What I find so far is that it isn’t necessary for you to dip the bread; these are things that are customary. It’s not ikar v’tafel—if you put it this way, it’s much easier. It’s not ikar v’tafel; it’s—
Please, Puker, no. The hitam ofsi. The Gemara has various sayings. What item in the middle of your meal do you need to say a Beracha (blessing) for? We had the opinions of Rav Huna, Rav Sheshet, and, I don’t know, Rabbi Chiya. That is the one who says—except we’re trying to define what that item is, the one that comes in the middle of the meal. We said that what’s inside the meal isn’t included in the—. We said that the ill hit the end of the Gemara. So what might be the exception to that? We’re trying to define it. No, there was a difference between the fruits and the—
The problem is that with fruit, there’s a makhloket (dispute) about whether you say a Beracha acharona (after-blessing) on it. Both agree that you say a Beracha rishona (before-blessing)—not Rabbi Chiya, but the first two agree that it’s a Beracha rishona. The makhloket is whether you say a Beracha acharona. But with pat haba’ah bekisnin (pastry), everybody agrees that it gets a Beracha rishona and not a Beracha acharona.
What’s the difference? I think that’s where the Rosh comes in and says it’s certainly no different from Rashi. Rashi is hard, hard to understand. We already said that Tosafot disagree with Rashi. The Rosh is in the same line as Tosafot, but different.
We spoke about ikar v’tafel. Don’t look at it as ikar v’tafel. What did he say about ikar v’tafel? He said to dismiss it; he dismissed it immediately. If it were ikar v’tafel, then you would have to eat it with the bread. I can’t say it’s ikar v’tafel if you eat it by itself. You’re talking about something more like an appetizer. My main course, I’m not eating with the bread. Why is that ikar v’tafel? How is that ikar v’tafel when you’re not eating it with the bread? Think of carpaccio, or drinks. The drinks bring the meal, the tafel (secondary item) to the meal. How is that tafel? Tafel means I’m eating two things together and saying one Beracha. I have a cracker and Baba Ganoush on top; that’s ikar v’tafel. Now I want to eat Baba Ganoush by itself—is that ikar v’tafel? No, that’s not ikar v’tafel.
Why can’t you look at a meal as a whole? That’s what it does. So it’s not ikar v’tafel. That’s not the Lacham. That’s not how ikar v’tafel works. Don’t look at ikar v’tafel as ikar (primary item) and tafel, just the words. The sugya (Talmudic discussion) of ikar v’tafel is not that. The sugya of ikar v’tafel is mevarech al ha-ikar u’potter et ha-tafel (One blesses the primary item and exempts the secondary item). You’re eating together. You’re eating a meal, but together, like chicken with rice.
Go back to the pasta. The pasta is not tafel to the bread. It just isn’t, because you don’t eat pasta with bread. With chicken and rice, if you eat them separately, you always have two Berachot. The way I do it is that sometimes they’re not together, but mainly they are. Here, they’re never together. You don’t say, “I’m going to eat some pasta without the bread, but the rest of the pasta…” What are you talking about? You never eat pasta with bread, and you’re not going to eat pasta with bread. A crouton? How is that tafel to the bread? That’s not true. That’s the main point of the Rosh. This isn’t just true at this time: bread is still—bread is always going to be the bread. I don’t want to use that word, because it takes you back to that. Find another word. Call it the Rosh; call it the king of the seudah (meal). Call it the Melech (king). Don’t call it ikar. Even if at some point it ceases to exist—if the bread itself is gone.
That’s a great example of what you just said. Let’s say you start eating that way, and you don’t want to eat like an animal lately. We try to do this in my house. Let’s say my wife and I decide to have a Friday night with nobody—just run. I’m not going to break the whole challenge. Let’s have a pizza. How long does it take to eat half a pizza? I want to do the cause. I eat the way halakha (Jewish law) does: I eat my half of a pizza in three minutes. Done. For the next hour, I’m not touching bread. That’s not the carpet. I’m not touching the bread. It’s the king. The bread is the king.
We said you open a bracket and close it with Birkat Hamazon (Grace after meals). Anything in there belongs to that bracket. I see it now: it’s not—you covered that thing. You’re getting together. I’m writing nothing together. I finished my bread in two minutes. There’s nothing left. You just said there’s nothing left. Great, perfect. That’s the point of the Rosh.
My doctor Tommy you have to move backtrack. Three lines. Meaning, at the same time—not together, not in front of them, in front of you. What is the meaning of—? Maybe you should get the other one, the one you had yesterday, the big one. It doesn’t come—
Does it mean “as a result of”? No. Mechamat means, “I went to a dinner because you were going.” That’s mechamat. It’s like, “Hey, Ronnie, are you going to that wedding?” “Yeah, you are?” “Okay, I’m going to come mechamat you.” Here’s the driver.
So mechamat ha-seudah (because of the meal): it’s true that I ate my apple because it was mealtime. I eat apples at the end of the meal, during the meal, whatever, but it’s not connected to the meal. Actually, the opposite: I eat apples whenever. Apples aren’t connected to my sandwich. The apple didn’t come because of the seudah. It just happened to be betoch ha-seudah (within the meal). I put it within this bracket, but it didn’t come because of the meal. It didn’t come to enhance my seudah. It’s not a pickle or coleslaw put on the side of your burger. You’re not eating it together; you’re eating it before, in the middle, or after.
That’s mechamat ha-seudah: because you’re having the burgers, therefore you’re having the coleslaw. It’s mechamat ha-seudah within the seudah. It’s not mechamat ha-seudah with an apple. What does the apple have to do with it? It just happened to be betoch ha-seudah.
Piresh Rashi (Rashi explained): He’s saying any side dishes—kruv (cabbage) is, uh, spinach, teradin (spinach), beats. She didn’t have any lafet. It is not coming to enhance the bread for a small bread because he said he carried that well, right? The hamlet. Rashi is different. He’s quoting Rashi; he’s not going to go along with that. These are side dishes. They’re not coming to enhance the bread. They’re for food. You eat them as part of the meal to get full. It’s hard to define; that’s what we’re trying to do. That’s not our sugya at all. That’s ikar v’tafel.
For Rashi, all these side dishes are for sova (fullness), but they’re not there to make the pat (bread). For Rashi, you would say a lot of Berachot during a meal. If you have French fries, you say borei peri ha-adama (Who creates fruit of the earth). You don’t say al ha-mechia (for sustenance), because bread is quintessential. Bread itself is defining. You have to make your bread. Rashi’s framework is ikar v’tafel: replace bread with rice, with bread as the ikar. The tafel is what enhances the bread. Your pasta isn’t enhancing the bread. Your rice isn’t enhancing the bread. Your side dish isn’t enhancing the bread. Therefore, you have to say a Beracha on every one of those, even if it’s in the seudah. He’s a bulldozer. Why not? According to this, according to Rashi.
It depends. If you always eat your olives with bread because you want to enjoy your bread with the taste of olive, then you don’t say a Beracha. That’s the answer to your question; it’s not a blank statement. If you want to eat the olives by themselves, then you say a Beracha. If you want to eat them to make your bread a better experience, then you don’t. That’s Rashi. It’s the same with the salad and all that stuff. What’s interesting is that according to Rashi, it makes no difference whether it’s bread or something else. Replace bread with rice and it’s the same thing, the same sugya. If you say a Beracha on the rice and you’re eating olives with the rice, you would not say a Beracha on the olives.
The only difference is that we’re talking about bread because Birkat Hamazon is a bulldozer; it takes care of everything according to Rav Huna. That’s why we’re talking about bread. According to Rashi, there’s no such thing as bread being more chashuv (important) than rice if we’re discussing ikar v’tafel. Under the ikar, you could have many things on the tafel, including bread. By the way, the Rosh says it’s impossible to conceive that, during a meal with bread, you would say a Beracha on a side dish, because you’re not eating it with the bread. So the Rosh is categorically—
Again, the problem is huge for Rashi, unless Rashi’s definition of ikar v’tafel is what we’re thinking. No, that’s not the problem. The problem is what mechamat seudah means. When Rashi says that mechamat seudah is the same as—or another way of saying—ikar v’tafel, he has a problem. Why do we have so many sugyot for the same thing? That’s one of the questions the Rosh asked yesterday. Why bring me another sugya of ikar v’tafel when ikar v’tafel is already dealt with somewhere else? There are two sugyot talking about the same thing, except that instead of rice you put bread. How many times are we going to talk about this? You have a Mishnah before, “eshet on this,” that’s coming up, and we’re going to talk about this too. The lashon (wording) mechamat seudah applies only to the bread aspect of ikar v’tafel. Why bring this story about mechamat seudah? I don’t understand mechamat seudah at all.
So if you say a Beracha on bread specifically, you have the parperet (appetizer). Parperet seems to mean the little things—I would call all the little salads parperet, not all the salads you serve, but the dips. If you have shishito peppers, palmitos, carrots, beets, pickles—whatever you want to serve—they’re not necessarily eaten with the bread. How do you understand that? He says, “because you can’t maseke de la.” If that’s included, he wants to say, all the more so the real meal, because is that my secret there are the stew what you cooked. Actually, gonna tell me this is not part of that. Let’s do it. I found that because it doesn’t come to an ancient bread and take it. I’m gonna lay a little in my secret.
Ah, okay. Then he just replaces the ikar. Now I’m replacing the ikar. Now they carry the meat, and therefore I don’t need to cover you. You don’t have to replace the ikar. You just disconnect from the ikar, and that’s enough to exempt it. Actually, you don’t need to make a new ikar. If the tafel isn’t connected to the ikar, even if it’s a tafel, it isn’t a tafel anymore. We’re saying the same thing with different words. You don’t need to call it ikar. Keep it. You’re saying that there’s always a tafel in relation to something. Once you separate the tafel, the bread ceases to be connected to it. Sure, it’s not connected to this, but now I call something else the ikar, and it’s connected to the ikar of the meal at that moment.
Fine, it’s the same as—therefore, I don’t need to say—. I’m saying the same thing you’re saying, and you’re not fighting anymore. The Rosh and Rashi aren’t fighting anymore. That’s what I’m trying to say: I’m trying to bring them together. It looks like—Who? The Rosh and Rashi? Of course they’re fighting. If I change the definition of the ikar at that moment, then practically speaking, Rashi can’t be saying seventy-five Berachot during a meal. We agree. Because that wasn’t the practice. He does. I’m not sure. It wasn’t the practice. The Rosh seems extremely upset: “I’m sure this is not the practice. How can this work?” He probably wasn’t. Are you saying the Rosh misunderstood? No, I’m saying that if you change the definition of ikar, according to Rashi you can make it fit perfectly. That’s what I’m saying.
They cut off the bread when the bread is with the dips. Now the ikar is the meat, and the meat is with something else, so you need to say a Beracha on the meat. The meat is the ikar; whatever is mixed with the meat is covered by it. And, by the way, he didn’t say that, because on the side this also means you’re going to have to say a Beracha. Once you separate the ikar from the tafel, there’s no more ikar and no more tafel. You have separate ingredients, and each one requires a Beracha. As long as you’re eating with the bread, within the context of the bread, it’s connected to the bread and you don’t say a Beracha. If it’s disconnected from the bread, then you have to say a Beracha on it. Even within the seudah, there’s no power in the seudah. The power is in the ikar, which takes care of the tafel.
The sandwich—if you eat shawarma in a pita, that’s a perfect example. You have a thousand ingredients, but they’re all coming together with the bread. Say one bit of bread. Or deconstruct your falafel and eat the little balls by themselves. How is that connected to the bread? How is the bread’s Beracha taking care of the falafel balls? That’s Rashi. So say adam on the bolitas. The Rosh says that’s not the sugya. That’s not our sugya. It’s the moment you have a king; you go by the king. You don’t have to eat the king. Even if you eat all your bread, everything else—
By the way, the Rosh’s view is very nice, but I think we don’t think of it as a chidush (novel insight), because we do it that way. But it’s a huge chidush. You ate your bread, you finished your bread, there’s nothing, you say left on the table and you don’t get any. Why not? How do you connect to bread that’s gone? I think the biggest difference between you and me is the Rosh’s view. We do that, so we consider it the norm, but really, we need to know how that works.
Rashi has problems with the wording, the repetition, whatever you want, but he has a daddy; he has logic. The Rosh has less logic, meaning less evidence. Someone might ask, “Why is that? Tell me once why I shouldn’t say a Beracha on my falafel balls.” You finished eating your shawarma. Are you still a little hungry? You say, “Give me a side of five falafel balls,” those little appetizers. You have them afterward because you’re still a little hungry. Why shouldn’t you say a Beracha on them? Rashi would say to the Rosh, “Are you out of your mind? Why shouldn’t you say a Beracha on these falafel balls? How do you connect them with the bread?” “Oh, they’re within the same seudah.” It’s a chidush, like the chidush with the drinks. It’s the same thing. But that doesn’t explain why. What’s your yesod (principle)? Do you have something? All you have. Right. But I’m saying it’s not pashut (straightforward). The Rosh is the chidush. It’s not that the Rosh is the chidush.
And another question on the Rosh: Where does the Lord of the Rings open the zayt (olive)? You should—it’s not a car. I was to get rid of the spicy eating. And what’s wrong with his radish? You have a meal of radish. He was eating together with us. We saw that he was, I think, Mimalef, but I won’t say Na’alef. What happened? It was Mimalef, but I won’t say Na’alef. No, I think it was Mimalef. Maybe it was—oh, you’re right! Mimalef and Mimalef. Al guna yena peyot. Makhloket, yes. Makhloket is Shavuot. Derad Yehuda sovar min shiva ha-adif. Rebbe Nazareh. “Aval meitivya, ayu lefanav tznon ve-zayit, mevarech al ha-tznon ve-poter et ha-zayit” (One blesses the radish and exempts the olive). “Acham ha-yaskinan kisha tznon ikar.”
He’s saying, forget about the order of which one you start with. It’s because the tznon (radish) is the ikar. Rashi says, “sheha-tznon ikar, shehu ba techilat achilah, ve-ha-zayit ba le-hafig charifuto shel tznon” (The radish is primary, as it comes at the beginning of the meal; the olive comes to lessen the radish’s sharpness). The radish has a strong ta’am (taste).
So do you still call it ikar v’tafel even though you ate it separately? Yes. You just said that it wasn’t. No, no, no. Usually it is together. We learned about the fish, remember the anchovies? If you eat a piece of bread to lessen the taste, that’s ikar v’tafel, even though you’re saying it’s separate. Yes, but it’s always focused on the fish. The bread has no identity; it’s completely secondary to the fish, and you don’t even have to say anything. But when you eat a piece of bread at the beginning of the meal and then, for an hour, eat other things, you can’t call that tafel in Rashi’s framework.
When you eat a piece of kezayit (olive-sized measure) at the beginning of the meal, and then for the next two hours you’re eating everything else, you can’t call those things tafel to that bread. They had nothing to do with it. So yes, it’s possible. If it’s really fully intended to—so that’s not—he’s a good example. It’s very hard, even today. You eat radish; it’s strong, and you want to change the taste. You take a side. You don’t save it up.
So let’s see how the Rosh connects this against us. I’ve been to yourself, sorry, he quotes. I’ve been to yourself. They let me know. I’ve ever had some potential image. “This is an ikar, kol sheken (all the more so) hacha, the pat ikar.” I didn’t get the—It says all the more so when you ate bread. He’s asking: you don’t need to teach it again; we already learned it. That’s what he’s saying. I don’t think that’s what he’s saying. He says kol sheken. He says kol sheken, all the more so.
The way we learned the sugya over there, which I just read to you, you would have to replace it. You’d say, “This bread is so good, but I want to change the taste a little. I’ll eat more bread, but I need something.” Even if you don’t eat it with the bread, you don’t have to be out of it. Is that the same as the cases where you have—I, you have a case of the current affair. That’s okay. You can understand that’s not a very strong—no, but it’s kind of, we can—you let it pass. Or you have, you kind of felt by that son on the side, and it’s kind of, we can—you let it pass. Is it to call it a bit? I think I love America. You go check in again, that it’s a—it’s a strong case. How is this one the strong case? How is this bread?
You can’t replace the tznon with bread and have the story still be the same unless the bread is boring and needs enhancing. No, the bread is satisfying too. Boring? Wait, I’m not kidding, but don’t lose where we came from. You’re eating bread that doesn’t have a lot of flavor, and then you need to put something on it. Fine, but then that’s not the question about the side dish. We’re talking about French fries. How does that come from snow and diet? No, because there you have—you can’t interface with your two other things out of it. Not a killer. What does that have to do with it? She’s going to tell you in two seconds. Nothing to do with one another. Over there, you got a little spicy in your mouth because you need to change the taste. Here, you’re in the middle of the meal. You’re done with your bread or not; it doesn’t matter. You’re eating the main course, which doesn’t go with bread, same as the rest, and all the tznon—I kiss it, but don’t say maybe what we’re saying. Don’t push this question. I don’t think this is a very strong question.
He’s still the bread, he’s the king. He’s the bread, he’s the king, okay. Whether he’s there or not, whether he’s there or not. He was there in the beginning, he’s the king.
There was a Gimel (third letter) here. I want to see what he says in note Gimel, Ma’adanei Yom Tov. He has our question. He’s going to polish it a little. You don’t want to eat bread by itself. What bread can you eat by itself? You need to have other things, but that’s not our question. Our question is about the thing you don’t eat with the bread. He brings proof for his point. The Aruch, with the old, old, old Rishon (early rabbinic authority), held that you don’t say a Beracha before and after when you’re talking about dayasa. So the side dishes, whatever they are, if they’re part of it, are considered as if they had pieces of bread inside. Remember? So then those foolish bablayim who put bread with bread. They are collect ownership completely. Yeah, I have a suit.
He’s done with that point. But now we’re going to talk about the brackets, so the Rosh becomes a lot looser. There are two expressions: mechamat seudah and betoch seudah. You need both. Again, I’m eating dessert. I don’t eat dessert by itself. It’s betoch seudah. It’s not mechamat seudah. You said it: there are two kinds of dessert. Let’s call them the middle dessert and the end dessert. For fancy people, the palate cleanser. On that melon or whatever. That’s like the melon, and I don’t need the olive inside that bracket. A hundred percent. You do it at the end, and we could argue. Of course I see your point. By the way, you’re not wrong.
I know people who are makpid (careful to) do Birkat Hamazon first and the Berachot afterward, because at the end of the day there’s a small suffix (doubt). The crushing majority of Yishman would never consider that the meal is connected to the bread either, because it has a similar function. You don’t eat dessert to fill yourself up. You eat because you’re hungry; that’s the main purpose of people sitting down to eat. You don’t eat dessert because you’re hungry. You eat dessert because you want to change the taste.
Having said that, there’s no way to connect this to the bread other than that I still haven’t said Birkat Hamazon. So you just bring Berachot here. Don’t bring Berachot. Berachot actually will depend on what you do. We’re in the pasta example with the Rosh, who says for sure that you don’t say a separate Beracha for the pasta. You still have both expressions, and the question was what exactly mechamat seudah means.
No, I’m asking what you call betoch seudah. Before Birkat Hamazon? Dessert is inside the bracket of Birkat Hamazon. No problem. You’ve got one. What about mechamat seudah? What is mechamat seudah? Am I eating dessert because Ron is going to a wedding? Am I eating it because I just ate meat? What is a seudah? That’s exactly what I’m saying. Sa’id, to get full. That’s the definition of seudah. When you’re eating your French fries, they’re part of the seudah. They do something like the bread does, without the bread. When you eat dessert, unless you’re really hungry—then we have another story—but that’s not how you usually do it. So the mechamat is missing.
You could even say, loosely, that the ikar of the dessert is almost like the radish and the olive, because you eat the pasta, right? You don’t want to get up with a salty taste or whatever. I would think that the olive and it’s none in the normal way you want to eat more. It’s just too much, so you pause it.