A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Gemara Berachot Daf 42a #487 Pat Habaah Bekisnin (Beth Yosef)

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
January 7, 2025
Duration
30:51
Lecture code
RGK-1466

The Safek Between Mezonot and Hamotzi

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas opens with the question of whether the doubt here is a safek sefeika (doubt upon doubt). He clarifies that the issue is a safek whether the food requires mezonot or hamotzi; it is not simply a question of choosing a lenient option, but of determining which beracha applies.

The Tur’s Rules for Pat Haba’ah Bechisnin

  • The Tur describes pat haba’ah bechisnin as *pat she’asui kemin kisim*—bread made like little pockets and filled with sugar, almonds, nuts, and spices. He rules that one says borei minei mezonot before eating and beracha achat mei’ein shalosh afterward.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that the Tur adopts the “pocket” definition, rather than the cracker definition, while also mentioning spices. He raises the question of whether the spices are inside the dough.
  • If a person eats an amount that others ordinarily establish as a meal, he says hamotzi and the three berachot, even if he himself is not satisfied. Personal hunger does not change the ruling once the standard meal amount has been reached.
  • If he initially intends to eat a little and says mezonot, but then eats the amount that others establish as a meal, he says the three berachot afterward even though he did not first say hamotzi. The initial and final berachot are independent of one another.
  • If the amount is less than what others establish as a meal, a person’s own decision to treat it as his meal does not require hamotzi and the three berachot. The Tur explains that his personal view is nullified in relation to everyone, because we follow the majority. He still says mezonot and al hamichyah.

Lachmaniyot

  • The Tur says that lachmaniyot whose batter is thick are actual bread and require hamotzi and the three berachot.
  • Those with soft, very thin batter—like a wrap—require mezonot, unless a person establishes his meal on them, in which case he says hamotzi and the three berachot.
  • If they are eaten during a meal, but not as part of the meal itself, they require a beracha beforehand but not afterward, like a dessert.

The Gemara and the Opinions on the Final Beracha

  • In Keitzad Mevarchin, Rav Huna says in the name of Rabbi Yehudah that one says hamotzi over pat haba’ah bechisnin. The Gemara concludes that the halacha does not follow this opinion.
  • The Gemara challenges this from Rav Yehudah in the name of Shemuel, who says that one can establish an eruv with rolls and says hamotzi over them. The answer is that this applies when the person has established his meal on the rolls; where he has not, it does not.
  • The Gemara further recounts that Rav Huna ate twelve loaves and took three kav without blessing. Rav Nachman asked him whether he was still hungry. The conclusion is that anything others establish as a meal requires a beracha, regardless of whether the person remains hungry.
  • Rashi, the Rif, and the Rosh interpret the discussion as referring to pat haba’ah bechisnin. The Rif says that when it is eaten as kisnin, one says borei minei mezonot beforehand and nothing afterward; when it is eaten as a fixed meal, one says hamotzi and the three berachot.
  • Rabbeinu Yonah cites two opinions about the final beracha when the eating is not fixed: one says nothing, and one says borei nefashot. The Rosh says me’ein shalosh. The Rashba and Rambam agree with the Rosh, and this is the ruling described here: after eating pat haba’ah bechisnin below the amount others establish as a meal, one says al hamichyah.
  • The Rav Huna story means that a person who reaches the meal amount must say Birkat Hamazon even if he is not hungry. Conversely, being satisfied below that amount does not require Birkat Hamazon; the final beracha is me’ein shalosh.
  • The exact amount that others establish as a meal has not yet been defined. The Rosh states the general rule: whatever others establish as their meal requires hamotzi and the three berachot.

The Standard Meal Amount Versus Personal Intention

  • Rabbeinu Moshe rules that if others do not establish a meal on the food, a person does not say hamotzi and the three berachot even if he personally does. His view is that we follow the majority and that an individual’s intention is nullified in relation to everyone.
  • The Ravad disagrees: if a person establishes even a small amount as his meal, he says hamotzi beforehand and the three berachot afterward.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas explains that the Ravad’s view would make a person’s own intention decisive, whereas the *Rambam*’s approach makes the amount established by others decisive. The Beit Yosef says that the words of Rabbeinu Moshe appear correct.
  • The Rosh also says that if someone initially intended to eat a little, said mezonot, and later ate the amount others establish as a meal, he says the three berachot even though he did not first say hamotzi.
  • The Beit Yosef cites Rabbeinu Yonah as likewise ruling that a person’s personal decision does not suffice when others would not establish a meal on that amount. The Rosh, Rabbeinu Yonah, and the Rambam therefore all base the ruling on what people generally do, rather than on the individual’s claim that “this is my meal.”
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas cautions against assuming that calling a small amount—such as two slices of pizza—one’s meal makes it require hamotzi. He notes that the discussion is not yet the practical ruling about pizza.

Whether the Time and Setting of the Meal Matter

  • The Agur cites Rabbeinu Avigdor, who says that the relevant meal is specifically a morning or evening meal, not a casual meal. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas explains this as reflecting a society that ate two meals a day, in the morning and at night; a snack would not become a meal merely because of how much one chose to eat.
  • On that approach, even someone who ate 500 grams of pat haba’ah bechisnin in the middle of the afternoon, after lunch, would not say hamotzi: it was not eaten at a time that people establish as a meal. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas connects this understanding with the beginning of *Rav Moshe Feinstein*’s explanation of pizza in America: a slice is ordinarily not what people eat for dinner, unless they are especially hungry.
  • He raises the consequence that, on this reading, even a business lunch might not count as kevi’ut se’udah. He presents this as an issue to be explored further, rather than as the practical conclusion.
  • The Beit Yosef, citing Shibolei Haleket, rejects the added time condition. Whether the eating takes place at breakfast, in the evening, or as a casual meal, it is kevi’ut if the person eats the amount people establish as a meal; otherwise it is not.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas explains that, in the Beit Yosef’s reading, the Gemara specifies an amount that others establish, not both an amount and a time. He notes that this possibility appears in later Rishonim and considers whether the earlier authorities’ silence means the point was obvious or was not part of their definition.
  • He also questions how to combine the two criteria. If kevi’ut se’udah depends on the amount, why should the time or structure matter? If it depends on the setting—such as breakfast or dinner—why should the amount matter? He says the definition of se’udah requires examining whether the distinction between keva and arai is based on quantity, mindset, timing, or what the person is doing.

The Definition of Pat Haba’ah Bechisnin and the Dough

  • Turning to the definition of pat haba’ah bechisnin, the Beit Yosef says that the Tur’s explanation comes from Rabbeinu Chananel, as cited by Rabbeinu Yonah in Keitzad Mevarchin. The Aruch and the Rashba also mention ublyash among foods that come during a meal.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says these sources show that the Tur follows an established explanation; he identifies Rabbeinu Chananel and the author of the Aruch as early authorities, and notes that Rabbeinu Yonah and the Rashba also support this definition.
  • The Rambam, in chapter three of Hilchot Berachot, defines the relevant dough by its ingredients: dough kneaded with honey, oil, milk, or various spices. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas contrasts this with the Tur’s pocket definition: the Rambam’s focus is the dough itself.
  • The Beit Yosef suggests that the Rambam’s rule applies when the dough contains little or no water. If a substantial amount of water is used, the other liquids are a minority and are nullified in relation to the water.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas illustrates this with a small amount of egg in a batch of several challot, or a little sugar that does not change the taste: these additions may affect texture without significantly changing the dough’s character.
  • The Beit Yosef’s wording matters: sheniloshah bidvash means kneaded with honey, while natan letochah dvash would mean that some honey was added to the dough. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas understands the former wording to indicate a significant ingredient.
  • The Rambam uses a different expression for spices, saying that they were mixed into the dough. The Beit Yosef might therefore be understood to mean that spices are only a small amount; Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that spices can be kneaded into the dough too, and that even a small amount may be perceptible.
  • Even so, the Beit Yosef says that the spices remove the food from the status of bread for the purpose of hamotzi, making it mezonot.
  • The Beit Yosef adds that dough kneaded with fruit juice is obligated in chalah, but does not require hamotzi as long as the person has not established a meal on it. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas draws out the distinction: such dough can require chalah while remaining mezonot absent kevi’ut.
  • The Beit Yosef concludes that the berachot do not depend simply on whether something can be called bread. The Sages established hamotzi and the three berachot for bread that people customarily establish a meal on—dough kneaded with water alone, without another mixture.

Practical Questions About Enriched Breads

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that a strict reading of the Beit Yosef’s discussion could make much commercially sold challah mezonot if it contains significant honey or egg. The question is whether an ingredient is present in a substantial amount or only in a small amount that does not change the dough’s character.
  • He raises similar questions about other breads, including baguettes, pita, burger rolls, and ciabatta. The discussion of pita illustrates uncertainty about whether oil or sugar is added; the key issue in this approach is whether the dough is really made with water alone.
  • He says that another shitah will be discussed later and remarks that Ashkenaz baking used different ingredients. He gives the example of a person whose wife made each challah differently, joking about which one was intended for Sunday breakfast, and quotes “at alit al kulanah.”
  • He notes that a burger roll made with a lot of egg might be mezonot under this approach, as might some whole-grain or olive ciabatta. He stresses that the issue is not choosing a lenient option; one must determine which beracha is correct.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas describes the practical difficulty of applying the approach at Shabbat meals and when visiting another home. He recalls being invited to an Ashkenazi home on Sukkot and not saying hamotzi.
  • He mentions that a challah weighing 230 grams—about three slices—may still have to be assessed against the meal amount, which will be discussed as possibly three or four beitzim. A hamburger roll, he says, does not reach the amount others establish as a meal; he adds that one could eat a burger at lunch and say mezonot, although he personally always washes.

Choosing the Correct Beracha

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas warns that saying hamotzi is not automatically more religious or better. Saying it when it is not required may create a safek beracha levatalah.
  • He points to the *Shulchan Aruch*’s treatment of the three definitions: in all three cases, it says mezonot. He says this implies that when there is a safek between hamotzi and mezonot, one says mezonot.
  • The reason he gives is that mezonot covers hamotzi, but hamotzi does not cover mezonot: saying hamotzi on babka cake does not fulfill the obligation, whereas saying mezonot on pita does.
  • He rejects the claim that hamotzi is always the safer or more religious choice. The beracha must be chosen precisely; saying hamotzi merely to appear more religious is not the right approach.