like cereal and milk. Even if you drink a little bit of milk, you don't say a berachah; it's together.
But if the meat is placed separately at the side of the plate and he eats it by itself, without the rice, he blesses over the meat. “Bein im ochlo levasof bein im ochlo ba'emtza” (whether he eats it at the end or in the middle), especially if the meat or chicken was cooked in one pot and the rice in another. If he eats the meat together with the rice, he does not bless over the meat. The order of the blessings is a different discussion: kedimah bivrachot (precedence in blessings), another siman (section), siman resh-yud-alef; this is resh-yud-bet.
It is interesting that the text does not mention the rov. Why does it say automatically that you do not make a berachah on the meat? Because they are mixed. Why does it not say that you do not bless over the minority? Usually there is more rice than meat, but it depends on the kind of meat. With a large steak, the side dish may be smaller than the main dish; at home, there may be more rice, while in a restaurant the side dish is often smaller.
Berachot daf mem-dalet says, “Berach al ha'ikar patar et hatefelah” (one who blesses over the primary exempts the secondary). That is the Mishnah we saw last time when we discussed crackers. This is the wording of the Ritva: “Tavshil sheyesh sham she'ar tevu'ah shelo mechamheshet haminim, kegon orez vedochan, vehem ikar hatavshil” (a cooked dish containing other grains, not from the five species, such as rice and millet, when they are the main part of the dish). It does not say what makes them the main part, but it says they are the main part. That suggests they are not automatically primary; they are primary in this case.
“Keshe'ochlam kemo shehem bederech achilah bekach, mevarech aleihem borei minei mezonot uvasof nefashot” (when eaten in their usual way, one blesses over them with “Who creates kinds of foods,” and afterward, “Who creates souls”). But if they are not the ikar (primary) of the dish, one blesses over the ikar and ufoter et hatefelah (and exempts the secondary). Likewise, for any mixture of foods with different blessings, when the five species are not present, we follow the primary part of the food. That sounds like a broad rule: one blesses over the primary and exempts the rest. According to this, with rice, meat, and legumes, one should seemingly bless over the rice, which is the primary part of the dish, and thereby exempt the mixed vegetables.
Is rice the primary part of the dish because its blessing is mezonot? The text says, “ve'einam mechamheshet haminim”—specifically, they are not of the five species. But when you raise the rice to mezonot, perhaps it acts that way, though not as much, since he keeps repeating that they are not of the five species. Let's see. This is the wording of maran (our master) in the Shulchan Aruch: “Ha-koses et ha-orez mevarech borei peri ha-adamah, ve-acharav borei nefashot” (one who chews raw rice blesses “Who creates the fruit of the ground,” and afterward, “Who creates souls”). If it is cooked, one blesses “borei minei mezonot” (Who creates kinds of foods) over it, and afterward “borei nefashot” (Who creates souls), provided it is not mixed with something else and is rice alone. If it is mixed with another cooked dish, then that other dish is the majority, and one says the blessing for that dish.
See what the Taz asks about the words of the author; it is a kushya (difficulty). The Magen Avraham and the Shiyarei Keneset Ha-Gedolah agree with the author. The Eliyah Rabbah adds that even at half and half, one says the blessing for rice, which is borei minei mezonot. That only works when it is chatzi chatzi (half and half). According to this, in our nidon didan (our case), one would apparently bless over the rice with borei minei mezonot and exempt the mixture. If that is the psak (ruling), then, as we said, it depends on the case.
The Chayei Adam writes: “Ye'arev shenei minim she-ein birchoteihem shavim” (if two kinds of food with different blessings are mixed), such as a tree fruit with a ground fruit, “af al pi she-ba litein ta'am holchim achar ha-rov u-mevarech alav” (even if one was added for flavor, we follow the majority and bless over it). This applies specifically when the ingredients are not recognizable. But if each one is recognizable on its own and does not become secondary, one blesses each with its appropriate blessing.
That is the shitah (view) of Ashkenazim. The text continues: if there is something in the mixture that is not nitpal be-einav (secondary in his eyes), then even if most of the mixture is another ingredient, we do not follow the majority; one must bless over each item. That applies to sushi: do not tell me the fish is insignificant because it is a smaller piece. It is important. Take out the fish, and I am not eating that piece. Some people do this; others say nobody acts that way.
However, the Peri Megadim and the Bi'ur Halachah disagree with the words of the Chayei Adam. In Shut Rav Pe'alim, he writes about a rice dish with pieces of meat and ground fruit on it: one should bless over the rice and thereby exempt everything. Either because the rice is primary and the rest is secondary, or because the majority is rice. Notice that he gives both explanations: it is either because rice is the rov (majority) or because rice is the ikar (primary) food.
This is the wording of the Ben Ish Chai: if other kinds of food are mixed together and each one is recognizable on its own, one blesses each with its appropriate blessing. If they are “nitma'achu ve-nidbeku zeh ba-zeh” (they were mashed and stuck together), we follow the majority, because they have become one thing. Seemingly, his words sotrim zeh et zeh (contradict each other): in one case, the rice is more important, and in the other, the ruling in Rav Pe'alim seems to depend on the rice. U-lefi aniyut da'ati (my humble opinion), what Rav Pe'alim wrote is a case where the rice is primary, the rest is secondary, and the majority is also rice. So you have both the majority and the primary ingredient. When you choose rice over salad as a side dish, it may be because you like it or because you are hungry and want to be full. Often you think that if you eat salad with the meat, you will still be hungry.
An unidentified teaching of Maran on muktzeh (set aside) says: “Zeh sheha'adam maktzeh oto mida'ato, kamuvan” (that which a person sets aside in his mind, of course). But that is not how it works: “Ani machlit shezeh muktzeh, az zeh yiheyeh muktzeh, zeh lo kachah. Chazal (the Sages) considered people’s general outlook. For example, a keli shemelachto le'isur (implement used for forbidden work)…”. The question is whether sushi is muktzeh on Shabbat because the fish is raw. The Gemara says it is muktzeh, but today they eat everything, of course.
“Im achal basar vedagim” (if he ate meat and fish).
“Kodem lachen bebeitzah” (before that, with an egg). They make it with pirurei lechem (breadcrumbs) or kemach (flour). “Misaviv lezeh yesh...” (around it there is…). They dip it in an egg, put it in breadcrumbs, and sometimes fry it immediately. “Yesh omrim, kol davar she...” (there are those who say, anything that…).

