A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Hilchot Birchat Cohanim - Can a kohen not wash if he did netila in the morning

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
July 2, 2025
Duration
3:33
Lecture code
RGK-BC-31

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

The greatest of Gedolim (great Torah scholars) sometimes also had safek in halakha (Jewish law); they had doubts and didn’t know what the answer was. Actually, I respect that very, very much: somebody being honest and saying, “I don’t know the answer.” This is much better than people who don’t know how to say, “I don’t know,” because you don’t know what kind of answer you’re getting.

Let me give you one example related to yesterday’s halakha. Yesterday, we mentioned that there was a big Machloket (dispute) among the Rishonim (early authorities): the Charedim and the Raavad against the Ritva. The Charedim and the Raavad say that there is a mitzvah (commandment) on Yisrael to receive the Beracha (blessing) from the Kohanim (priests). It’s a mitzvah on them to receive. According to the Ritva, there’s no such mitzvah. It’s just that you’re part of this; you’re a receiver. You don’t get any mitzvah for that. And that’s not so clear. Is there a halakha, is there a mitzvah, or is there no mitzvah? It’s a Machloket of Rishonim. It’s very hard to know what the halakha would be.

But Hacham Ovadia, in Yabia Omer, says he has a safek based on this. He says, “What happens if somebody in the morning needs to catch a flight? He has five minutes to spend in Shul (synagogue). Should he go for Birkat Kohanim (Priestly Blessing), or should he go to listen to the Keriat HaTorah (Torah reading)?” Because in Keriat HaTorah, you have the same kind of safek. Is it a chiyuv (obligation) on each? Is it a chiyuv on each person to listen to Keriat HaTorah, or is it a chiyuv on the tzibur (community) to have a Keriat HaTorah? It’s also a safek. Is somebody yotzei (fulfills) the chovah (obligation) by listening? Is there any chovah to listen? Or, when the Hachamim (sages) said that Ezra HaSofer said, “On Monday and Thursday, you’re going to have the Sefer Torah (Torah scroll),” it’s a concept that was for the tzibur. It’s for the community to have this.

Which means, it’s as if I say, “Oh, I make sure that there are ten people; I was yotzei my chovah.” My chovah is to make sure that there’s going to be a minyan (ten people), and that they’re going to be reading the Torah in every community. As far as each member is concerned, that should be the concern. But do I have to be present here to listen to the Keriat HaTorah? It’s a Machloket. Some say the imposition of this—to be listening to Sefer Torah every three days—is on each individual. And some say, no, it’s just for the community to have this. It’s a safek.

So you have a similar safek. Hachamim says, “If you have the choice between listening to Birkat Kohanim or listening to the Keriat HaTorah, which one would you take?” Both are safek. It’s not clear. Maybe you have no mitzvah at all to listen to the Keriat HaTorah. Maybe you have no mitzvah at all to listen to the Birkat Kohanim either. I would say, take the Birkat Kohanim; at least you get something out of it. If it’s only the safek, you get blessed. But that’s business. We don’t talk business right now. We’re talking halakha.

And in halakha, it’s not clear. And Hachamim says, “I don’t know,” which means, do whatever you want, basically. Then you could talk business. Then I would tell you, take Birkat Kohanim, because at least you get something out of it. But halachically, that’s a safek. Safek Rishonim. There’s no halakha on it. It’s not pashut (obvious). So in that case, I don’t know.

This is one example of not knowing what the halakha is. And it’s okay. It’s not a huge enough coming. I just have to know what to do. But best would be to come for the whole minyan, so you don’t have a problem. And that’s actually what he says at the end: because of the safek, please try to stay for both. That’s what he says in a very cute way.