A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Gemara Berachot Daf 49a #568 The extra beracha when someone forgot Yaaleh Veyavo

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
March 19, 2026
Duration
22:09
Lecture code
RGK-1777

Hatov Vehametiv and malchut

  • On Daf 49a, Rabba bar bar Chana reports in the name of Rabbi Yochanan that Hatov Vehametiv requires malchut. Rabbi Yochanan had already stated the general principle that a beracha without malchut is not considered a beracha.
  • Rav Zeira explains that Hatov Vehametiv needs two mentions of malchut: one of its own and one corresponding to Bonei Yerushalayim.
  • The Gemara asks why three mentions are not required, including one for Birkat Ha'aretz. Al hakol and lechem do not have malchut; Birkat Ha'aretz does not because it is a beracha hasmucha lachaverta (adjacent to another blessing).
  • Bonei Yerushalayim is also adjacent to another beracha, including hazan et hakol. The Gemara explains that since Bonei Yerushalayim mentions malchut beit David meshichecha, it is not derech eretz to mention the kingdom of David without also mentioning malchut shamayim.
  • Rashi explains that since malchut shamayim was not mentioned in Bonei Yerushalayim, it is included again in Hatov Vehametiv. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that Hatov Vehametiv begins with “Baruch ata Hashem elokeinu melech ha'olam,” following the mention of malchut beit David in the previous beracha.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas raises the question of how this worked in earlier times, before the gezeira. He notes that Beitar’s story took place after the second Beit Hamikdash, and wonders whether malchut beit David had been omitted earlier. He also observes that Hatov Vehametiv is derabanan and might therefore be treated as a new beracha with its own opening. He leaves open the question of why this beracha says “elokeinu melech ha'olam” when the others do not.
  • Rav Papa offers another explanation: Hatov Vehametiv requires two mentions of malchut besides its own. As Rashi illustrates, titles such as “avinu malkenu,” “hamelech hatov vehametiv lakol,” and others supply two mentions, in addition to “elokeinu melech ha'olam.”
  • Tosafot explains that one of the required mentions corresponds to Bonei Yerushalayim: malchut cannot be inserted there because it is adjacent to another beracha, so it is said in Hatov Vehametiv instead. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that, on this explanation, it was not possible to add “elokeinu melech ha'olam” in Bonei Yerushalayim.
  • Rav Gidel says that although Birkat Ha'aretz is adjacent to another beracha, it was instituted after Birkat Hamazon: Yehoshua instituted Birkat Ha'aretz and Moshe instituted Birkat Hamazon. The lecture cites the statement that because it took up malchut, they are not considered adjacent blessings. Nevertheless, since they are now instituted in sequence, we do not begin with “Baruch.” There are those who have the custom to mention malchut in Bonei Yerushalayim.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas suggests that in the earlier practice they may simply not have said malchut there, which would avoid the question of why one malchut was included and not the other.

Supplementary berachot for omissions in Birkat Hamazon

  • Rav Zeira sat behind Rav Gidel, who sat before Rav Huna. Rav Gidel taught that if someone erred and did not mention Shabbat, he says: “Baruch shenatan Shabbatot limnucha le'amo Yisrael be'ahavah le'ot ulevrit, baruch mekadesh haShabbat.”
  • He then taught the corresponding formula for someone who omitted Yom Tov: “Baruch shenatan yamim tovim le'amo Yisrael lesimchah ulezikaron, baruch mekadesh Yisrael vehazmanim.”
  • He also taught that if someone omitted Rosh Chodesh, he says: “Baruch shenatan roshei chodashim le'amo Yisrael lezikaron.” The Gemara is unsure whether the Rosh Chodesh wording included “simcha,” whether it had a concluding beracha, and whether it was Rav Gidel’s own teaching or was said in the name of Rav.
  • Rashi explains that the uncertainty concerns whether Rav Gidel said “lezikaron ulesimchah” or only “lezikaron,” whether he concluded with “mekadesh Yisrael veharoshei chodashim,” and whether the teaching was attributed to Rav.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that the Shabbat and Yom Tov formulas are full berachot, with an opening and a conclusion. He raises the question of why an omitted reference calls for a new beracha rather than simply adding the missing words.
  • The Gemara’s exchange asks who said the teaching; the answer is Rav. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas discusses the sequence of Rav Zeira, Rav Gidel, and Rav Huna and the wording “man amrah?” A handwritten gloss adds “Amar leih Rav.”

Why a new beracha is said

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas compares the omission in Birkat Hamazon to omitting Ya'aleh Veyavo in the Amidah. On Rosh Chodesh, one who omits it must repeat the entire Amidah, rather than repeat only one beracha.
  • He asks why Birkat Hamazon is treated differently. Since Birkat Hamazon is de'oraita and can be viewed as a unit, one might expect a person who missed part of it to repeat the whole thing. Instead, the supplementary beracha gives a shorter alternative; Rabbi Gabriel Koskas describes this as a possible “downgrade,” rather than an upgrade.
  • He compares this with opportunities to insert a missed passage in the Amidah. If someone remembers Ya'aleh Veyavo before beginning Modim, he returns to Retzei; if the next beracha has not begun, the missed words can still be inserted. Similarly, if someone omitted v'ten tal u'matar before beginning teka, it can be said then; after beginning teka, there is another opportunity in shma koleinu.
  • He asks why the same approach is not used in Birkat Hamazon: why not say Ya'aleh Veyavo before beginning the fourth beracha, instead of instituting a new beracha? If the person remembers too late to add the missing reference, Rabbi Gabriel Koskas questions how a new beracha helps.
  • He recalls a possible earlier machloket about where the Rosh Chodesh addition belongs, but is unsure whether the discussion concerned Birkat Hamazon or the Amidah.

Tosafot on the supplementary berachot

  • Tosafot asks whether the supplementary beracha is adjacent to another beracha and, if so, how it can begin with “Baruch.” It answers that when someone occasionally forgets Retzei v'hachalitzanu, the supplementary beracha is not considered adjacent and therefore needs an opening with “Baruch.”
  • Tosafot distinguishes this from the berachot of the Amidah, which are adjacent to one another. It says that “El chai v'kayam” or “elohei Avraham” counts as malchut, citing the teaching that no one called Hashem “Master” until Avraham did, as in “Adonai elohim ma titen li.”
  • Tosafot says that when the omission occurs on Yom Tov, Shabbat and Yom Tov can be included together in the supplementary formula. The same applies when Shabbat coincides with Rosh Chodesh.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that this discussion does not resolve his question about why the Rosh Chodesh formula differs, and asks whether the beracha is said only in the case of an omission in Birkat Hamazon or also in other circumstances.

The Rif’s distinctions and the explanation of Rabbeinu Yonah

  • The Rif states that if someone recited Birkat Hamazon on Shabbat and omitted Shabbat, he says the supplementary formula ending “baruch ata Hashem mekadesh haShabbat.” For Yom Tov, he says the formula ending “baruch ata Hashem mekadesh Yisrael v'hazmanim.”
  • These Shabbat and Yom Tov formulas apply when the person remembers before beginning Hatov Vehametiv. If he has already begun Hatov Vehametiv, he returns to the beginning.
  • For Rosh Chodesh, the Rif gives “baruch shenatan rashei chodashim l'amo Yisrael l'zikaron,” with no concluding beracha. If the person remembers only after beginning Hatov Vehametiv, he completes that beracha and does not return to the beginning.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas points out the difference: in one case the person must return to the beginning, while in the other he does not.
  • Rabbeinu Yonah explains that the Shabbat formula adds “as a sign and a covenant” after saying that Hashem gave rest to Israel. These are two matters, making an extended formula; therefore, it concludes with shem u'malchut. He gives the same explanation for Yom Tov, since the formula adds gladness and joy.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas highlights this as a chiddush: he understands Rabbeinu Yonah to mean that the conclusion includes “Baruch ata Hashem elokeinu melech ha'olam,” and remarks that he had not heard this before.
  • Finally, regarding the Rif’s statement that someone who remembered after beginning Hatov Vehametiv returns to the beginning, some mefarshim explain that “the beginning” means the beginning of Birkat Hamazon.