A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Hilchot Birchat Cohanim - Can a kohen go wash his hands if they are just 10?

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
July 2, 2025
Duration
3:29
Lecture code
RGK-BC-32

Ten for Birkat Kohanim

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas discusses the Beit Yosef’s ruling that birkat Kohanim, like any davar shebikdusha, requires 10 male gedolim.
  • The question is whether the Kohanim count toward the minyan or whether 10 people are needed in addition to them, since they are blessing the congregation and one might think 10 people must receive the Beracha.
  • The Beit Yosef cites the Gemara in Ketubot, Daf Chet: “Birkat chatanim be'asara, vechatanim min haminyan” (The blessing of bridegrooms is with ten, and the bridegrooms are included in the quorum). He applies this to birkat Kohanim: the Kohanim are included in the minyan, since a davar shebikdusha does not require 10 people besides the person officiating.
  • The Levush explains that “Va'ani avarechem” includes the Kohanim too: the Beracha encompasses both the giver and the recipients, and ultimately everybody receives. The pshat of the Rambam does not fit this explanation, since he understands “Va'ani avarechem” to mean that Hashem will bless Yisrael, not the Kohanim. This is presented as the source for requiring 10 for birkat Kohanim.

Birkat Kohanim When Someone Leaves

  • The Rashba says that when a davar shebikdusha begins with 10 and someone leaves, it may be continued. For example, if the Chazara begins with 10 and someone must leave in an emergency, the Chazara, including kedusha, is completed.
  • The question is whether birkat Kohanim is part of the Chazara or a separate mitzvah. Although it is performed at the time of the Avodah for technical reasons of Sherut, in order to mirror the Beit HaMikdash, the lecture raises the possibility that it has nothing to do with the Chazara.
  • The Yerushalmi says, “Ein birkat Kohanim ba-layla” (There is no priestly blessing at night). This suggests that birkat Kohanim’s rules are not dependent on the Chazara: the reason it is not said at night is not that there is no Chazara then.
  • There is a major machloket among the Aharonim. Torah Chaim, Sofer, and Shevet Yehuda say that birkat Kohanim is part of the Chazara and can be continued. Most poskim disagree.
  • The Yerushalmi distinguishes between the two: the Chazara may be continued after someone leaves, while birkat Kohanim may be continued if it was begun with 10. This implies that birkat Kohanim must begin with 10 and is not part of the Chazara.
  • Halacha le-ma'aseh, Rav Shmuel Wosner and Rav Ovadia Yosef rule that if someone leaves during the Chazara, leaving only nine, the Chazara is completed but birkat Kohanim is not performed.
Words in this lecture1
Ketubotכתובות
Terms Ketubot, a tractate in the order Nashim about marriage contracts.
Also written: Ketubos, Kesubos, ktubot