A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Gemara Berachot Daf 50a #585 Can one change table for zimun? Halacha Lemaaseh

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
May 13, 2026
Duration
46:36
Lecture code
RGK-1798

Framing the Cases in Siman kuf-tzadi-gimel, se'if heh

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas asks how the Shulchan Aruch should rule in light of the cases discussed previously. He notes that the Rambam and Rif do not state a position here, while the Rosh does.
  • The key is to treat the three-three-three and four-four-four situations as different cases, rather than assume that the Rishonim are giving conflicting rulings about one case. A halachic ruling can address both, since both situations can arise.
  • In the three-three-three case, lo lechalek applies at the original tables. Once a person joins another group, however, he cannot assume that leaving his original table removes his personal obligation: he ate with the new group, so he remains obligated to say Birkat Hamazon.
  • The four-four-four case is the chidush. A person need not remain at his original table: he leaves three people behind, whose zimun is unaffected, and may join a new group as long as he continues to fulfill his chiyuv zimun.

Three People from Three Groups: Whether Zimun Was Already Said

  • The Gemara’s case, sheloshah sheba'u mishalosh chaburot, describes three people who came from three groups of three and joined together. One reading among the Rishonim is that each had already participated in zimun with two others at his original table.
  • If they had already answered zimun there, they cannot say zimun again. They had to answer until Hazan; even if the three later eat another kezayit together and finish their meal, they do not acquire another chiyuv zimun.
  • Rav Hai Gaon explains lo lechalek in this situation as meaning that they cannot separate from the original group after zimun has already been said there. They must say Birkat Hamazon without zimun, even if they are now sitting and eating together.
  • Whether a person who continues eating after answering zimun needs netilat yadayim again is a separate machloket. The halachah is that he does not: under safek berachot lehakel, he continues eating without washing again, since he has not said Birkat Hamazon and has not ended the same meal.
  • The discussion also distinguishes someone who wants to keep eating from someone who does not want to eat more but intends to say Birkat Hamazon later. Rashi is cited regarding continuing from Nodeh Lecha. Even according to shittot that include Hazan et hakol in zimun, someone who intends to eat more is not yotze with Hazan et hakol; the general halachah in that case is to begin Birkat Hamazon from the beginning and continue eating without a berachah.
  • As long as a person has not said Birkat Hamazon, he remains within the first seudah and cannot recite another zimun.

If Zimun Was Not Said at the Original Tables

  • If they did not say zimun in their original groups, they remain obligated in zimun and are not permitted to divide. The wording is difficult, because it seems to require the three to say zimun together even if they did not eat together after joining.
  • One straightforward reading is that if two people say Birkat Hamazon and the third answers with them through Hazan, that third person has already participated in zimun and cannot return to another group, whatever he eats afterward.
  • A different situation is where the person leaves before any zimun has been said. He may then join new people, but the question is what happens to the two he left behind and the obligations of the original groups.
  • One approach is that the person can carry his still-pending chiyuv to another group, while the others must resolve their own obligations. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas questions whether that is adequate: the halachic ruling should not leave the remaining people with an unresolved problem.
  • The difficulty is illustrated by three people meeting at a bar who have not eaten together. If two of them ask the third to return, can he instead say he is now part of a new group and must recite zimun with the other two, despite not having eaten with them? The suggestion is that an unresolved obligation can be carried like a debt, but it is not simply a personal debt: it originated in a group obligation.
  • This transfer seems to work only if the people left behind also have a way to resolve their obligation. The question is therefore not only how the new group is formed, but whether the person was entitled to leave the original group.

Bi'ur Halachah and the Effect of Leaving a Group

  • The Bi'ur Halachah says that the same law apparently applies when one person interrupts for two: the zimun has departed from him, leaving only two there. It cites the Riaz and halachic novellae, while its discussion of the Magen Avraham appears to indicate that a person may join the same two again if they eat together and have not yet said zimun.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas examines whether the zimun departs from the whole group when one person leaves. The cases must be distinguished: two people can compel the third to interrupt for them, but one person cannot compel the other two to interrupt.
  • The phrase hifsik lishnayim means that one person interrupts for two. The discussion considers whether the Bi'ur Halachah is describing a different case in which that person leaves before zimun is said, and whether the novelty is that he may leave because the others have not yet recited zimun.
  • The cited ruling in section 200 says that when three ate together, one is compelled to interrupt for the two and answer their zimun. Even if he does not want to interrupt, they recite zimun with him, whether he answers or not, as long as he remains there.
  • The two, however, cannot be compelled to interrupt for one. If they do not agree to interrupt, the one cannot simply recite a blessing and leave; he must wait until they finish and recite zimun with them, since he became obligated in zimun by eating with them.
  • He need interrupt only until he says, “baruch she'achalnu mishelo,” and so on. This raises the possibility that he can carry his chiyuv elsewhere, but the question remains how he may leave the original group and how a new group is established.

Repeated Zimun with New People

  • The Mishnah Berurah, section 200, subsection 9, cites decisors who say that one person may interrupt for two more than once. For example, after one person has interrupted for two, two new people may come and eat with him.
  • The new people need to have eaten with him in this case, so that they form a new zimun group. The Mishnah Berurah says the person can interrupt for them as well, and again for further new pairs, because those people have not yet said zimun.
  • By contrast, if five people were in the original group and one interrupted for two, he cannot later say zimun with the two who remain, even if they eat together afterward. Their zimun has already departed through the first zimun.
  • The distinction appears to be between a new zimun formed with two people who have not yet said zimun and a repeat zimun with the same people who were already included.
  • In a group of seven or eight, one person may interrupt for two and later interrupt for others who remain, since the original group had enough people to form zimun. But the first two cannot return and make another zimun with the same people; the discussion concludes that the possible zimun groupings are limited to two.
  • The lecture raises, but does not resolve, a related question about a group of 19 or 20 and Elokeinu. With 20, groups of ten are possible; with 19, they are not. The chiyuv of zimun is stronger than the chiyuv of Elokeinu, and creating Elokeinu is easier when the zimun obligation already exists for nine. The open question is whether one person can participate in both groups.

Why Those Who Already Said Zimun Cannot Repeat It

  • The Shulchan Aruch states that those who already said zimun cannot say it again, even if they later eat together and finish their meal.
  • The Mishnah Berurah explains that the zimun had already departed from them when zimun was said over them earlier. They must still say Birkat Hamazon from the beginning, from Birkat Hazan, as explained in section 200.
  • The novelty is that all three had already been included in zimun with their original groups; there are not two new people who have not yet said zimun. One person may be drawn into a new zimun by two people who are still eligible, but two cannot draw someone into another zimun when all three have already participated in the earlier zimun.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that these cases are uncommon but can occur at weddings, when people move between tables, and in restaurants. He adds that the “roof” story is not really about a roof, but about a united place.

The Case Where They Did Not Say Zimun in Their Original Places

  • The second case is lo zimnu aleihem mimekomam: they did not say zimun at their original places, but got up and joined at a new place, group D. The ruling is that they are obligated to say zimun and are not permitted to divide.
  • One explanation is that each person brings a personal, still-pending chiyuv zimun from his original group, and their obligations join when they come together. This does not necessarily mean that they ate together.
  • Section 6 had explained that separating from a group of three is forbidden because it causes that group to lose its zimun. The present case may be bedi'avad, after the original group has already separated.
  • If the original group is still available, Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says it seems the person must return to it: he cannot create a new chiyuv zimun while the original one is still pending. If the others have left, however, three people who are each personally obligated in zimun may sit together and recite it, even if they did not eat together.
  • The phrase eino rashai lechalek sounds like a prohibition against leaving, rather than merely permission to fulfill an obligation elsewhere. The wording hitva'adu yachad suggests that the three formed a group: their personal chiyuvim have joined, so one may not leave even if he did not eat with the other two.
  • This does not mean that a person must go searching for two others. The point is what happens once he finds himself with two other people after his original group is no longer available. If the original group is still there, he should return to it.

Ones, Financial Loss, and the Unresolved Case

  • The Mishnah Berurah gives an alternative, citing the Eliyah Rabbah and later authorities: in a case of ones or hefsed mamon, one person may finish his meal before the other two and say Birkat Hamazon by himself. The example is someone who must leave to catch a flight.
  • The Mishnah Berurah adds that if these three people, who were compelled to hurry, later happen to meet together, they should recite zimun together.
  • The discussion considers whether three people with separate pending obligations can meet, form a new zimun, and then leave. It is unclear how this fits with einam rasha'im lechalek: once they have formed the new group, perhaps one cannot divide from it, although the original zimun obligation seems stronger.
  • The case remains difficult if someone becomes subject to ones after the new group has formed. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas returns to the distinction that if the original group is still available, the person should go back to it.
  • The final question is makom she'achal, the place where he ate: if he can see his table, that is sufficient. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas leaves the further case to be revisited.
Words in this lecture1
Gemaraגמרא
Terms Gemara, the Talmud's discussion of the Mishnah. English: Commentary on the Mishnah
Also written: Gemarah, G'mara, Guemara, gmara
Plural: gemarot, gemaras