A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Gemara Berachot Daf 50a #580 Someone who already said birkat hamazon-Zimun?

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
May 5, 2026
Duration
30:45
Lecture code
RGK-1793

The basic case and the Rashba

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas begins by reviewing the Gemara’s case: three people ate bread together, and one said Birkat Hamazon before the others. The other two may still do zimun with him, but he does not fulfill his own zimun, because zimun cannot be done retroactively.
  • The Rashba explains that the other two may invite him to join, provided he is present. One person cannot annul the other two’s ability to do zimun.
  • If two of the three have already said Birkat Hamazon, however, the zimun has passed from them: two can annul the zimun for the remaining one. The Rashba says this is the halachah.
  • The Rashba states the outcome but does not explain its mechanics. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas asks how the first person’s having already said Birkat Hamazon does not break the zimun, since zimun is an invitation to join and say the zimun.
  • The person is no longer yotzei, but can apparently still help complete the zimun for the others. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas considers whether this resembles a minyan in which some people are not praying but can still count toward the quorum. He notes a difference: for zimun, all three must have eaten together; one cannot bring in a random third person as one might complete a minyan.
  • He suggests that the comparison with a minyan is therefore imperfect. Zimun is not simply a matter of finding a third person: it involves three people who ate together and are joining to thank Hashem for the food.
  • The Me'iri, Shitah Mekubetzet, and Rashba give the same basic ruling: the person who already said Birkat Hamazon may join aloud, but is not yotzei. They do not explain why he can help the other two.

The Tur and Beit Yosef

  • The Tur rules that if three people ate together, forgot to do zimun, and each blessed individually, they have lost the zimun and cannot do it retroactively. If only one blessed, the other two can do zimun with him even though he has already blessed.
  • The person can say, “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo” (“Blessed is He from whose food we ate”). The Tur says he is no worse than someone who ate a vegetable with them: the others fulfill their zimun through him, but he does not fulfill his own, because zimun cannot be done retroactively.
  • The Beit Yosef cites the Gemara’s “Amar Rava Tosfa'ah” and the Rosh: the others fulfill their zimun because the person can say “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo,” just as someone who arrived during the meal and ate a vegetable could say it with them. The Rashba says the same.
  • The Beit Yosef also discusses three people who came from three different groups and may not separate. According to Rabbenu Hai’s version, the original group can do zimun through the third person only if he has not already fulfilled zimun. If he already did zimun with two people from other groups, the zimun has passed from the original group.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas distinguishes that case: it concerns five people, with one person moving between two groups. Once he has done zimun with one group, he cannot return to do zimun with the other.

Intentional blessing and cases with more people

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas asks whether the Tur’s wording “im shachach” (“if he forgot”) implies a different ruling when the person blessed intentionally.
  • The Ma'amar Mordechai raises a case of four people, two of whom blessed first without zimun. He is uncertain whether the remaining two can do zimun. His inclination is to allow it: they need only one of the two who blessed to join them, so the fact that one additional person blessed does not change the situation.
  • The Bi'ur Halachah writes, “Shachach, ve'hu hadin hezid”: the same ruling applies if the person acted intentionally. “Forgot” is used because that is the wording of the earlier case. The Bi'ur Halachah brings the Ma'amar Mordechai.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas asks what happens when five people ate together and three have already said Birkat Hamazon. The explanations he has seen say, in different formulations, that the person who ate with them was in truth obligated in zimun, but has no remedy after blessing because zimun cannot be retroactive; nevertheless, his joining helps the others fulfill their obligation.
  • He presses for the underlying reasoning: why does the person remain able to help after disconnecting himself by blessing? He compares it tentatively to a partnership that one cannot break merely by leaving, while acknowledging that this analogy does not itself explain the halachah.

The Tosefta on twenty people

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas examines the Beit Yosef’s discussion of the Tosefta in Berachot, chapter five: “B'esrim nechleku, u'vilvad shelo yehe bahem echad shemaftirin oto min hazimun”—twenty may divide, provided they do not exclude one person from the zimun.
  • The Beit Yosef explains that twenty may divide only if nobody has done zimun. If one person already did zimun with three, or blessed Birkat Hamazon by himself, the others may not divide, because the zimun has passed from him and he cannot join them.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that this appears to conflict with the earlier case. He suggests that perhaps the difference is that the group of twenty still has the possibility of making zimun with ten without the person who blessed. The mechanics of being both connected to, and excluded from, the zimun remain unexplained.

The Gemara’s case of the person who left

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas cites Rav’s statement: if three ate together and one went out to the marketplace, they call him and do zimun with him. The implication is that if they do not call him, they do not do zimun with him; the Gemara distinguishes this case because the obligation was established from the outset.
  • The discussion returns to when the zimun obligation begins. One suggestion is that it begins when the group eats. If one person leaves and starts Birkat Hamazon, the other two may still have a pending obligation that he can join. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas questions why his completed Birkat Hamazon does not end that connection, and notes that none of the Rishonim presented so far supplies the underlying reasoning.
  • He considers whether the ruling is simply divrei Kabbalah, and whether the comparison to someone who ate a vegetable is sufficient. Such a person remains connected through what he ate, whereas the person who already blessed may have disconnected himself.

Possible explanations for the connection

  • Tosafot Rabbeinu Yehudah, in dibur hamatchil “Shama,” and the Rosh explain that the person who already blessed can join and say “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo,” because he is no worse than someone who arrived at the end of the meal and drank a revi'it or ate a leaf of a vegetable, even though that person is not obligated in Birkat Hamazon. The Magen Avraham gives the same explanation; the Shulchan Aruch brings a disagreement about whether this works at all.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas focuses on the phrase “af al pi she'eino chayav” (“even though he is not obligated”). It suggests that someone who is not himself obligated in zimun can still help others fulfill their obligation. He calls this a pele (wonder), since someone who is not obligated in Birkat Hamazon is also not obligated in zimun, yet may still participate in it.
  • He revisits the minyan comparison and asks why, if the person is merely completing the group, any third person cannot be brought in. One possible explanation is that eating with the group creates a continuing connection, even if that eating does not itself create an obligation.
  • He proposes that a minyan is based on the presence of ten people, whereas the connection in zimun is formed by eating together. The three people ate as one unit; the zimun connection remains even after one has said Birkat Hamazon. On this account, Birkat Hamazon is no longer relevant to whether the person remains part of the group.
  • He illustrates this with a person who ate with two others but says in advance that he will not say Birkat Hamazon and will leave when they do zimun. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas suggests that the two could still have a connection through having eaten together.
  • He then considers whether zimun follows a form of rov (majority): two people say Birkat Hamazon, while the third remains connected to them even though he will not fulfill his obligation, whether because he already blessed or because he refuses to do so. This is not the same as a minyan, where the connection comes from ten people; here, the group consists of three, and the third person’s prior participation in the meal matters.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas suggests that “alei shel yarak” (“a leaf of a vegetable”) is central to this reasoning: it shows that a person without an obligation in Birkat Hamazon can still count as the third. He combines the minyan comparison with the idea that three are connected by eating, not by a spiritual status equivalent to a minyan.
  • He qualifies this proposal by recalling that a view previously learned treated two rabbis plus Shabbat as making three, though that is not the halachah. That case may indicate a spiritual component to zimun, and perhaps the disagreement reflects different understandings of what connects the three.
  • He offers another possible explanation: zimun and Birkat Hamazon are separate. By answering “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo,” the person has completed the zimun portion, even if he does not continue with Birkat Hamazon. This would explain his role differently from the idea that his connection comes solely from having eaten with the group.

Possible practical difference between the explanations

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas identifies a possible nafka mina between the explanations: what if the third person is asleep, or is deaf and unable to speak? If the connection is through eating and the group’s majority, perhaps he can still count; if participation requires answering “Baruch she'achalnu mishelo,” he cannot.
  • He also considers a third person who refuses to answer or does not understand what zimun is. He says that one still requires an answer, and that in the ordinary case where a person is lost during zimun, one does not do it.
  • He suggests that this non-answering case could distinguish the explanations: his proposed rov-based explanation might allow it, while the explanation requiring an answer would not. He says he needs to check the halachah.
  • He notes a further difficulty for the Sefaradim, whose practice connects the first berachah to the zimun: the person who has already returned or blessed would not repeat the first berachah, but would only answer the zimun. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas asks how that works under that practice.

A third person joining after the meal

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas cites the case of two people who ate together and finished, and then a third arrived. It is a mitzvah to wait for him and give him something to eat so he can join them, provided he arrives before they say “Hav lan venivrich” (“let us prepare and bless”). If they have already said that, he does not join them.
  • When nine people ate grain, the person joining must say the after-blessing for what he ate, but does not say Birkat Hamazon.
  • For completing ten, the person may join after eating any food. For completing three, he does not join unless he eats a kezayit of bread. Other opinions say that a kezayit of grain suffices, or that a vegetable or any food suffices.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas returns to the case of friends who ate together and asks whether a third person who is still present but does not answer can count. If he has left, he certainly cannot count. He wonders why they cannot call him to join, as in the case of someone who went out to the marketplace, and says he needs to check the issue.
Words in this lecture1
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem