So, siman (section) kuf-tzadi-gimel, se'if (subsection) heh. Before you look, what would you do if you were the Shulchan Aruch? How would you posek halachah (decide halachah) in this, based on what we discussed yesterday and the day before? Which case first?
We also have the Rambam, who did not speak. The Rosh spoke. Did the Rif speak? No. The Rif didn't speak. The Rosh spoke. No. Hm. I think if we bring in the fourth person to the remaining tables, or to the original tables, everything fits, even if the words are not there. Everything fits and is explainable. Otherwise, unless you take my approach—
“No, hold on. I’m going to stop you in the middle. We don’t care—let me stop you for a second. Now you’re thinking in terms of Gemara. I’m in halachah mode. These are two different cases.”
“Which ones? Are we talking about four or three?”
“That’s for the Gemara, to understand the case. Now I’m a posek halachot (decide halachah). If I were the Shulchan Aruch, I’d write both cases.”
“That makes sense.”
“That’s why I wanted to stop you. Now you need a psak (ruling) for three-three-three and for four-four-four.”
So, for three-three-three, lo lechalek (not to divide) applies at al hashulchanot harishonot (at the original tables). Once there is a fourth person, lo lechalek means that you cannot get rid of your obligation. You might have thought that you no longer had a personal obligation once you split from that group, and that you would now have to say Birkat Hamazon (Grace After Meals) by yourself. But since you joined the third group, besha'ah she'achalta (at the time you ate), you have to say it.
Let’s start with the easy case: four-four-four. That is the chidush (novel point). Do you agree that you have Rishonim (early authorities) learning the same case in different scenarios? If it were the same scenario with different rulings, we would have a problem: how could I decide the halachah? But if I’m the Shulchan Aruch, it is actually easy once I recognize that we are talking about different cases. I can address all the cases, because all of them could happen.
In the four-four-four case, do you have to stay at your table? No, because you have two chiyuvim (obligation): one to your group and one to yourself. Regarding your group, there is no problem: you are leaving three people behind, and that will have no consequence for them. Are you allowed to form a new group with the other people? Yes, as long as you continue with your chiyuv zimun (obligation of zimun) and onward.
What about the three-three-three case? That is two different cases. Let’s see what happens. Maybe he will bring Tosafot (Tosafot); maybe he will bring the Rosh. Also, if you eat again, don’t you have to eat again? At least I want to make that distinction.
Sheloshah sheba'u mishalosh chaburot (Three who came from three groups). We start with the case of three and three, which is the simple reading of the Gemara, so I suppose that was the obvious choice: three people who come from three groups, each of three people, and venitchaberu elu hasheloshah (and these three joined together).
There are a few cases. One reading among the Rishonim is that they already did zimun (invitation to bless together) two and one, and wanted to continue. Let’s consider that, and then consider what happens if they did not. Im zimnu aleihem bimkomam (If they recited zimun in their place): if they already participated in zimun, meaning there were three of them and each one interrupted for two, they had to answer the zimun to those two, until they said Hazan (the One who sustains). They had just answered the zimun, so they can no longer recite zimun.
What if the three of them ate another kezayit (olive-sized portion) together? Perhaps they now have a new chiyuv zimun. No. Afilu achlu achar kach yachad vegamru se'udatan (even if they later ate together and finished their meal), they are not allowed to recite zimun. What is the interpretation? That would be like Rav Hai Gaon: “They are not permitted to divide” means they cannot divide from the first group. They already recited zimun there and finished.
They are supposed to say Birkat Hamazon without zimun, even though the three are sitting together and eating more. Does the person who wants to continue eating have to wash his hands again? That is a different machloket (dispute). In this scenario, two recited zimun and one wants to continue eating. Does he need to do netilat yadayim (ritual handwashing) again? The halachah is that he does not. Safek berachot lehakel (in doubt, be lenient with blessings); he continues eating. For him, it is the same meal. As long as he has not said Birkat Hamazon, he has not brought his meal to an end, and therefore he cannot recite another zimun.
There was a discussion about whether he continued from Nodeh Lecha (We thank You). Rashi said that. If he wants to eat more, even in the shittot that include Hazan et hakol in zimun, he is not yotze with Hazan et hakol. That is different from the case where he does not want to eat more but plans to say Birkat Hamazon later. Otherwise, the general halachah is that you start from the beginning, and continue eating without a berachah.
That is the case. Can you recite another zimun? Absolutely not. As long as I have not said Birkat Hamazon, I am still in the first seudah (meal).
Ve'im lo zimnu aleihem bimkomam (If they did not recite zimun in their place), then they did not recite zimun in groups A, B, and C. They are obligated to recite zimun and are not permitted to divide. That wording is not very helpful; it does not tell us what is happening. It sounds as though the three have to recite zimun together, even if they did not eat together after joining.
As I understand the straightforward reading, the case is three people from three different places. If two decide to say Birkat Hamazon and the third is there, they make him say Birkat Hazan. He stays until Hazan. He cannot go back, no matter what he eats afterward with the other three people he meets. He has already recited zimun; he is finished. That is the first case.
Now suppose they did not recite zimun. For example, he left, they did not recite zimun, and he decides he will recite zimun with these other people. Can he break away from the new group? He is part of the new group. The problem is what the other two are obligated to do with the people who remain there. There are three groups, and he has left the other group with a problem: how will they recite zimun?
One reading is that we do not concern ourselves with how the other six solve their problem. They have a problem, and they have to solve it. But einam rasha'im lechalek (they are not permitted to divide): now these three Avrahams (Abraham) are standing by the bar. Did they eat together? Let’s take the difficult case: they did not eat together; they are simply there. Yitzchak (Isaac) and Yaakov (Jacob) come to Avraham and ask him to come back. He says, “No, I’m part of this group now. I have to recite zimun here.” With whom? With the other two Avrahams, whom he did not eat with. Just because he sat with them at the bar? That does not seem right. If they did not eat anything together, what made them into a group?
“Maybe the obligation is still pending. If you don’t resolve it here, you can carry it to another group.”
“But the other two are still saying, ‘Come back to us.’”
“You have an obligation that you can carry. It is like a debt: as long as you haven’t paid it here, you can carry it somewhere else.”
“But it is not a personal debt.”
“It is both. It is based on a group, but it becomes personal. It seems that this only works when there is a solution for the others, because this case is not one where there are only three people.”
Fair enough. As long as they can also resolve their issue, you can carry your chiyuv to another group. When I read the wording, it seems that he is copying the wording of the Gemara without explicitly addressing what happens to the others. That was a dispute among the Rishonim. This is a halachah book; we cannot leave the others with a problem. That is what the Mishnah Berurah is here for. Let’s see how he decides the halachah.
Kaf-tet, kol echad lishnayim (each one for two): see Bi'ur Halachah. That means it is complicated. Let’s look at the Bi'ur Halachah. It is not complicated in itself; it is confusing why we do not care about the other group. No, that is something else. We should care about the others. Here, he is going to explain what we already know.
The Bi'ur Halachah says: “Lecha'orah nireh dehu hadin im echad mehen hifsik lishnayim, gam ken amrinan dekvar parach zimun mineih, velo nish'aru kan ela shenayim” (Apparently, the same applies if one of them interrupted for two: we also say that the zimun has already departed from him, and only two remain here). “Vechen matzati ba-Riaz uvechidushei halachah” (And so I found in the Riaz and in the halachic novellae). “Harei poh achen lefi mah shemevo'ar lekaman besiman resh vetet-vav, uveshem ha-Magen Avraham mashma de'echad yachol lehitztaref od pa'am im hashenayim she'achlu itah beyachad, acharei shehem lo zimnu adayin, tzarich lomar deharishonim” (But here, according to what is explained later in section 215 and in the name of the Magen Avraham, it seems that one can join the two again if they have eaten together and have not yet recited zimun; we must say that the earlier authorities…).
It is not simple at all. What is he saying? Does the zimun depart from the whole group because one person breaks away? There is no such thing. If the chiyuv zimun has been broken, then you are free to go; you did an aveirah (transgression), but you do not have to look back. In our first case, though, there has not yet been a split: they are reciting zimun at their table.
Let’s parse the wording. The case we have been discussing is that two people want to leave and one wants to stay in each group. The two can force the one to recite zimun. When it is the opposite, and one wants to leave while two want to stay, we said that the one does not have the power to force them to recite zimun. Does the one’s leaving mean that the whole group loses its status?
“It sounds as if the group is dissolved.”
“But the case he is discussing cannot be the one where two recite Birkat Hamazon and one stays. It must mean that one person interrupts for two.”
“Yes. Hifsik lishnayim means that he interrupts for two. That is our case.”
“But then that is not a new case in the Bi'ur Halachah.”
“When he says dehu hadin (the same law applies), perhaps he is speaking about another case: the one who would normally have to interrupt for two is leaving instead. The novelty is that he has the power to leave because they have not yet recited zimun.”
But if that is our case, it is not a case where he is interrupting for two. There are only two possibilities: either two interrupt for one, or one interrupts for two. There are not fifteen options. Let’s see whether the text supports that reading.
The Bi'ur Halachah continues: “Vechen matzati bepiskei Riaz, bechidushi hara'a, ot alef. Achen lefi mah dimevo'ar lekaman besiman resh, batur uvashu'a uMagen Avraham, mashma deba'echad yachol lehitztaref od hapa'am im hashnaim keshe'achlu atah beyachad” (And so I found in the rulings of the Riaz and in the novellae of the Raa, letter aleph. But according to what is explained later in section 200, in the Tur, in the Shulchan Aruch, and in the Magen Avraham, it seems that one person can join the two again when they have now eaten together).
Let’s look at section 200. “Sheloshah she'achlu ke'echad, echad mafsik al korcho lishnayim, ve'oneh imahem birkat hazimun, ve'afilu lo ratzah lehafsik mezamnin alav, bein oneh bein eino oneh, kol shehu omed sham” (Three who ate together: one is compelled to interrupt for the two, and answers with them the blessing of zimun. Even if he does not want to interrupt, they recite zimun with him, whether he answers or not, as long as he remains there).
They force the dissolution of that group. But two are not obligated to interrupt for one. Therefore, the obligation of zimun does not take effect until they agree to interrupt for one and bless. If they do not agree, and he recites zimun over them anyway, he has accomplished nothing. If the two do not agree to interrupt, the one is also not permitted to bless and leave for the marketplace. He must wait until the two finish and recite zimun with them, because he has already become obligated in zimun by eating with them. How could he say a blessing without zimun?
“Ve'eino tzarich lehafsik ela ad sheyomar baruch she'achalnu mishelo vechu'” (He need interrupt only until he says, “Blessed is the One from whose bounty we have eaten,” and so on).
So it seems that he can carry his chiyuv somewhere else. The question is when that is possible. In the case we are discussing, there are three groups of three, and one person leaves. Can he carry his chiyuv to another group? The question is what happens to the two who remain at each table. But we are concerned about the three: how did they create this new chiyuv? The Mishnah and Gemara say that they do; that is not the question. The question is how this person was able to break away, and then how the new group was created. This may be bedi'avad (after the fact): I left, and now the other two come to me and ask, “What did you do?”
There is a Mishnah Berurah in section 200, subsection 9, a long subsection. He says: “Katvu haposkim de'echad hamafsik lishnayim yachol lehafsik kamah pe'amim. Kegon shemitechilah achlu sheloshah vehifsik lahem echad, achar kach ba'u shenayim acherim ve'achlu im ha'echad” (The decisors wrote that one who interrupts for two may interrupt several times. For example, three ate together and one interrupted for them; afterward, two others came and ate with the one).
They also want to leave. Umgeladn. This is for minyan (prayer quorum): you're not part of their meal, you're not praying with them, but you're answering amen (amen). Here, though, the two others ate with the one; they need to eat together in this case to create zimun.
Could the fact that he did not answer mean that he can go on to the next one? You said before that one is forced to recite zimun for two even if he does not answer. Even if he did not answer. If he did answer and he eats again, he could do it. “Yachol zeh od hapa'am lehafsik lishnayim ha'elu, delo shayach lomar parach zimun mineyhu, keivan shenitztarfu imo shenayim shelo zimnu, yecholim lezamen alav. Vechen pa'am shelishit veyoter” (Can this person interrupt again for these two? It is not relevant to say that the zimun has departed from them, since two who have not recited zimun joined him and can recite zimun with him. The same applies a third time and more).
He can do this multiple times. But if five were in one group and one interrupted for two, he can no longer recite zimun with the two who remain, because the zimun has departed from them through the first zimun, even if they ate afterward with the one. But the other two did not participate in the zimun—is that what it is saying? It seems that this is an obligation that renews itself under certain conditions: with two new people, there can be a new zimun; with the same people, no.
But if there were seven or eight, and one interrupted for two of them, he can afterward interrupt again for the rest, because the zimun has departed from them, since there were enough people to form a zimun. That is for that table. Suppose I answered zimun for those two, and now two others want to leave. I can answer zimun for them too. But when the first two return, can we recite zimun again? No. We can only have two zimun groups, even though there are technically more ways one could arrange it; the maximum possibility was always two.
What about a group of 19 or 20? The question would be about Elokeinu (our God). Could someone answer with one group and then another? I do not know. On a wedding of 20, could you do 10 and 10? No, nine here, nine here, and two to answer. With 20, it is possible to form groups of ten. With 19, it is not. The chiyuv of zimun is stronger than the chiyuv of Elokeinu. But can you participate in both groups? That is the question. Creating Elokeinu is easier than creating zimun, because the chiyuv of zimun already exists for the nine. But have you already fulfilled it? Can you participate in both? That is the question.
Now, in our case, it does not work because each person had his own connection with his own group. No, our case is a kitty plate, because now he can go in and create a new group. The problem is he can't go back to his old group, because once you left them. But if they did recite zimun already, we said the first case of the Shulchan Aruch is that they did recite zimun together. When they get back together, why can’t they recite zimun again? If they ate together, perhaps they can. The condition may be that they did not eat together, which is why they cannot. But if they did eat together, why not? A new chiyuv zimun comes upon them, even though none of them has yet said Birkat Hamazon.
So perhaps the novelty is this: if you did not eat together, you can recite zimun only if you did not already recite zimun with your original group. If you did recite zimun with your original group, you can recite it with the new people if you ate with them. That would mean there is no dispute between the two sources. But if you ate, there should not be a restriction, because every time you eat with two new people, the obligation should renew.
The problem is that the Shulchan Aruch does not say that. It says, “Shuv einam yecholim lezamen, afilu achlu achar kach yachad vegamru se'udatan” (They can no longer recite zimun, even if they later ate together and finished their meal). The Mishnah Berurah explains: “Afilu achlu achar kach, dikevar parach zimun minayhu al yedei shezimnu aleihem mikodem. Umikol makom bevirkat hamazon chayavim levarech mitechilat birkat hazan, ki lekaman besiman resh” (Even if they ate afterward, because the zimun had already departed from them when it was recited over them earlier. Nevertheless, for Birkat Hamazon they must bless from the beginning, from Birkat Hazan, as explained later in section 200).
Here is the novelty: each one’s zimun had already departed, because the three came from groups that had already recited zimun. There are not two fresh people who have not recited zimun. In the other case, there were two new people. One person may be drawn into a new zimun by two people, but if all three have already been drawn into the previous zimun, the other two cannot draw them into another one.
Hilchot zimun is one of the hardest areas of halachah. These are unlikely cases, but they can happen at weddings: people go from one table to another. Even if he did not eat—that is the second case we have not seen yet. They can happen in restaurants too. By the way, the roof story is not really about a roof; it is a united place.
Now, section 31. The second case was lo zimnu aleihem mimekomam (they did not recite zimun in their place). They got up and went to the bar, group D. The ruling is that they are obligated to recite zimun and are not permitted to divide. It seems that this applies to their new group: since they have now come together, each person comes from a group where he was already obligated in zimun and is carrying his personal chiyuv zimun.
Although it was explained in subsection 6 that it is forbidden to separate from a group of three, because by doing so he causes them to lose their zimun, one might say that here the case is bedi'avad, where the original group has separated.
That is important. If the original group is still there, it seems that he has to go back. You cannot create a new chiyuv zimun while the old chiyuv zimun is still pending. We do not know exactly what the Gemara’s case is, so you can fit different circumstances into it. Suppose the others have left. Can I still fulfill my personal chiyuv zimun without eating with the new people? I can, because there are three people who are each personally obligated in zimun. They can sit down together and recite it, even if they did not eat together.
But the wording is a problem. Eino rashai lechalek means that he is not permitted to divide; it sounds like he is being prohibited from doing something, not that he is looking for a way to fulfill his obligation. If I were writing it, I would say he is permitted to join the new group—or that he is obligated to join and recite zimun.
Imagine the three Avrahams are sitting together. One says, “I have to go,” and the other two say, “We’re not going anywhere.” Eino rashai lechalek: he is not allowed to leave. He has bonded with them in a pending chiyuv zimun. He has not eaten with them at all, but he is still not allowed to leave.
“What if the others have already left, and I find myself sitting with two other people? I might think I have lost my zimun and have to say Birkat Hamazon by myself.”
“No. You have a zimun pending with them.”
“But I did not eat with them!”
“Too bad. You are with them now.”
The point is not simply that he sat with them. The wording is hitva'adu yachad (they joined together); they formed a group. Their personal chiyuvim become joined, and he is not allowed to leave, even though he did not eat with them. But if his original group is still available, does he have to return to it? Yes. He left in the first place. The novelty applies to his obligation once he finds himself with two other people; it does not mean that he must go looking for them.
The Mishnah Berurah continues, “I nami”—i nami (alternatively). Why give another possibility? It is a ruling; I need to know what to do. He says: “Lefi mah dimevo'ar lekaman besiman resh be'Eliyah Rabbah she'ar acharonim, devemakom sheyesh ones (circumstance beyond one's control) o hefsed mamon (financial loss), muttar le'echad ligmor se'udato mikodem sheyigmeru hashenayim ulevarech bifne atzmo” (According to what is explained later in section 200 in the Eliyah Rabbah and other later authorities, in a case of circumstances beyond one’s control or financial loss, one person is permitted to finish his meal before the other two finish and bless by himself).
Suppose someone tells the other two, “I really need to go,” and they do not care. He is going to miss his plane. At what point can he say, “I’m sorry, but I have to go”? There are circumstances in which he can. The Mishnah Berurah adds: “Mihu hacha gam ken bechai gavna, shehayu ellu hasheloshah mukrachim lemaher, velachen im nizdamenu ellu hasheloshah beyachad yezamnu bifne atzman” (However, here too, in such a case, if these three were compelled to hurry, then if these three happened to meet together, they should recite zimun by themselves).
Which case is that? The three Avrahams are saying, “You two do not want to recite zimun with me? I’m going to find another two people in the same situation.” They each have their own chiyuv zimun, and they form a new chiyuv zimun so they can leave. Should they do that before saying Birkat Hamazon by themselves? I can say Birkat Hamazon by myself because I have an excuse, but I still have a personal chiyuv zimun. If the three meet together, they recite zimun by themselves.
But what does einam rasha'im lechalek mean in that case? The three Avrahams together cannot divide, even if the other two now say, “Fine, let’s recite zimun.” Only if one is ones can he consider breaking away from the original two.
Perhaps the point is that once the three have decided to sit together and recite zimun, they have formed a new group, and now they have a full chiyuv zimun. If one then says, “My Uber is outside; I can’t wait,” einam rasha'im lechalek: he cannot divide from them. But what if he is under circumstances beyond his control at that point? That is still difficult. The first zimun is definitely stronger than the second. If the first group is still there, of course he goes back to it. I thought the Rema and the Mishnah Berurah were explaining the case from within. Who's on this new event? It doesn't work? So it could work on the prior one, it doesn't work now? No, hay que porque ya they formed that precondition. I think that's what it means. That part, that's weird.
Suppose the three met, but two of them now have their flight delayed and want to stay longer. What do you do about makom she'achal (the place where he ate)? If you can see your table, you are fine. We will return to that case.