Daf mem tet amud aleph (folio 49a). Amar Rabba bar bar Chana, amar Rabbi Yochanan: Hatov Vehametiv (The One who is good and does good) tzericha malchut (requires sovereignty). Hatov Vehametiv also needs malchut. Mai kamashmalan? (What does this teach us?) Kol beracha (every blessing) she'ein bah malchut (that has no sovereignty) lo shema beracha (is not called a blessing). It is already a second beracha (blessing), and amar Rabbi Yochanan chada zimna (Rabbi Yochanan already said this once). Amar Rav Zeira lomar shetzericha shtei malchuyot (to say that it requires two mentions of sovereignty): chada dida vechada debonei Yerushalayim (one of its own, and one for Bonei Yerushalayim).
Ei hachi niv'ei tlat, chada dida vechada debonei Yerushalayim vechada debirkat ha'aretz (If so, let it require three: one of its own, one for Bonei Yerushalayim, and one for Birkat Ha'aretz). So if all of them need it, then you should say all of them. Now we know that al hakol and lechem do not have it. Ela birkat ha'aretz mai ta'ama lo? Mishum dehavya beracha hasmucha lachaverta (Why does Birkat Ha'aretz not have it? Because it is a blessing adjacent to another blessing). Bonei Yerushalayim nami havya beracha hasmucha lachaverta (Bonei Yerushalayim is also a blessing adjacent to another blessing), meaning it is still adjacent to hazan et hakol. Once you have one beracha, like the Amidah (standing prayer), once you have one complete beracha, all the other berachot (blessings) are connected to it.
Vehai dinve'ei de'afilu bonei Yerushalayim nami liv'ei (And this one should require it, so that even Bonei Yerushalayim should require it). You're right, then. Ela ayidi de'amar malchut beit David lav orach ar'ah dela amar malchut shamayim (Rather, since he mentions the sovereignty of the House of David, it is not proper not to mention the sovereignty of Heaven). In Bonei Yerushalayim, where you mention malchut beit David meshichecha (the kingdom of David, Your anointed), it is not derech eretz to mention malchut beit David and not malchut shamayim.
Rashi: De'avur achara delo amar malchut shamayim bebonei Yerushalayim lekach mehader leh behatov vehametiv (Because he did not mention the sovereignty of Heaven in Bonei Yerushalayim, he repeats it in Hatov Vehametiv). I thought I was going to say anyway, “Baruch ata Hashem elokeinu melech ha'olam bonei Yerushalayim.” As soon as you finish Bonei Yerushalayim, you're going to have to mention malchut shamayim, because you just mentioned malchut beit David. That's why, in Hatov Vehametiv, you start, “Baruch ata Hashem elokeinu melech ha'olam ha'el avinu malkenu.”
That answer is for the later time. But how did they do it in the earlier time? Which earlier times? The braita (tannaitic teaching) warns us about the Rabanan (the rabbis), who say that you had the first three, but you didn't have the next one. Before the gezeira (decree)? Before the gezeira. I don't know what they did. Maybe they didn't mention malchut beit David, because they had Beit David. Actually, no: the story of Beitar is after the second Beit Hamikdash (Temple). It was way after that. I thought Hatov Vehametiv is derabanan (rabbinic), so it's a whole new beginning and you start the beracha.
If anybody asks you why you say “elokeinu melech ha'olam” in this one and not in the others, it would be a nice question to look at. Rav Papa amar hachi ka'amar tzericha shtei malchuyot levad midida (Rav Papa said: This is what it means; it requires two mentions of sovereignty besides its own). You need two malchuyot besides its own. What does that mean? Look at Rashi: Kegon avinu malkenu adirenu borenu go'alenu kadoshenu kedosh Yaakov ro'enu roeh Yisrael hamelech hatov vehametiv lakol (For example: our Father, our King, our Mighty One, our Creator, our Redeemer, our Holy One, the Holy One of Jacob, our Shepherd, the Shepherd of Israel, the King who is good and does good to all). So right there you've got two mentions of kingship, plus “elokeinu melech ha'olam.”
Tosafot says something different. “Chada debonei Yerushalayim dela orach ar'ah vegam bah ein yecholim lomar malchut desmucha hi” (One is for Bonei Yerushalayim, because it is not proper, and also one cannot say sovereignty there, since it is adjacent to another blessing). So you couldn't insert malchut in the beracha Bonei Yerushalayim, because it is adjacent to hazan et hakol. “Al ken omra behatov vehametiv” (Therefore, he says it in Hatov Vehametiv). So the answer to your question, Ari, is that it wasn't possible back then. Once it is adjacent to another blessing, you cannot add “elokeinu melech ha'olam”; you're canceling the one before it. “Ho'il ve'amar ba malchut beboneh Yerushalayim, lav orach ar'a” (Since he mentioned sovereignty in Bonei Yerushalayim, it is not proper).
Amar Rav Gidel bevirkat ha'aretz (Rav Gidel said, regarding Birkat Ha'aretz): “Af al pi shehi smucha lechaverta, ho'il venutkenu zeh achar zeh” (Even though it is adjacent to another blessing, since they were instituted one after the other). Yehoshua tiken birkat ha'aretz (instituted Birkat Ha'aretz); Moshe tiken birkat hamazon (instituted Birkat Hamazon). Mikeivan denakat malchut delav smuchot (Since it took up sovereignty, they are not adjacent blessings). Mihu hashta, ho'il venutkenu al haseder, ein anu potchim bevaruch (But now, since they were instituted in sequence, we do not begin with “Blessed”). Yesh nohagim lomar beboneh Yerushalayim malchut (There are those who have the custom to mention sovereignty in Bonei Yerushalayim).
So the answer for the time before that is that they didn't say malchut there, as you said. Maybe they didn't. That way, you don't have the question of why you have one malchut and not the other.
Ativ Rav Zeira achoreih derav Gidel, ve'ativ Rav Gidel kameih derav Huna, ve'ativ veka'amar (Rav Zeira sat behind Rav Gidel, and Rav Gidel sat before Rav Huna, and he sat and said): “Ta'ah velo hizkir shel Shabbat” (If one erred and did not mention Shabbat), “omer baruch shenatan Shabbatot limnucha le'amo Yisrael be'ahavah le'ot ulevrit, baruch mekadesh haShabbat” (he says, “Blessed is He who gave Sabbaths for rest to His people Israel in love, as a sign and a covenant; blessed is He who sanctifies the Sabbath”). That's the famous ruling: if you forgot to say Retzei (Be favorable), you have “alav hashalom” (peace be upon him).
Ve'ativ Rav Gidel kameih (And Rav Gidel sat before him): if you didn't mention it, then you say—Rashi says, “Ta'ah Rav Huna veRav Gidel mai amrah?” (Did Rav Huna and Rav Gidel err? What did he say?). I don't know. “Amar leih man amrah?” (He said to him, “Who said it?”) Rav. Hадар yativ veka'amar (He then sat and said): “Ta'ah velo hizkir shel Yom Tov” (If one erred and did not mention the festival), omer (he says)... “Man amrah?” Rav. Who said it, from all those names that were mentioned? Man amrah? Who said it? Who said what? That phrase. Who coined the phrase? I don't know. Ativ Rav Zeira achoreih derav Gidel, ve'ativ Rav Gidel kameih derav Huna, ve'ativ veka'amar: ta'ah (Rav Zeira sat behind Rav Gidel, Rav Gidel sat before Rav Huna, and he sat and said: “If one erred”). So he taught this, then asked him, “Amar leih man amrah?” I guess, who coined the phrase? Maybe who was the earlier source, since Rav would be earlier than all of those. Hagahot bichitivat yad mosif amar leih Rav (The handwritten gloss adds: “He said to him, Rav”). Amar leih Rav. Yes, something like that.
Hadar yativ veka'amar: “Ta'ah velo hizkir shel Yom Tov, omer baruch shenatan yamim tovim le'amo Yisrael lesimchah ulezikaron, baruch mekadesh Yisrael vehazmanim” (He then sat and said: “If one erred and did not mention the festival, he says, ‘Blessed is He who gave festivals to His people Israel for joy and remembrance; blessed is He who sanctifies Israel and the seasons.’”). Amar leih man amrah? Rav. Hadar yativ veka'amar: “Ta'ah velo hizkir shel Rosh Chodesh, omer baruch shenatan roshei chodashim le'amo Yisrael lezikaron” (He then sat and said: “If one erred and did not mention the new month, he says, ‘Blessed is He who gave new months to His people Israel for remembrance.’”). Velo yadna i amar ba simcha i lo amar ba simcha; i chatim ba i lo chatim ba; i didei i derabeih (And I do not know whether he said “for joy”; whether he concluded the blessing; or whether it was his own teaching or his teacher's). I don't know the difference there. We're going to see that there is actually a difference in halacha (Jewish law).
Rashi: Lo yadna leRav Zeira ka'amrah, velo yadna i amar Rav Gidel lezikaron ulesimchah i lo amar lesimchah, ve'i amrah mishmeih deRav i lo amrah (Rav Zeira said, “I don't know”; I don't know whether Rav Gidel said “for remembrance and joy” or did not say “for joy,” and whether he said it in the name of Rav or did not). I chatim ba mekadesh Yisrael veharoshei chodashim i lo chatim ba (Whether he concluded with “Who sanctifies Israel and the new months”). Because you saw that it was a long beracha with “baruch” and “baruch.” So, for Shabbat, instead of Retzei and Ya'aleh Veyavo (May it rise and come), you have a full beracha. If you skip it, it is adjacent in the space before the fourth beracha. You skip the regular nusach (wording), and because of your omission, you go up a level.
That's a good question that everybody asks: Why are you saying a beracha if you didn't...? You could ask the same question if you missed Ya'aleh Veyavo in the Shemoneh Esrei (Eighteen Benedictions), in the Amidah: you have to repeat the Amidah. If you skip the Amidah, or miss it, you have an opportunity; you have to repeat the Amidah for that, in the sense of a zechut (merit). But with torat nedavah (the law of voluntary prayer)—no, if you skipped Ya'aleh Veyavo on Rosh Chodesh, you have to repeat the entire Amidah. Why don't you do one beracha? You're repeating eighteen or nineteen berachot. It's the same logic.
In reality, if you look at it that way, Birkat Hamazon (Grace after Meals) is de'oraita (of Torah law), so you should repeat the entire Birkat Hamazon, but you're just adding that little piece. If you don't do that, you will repeat it. They gave you a chance there, with one beracha. So in reality it's not an upgrade; it's a downgrade. I have a question, though. You see Birkat Hamazon as a unit. If you miss part of the unit, you should say the whole thing again. You had the option to say just one beracha instead of the whole thing. Let's go deeper. Let's compare with the Amidah. You missed Ya'aleh Veyavo in the Amidah. You also have the chance, when you finish the beracha. Ya'aleh Veyavo is said in the middle of the beracha of avoda (service). If you missed it and said, “Baruch ata Hashem hamachazir shechinato l'tziyon,” and then remember that you didn't say Ya'aleh Veyavo, you could still say it, as with many things.
If you remember before Modim (we give thanks), you go back to Retzei. If you have not started Modim, you could say it right there. You said, “Eloheinu v'elohei avoteinu,” and then Modim. Correct, because you still didn't start the new beracha; it is still connected to the old beracha. We have the same idea in barech (bless), barech aleinu (Bless us): if you didn't say v'ten tal u'matar (Give dew and rain) before you start teka (sound), you could just say the words of v'ten tal u'matar. Once you start teka, you have another chance in shma koleinu (Hear our voice) and so on.
We don't find a new beracha, though. Why did they need to make a new beracha? How about doing what I just said with Ya'aleh Veyavo? If you missed Ya'aleh Veyavo, say it before the next beracha. So here, too, before you start the fourth beracha, say Ya'aleh Veyavo. Why a new beracha? What's the necessity? There's no source; it just goes straight. Why a beracha? We don't find the concept of adding a beracha. So it's similar to what you said, but it's not the same. I'm asking maybe even earlier: why? At the end, it's the me'ein hameora (a reference to the occasion); you're just saying what you missed. If you're not too late, then say it. If you're too late, what is a beracha going to help? That's the problem.
Didn't we study before that there was a machloket (dispute) about where to put that part of Rosh Chodesh, whether it would be something separate? Didn't we do that already? Maybe it was in Birkat Hamazon, or maybe it was in the Amidah, where we didn't know where to put the extra portion of Rosh Chodesh. I thought we did that a while back. Maybe it was three pages ago, but it was a while back.
Let's see; perhaps Tosafot explains. Tosafot says, “Baruch shenatan Shabbatot limnucha” (Blessed is He who gave Sabbaths for rest). “Tomar v'ha smucha hi” (You might ask: Is it not adjacent to another blessing?). He has another question: if it's adjacent, how do you say “elokeinu melech ha'olam”? We don't; we don't say it. “V'yesh lomar ho'il v'lo nitkena sham” (One can say that it was not instituted there). Well, it's not adjacent in the regular case, but this is not the regular case. “Ela hacha amar Rav Ashi d'lifrakim k'sheshachach Retzei v'hachalitzanu, ein ze karuy smucha v'tzarich peticha b'varuch” (Rather, here Rav Ashi says that when one occasionally forgets Retzei v'hachalitzanu, this is not considered an adjacent blessing, and it requires an opening with “Blessed”).
“Mihu berachot shel yod chet” (However, the blessings of the eighteen) — sorry, “baruch.” The berachot of the eighteen of the Amidah are all adjacent to one another. “El chai v'kayam,” or “elohei Avraham,” hainu malchut (that is sovereignty). For we say that from the time the world was created, no one called the Holy One, blessed be He, “Master,” until Avraham came and called Him “Master,” as it says, “Adonai elohim ma titen li.”
“V'im hu Yom Tov kolel v'omer baruch shenatan Shabbatot limnucha v'Yom Tov yamim tovim l'amo Yisrael l'simcha” (And if it is a festival, he includes it and says, “Blessed is He who gave Sabbaths for rest and festivals to His people Israel for joy”). “V'chen ki mikla Shabbat b'Rosh Chodesh” (And likewise, when Shabbat coincides with Rosh Chodesh), you can bundle them. All right, so it went through three subjects, but not what we're looking for. Maybe Rabbeinu Yonah has something; if not, the Beit Yosef. I want to see why on Rosh Chodesh you don't say it with shem u'malchut (divine name and sovereignty), but on Shabbat and Yom Tov (festival) you do. Do you still say that beracha, or only if you missed the whole Amidah?
Mem tet amud aleph. The Rif would be on page tzadi vav. Say “ahava” at the bottom. Tzadi vav amud bet. “V’heicha d’varich birkat hamazon b’Shabbat v’ta-ah v’lo hizkir shel Shabbat omer baruch shenatan Shabbatot limnucha l’amo Yisrael b’ot uvrit baruch ata Hashem mekadesh haShabbat” (If he recited Birkat Hamazon on Shabbat and erred by not mentioning Shabbat, he says, “Blessed is He who gave Sabbaths for rest to His people Israel as a sign and a covenant; blessed are You, Hashem, who sanctifies the Sabbath”). “V’ta-ah v’lo hizkir shel Yom Tov omer baruch shenatan yamim tovim l’amo Yisrael l’simcha u’lesason baruch ata Hashem mekadesh Yisrael v’hazmanim” (If he erred by not mentioning the festival, he says, “Blessed is He who gave festivals to His people Israel for joy and gladness; blessed are You, Hashem, who sanctifies Israel and the seasons”). “V’hani milei heicha d’adkar kmi d’liptach b’hatov v’hametiv” (This applies when he remembered before beginning Hatov Vehametiv). “Aval d’hashta d’patah b’hatov v’hametiv chozer l’rosh” (But now, if he began Hatov Vehametiv, he goes back to the beginning). He goes back to the beginning.
“V’heicha d’ta-ah v’lo hizkir shel Rosh Chodesh omer baruch shenatan rashei chodashim l’amo Yisrael l’zikaron v’leit bah chatima” (If he erred and did not mention Rosh Chodesh, he says, “Blessed is He who gave new months to His people Israel for remembrance,” and it has no concluding blessing). “V’ei lo adkar ela batar d’patah b’hatov v’hametiv, gamir lah l’beracha v’lo ba-ei l’mehadar b’reisha” (If he remembered only after beginning Hatov Vehametiv, he completes the blessing and does not need to return to the beginning). Gamir lah l’beracha: he should finish the beracha and does not have to go back to the beginning. Interesting. So he may be talking about Rosh Chodesh. One case is machzirim (we require him to go back), and one is lo machzirim (we do not require him to go back).
Rabbeinu Yonah says: “B’ot uvrit baruch mekadesh haShabbat. U’mipnei she-achar she-omer shenatan menucha l’amo Yisrael mosif b’ot uvrit; havu lehu shnei inyanim, v’havi lehu matbei-a aroch, lefichach chotem bah b’shem u’malchut” (Because after saying that He gave rest to His people Israel, he adds “as a sign and a covenant”; these are two matters, making it an extended formula, and therefore he concludes it with the divine name and sovereignty). Because he said a number of things, it is not just a single lashon beracha (wording of a blessing). That's another yesod (principle) we have here. The one-liner is one subject. Even in the long berachot, the one-line chatima (concluding blessing) is only one subject, but in the middle you can add things. That's why you add a lot of things here. So it says, “Baruch ata Hashem elokeinu melech ha'olam mekadesh haShabbat.” “V’chein chotem Yom Tov mipnei she-mosif sason v’simcha” (And likewise, he concludes the festival blessing because he adds gladness and joy).
Interesting: he would also be saying “Baruch ata Hashem elokeinu melech ha'olam” in the chatima. You see that? “Mekadesh haShabbat, chotem bah b’shem u’malchut.” I never heard that. That's a big chiddush (novel insight). There's a little star there; I don't know who that is. “V’ha d’amrinan d’ei lo adkar ela batar d’patah b’hatov v’hametiv chozer l’rosh, yesh mefarshim rosh birkat hamazon” (As for what we said, that if he remembered only after beginning Hatov Vehametiv he goes back to the beginning, some explain that “the beginning” means the beginning of Birkat Hamazon).