Hanei gimel d'karchei rifta, three people who ate bread; behadei hadadei, together; u'kadim chad minayhu u'veirich le-nafshei (One of them preceded and blessed for himself); inun nafkin bezimun dideih (They fulfill their zimun through him); ihu lo nafik bezimun didehu (He does not fulfill their zimun); lefi she'ein zimun lemafre'a (because zimun cannot be done retroactively). We did that yesterday. The three people ate together, and one of them said Birkat Hamazon (Grace after Meals). We said they could still use an opportunity to do zimun, but he does not fulfill his mitzvah (commandment), because he has already blessed, while the other two do fulfill their obligation.
We need to see what the Rishonim (early authorities) say. Let’s look at the Rashba. I also want to see the Beit Yosef and the Shitah Mekubetzet.
The Rashba says: “Kelomar, sheyezamnu alav, vehu sheyehe sham”—meaning, they can invite him to join, provided he is there. “Ki ha milta bereish pirkin, korin lo umezamnin alav.” They call him and invite him to join. This is specifically when one of them blessed first: “Bidekadim chad minayhu, detrei adifei, delav kol kemineih deyachid levatel torat zimun minayhu.” One person does not have the power to annul the other two’s ability to do zimun.
But if two said the berachah (blessing), Birkat Hamazon, first, “Aval kadmu trei uverichu,” and the third says, “What did you do? I’m still here,” then “parach zimun minayhu, detrei mevatlei torat zimun mechad, vechein hilcheta.” The zimun has passed from them, because two can annul the zimun for one, and that is the halachah (Jewish law).
It tells you that you cannot break the zimun, but it does not explain how it works. With all due respect, no, ka mashma lan is another thing. He's not explaining how it works. Once you are chayav (obligated) to participate, you cannot break it. Why not? He has already said Birkat Hamazon. Isn’t saying Birkat Hamazon breaking the zimun? Zimun is an invitation for him to join and say the zimun. He has already done that. How does that not break it? We did not see Rabbenu Yonah. Maybe Rabbenu Yonah has something to say.
We say that he is not yotzei (fulfills his obligation); he is done. But he can still be efshar (possible) to be mashlim (complete) for the zimun. How does that work? It seems very strange. Is it like the four other people in the repetition of the Amidah who are not praying with the congregation, but count for the minyan (prayer quorum) to answer Kaddish or Kedushah? This man has already eaten and blessed, but he is still part of the zimun minyan, which requires three.
I don’t see why that should be difficult to accept. —Because in zimun, you need three active participants. —So in minyan, I guess, you could say the same thing about a minyan. Yeah, we are a minyan, a kahal (congregation) praying together, yet we accept six people praying and four just answering.
Even with a minyan, there is a delay; that is different from a minyan. If three people did not eat together—two ate together and one did not—you cannot bring in someone at random to make a minyan. Here, they did eat together; one of them just said Birkat Hamazon first.
That is different from a minyan. For a minyan, you can bring anybody at random to complete it. Here, you cannot bring anybody at random to complete the zimun. I understand that, but he was part of the meal. The problem is that the third person must have eaten; you cannot bring in a third person from the street. He was part of the meal. He just said Birkat Hamazon first by himself.
So why do you need someone who was part of the meal? Why can’t you have two people and then bring in a third, just like a minyan? I don’t know the answer, but that means the comparison is somewhat flawed; there is a step to step on it. The Rashba does not explain why; he just says that one person does not have the power to break it.
He was part of the meal. They ate together. It is not so complicated to assume that he can be part of the zimun. But you have to understand what zimun is for. It is not like a minyan, where we say, “We will be yotzei with the minyan; we need the tenth person.” Here, all three of us are going to pray to Hashem—to thank Hashem for the food He gave us. So it does not work to say, “Let me just get anybody and we’ll do zimun.” It is three people who ate together, and all three are going to pray to God. It is an invitation to pray.
The Me'iri, the Shitah Mekubetzet, and the Rashba all say the same thing. He has already said Birkat Hamazon. They can say zimun aloud, but he is not yotzei. The halachah is not like this. No, like Iki, the question is how can he help the other two be yotzei? They do not give the reason.
The Tur says: “Sheloshah she'achlu k'echad v'shachchu, u'veirach kol echad ve'echad le'atzmo, batal mehem hazimun ve'einam yecholim lachzor ulezamen lemafre'a.” Three people ate together, forgot, and each blessed individually; they have lost the zimun and cannot go back and do it retroactively. “Ve'im beirchu shnayim mehem”—if two of them blessed. “Aval im shachach echad mehem u'veirach, hashnayim yecholim lezamen al hashlishi, af al pi shekvar beirach.” If one of them forgot and blessed, the other two can do zimun with the third, even though he has already blessed. He can say, “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo” (Blessed is He from whose food we ate), because he is no worse than someone who ate a vegetable with them. They fulfill the zimun, but he does not fulfill the zimun, since zimun cannot be done retroactively.
The Beit Yosef brings the Gemara: “Amar Rava Tosfa'ah.” He also writes, “Ve-chatav ha-Rosh: Inun nafkei bezimun dideih.” The others fulfill their zimun, even though he has already blessed, because he can say, “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo.” He is no worse than someone who came during the meal and ate a vegetable with them, and says, “Baruch she'achalnu,” with them. However, he does not fulfill their zimun. The Rashba writes the same.
The Beit Yosef also brings a passage about the case where three people came from three groups and are not permitted to separate. “U'firakh u'firak hanizkar” is brought regarding the statement of Rav Huna: “Sheloshah sheba'u mishloshah chaburot, einam rashaim lechaleik.” According to Rabbenu Hai’s version, when it says that the others fulfill the zimun through him, that is where the third person has not yet fulfilled his zimun. But if he has fulfilled it—because he joined two people from two other groups and did zimun with them—then the zimun has passed from his original group, and he cannot do zimun with them afterward.
That is a different case. It is a case of five, with one person moving between two groups and eating with both. Can he do zimun with both? No. Once he has done zimun with one group, he cannot go back to the other one. Chazak u-varuch. I know it does not answer anything.
Can we infer something from the word “im shachach”—“if he forgot”? In other words, what if he did it on purpose? That is a good question and a good diyuk (inference). Let’s see whether any of the Acharonim (later authorities) infer that. So far, we have no sevara (reasoning).
The Ma'amar Mordechai asks what happens in a case of four people. Two of them say Birkat Hamazon first. He writes: “Yeish lehistapek be'arba'ah she'achlu, ushnayim mehem hikdimu u'veirchu belo zimun, ha'im yecholim hashnayim.” There is a doubt whether the two can do zimun. Two, after all, are more powerful than one. What about two and two? He writes that his view tends toward allowing them to do zimun, because they need only one of those who blessed to join them. In that respect, the majority did not bless, compared with one; the second remains as though he were not there.
The Bi'ur Halachah asks: “Shachach, ve'hu hadin hezid.” The same applies if he did it intentionally. “Venakat shachach aydi d'reisha”—it says “forgot” because that is the wording of the opening case. So the case where three people each said their own Birkat Hamazon was not malicious. The Bi'ur Halachah brings the Ma'amar Mordechai here.
Even more: suppose you have five, and three have already said Birkat Hamazon. How does that work? What is the sevara? Why? Because you need three. Yeah, but the third is gone. So, too bad. The explanations all say, in different words, “D'be'emet mechuyav b'zimun hu she'achal imahem b'yachad, ela she'ein lo takanah mishum shekvar beirach ve'ein zimun lemafre'a, lachen mahani hitztarfuto al kol panim shehem yotzim al yado.” In truth, he is obligated in zimun because he ate with them, but he has no remedy because he has already blessed and zimun cannot be done retroactively. Therefore, his joining still helps them fulfill their obligation.
They all say that in different words, but what is the reasoning? It is like a partnership that you cannot break, even if you have already left. It is not in your power to break the partnership. This has nothing to do with the issue, but can you make something muktzeh (set aside from use) for somebody else? Who would have a crazy sevara on this? We should call Rav Eliyahu Levin.
Look at the Beit Yosef in kuf-tzadi-gimel, the previous section, siman alef (section one), se'if alef (subsection one), dibur hamatchil katuv. It looks as if he brings a difference regarding ten and one. No, no, ten and one said something. One said no and he said by himself. It seems to be that he holds that the ten cannot hold them to do. He cites the Tosefta in Berachot, chapter five: “B'esrim nechleku, u'vilvad shelo yehe bahem echad shemaftirin oto min hazimun.” With twenty, they may divide, provided there is not one person whom they exclude from the zimun. The Beit Yosef explains: “V'nireh li d'hachi peirusho, d'ha d'esrim nechlakin davka k'sheshum echad mehem lo zimen klal, aval im echad mehem kadam v'zimen bishlosha o beirach Birkat Hamazon le'atzmo, einam nechlakin.” It seems to me that the meaning is that twenty may divide only if none of them has done zimun at all. But if one of them went ahead and did zimun with three, or blessed Birkat Hamazon by himself, they may not divide, because those with him cannot do zimun with a name of God: since he went ahead and did zimun, the zimun has passed from him and he does not join them.
That seems to contradict what we just said. I suppose it is because they have the possibility of doing it with ten anyway. There are nineteen without him, so why bring him in? We still do not have the sevara explaining the mechanics: how can you be part of it, but not part of it?
There is also a meimra (statement) in the Gemara: “Amar Rav: Sheloshah she'achlu k'echad v'yatza echad mehem lashuk, korin lo u'mezamnin alav. Ta'ama d'korin lo, ha lo korin lo, lo. Shani hatam d'akru lehu chovah (obligation) me'ikara.” Rav said that if three ate together and one went out to the marketplace, they call him and do zimun with him. The implication is that they call him; if they do not call him, they do not. The case is different there, because the obligation was established from the outset.
We have been saying that. The question is why. As Avram was saying, there is a chalut (legal status) of a chiyuv (obligation) of zimun when you sit down. When does that obligation start? When you eat. Now one person leaves and starts blessing, while the other two say, “Wait, we still have a pending obligation that you can join.” But isn’t it connected to his Birkat Hamazon? Is it connected to his Birkat Hamazon? For sure. Yeah. So when he finishes Birkat Hamazon, he is essentially saying, “I made a mistake. I said Birkat Hamazon, and I am not connected with you anymore because I am done.” We are saying, “No, you disconnected; we did not disconnect.” That should be the end of it. We are missing a sevara. None of the Rishonim gives one.
Is it simply divrei Kabbalah? The only sevara we have is that he is no worse than someone who ate a vegetable. I think it could be worse than someone eating a vegetable. The person eating a vegetable has that hitztarfut (joining together) and is still joining them. You could consider it a small hitztarfut: he cannot say the zimun, but he is still part of the meal. That would be a great chiddush (novel insight). But the person who disconnected is worse than someone who is connected through a piece of candy. Why is that a good sevara?
Here is what the book says: “Inun nafkin bezimun didan.” Tosafot Rabbeinu Yehudah, in the dibur hamatchil “Shama,” and the Rosh explain that even though he has already blessed, he can join them and say, “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo,” because he is no worse than someone who came at the end of the meal and drank a revi'it or ate a leaf of a vegetable, and says, “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo” with them, even though he is not obligated. The Magen Avraham writes the same, and the Shulchan Aruch brings a disagreement about whether that works at all.
But hold on. He said a key phrase I had not thought about: “Af al pi she'eino chayav”—even though he is not obligated. He does not have a din (law) of being chayav in zimun, but he still helps them. That is what we are saying. Maybe that is the only sevara we have, so we have to work with it. Maybe it shows that you have an efsharut (possibility) of taking part in an obligation that you yourself do not have. That is a pele (wonder). I am not chayav in Birkat Hamazon; I am not chayav in zimun either. But I am helping them. If you are not chayav in Birkat Hamazon, you are not chayav in zimun. And yet you can participate there.
So we are going back to Avram’s sevara: you are completing the minyan. But then why can’t you bring in somebody at random? That is what we have to think about: why do you still need some connection? I have a small, not very nice sevara. Are you chayav to complete the minyan? Yeah. The only thing to say is: you're talking about chiyuv, okay, ability. Eating something and being part of the group joins you, even though eating that food does not create an obligation. Or you could say that since he already ate with them, he never got rid of that connection. He is still attached to them through it, even though he will never be able to fulfill his obligation; he can still help them.
Why does simply being present, even sleeping, complete the minyan? It is a matter of presence. You have ten souls, and it works. Here there are three, so you are creating something that has no spiritual component. Think about it coldly, secularly. There is no spirituality in three people eating together. It is just the fact that they formed a group through food. Then, when the obligation to say Birkat Hamazon comes later, they have been eating as one unit.
Can you say that he is not chayav in the way we are describing, but their chiyuv is connected to his? There was already a chiyuv. He is stuck with it, because of Birkat Hamazon, which he will never be able to fulfill. He himself is not chayav, but he has a chiyuv connected to theirs. No, I am still stuck. Can we focus on this for a moment? He is chayav. He will never be able to fulfill it, because he has already said Birkat Hamazon. He left himself out.
All we have to study here is how you connect three people. I like the minyan comparison; it is the only thing we have to compare with. In a minyan, you can have one or two people who are not praying. That is enough. I think you are getting back to what the study is saying: there is a spiritual element based on the pesukim (verses), and there is an edah (congregation); that is ten people. Do I have to do anything to connect to the other nine? Nothing.
The connection of three does not exist anywhere in the Torah. There is no spiritual component to it. We do not find anywhere that three, four, five, six, up to nine people have a spiritual connection. There is one, or nine, and then ten. Once you get to ten, you have a minyan and a davar shebikdushah (matter of holiness). That does not exist below ten in any other topic. The only thing is zimun. What is this miraculous zimun? It is based on a pasuk (verse), probably an asmachta (supporting allusion) from “gadlu l'Hashem iti uneromemah shemo yachdav” (Magnify Hashem with me; let us exalt His name together). But that does not create any kedushah. There is no din of kedushah here. It is a way to do berov am (with a multitude), or a pasuk that supports the structure described. That is all.
How do you connect three people? Not through souls; it is not ten souls anymore. It is three people eating. That is true: it is three people eating. The question now is whether the Torah goes by rov (majority). In a minyan, ideally, all ten people pray. But if seven are praying and three are not—or nine are praying and one is not—can you make a minyan? Yes. Great. Can I do the same with two and one? Yes. But there, the connector is the fact that there are ten people; the Shechinah, the Divine Presence, comes. Here there is no Shechinah. It is three. What connects them? Food. Food connects the three, not the chiyuv.
The connection is mundane: three people ate together. What do they have to eat? At least two need to eat bread, because the chiyuv is Birkat Hamazon. According to that shitah (opinion), one does not have to eat bread. Am I connected? Yes, like the person sleeping in a minyan. But in a minyan, the Shechinah comes and connects the ten souls. Here there are three people, and nothing connects them other than food. The connector is the food. The chiyuv of Birkat Hamazon is gone, because you have already said Birkat Hamazon, but the hitztarfut of the three still exists. It does not matter whether you say Birkat Hamazon or not.
Suppose one of the three says, “I do not pray. I never say Birkat Hamazon.” He is a chiloni (secular Jew), and the other two are dati (religious). Can they do zimun? Yes. You have three people who ate together. He says, “I am not going to say Birkat Hamazon. I am telling you in advance: you do zimun, and I get up and leave.” That is fine. There is a connector. The connection happens spiritually in a minyan, through the presence of the Shechinah. Here there is no Shechinah; the only way to connect the three is through food. The connection exists regardless of Birkat Hamazon, which is a huge chiddush.
Then you go by rov. Now I have two and one: two people are saying Birkat Hamazon, and one is not doing his chiyuv because he has already said Birkat Hamazon, or he is a poshea (transgressor) and does not say Birkat Hamazon. That is his problem. Is he still connected to us, to complete the rov? Yes. But this is not the rov of a minyan. Here we have three, not two and nothing. If he left, you would not say rov; you need two plus one.
Maybe that is the pshat (plain meaning). That is why “alei shel yarak” (a leaf of a vegetable) is fundamental: it shows that he has no chiyuv of Birkat Hamazon, but he can be the tenth in a minyan, or the third here. So you go by two; you go by the rov. At the end of the day, that sevara is the only way to do it. You need to combine the minyan comparison—thank you, Avraham—with the way to count three. Three does not have that spiritual component; it has only a physical component. If it is a physical component, then Birkat Hamazon is removed from the equation in order to make the hitztarfut, and now you can do rov. That is the pshat.
I would not say it is physical. There is definitely a spiritual part to it, because we learned that two rabbis plus Shabbat made three. That means it is not a physical component. We also learned that the halachah is not like that. Maybe that is why the halachah is not like that: perhaps that is not how it works. And that is how we learned the reason was. But maybe the rabbi who holds that shitah would not accept this. Still, that means there is a spiritual component, too. They would not say that sevara if there were no spiritual component. Maybe that is the machloket (disagreement).
Maybe there is an additional component: zimun and Birkat Hamazon are separate. When you complete the zimun by answering, “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo,” you have, in a way, blessed partially. The invitation is to say Birkat Hamazon, but once he has said, “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo,” the zimun part is complete. Then we can go with the case of someone who does not pray and does not say Birkat Hamazon. He is clearly not joining, but perhaps it works because he answered, “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo.” He is saying, “I am not going to say Birkat Hamazon, but I completed the invitation to bless, and we said ‘Baruch she'achalnu mishelo.’” That is a very different sevara. I understand it; I am just adding it.
The nafka mina (practical difference) between the two explanations would be what happens if the third person is sleeping, or is deaf and unable to speak. Can you say zimun? It is easier to find a case in halachah where the third person is sleeping. As with a minyan, the tenth person could be sleeping. There was hitztarfut through the food, but can you do rov? According to the other explanation, he did not say “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo,” so he is not part of the zimun. He might tell you, “I am not joining.”
My uncle is against it, but he ate with us. Can we do zimun on time? Don’t ask. You still require an answer. This happens often: you have three people, and one does not know what zimun is; he is an am ha'aretz (ignoramus). Some people do zimun and the others have no idea what is happening. Usually there are more people, but suppose you have three and one answers while the other is lost. You do not do it.
I think the nafka mina would be this: if you use the rov, then according to my sevara it should work. That would be a big chiddush. Let me check the halachah. You have a third person who is not going to answer. Where can I find this? Next to the explanation of this case. That should be the nafka mina: according to your explanation, it would not work; according to mine, it should.
It also creates a problem for the shitah of the Sefaradim (Sephardim), where the first berachah (blessing) is connected to the zimun. This person who is coming back is definitely not saying the first berachah again; he is just answering the zimun. How is that a good answer?
“Shnayim she'achlu k'echad vegamru, uva shlishi”—two people ate together and finished, and a third person came. “Mitzvah lehamtin lo kedei sheyitztaref imahem, u'tzerichim liten lo le'echol kedei sheyitztaref imahem.” It is a mitzvah to wait for him so that he can join them, and they must give him something to eat so that he can join them. “Vehu sheba ad shelo amru hav lan venivrich”—that is when he comes before they say “Hav lan venivrich” (let us prepare and bless). “Aval im amru hav lan venivrich uva shlishi, eino mitztaref imahem.” But if they have said that and then the third person comes, he does not join them.
“Tishah she'achlu dagan (grain)”—nine people ate grain. “Hamitztaref tzarich levarech berachah acharonah mah she'achal, ve'eino mevarech Birkat Hamazon.” The person who joins must say the after-blessing for what he ate, but does not say Birkat Hamazon. “Bameh devarim amurim? Shemitztaref bechol ma'achal lehashlim le'asarah, aval lishloshah eino mitztaref ad sheyochal kezayit (olive-sized amount) pat.” This applies when joining to complete ten: he may join after eating any food. But to complete three, he does not join unless he eats an olive-sized amount of bread.
“Yeish omrim devichzayit dagan.” Some say an olive-sized amount of grain suffices. “Yeish omrim deveyerek o vechol ma'achal.” Some say a vegetable or any food suffices.
“Chaverim she'achlu k'echad, kevi'utam kedei sheyevarech”—friends who ate together have established their meal in order to bless. If three ate together, then if the third person is still there but not answering, that is the question. If he left, it certainly does not work. Then why don't we call the third one? Why don't we do that? Why? Because he is not going to answer. If that were not the issue, perhaps it would work, since you ate with him. I have to check. “Ela im ken yatza echad min hashuk, korin lo u'mezamnin alav.” Unless one went out to the marketplace, they call him and do zimun with him. I’ll check.