A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Gemara Berachot Daf 37b #400 The beracha on sushi part 3

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
January 10, 2024
Duration
23:35
Lecture code
RGK-1111

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

What is the maskanah (conclusion)? Hold on, maskanah is mezonot (grain foods)? Don't eat it. Maskanah is usually we do mezonot. You, I don't know if there's a rov (majority) of, of, of rice, depends on the, on the rice that you do, depends on the place you go. I think the one that makes more sense, I mean, if you understood the rice as a tafel (subordinate food) being shehakol (everything) and not being mezonot, which I think was the Taz, that makes a lot more sense. There's rov, there is the, the, the, you know, the rice. Rov of what? Rov not rice. No, but you have adamah (ground produce) and etz (tree produce), and that's the problem. And you have the ikar (main component). So ikar was fish, right? The tafel is the rice. Why is the ikar the fish? Why? For me it's not the ikar. First of all, it's the most expensive thing. I don't necessarily—like the fish is not the ikar. It's the most expensive doesn't mean that that's the ikar. The most expensive things, the one that gives the taste, the taste, I understand it's the most expensive, but, and it's most of the times it's the rov. Rabbi, the HaShulchan Aruch HaRav holds shehakol on rice, yeah? So for them, well, shehakol if—if you don't have— He says safek mezonot, adamah, shehakol (Doubtful: mezonot, adamah, or shehakol). Right. He says eat one of each outside of the rice and then eat the rice. And but—but if you don't have any of that stuff, you should say shehakol. That was his—his—his thing was—his reason was hagoses? Because you're chewing it and goses, goses. Koses (gnawing), koses. D'A (derech eretz), etc. You'll be koses. The Taz was very interesting shitah (approach). He said rice is mezonot only when it's by itself. If it's with anything else, it becomes shehakol. I didn't get that far. Sevarah (reasoning) we didn't do. Now you have double shehakol. Now you have double shehakol in terms of amount, right? Which definitely is the majority. And that—and it's the ikar. Well, if you consider that to be shehakol. Remember, remember one thing: the basic sushi. But they don't agree with the Taz, don't use that as a—like the concept of sushi doesn't have the carrot and doesn't have the, the, the, the, the avocado. I don't care what the concept— What I'm saying is what you have in your plate now has avocado, cucumber, fish, and rice. I hear you, but what I'm saying is when—when they probably asked somebody, "What's sushi?", is the salmon and the rice with the green on top. The rest of the stuff is we added stuff. You understand? It's more added stuff. So the concept of sushi— Who cares the history of the sushi? I don't care what the history of the sushi is! Now we're here. What I'm saying is for sure it's tafel. Can we agree on the following? For sure it's tafel. Fine. Can we agree that if you buy the volcano sushi that has a lot of crab on top and inside, right, then your rov is the—is the fish, and you don't say anymore mezonot? Mezonot? You have to say shehakol. You know what I'm talking about? Yeah, yeah. The volcano. That—that—that thing is—I mean, every bite you're going to have— Yeah, that's made out of fish. It's made out of fish? It's made out of fish. It has—it has wheat also inside of it. The thing, the volcano thing, it's actually not real crab. Look at the crab. Okay, go with the Green Dragon. No, go with Godzilla roll, which is like a big fish. Imitation crab. Imitation crab. It's imitation shrimp. There's shrimp and crab. Okay, imitation crab, how is it made? They—The kani thing? Surimi. I think so. What's surimi? Surimi is that—is the name—Surimi is—or is surimi, or a white fish flesh that has been deboned and minced into a paste, and then mixed with other ingredients such as natural and artificial flavors, starch, sugar, sodium, eggs. For sure. So that's not mezonot, that's for sure. Huh? That's not mezonot. All right, this is shehakol. That's what I'm saying, if you have the volcano thing that you have a lot of it, or some sometimes you have the fish on top and inside, you have a chance of having of being near the... And by the way, there is the opinion that the adamah, you don't say adamah because it's tafel. No, for sure. The adamah and the ha'etz they are tafel over there, I think for sure. That's for sure. The question is if it's mezonot or if it's shehakol. That's for sure, it's not going into the equation. So now you hump the rice— Oh, we narrow it down to mezonot and shehakol. The rice up by itself, which is shehakol. There's the fish— No, no, no, no, no! You're using a shitah yechidah (single opinion) as that's it, it's like this. No, slow down. We don't hold like this. Hey, slow down, man. Yeah, don't—What is with you? We're not noheg (acting according to custom) like that! Who drives me crazy is the rabbanim (rabbis) who say that. I mean to criticize the—the—the ones who explain to the rabbanim how it's made exactly. According to what? According to what rov? It has to be rov, 51% of the whole thing, which is hard. That's never going to happen. It's hard. Especially the sushis that I buy, they're elaborated. I don't buy the cheap ones. So you're going shehakol. They have a lot of things inside that. So it's—it's If you're going to analyze, you're going to end up going shehakol 99% of the times. Maybe. I think the best way to do it, I'm sorry for saying that, I hate saying that, but— Nah, don't say it. Okay, don't say it. Is first of all, when you go to a restaurant, you're going to drink something, you're going to say shehakol already. Ah, and then you're going to grab a little cracker, you're going to say mezonot. So how about the egg roll, the pastrami egg roll? I'm not kidding now. It's a cover of something, I don't—I don't know what it is. It's wheat, it's wheat. It's wheat, but so little. It's an egg roll. But now that's holding it, and you want to buy it because you want to be save'a (satisfied). I mean, I would think so. I would say it's mezonot, it's like a wrap. Hakol holech achar hama'amid (everything follows what holds it together). Why would you say mezonot there if it's a very thin—Why? What mean not why not? I nachit leh dehana'ah (if he intended it for enjoyment), an egg roll, a pastrami egg roll, whatever, it's a very thin shell. So we're going back now to the schnitzel. For sure. There you go into schnitzel. We're going to schnitzel. No, because the schnitzel was to give a crunch to your chicken. That was always my sevarah that you eat chicken. Here you—No, here you're eating—To the pastrami, you're giving it a crunch. No, there you say kol sheyesh bo (anything that contains). There you say kol sheyesh bo. You're not eating pastrami, you're not eating wheat, you're eating this together. Schnitzel, you're eating chicken. And your chicken, you want it crispy, and you want it with this and you want it with that, it's batel (nullified) to the chicken. Here, you're eating this together. Oh, please. It's like the dayasa (porridge). Go back to the dayasa, kol sheyesh bo mechameshet haminim (anything containing one of the five species), I'm sorry. And then my, my snack. Let's go to my snack. One second. So it has M&Ms, it has cacahuetes de la de adamah. It has peanuts de la de—but they're all separate. del del Del sol. You grab it all—I want to eat them all together. A bar! A bar! Put it all together. A gluten-free bar, okay? But no, no, because the bar you have no option! The bar is integrated. Wait, wait, the bar you don't have an option. It's not a bar, it's a mix. No, it's a mixed bag. It's the same thing! No, like you have maní, you—let's say you have the mix thing. Maní con— So you eat each one separately? Or you—Sometimes I do, what? I grab un esto y me lo meto así. M&M and— So it's like a fruit salad. Fruit salad with—with—Y entra todo ahí dentro. with chocolate, yeah. It's different. Why different? A fruit salad, now with the—with the liquid and everything, they're all mixed, and you can say that the flavors got mixed. But here, you're talking about trail mix. A trail mix, everything is dry. You're eating one thing. Whenever you're eating one thing, okay, hold on, hold on, hold on. Whenever you—If it's separate, the easier to say the berachot (blessings). I understand, but you don't, right? Because you don't, he says he no. He's like me in a restaurant. No, that's for sure. You want to eat them all together. I eat my chicken with my—with my side dish. I don't want to eat the side dish after the—the dessert. You know? That's not derech ha'olam (the way of the world). So it's the same like a bar. But it's not wrong to take one separate—It's not if you like it separately. I—I would be that kind of person. I don't like having all together when it comes to that. This. So I'll take a M&M here, a— That's—that's exactly how I am. Like you tell me, now what if someone who always eat the—the mix? Right, the mix. It's a bowl. Some adamah, some etz. Right. Okay, but I don't like to take the whole thing together. If I do, I'm going to have to say one berachah. Okay, and if you do—You can never say two berachot on one—on one scoop. On one hand, of course not. Good, so if he's always one hand one hand, or generally speaking one hand, so you're going to have to pick one berachah. And you're doing that one hand because of practicality or because of—What difference does it make? No, no, I like it like that. You—you want the—the—the sweet, the sweet and the and the—It also had caramel mou, un poquito así como de—So, usually on those, they say ha'adamah, like the fruit salad, 'cause the fruit salad is the ha'adamah is ha'adamah, the ha'etz, the ha'adamah would cover the ha'etz, so then the poskim (halachic decisors) say do ha'adamah. Y el liquid no fue? What about the chocolate? Shehakol. So, the chocolate, I would say clearly is a very mi'ut (minority), 'cause it's just coming to enhance your things. Bottom line, it's very hard to do berachah on this. One more case would be the—the—the trail bars. They have a little Rice Krispies, bichlal (in general) is a she'eilah (question) if it's mezonot or adamah. That's a whole different story. Adamah? Rice Krispies? Why would it be mezonot, tell me. Sticking together? Rice Krispie because it's rice and it's been popped. Wait, okay, how do you pop rice? I don't know how they do it. Does it become pasty at one point? Probably not. The more pasty, the more difficult it would make it. It's probably—It's more like, like a corn, pop pop, popping. You cannot be a mezonot. So wait, what are they doing? They're grinding that and then making it into—No, it's the rice itself. Rice Krispies the cereal? The cereal? Yeah! It's puffed rice, right? I don't know. How do you pop it? If you put oil, it becomes tahdig. It doesn't become—Becomes what? Tahdig. You know the Persian rice, the—the burnt Tahdig! Tahdig. It's with a k? With a g. G-h or G-A. Tahdig. There's a lady, a girl did it for us many times. Tahdig. It doesn't become that. That's like air. That's nothing. Okay, how do you make Rice Krispies? Can somebody find out, please? It's a halachah lema'aseh (practical halachic) question. You say mezonot. Everybody says mezonot on Rice Krispies, am I wrong? I don't eat Rice Krispies. Everyone eats it. No, but if you would. We eat chocolate—The chocolate ones! You don't say mezonot on that? Tell me, what do you say on those? I haven't eaten that in years. Otra vez. Somebody asks you, your kid—your kid asks you, "What do you say?" Mezonot! People assume that rice is always mezonot. How is Rice Krispies made? They use that now in—in—in cuisines, in actually in—in puffed rice, they rice they use it a little bit as a decoration on sushi. Check what Dirshu has on rice crackers. What does it say? I don't remember, but it's there. It's there on Dirshu, the rice crackers, if you want to look at it. Yeah, yeah, I want to look at it. Ah, here. Rice and sugar paste. Oh, rice and sugar paste that is formed into rice shape or berries, cooked, then dried, and toasted. No, Rice Krispies. Yeah, that's Rice Krispies. Puffed, puffed. It's puffed. Puffed, puffed, puffed rice, puffed, thank you. Puffed grains of rice. No, o sea, los dos van, pero separados. Actually, Rice Krispies are made of crisp rice, which is rice and sugar paste that is formed into rice shapes or berries. So it's not even rice! So, probably if there's enough mani... Mani? Money where? There's no money where. In the building, there's a lot of money. And that guy buys buildings. We can solve it quickly. Bring a sandwich in. Enough money for everyone, what? We got Chewy, we got Chewy and Nutty for us. At the end of the day, it all comes down to money. Tov, le'inyanenu (Well, as for our topic). So ha'adamah, you go for ha'adamah. If there's enough, I would say ha'adamah, because ha'adamah covers the other one, but if clearly like the ones that we had at night, which is all ha'etz except maybe you have five peanuts... I'll bring it tomorrow and you can make a determination. Shulchan Aruch (Code of Jewish Law) in these halachot (laws), he's the only halachot left and right it tells you, you shouldn't do this, you—This morning in the halachah (law) I read—I read the halachah, you weren't here yet. He says—The—The Mishnah Berurah comes and said, "Everybody is cholek (disagrees) on the Shulchan Aruch. Yerei Shamayim (one who fears Heaven), don't do that." Just don't eat breads that have a little bit of wheat and other—you know, you take potato bread, for example, what's called potato bread here in Publix, whatever, and it's like a nice percentage of wheat, which is that it's not all wheat. So they have potato starch also with it. What's the problem? What's the halachah? What's the—What's the berachah? You don't want to say ha'motzi (Who brings forth bread). If you didn't eat a kezayit (olive-sized amount) of wheat betoch kedei achilat peras (within the time to eat a half-loaf), what berachah achronah (after-blessing) do you say? I want to say—You don't say. Safek berachot lehakel (when in doubt about blessings, be lenient). It's a huge problem. No, but you do have enough money? You go to Entebbe. Why al hamichyah? I'm fine. And if not—And if not, I'll still give him berachot and I'll get enough money. No, no, no, you still need a kezayit of dough. So do ha'motzi. No, that's always to do—Yeah, why not? If you're holding that still the dough's still kezayit. Why do you hold kezayit? Because your dough is half wheat and half—but if you have two of them, you probably have enough there to make—No, I'm giving you a case. Shulchan Aruch tells you the case, if you ate a kezayit of that mixture betoch kedei achilat peras, which means I don't know whose foot, but sorry whoever it is. It looks like it was yours, I don't really see. You understand? So you have half a kezayit of wheat betoch kedei achilat peras. What berachah achronah do you say? Can leave it to someone. So al hamichyah you can't, because half of it is not dagan. Birkat Hamazon, of course not. And shehakol—and Borei Nefashot, only if you consider that you could—that you could combine half a kezayit plus half a kezayit. It's a big problem. Shulchan Aruch says al hamichyah. Nobody understands why. I understand. They don't want to say—No, everyone explains. Why he says al hamichyah, it's a big problem. He says ha'motzi—No, he says ha'motzi. If it tastes like bread, you say ha'motzi and then al hamichyah. Mishnah Berurah says, "Where do you find in halachah you start ha'motzi and you say al hamichyah? Doesn't exist. You say ha'motzi, you say Birkat Hamazon. If you're not going to say Birkat Hamazon, you don't say ha'motzi." It makes no sense. And you don't have a kezayit of that, so you shouldn't be saying any berachah achronah. So that it's—it's a balagan (mess). So what Mishnah Berurah always said, "Yerei Shamayim, don't eat that. You wash on another bread, then you eat that, because you can't, it's a safek gadol me'od (a very great doubt)." We don't understand. So it's full of that. In Hilchot Berachot (Laws of Blessings), it's the only halachot that really Shulchan Aruch and the poskim left and right they tell—Don't do this, don't do that, wash, do... Here—Here we saw in the sushi, even washing is not a solution. Right. Tough. That's a big—Well, that's doubtful.