A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

If one goes to a party and has to leave before zimun

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
September 10, 2023
Duration
5:54
Lecture code
RGK-972

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Let's discuss a case that is one of the most common cases when it comes to zimun (invitation to Grace After Meals) that becomes a big problem of halacha (Jewish law). We studied that if somebody is part of a group of three or ten, there's no way to move out of it. Meaning, you have to wait for the zimun in order to do Birkat HaMazon. One of the most annoying cases is when you go to a wedding, for example, or to a party, and you're eating bread and it's getting late. You want to go? You want to leave already? You tell the guy, “Okay, let's do zimun.” He says, “What are you talking about? We're going to party for another two hours.” And you're like, “Unfortunately, in September of 2023, I was in Magen David, and I learned that halacha: once you're part of a group, you can't break it by just doing Birkat HaMazon.” Why did I come that Sunday morning? What do I do now? That's a typical case. Most people don't know these halachot. What do they say? “Okay, I couldn't find zimun. I'm just going to say Birkat HaMazon.” Well, we learned Shulchan Aruch last week. Meforash (explicitly), he tells you: once you're part of this group, this corporation—once you're part of this zimun corporation—you cannot break it like this. You've got to bring the lawyers, you've got to bring the whole thing. Lo pashut (not simple), top. So what do you do? There's a big machloket (dispute) between Rabbi Avraham miBuchach and Rav Shlomo Kluger. They were two big poskim (halachic authorities) from the 1800s. Rabbi Avraham miBuchach says, indeed, you're stuck.

Let's start with Rav Shlomo Kluger. Rav Shlomo Kluger says that when you come into the party, before you start, you have kavanah (intention) that you're not going to form that corporation with the other two guys. So you're sitting at the same table, but your kavanah is, “I don't want to form that group.” He says that works, but you have to have this kavanah when you come in. So before you start the party, think: “Look, in case I need to leave in an hour and these guys are going to stay longer, although I'm sitting with them, talking with them, eating with them, and we're all at the same table and sitting as a group, I'm not part of this corporation.” That's why Rav Shlomo Kluger says this. Rabbi Avraham miBuchach, the Eshel Avraham, comes and says, “This is ridiculous. Ridiculous.” I don't think he uses the word ridiculous, but I'm using it. Why? Because your actions don't match your kavanah. It's like going up a wall and saying, “I'm not going up a wall.” Really? You're wearing tefillin (phylacteries) and you say, “No, I'm not wearing tefillin.” Well, I see the tefillin. You're sitting with these guys—what's this zimun story? Is it a kavanah thing or is it a factual thing? You're sitting at the same table, you're talking to these guys, you want to sit with them because they're your friends, you're eating with them, and you say, “I'm not.” How is the kavanah going to take you out? That's the root of the problem. Kavanah isn't always stronger than the action. Actually, I would say the opposite: kavanah is not stronger than the action. If you're doing something that is evident, how are you going to come out of the problem just by saying, “Oh, I had kavanah that I'm not sharing the meal with them”? But you shared the meal with them. I say the same thing: “I had kavanah that I shouldn't gain weight from what I'm eating.” Well, you're still going to gain weight; it makes no difference. What kind of a kavanah is that? So he says, no, it doesn't work. If you're eating with them, you're eating with them. Oh, you want to do something? When it's time to eat, eat some of the things by yourself, or don't participate as you would if you were part of this. That way, you're doing something different.

There's a similar machloket, very quickly, with the Friday-night problem with the women. When it tells you, have kavanah in the tefillah (prayer) that you not mekadesh haShabbat (sanctifies Shabbat). Because if you mekadesh haShabbat, when you do Kiddush (sanctification over wine) later for your wife, she didn't do the tefillah. That's a sugya (Talmudic discussion). And then she's chayav (obligated) in that. So you're ready. You'll say, “What kind of a kavanah is that? I'm not mekadesh haShabbat. So then what did you say in the tefillah? ‘Baruch atah Hashem, mekadesh haShabbat’ (Blessed are You, Hashem, Who sanctifies Shabbat). What was that, a joke? You were joking. That's what you were doing, right?” “No, no. I was just reading the words.” “Yeah, but then what did you say? ‘Baruch atah Hashem, mekadesh haShabbat.’” “But I was not mekadesh haShabbat.” “Okay, that's great. So what do you do?” Clowns here? What kind of a sevara (reasoning) is that? I know they haven't discussed that, but it's kind of frustrating. Because then what are you doing? So here it's the same thing: “Oh, I'm sharing the meal with these guys, but I'm not. As kavanah, I'm not.” But you are. So what kavanah is that?

The bigger problem is that the poskim—not all, but the majority of poskim—agree with Rav Shlomo Kluger. The poskim agree with them. Big poskim. They say, “Yeah, the kavanah works.” So, I guess, one more time, I'm going to have to keep quiet and say that the halacha is that you should have kavanah when you come into a hall: have kavanah that you're not eating with these people as one group. But I would suggest that if that's really a kavanah, then show it somehow, so that you're really not eating with them. I don't know how. Maybe you—I don't know—but otherwise you kind of suck. Maybe eat at a different table. Visit them occasionally, but don't sit. If you're sitting with the people you like, and the people you intended to have a meal with, I really doubt that you could say that my kavanah is stronger than my actions. I personally think it makes no sense. But many poskim disagree with me. Who am I? So lema'aseh (in practice), if you want to rely on this, Yesh al mi lismoch (there is someone to rely on). B'chavod (with respect).