A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

If one answered Barechu, 2 Amidah of Arbit

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
December 24, 2025
Duration
4:04
Lecture code
RGK-1713

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Continuing with the halachot Shabbat (laws of Shabbat), the last halachot we studied included a chidush (novel insight): when a person comes to shul on Friday and the tzibbur (congregation) comes late to shul on Friday and has already accepted Shabbat, he has not yet prayed Mincha. As he walks into shul, they say Barchu (Bless [Hashem]) for Arvit. If you answer Barchu, you will automatically mekabel Shabbat (accepting Shabbat); you have accepted Shabbat upon yourself, and you can no longer say Mincha, simply by answering Barchu. Somebody who comes late should not answer Barchu, because if he answers Barchu, he can no longer do Mincha.

What happens once somebody answers Barchu? Let’s assume it’s summertime and Shabbat begins early; that would be the case. The person comes, let’s say, to the next minyan (prayer quorum), hears Barchu, and answers Barchu. Now he’s stuck. He can’t even pray Mincha. The halacha (Jewish law) is incredible: it’s still daytime, it’s still time for Mincha, but he cannot pray Mincha. He’s going to have to pray Arvit twice, doing two Amidot of Arvit.

Rabbi Akiva Eiger asks a she’eilah (question). Normally, whenever you talk about tashlumin (the replacement of the one before), the she’eilah of tashlumin is that you have to say two Amidot. The first Amidah is the chiyuv (obligation), and the second Amidah is the replacement for the one before. For example, during the week, if somebody missed Mincha, whatever the case, he says the Amidah of Arvit twice. The first Amidah is Arvit, and the second is the makeup for Mincha. Here, it’s the same: the first Amidah would be Arvit of Shabbat, and the second would be the makeup for Mincha. The second Amidah has the same text, of course: you can say the text of the Shabbat Amidah, but with the kavanah (intention) that it is making up for Mincha of Chol (weekday).

Rabbi Akiva Eiger says that if you make a mistake and switch the order, doing Mincha first—like doing the Amidah of Arvit on any night, with the kavanah that it is for Mincha—and then the Amidah for Arvit second, you have to say a third Amidah, because it didn’t work. You switched the order.

Rabbi Akiva Eiger asks: What about this case? Is this case different? Why would it be different? He says that when the person has kavanah in his first Amidah that he’s doing Mincha, although it’s wrong, it’s still daytime. You can’t say it’s not time for Mincha. The fact that it’s still daytime means he has a technical problem: he can’t do the regular Amidah of Chol because it’s Shabbat for him. But when he’s doing the Amidah of Shabbat with the kavanah that it’s for Mincha, it’s still daytime. The second Amidah will be Arvit. He did it wrong, but Rabbi Akiva Eiger and the Pri Megadim both say, efshar sheyatzah (perhaps he fulfilled it). Maybe he is yotzei (fulfilled). That doesn’t help much. Say, maybe he is yotzei, just because it’s still daytime.

Hacham Ovadia goes through a lot of back and forth on this sugyah (Talmudic discussion), and at the end of the sugyah he says, with all the mechilah (forgiveness), we don’t hold like this. But if a person made the error once, he cannot say Mincha. The only possible order that is halachically correct is to first do the Amidah of Arvit, and then the second Amidah, the makeup for Mincha. If he did the opposite, he would have to repeat a third Amidah. So, if somebody cannot do Mincha, he has to do Arvit first, and then the makeup for Mincha. There’s no difference between Chol, Shabbat, late, or early. It always has to be in this order. Bichavod (respectfully).