A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

If someone has less candles, Hatarat Nedarim?

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
February 12, 2026
Duration
4:05
Lecture code
RGK-1762

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Yesterday, somebody asked me a question based on the halacha (Jewish law) we discussed. What happens if a woman has the Minhag (custom) of always lighting five candles? She has three children, and that is what she lights: five candles. Now they are going on a trip. Does she have to worry about lighting five candles on Friday if she is out of the house? What is the halacha? We said yesterday that it is like a neder (vow). Once a person takes on an Hanhagah tovah (good practice), she has a Minhag—probably her mother did that, etc. It is like a neder, so how could you break it?

This is actually very interesting. There is a Rama in Hilchot Pesach. The Ashkenazim have a Minhag after the chagim (holidays) to fast, what we call BaHaB (Monday, Thursday and Monday). But let’s take an example that could apply to us. Some people are noheg to have a ta'anit (fast) on Erev Rosh Hashanah (the day before Rosh Hashanah); some people fast. Some people fast during the ten days of Teshuvah (repentance). You have all kinds of Minhagim.

The Rama is talking about the case of somebody who has a Minhag to fast, and there is a brit milah (covenant of circumcision). On one hand, he has to fast. On the other hand, there is a mitzvah (commandment) at the brit milah, which is a seudat mitzvah (mitzvah meal). What should he eat without? It is like a neder. Every year, he fasts on Erev Rosh Hashanah, let’s say. The Rama says it is a mitzvah to eat, and he does not need hatarat nedarim (annulment of vows). Because, if there is a brit milah, the Minhag is not to fast. So part of the Minhag is as if he had in mind that he would fast whenever he was supposed to fast. If he is not supposed to fast, he is not supposed to fast.

However, the Shulchan Aruch brings a similar case in Yoreh De'ah, siman (section) reish yud-dalet (214), of somebody who says, “When I was young, I was able to do this ta'anit. I’m not young anymore, and I’m not healthy anymore. It’s not good for me to do the ta'anit.” The Shulchan Aruch says he needs hatarat nedarim, the three. The Shach asks about the difference between the two, and most of the Acharonim (later authorities) say the following. I’ll read just one of them: Dagul MeRevavah, who is the author of Noda BiYehuda. He says, “No, he is not completely chozer (retracting). Now he wants to eat because it is a mitzvah. Next year, he is going to do it.”

However, somebody had a situation this time, but he is not planning on cancelling his Minhag. In the other case, he is saying, “I’m getting old; it’s not for me anymore.” “Ah, okay, so you want to stop doing this Minhag. You’re planning on stopping this Minhag.” That is a different story. Then you need hatarat nedarim.

I told this individual that, for sure, if he can take a few tea lights, he should. It’s not impossible. I mean, we’re not talking about someone lighting 36 candles. Five candles, six candles, whatever. So take a few tea lights, and that’s it. You do your Minhag. If a person is in a situation where they cannot fulfill the Minhag—it’s too late, they forgot, and they found two tea lights—then you use two tea lights. You don’t have to do hatarat nedarim, because as long as the kavanah (intention) is to do the Minhag, you’re not trying to cancel the Minhag. You’re just, “Oh, I’m not used to this.” You’re not trying to cancel the Minhag; you’re just trying, in this case, to alter the Minhag because of the situation. Then no hatarat nedarim is necessary.