A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Gemara Berachot Daf 41b #474 why does Birkat Hamazon cover the fruits? (Rosh part 2)

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
November 21, 2024
Duration
31:52
Lecture code
RGK-1412

The Question of Berachot During a Meal

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas returns to the Gemara’s discussion of which foods eaten during a meal require a Beracha. The Gemara brings views including those of Rav Huna, Rav Sheshet, and Rabbi Chiya.
  • Regarding fruit, the first two agree that it requires a Beracha rishona; the dispute is whether it requires a Beracha acharona. By contrast, everyone agrees that pat haba’ah bekisnin requires a Beracha rishona but not a Beracha acharona.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas presents the Rosh as aligned with Tosafot against Rashi, though the Rosh’s explanation differs.

Ikar v’tafel and the Rosh’s View

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas argues that the Rosh’s point should not be explained through ikar v’tafel. That principle concerns eating two things together, making a Beracha on the ikar and thereby exempting the tafel—for example, a cracker with Baba Ganoush on it, or chicken eaten with rice.
  • Pasta is not tafel to bread: people do not eat pasta with bread. Likewise, a side dish eaten on its own is not automatically tafel to bread just because both are part of the meal.
  • The Rosh’s idea is instead that bread is the “king” of the seudah. The meal is bracketed by eating bread and reciting Birkat Hamazon, and foods eaten within that bracket belong to the meal even if they are not eaten together with bread.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas illustrates the point with someone who eats half a pizza quickly and then does not touch bread for an hour: the bread is gone, but, according to the Rosh’s approach, it still established the meal.
  • He emphasizes that this is a significant chidush: ordinary practice may make it seem obvious that food eaten later in the meal is covered, but the Rosh’s view still needs an explanation of how that food remains connected to bread that has already been finished.

Rashi: Side Dishes and Ikar v’tafel

  • In Rashi’s framework, many side dishes are eaten for sova, or fullness, but are not there to enhance the bread. Consequently, a person would make a Beracha on foods such as French fries even during a bread meal.
  • Bread remains distinctive for Birkat Hamazon, but in the framework of ikar v’tafel it is not necessarily more important than rice. The same principle could apply with rice as the ikar.
  • Whether a food is exempt depends on how it is eaten: if someone eats olives to improve the taste of bread, no separate Beracha is needed; if the olives are eaten by themselves, a Beracha is needed. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says the same distinction applies to salad and similar foods.
  • This is why, on Rashi’s account, the discussion is specifically about bread when considering Birkat Hamazon: according to Rav Huna, Birkat Hamazon covers the other foods of the meal.

Mechamat seudah and Betoch seudah

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas distinguishes mechamat seudah (“because of the meal”) from betoch seudah (“within the meal”). An apple may be eaten betoch seudah simply because it happens to be mealtime; it did not come because of the seudah and does not enhance it.
  • A pickle or coleslaw served with a burger is different: it is eaten mechamat seudah, because it is served as part of that meal.
  • This distinction raises a question about Rashi: if mechamat seudah is just another way of describing ikar v’tafel, why does the Gemara need a separate sugya when ikar v’tafel is discussed elsewhere? Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that this is one of the Rosh’s questions.
  • He also discusses parperet, such as dips and small sides—shishito peppers, palmitos, carrots, beets, and pickles—which need not be eaten with bread. The question is whether their place in the meal exempts them, or whether their connection to bread matters.

Can Rashi and the Rosh Be Reconciled?

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas considers whether Rashi and the Rosh can be brought together by defining the ikar according to what is being eaten at each moment. If bread is eaten with dips, bread is the ikar; later, meat may be the ikar, with foods eaten together with it exempted.
  • He clarifies that this does not necessarily mean one must establish a new ikar. Once a food is disconnected from the original ikar, it is no longer tafel to it; separate foods then require separate Berachot. On this account, exemption comes from the ikar, not from the seudah as a whole.
  • A shawarma in pita illustrates the distinction: the ingredients eaten with the pita are connected to the bread. If the falafel balls are taken apart and eaten by themselves, Rashi’s framework would require a Beracha on them; the Rosh’s approach would treat them as part of the bread-established seudah.
  • The challenge to the Rosh is that someone might finish a shawarma and then eat five falafel balls because they are still hungry. Why should those falafel balls be exempt? Saying only that they are “within the same seudah” states the rule but does not fully explain its yesod.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas observes that the Rosh’s position is a chidush, even if it resembles familiar practice, and asks what makes the connection to bread persist after the bread is gone.

The Radish and Olive Example

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas raises the Gemara’s example of radish and olive: “mevarech al ha-tznon ve-poter et ha-zayit” (“one blesses the radish and exempts the olive”). The explanation is that the radish is the ikar and the olive lessens its sharpness.
  • Rashi explains that the radish is primary because it is eaten at the beginning of the meal, while the olive comes to lessen the radish’s sharp taste.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas asks whether this is still ikar v’tafel when the foods are eaten separately. He compares it to eating bread to lessen the taste of fish: even though the bread is eaten separately, it is clearly secondary to the fish.
  • But a piece of bread eaten at the beginning of a meal cannot readily make everything eaten an hour or two later tafel to it. The Rosh’s argument that bread is the king of the seudah is what would sustain that broader connection.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas questions whether the radish example is a strong proof for the Rosh. In that case, the olive directly addresses the radish’s sharpness; French fries or a main course eaten during a bread meal may have no comparable connection to the bread.
  • The Rosh’s response, as Rabbi Gabriel Koskas presents it, is that bread remains the king whether or not it is still present.

Ma’adanei Yom Tov and Desserts

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas turns to note Gimel of the Ma’adanei Yom Tov, which addresses the question. The fact that bread is not usually eaten by itself is not decisive: the issue is food that is not eaten with the bread.
  • The Ma’adanei Yom Tov brings the Aruch, an early Rishon, who held that one does not say a Beracha before or after in the case of dayasa; the side dishes are treated as though they had pieces of bread in them.
  • The discussion then returns to the meal’s “bracket.” Dessert may be betoch seudah because it is eaten before Birkat Hamazon without being mechamat seudah. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas distinguishes a dessert eaten during the meal, such as a palate cleanser, from one eaten at the end.
  • Some people are careful to say Birkat Hamazon before making the Berachot on dessert, because of a small suffix. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that dessert is generally eaten to change the taste, not to satisfy hunger, so its connection to the bread is not self-evident.
  • The unresolved question is what counts as mechamat seudah. Foods such as French fries are part of the seudah and serve a function within it; dessert, unless someone is genuinely hungry, is usually not eaten for fullness. It may be betoch seudah without being mechamat seudah.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas suggests that dessert might loosely resemble the radish-and-olive case, where one food changes the taste after another, but leaves this as a possible comparison rather than a settled conclusion.