This chacham (sage) is trying to bring a re'ayah (proof) for his point. His point was that when you repurpose a piece of bread, as long as the piece retains a kezayit (olive-sized portion), it is hamotzi (the blessing over bread), even if you have repurposed it. If it is less— But wait: you do not have to go through all the lists of food. He brings a re'ayah from the korban minchah (meal offering). At one point, you make the minchah into ptitim (crumbs). I think the pasuk (verse) says, “patot otah” (break it into pieces). What are ptitim? You crush it. How large does each piece have to be? It says they have to be a kezayit. Since the Mishnah in Menachot says they have to be a kezayit for the offering to be a korban minchah, that is his re'ayah that, to retain its status as bread, it cannot be crumbs. They used to smear it with oil, and so on. That is why it keeps its status only if it is a kezayit.
We had a little bit of a problem with this on two counts. First, I said that this is our sugya, but it is not really our sugya. The question is: what is the case in which something is hamotzi? According to the Shulchan Aruch psak (halachic ruling), there seems to be no minchah that would be hamotzi. We opened the list of menachot (meal offerings). There are four kinds of minchah: minchat machavat (griddle meal offering), minchat ma'afeh (baked meal offering), minchat marcheshet (deep-pan meal offering), and another one. They are all made with solet (fine flour), oil, and water. But there is enough oil in the ingredients that the bread would be mezonot (the mezonot blessing). The last one, minchat ma'afeh, seems to be baked first and then smeared with oil. That would be fine: if it was already bread, then it is hamotzi. The only other thing is that even that bread, if I am correct—I have to double-check—is matzah (unleavened bread). There is no bread in the Beit HaMikdash (Temple). The only bread in the Beit HaMikdash is lachmei todah (thanksgiving offering loaves). Even the lechem hapanim (showbread) is matzah. I know everybody thinks it is fluffy, like baker's bread. But it is matzot, “lechem oni” (bread of affliction). Then there was no miracle of it staying fresh for seven days. I still have matzot from two years ago. They tell you that you slice the bread and there is still smoke coming out of it. So, I think lachmei todah is the only one that is chametz (leavened bread). The rest is all— So when they talk about making hamotzi— What were we talking about, then? What does it mean when it says that the— And warm matzah— What were we talking about?
I claim that the only thing that was chametz in the entire Beit HaMikdash was lachmei todah. Maybe the two loaves of Shavuot (Feast of Weeks), I am not sure. Shavuot is actually leavened bread. The lechem hapanim is matzah. The Shtei HaLechem (the two loaves) are leavened. So that is it; there is no more. All I am saying is that, according to the Shulchan Aruch, there is no minchah that is ever hamotzi, according to our minhag (custom). Three are full of oil, so they are mezonot, as we saw yesterday. The one that is like a cracker is matzah. Actually, all of them are matzah. That is it. You do not even have to get to the oil. How does the Shitah Mekubetzet (Collected Method) answer that question? First, let us start with that. Rashi has a problem anyway, so forget about the matzah for a minute. Rashi says more than one, and he talks about not minchat ma'afeh, but about the minchah offerings on a griddle and in a deep pan, before the kemitzah, when they are returned to their flour. Those two are made with oil: flour and olive oil, and a little bit of water. The Mishnah in Menachot says, “Netalan le'echol, omer hamotzi lechem min ha'aretz.” The Shitah Mekubetzet brings another perush (commentary), which is not like Rashi: “Hame'ora b'minchat ma'afeh tanur u'vahen ra'ui levarech hamotzi, aval b'minchat machavat u'marcheshet, kol shehu al yedei mashkeh lo chashiv pat.” They were fried. “V'lo mevarchin hamotzi aleha k'dimochach b'Pesachim.” In Pesachim, when we make hamotzi on matzah at Pesach (Passover), would that be equivalent to the same matzot they would bring as one of the offerings, as a minchah? Maybe you could say that at that particular time it is called lechem (bread). It is called lechem. So perhaps in the Beit HaMikdash it is called their lechem. But that was a special time, Pesach, because it was lechem oni. The point is that it is a time. Why would you take that and put it throughout the Beit HaMikdash all year? If that is the lechem of the Beit HaMikdash, what is so special about Pesach? Not in the Beit HaMikdash, ein hachi nami (indeed, so). So at the end of the day, you always have Pesach. Not about having Pesach; it is about that being the lechem of the Beit HaMikdash. At the end of the day, it is about what people call lechem and what they do not call lechem.
Do you make a meal out of matzah these days? There is a machloket (dispute): the Ashkenazim do, and some Sephardim (Sephardi Jews) do too. They say hamotzi all year long; we do not. I think some Sephardim do. I think Rav Benaim had a whole discussion about that. He makes hamotzi. He said he went to Harav Ovadia and asked him, “Do you really say hamotzi or not?” Harav Ovadia told him, “Okay, fine, hamotzi.” So he said, “I got Harav Ovadia; he said you do hamotzi on matzah.” When Rav David Yosef was here, I asked him, “What does Father say on matzah?” He said his father says mezonot. I said, “But Rav Benaim said he asked him and he said hamotzi.” He said that Rav Benaim made his father so crazy that he told him, “Okay, fine,” and then he did mezonot. Rav Benaim insisted that Harav Ovadia said hamotzi, hamotzi, hamotzi, but Rav David Yosef said, “No, my father did mezonot.” Rav Benaim said, “Yeah, I remember. After 20 years of making him crazy about matzah being hamotzi, he said, ‘Okay, fine, hamotzi.’ And then he turned around.” You have to be careful when you quote a chacham. You have to know the context.
We are stuck here. We have to look for what was chametz in the Beit HaMikdash. There was a very limited amount. I think it was lachmei todah and the loaves of Shavuot. All the rest was matzah, as I remember. Even the loaves of the week—what are the Shabbat loaves called? Lachma ba'ajin. What are the Shabbat loaves called in the Beit HaMikdash? Lechem hapanim. I think lechem hapanim is also matzah. It is not lechem; it is cake. Where can we find this? I do not know, but there must be a Rambam or something. Yesterday we started looking at what is chametz and what is not. I think there is a source here. Maybe in hilchot (laws of) korbanot. I asked ChatGPT. Or ask Google. No, ChatGPT is am ha'aretz (ignoramus). Don't do ChatGPT. Better Google than ChatGPT. ChatGPT is am ha'aretz. I tried a few times. But it's still good for the basics. In Torah? No.
I found it. There is a pasuk, “lo te'afeh chametz.” Here it is: “Kol hamenachot hane'efot niloshot befoshrin umeshamran shelo yachmitzu.” All the baked minchah offerings are kneaded with warm water and guarded so that they do not become chametz. There is no chametz in a minchah. If you make the lechem hapanim chametz, you get malkot (lashes). It says: “Hamechametz lechem hapanim, lokeh.” The lechem hapanim is not chametz; if you make it chametz, you get malkot. It says, “kol haminchah.” “Aval minchat nesachim (libation meal offering) ein bah malkot, she'im giblah bemayim harei nifselah kodem she-titchametz, ve'im giblah beshemen shel nesachim mei peirot hen ve-einam machmitzim.” There is no such thing. In fact, you're saying you weren't even allowed to make it chametz. Right? No, if you made it chametz, it is pasul (invalid).
There are three formulas in the Beit HaMikdash. One is like matzah: wheat and water. One is flour and oil. One is flour, oil, and water. With water and flour, you have to be careful that it does not become chametz. What is that? Lechem hapanim. You have to be very careful with lechem hapanim. There is also one minchah like that, the baked minchah we saw. But when you make it, it says it is asur (forbidden) to make it chametz. Then you have the lechem that comes with the offerings. There is no water in that; it is different. It is like a cracker. It is made with flour and olive oil. It comes out like Bukharian bread, big and dome-shaped. If there is no water, perhaps it becomes very thin. The third formula is a mixture of all three: oil, water, and flour. If you made it with water, it is pasul; that is not the formula. If you made it with oil, there is no chametz, so it is fine. So the original question about patot otah, making it into ptitim and retaining a kezayit, has no legs. The original question was about retaining a kezayit, but there was no bread to begin with. What hamotzi? There is no hamotzi there. We just saw that the minchat ma'afeh is matzah. According to the Shulchan Aruch, if it is hard like a cracker, it is mezonot. Maybe we will find a teirutz (answer), but first I want to clarify whether we are right.
According to the Shulchan Aruch, perhaps the matzah in the Beit HaMikdash was not like a cracker. Maybe it was like Yemenite matzah, the soft kind. If it is not a cracker, perhaps that is why you can say hamotzi on it. It is bread that did not rise, but it is still bread. According to the Shulchan Aruch, do you know how thick your matzah could be? One tefach (handbreadth). The Shulchan Aruch gives that as a shi'ur (measure). You could have a matzah a tefach thick. It means it is a bread. You could put down a lot of dough and not let it rise; it would be very chewy. It would clearly be heavy, but soft. It cannot be hard if it is that thick and did not rise. Wait, you can let it rise for up to 18 minutes, right? So you let it go for like 12-13 minutes, then put it in the oven. That might be way too thick already. The ones we eat that are soft are like this, max, a little bit heavier. It's a pound each almost. Maybe that could be an answer. I just want to make sure we have clarified what is chametz in the Beit HaMikdash. So far, no minchah is chametz. The Shulchan Aruch says the Rambam said, “Kol hamenachot hakerevot legabei hamizbe'ach matzah.” That would be the answer: Yemenite matzot. We will discuss it.
“Vechol shirei hamenachot she'ochlin hakohanim (priests), af al pi shehem mutarin le'echol otan bechol ma'achal uvidvash, ein ochlin otan chametz.” You could eat them with blintzes, but not with chametz. The achilat shirei hamenachot (eating the remaining offerings)—whatever is left from the minchah offerings—has to be kasher lePesach (kosher for Passover). “Shene'emar, lo te'afeh chametz chelkam. Afilu chelkam lo yachmitzu. Ve'im hechmitz shireha, lokeh.” If he made some of the remaining portions chametz, he gets malkot. “Vehamachmitz achar hamachmitz chayav. Velokin al kol asiyah va'asiyah shebah. Keitzad? Lashah chametz, o archah chametz, o katafah chametz, o afyah chametz, lokeh.” Any process that you did with chametz, he gets malkot. “Shene'emar lo ta'aseh chametz, ven'emar lo te'afeh chametz, lechayev al kol ma'aseh yachid shebah. Asiyat chametz mitechilah ve'ad sof, lokeh al kol ma'aseh mehen.” It was Pesach year-round for the priests in the Temple. “Hini'ach se'or (leaven) al gabei ha'isah, vehalach veyashav lo, venitchamtzah me'eleha, lokeh, shehanachat hase'or hu ma'aseh.” You cannot say, “I did not do anything; I let it rise.” That is your action. You get malkot. “Tibel hashirayim beketzaḥ uv'shumshamin uvechol minei tavlin ushmanim, kesherah. Matzah hi ela shenikret matzah metubelet.” He dipped the remaining portions in ketzaḥ, uv'shumshamin, and every kind of tavlin and ushmanim; it is valid. It is matzah, but called dipped matzah. “Hamachmitz minchah pesulah, patur, because it's pesulah. Shene'emar asher takrivu l'Hashem lo ta'aseh chametz. Hakesherah l'Hashem, lo hapesulah. Chamtzah kshehi kesherah, veyatzat lachutz, lokeh. Hamachmitz lechem hapanim, lokeh, shene'emar kol haminchah.” If he makes a valid minchah chametz, he is liable, but if it is invalid, he is exempt. So the lechem hapanim is also considered a minchah.
I do not know how you are going to resolve the pictures in the books about Pesach. The Yemenite matzot are big and fluffy, and have a shape. They say they were very soft and nice. “Aval minchat nesachim ein bah malkot. She'im giblah bemayim, harei nifselah, kemo shenitba'er.” That is what he is saying. “Hachitim shel menachot ein lotetim otan shema yachmitzu.” You cannot even rinse the wheat for the offerings, lest it become chametz. Remember letitah (soaking)? We learned that in Hilchot Pesach (Laws of Passover) in the afternoon. “Ve'ein hakol zerizin leshomran.” You can rinse them, but you have to dry them right away. If you do not, you have a problem. “Aval minchat ha'omer (omer meal offering), ho'il vehi shel tzibur lotetin otah shehatzibur zerizin hem umeshamrin otah.” You mean minchat ha'omer is a barley matzah? “Kol hamenachot hane'efot, niloshot befoshrin, umeshamran shelo yachmitzu. Ho'il velishtan va'afiyatan bifnim ba'azarah (Temple courtyard), anshei fanim zerizin hen.” They were less worried because kneading and baking took place inside the azarah, and the people there were careful. “Uvimkom shemevashlin kodshei kodashim, sham ofin et hamenachot, shene'emar zeh hamakom asher— blah blah blah.” All the minchah offerings are ground and sifted outside, and kneaded and baked inside. All their procedures are valid when done by a non-priest, until they reach the kemitzah. The griddle and deep pan were in the azarah; both were sacred vessels, and the Temple oven was made of metal.
Now, which one is chametz? Again, I am not sure, but I think it is the arba'im lachmei todah (forty thanksgiving loaves). I think those were chametz, but I am not sure. So far, everything is kasher lePesach all year round, except for Shavuot and lachmei todah. Let us look for the lachmei todah. I found WikiMikdash. It says that the thanksgiving offering is accompanied by 40 loaves of bread. Specifically, 30 of those loaves are matzah, while 10 are chametz. The pasuk says, “V'zot torat zevach hashlamim asher yakriv l'Hashem” (This is the law of the peace offering that one offers to Hashem), and, “im al todah yakrivenu v'hikriv al zevach hatodah chalot matzot belulot bashemen urkikei matzot” (If he offers it as a thanksgiving offering, he shall offer with it unleavened loaves mixed with oil and wafers of unleavened bread). Then it says, “al chalot lechem chametz yakriv korbano al zevach todot shlamav” (With loaves of leavened bread he shall offer his offering with the sacrifice of his thanksgiving peace offerings). “V'hikriv mimenu echad mikol korban terumah l'Hashem.” So 10 of them are chametz, and 30 are matzah.
What are these 40 loaves? The korban todah comes with 40 loaves: 30 are matzah and 10 are chametz. How do they eat them? The ones that are not chametz cannot be made chametz, so they probably eat them separately. The leftovers have to be split. The offering was eaten by everyone anyway; they could give it to people. The Shtei HaLechem come only from the land and from the new crop, as it says, “mimoshvoteichem tavi'u.” There is a discussion about wheat that came down in clouds: “Chitim sheyardu be'avim im yesh lahem safek, keitzad hayu osim?” The two loaves from the new crop have to come from an isaron (tenth of an ephah) per se'ah. They knead them together outside and bake them inside, like all the minchah offerings, “v'einan dochot.” “Erev Yom Tov ein mepaglin oto ... B'kitzur, az mevi se'or mimakom acher venotno letoch ha'isaron. Umeruba'ot hen.” Then it says, “Hal'chamim haba'im al korban hatodah vehilchoteihem.” The loaves that come with the thanksgiving offering and their laws: the 40 loaves are divided into chametz and matzah. Ten are leavened loaves and 30 are matzah. The matzah is divided into three kinds: baked loaves, wafers, and rekikim. They give one loaf of each kind to the priest, so the priest receives four loaves. The priest waves the four loaves given to him together with the portions, the breast, and the thigh, and then he goes home and eats them with his family. So we have only two kinds of chametz: the lachmei todah and the loaves of Shavuot. That is it. All the rest in the Beit HaMikdash is kasher lePesach.
Rashi is still a big problem, because he is talking about the two minchah offerings that are pure oil. How do you say hamotzi on that? It is impossible. Maybe they all come at the same time; maybe there is a time when you bring the matzah-style ones separately. I have no idea how you bring them. The todah comes with 40 breads. The offering is meat. They make a sandwich. For the Shitah Mekubetzet, we are good: soft Teimanim (Yemenite Jews) matzah. For Rashi, we have a problem. The Shitah Mekubetzet does not mention Rashi; it just gives its own perush. What is the problem with Rashi? He talks specifically about the two minchah offerings, marcheshet and machavat. They are not smeared with oil; the recipe is oil and solet. But we are talking about pieces of a kezayit. If you are kove'a se'udah (establishes a meal), that is it. Even if the pieces are less than a kezayit, you have to say Birkat HaMazon (Grace After Meals). But frying is another issue. Fried, you don't do. With Sufganiyot (doughnuts), you can eat 500 and it still is not hamotzi. What are you talking about? It is fried. Maybe he has his own shitah. We have to find out, because here we have a problem. I said I'm not sure. I'm not a big baki (expert) in hilchot menachot.
Do you want to do Rabbeinu Yonah? I do not know if he will bring it, because Rabbeinu Yonah usually explains halachah (Jewish law), and this is in discovery of halachah. I would doubt it. But let us see. “Chaf-Zayin amud bet” (27th folio, side b): “Hai chavitza (crumb mixture), i it bah pirurin (crumbs) kezayit, mevarech alav lechem min ha'aretz veshalosh berachot (blessings). Ve'i leit bah pirurin kezayit, mevarech alav bore mine mezonot (Who creates various kinds of food) uvesof berachah achat me'ein shalosh (one blessing summarizing three).” If the chavitza has crumbs the size of a kezayit, he says hamotzi and the three blessings. If it does not have crumbs the size of a kezayit, he says bore mine mezonot, followed at the end by berachah achat me'ein shalosh. “VeRav Sheshet amar: Afilu pirurin she'ein bahem kezayit, mevarachim aleihem hamotzi.” Rav Sheshet says that even if the crumbs are not the size of a kezayit, one says hamotzi over them. “Amar Rava: Vehu de'ika aleih torita denahama.” Rava says this applies when torita denahama—you could see it's bread. “VeHilcheta...” Let us see whether Rabbeinu Yonah discusses the point we were trying to understand.
“Hai chavitza metuganim bidvash.” Chavitza is crumbs from bread fried with honey. It is already pat (bread), so that is different. “VeRav Yosef savira leih de'i it bah pirurin kezayit mevarech alav HaMotzi uvesof shalosh berachot, ve'i leit leih pirurin kezayit mevarech alav bore mine mezonot...” No. He explains Rav Yosef as saying that when the pieces remain intact, one says hamotzi if they are the size of a kezayit. That means they have a kezayit and are therefore considered important. But how can you say they fry it after it becomes bread? That is the baked one; the other ones are made before. We need to check. “Kasheh, heich yachol lomar liket mikol hamenachot kezayit chametz, vahalo hamenachot kulan lo hayu ba'in ela matzah chutz mishtei halechem bilvad? Ve'od, sheheich yachol lomar im matzah hu adam yotzeh bah yedei chovato (fulfills his obligation) bePesach, veha tenan...” I do not know; go up about 15 lines from “leficach.” “Peresh Rashi z"l deliket mikulan kezayit, hamenachot ka'e.” He means that if someone gathered a kezayit of chametz from all the minchah offerings and ate it, even though it came from many offerings, he is liable for karet. If it is matzah, even though it came from many offerings, it combines to the measure of a kezayit and exempts him from the obligation to eat matzah. But that cannot be right. How could someone gather a kezayit of chametz from all the minchah offerings when all the minchah offerings were matzah, except for the Shtei HaLechem? There is another question about the chiyuv karet (liability for excision). If you ate a kezayit from all the minchah offerings together, you would be liable for karet—but that is not possible, because they are all matzah, except for the Shtei HaLechem. “Ve'od, sheheich yachol lomar im matzah hu, adam yotzeh bah yedei chovato (fulfills his obligation) bePesach, veha amrinan ‘bechol moshvoteichem tochlu matzot,’ matzah hane'echelet bechol makom, adam yotzeh bah yedei chovato, aval matzah she'einah ne'echelet bechol moshvoteichem, ein adam yotzeh bah yedei chovato bePesach. Umenachot lo hayu ne'echalim bechol chutz miYerushalayim.” So it is not eaten in all your dwellings; he would not fulfill his obligation with it on Pesach. “Ela vadai lo ka'e amenachot, ela achameshet haminim (five species).” He disagrees with Rashi. He means that if someone gathered a kezayit of chametz from the five species on Pesach and ate it, he is liable for karet. Do not say that he is liable only if he ate a kezayit of one species; even a kezayit made up of all five species combines. Likewise, if he ate a kezayit of matzah on Pesach made up of pieces from the different species, they combine, and he fulfills his obligation.
“Ve'im kedivrei Rashi shemefaresh chavitza al yedei tigun (frying) be'ilpas...” The chavitza is made by frying. Here the question is: “Mai ka parich... Abaye le-Rav Yosef, de-ha chamirei she-liket mikulan perurin ketanim ve-ein bahen kezayit, ve-lifichach ameru she-yotzin bahen me-achilat Pesach u-mevarech aleihem hamotzi she-me'achar she-yotzin be-achilat matzah vadai de-yotzin bah u-mevarech aleihem hamotzi. Aval le-Rav Yosef lo airi ela be-davar she-hu mevushal ve-lifichach sevira leh she-im ein perurin kezayit eino mevarech alav hamotzi.” So he disagrees completely with Rashi. Everybody is pointing out the problems with Rashi, as we did. “Ve-lifichach nir'eh she-ha-perush ha-nachon hu kemo she-pirshu Rabbeinu Hai Gaon ve-Rav Natan Baal Ha-Aruch,” that chavitza is made by taking crumbs and joining them with honey or soup, without cooking them at all. Rav Yosef holds that if the crumbs do not add up to a kezayit, even if they were joined together, one does not say hamotzi over them. Abaye challenged him with the teaching that if someone gathered a kezayit from all the offerings, if it is chametz he is liable for karet, and if it is matzah he fulfills his obligation on Pesach. The question is about whether the pieces were baked together. If the crumbs of matzah combine to make a kezayit, even if each crumb is smaller, it is still hamotzi and he fulfills his obligation. “Ve-hashta parich shapir, she-kemo she-zeh belo bishul (cooking) u-mevarachim alav, hu hadin nami chavitza, keivan she-ein sham bishul, ela chibur (joining) be-alma she-mechabrim otam be-ke'arah im devash o im ha-marak, it lan le-meimar af al pi she-ein ba-perurim kezayit mevarech alav hamotzi.” The question is whether you need cooking to transform the pieces. He says you need only a joining; the joining does not change their nature. Therefore, it should be hamotzi, since you fulfill the obligation on Pesach with pieces of matzah that combine to a kezayit, even if each piece is smaller.
So do not say that a piece of bread smaller than a kezayit is mezonot. Many people make that mistake. There is no such thing. “Al ken nir'eh le-mori ha-rav (my revered teacher) nero she-sheloshah dinim chalukim hen.” There are three different halachot. First: “Heicha she-hu mevushal, im yesh bo bi-ferusot kezayit, mevarech aleihem hamotzi ve-shalosh berachot.” If it is cooked and the pieces are a kezayit, one says hamotzi and the three blessings. You take bread and make French toast; you have repurposed it. If the pieces are a kezayit, it is hamotzi and the three blessings. “Ve-im ein ba-perusot kezayit, af al pi de-mechzei de-ika aleih torita denahama, eino mevarech alav ela borei minei mezonot.” If you make tiny pieces of French toast, even though you can see it is bread, you say only borei minei mezonot. Since it has been cooked again, it loses its to'ar lechem—you can see it's bread. It is the same with croutons that are fried and seasoned. Second: “Ve-heicha she-eino mevushal ela she-hu mechubar al yedei devash, o marak belo shum bishul, im yesh ba-perusot kezayit mevarech alav hamotzi.” If it has not been cooked, but is joined with honey or soup, and the pieces are a kezayit, one says hamotzi. “Ein ba-perusot kezayit ve-ein bahem to'ar lechem mevarech aleihem borei minei mezonot.” If the pieces are not a kezayit and do not look like bread, one says borei minei mezonot. “Aval im yesh bahem to'ar lechem, af al pi she-ein bahem kezayit, mevarech aleihem hamotzi.” But if they still look like bread, even if they are not a kezayit, one says hamotzi. Imagine throwing little pieces of bread into soup. If you leave them for a long time, they become very mushy and melt; it depends on the bread, but you can still see it. Third: “Ve-heicha she-eino lo mevushal ve-lo mechubar, ela perurin levadam, af al pi she-ein bahem kezayit ve-ein bahen to'ar lechem she-hem dakim be-yoter, mevarech alav hamotzi ve-shalosh berachot.” If they have not been cooked or joined, but are just very fine crumbs, one says hamotzi and the three blessings. “She-keivan she-hu pat bifnei atzmo, eino yotzei le-olam mi-torat pat.” Since it is bread by itself, it never loses its status as bread. You have to remove it from torat pat (status as bread), either by cooking it—in which case the kezayit matters—or by joining it, in which case the appearance of bread matters. Otherwise, even over every little crumb, you have to say hamotzi.
So Rashi is very difficult; everybody disagrees with him. We still have to understand what he said. We skipped ahead from the sugya to Rabbeinu Yonah. Maybe we should go back to the sugya. At least we clarified the chametz and all that. Now you can tell people that in the Beit HaMikdash there was no chametz, except for the Shtei HaLechem and the ten loaves of the todah. He does not mention the ten loaves of the todah. That is interesting. He says “except for the Shtei HaLechem” because he is discussing minchah offerings. The ten loaves of the todah accompany the todah, which is a kodashim kalim (lesser sanctity offerings). That is why. It wasn't even eaten there. The owner eats the todah, not the priest. He could give it to people. They give one of each of the four loaves to the priest, and 36 to the owner, who can give them to his mishpucheh (family). We will have to go back to this sugya tomorrow. “Amar leih Abaye.” Turn it around here. Fine, beseder (all right).

