A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

If someone said haadama instead of haetz and also wants to eat a pickle

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
November 27, 2023
Duration
3:38
Lecture code
RGK-1058

The Question of Eating a Cucumber After a Mistaken Blessing

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas recalls the previous discussion: if someone says Borei peri ha'adama instead of Borei peri ha'etz on a fruit of a tree, the blessing works bedi'avad.
  • He asks what happens if the person then wants to eat a cucumber. Must he say Borei peri ha'adama again?
  • The safek is whether Borei peri ha'adama, when said on a grape, remains the blessing he said and covers the grape as well—or whether it is treated as though he said Borei peri ha'etz, the blessing he should have said.
  • If Borei peri ha'adama remains the blessing, the cucumber is covered. But if his mistaken blessing is treated as Borei peri ha'etz—particularly because his kavanah was to eat the grape—then he did not say Borei peri ha'adama for the cucumber.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says this is a major question among the Poskim, not a simple matter.

The Parallel Case of Shehakol

  • The same safek arises with Shehakol nihya bidvaro. The Shulchan Aruch says that it covers everything, and if someone says it on a piece of cake, it works bedi'avad.
  • If he then wants to drink something, does he say Shehakol again? The doubt is whether the mistaken Shehakol is treated as the blessing he said and covers the drink, or as though he said Borei minei mezonot, since that was the blessing appropriate to the cake.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas notes that although the person said the word Shehakol, he may be considered to have meant Borei minei mezonot; he describes whether to say Shehakol on a drink such as Coke as a major safek in halakha.

Practical Ruling and the Limits of the Case

  • Because of safek berachot lehakel, when there is doubt about a beracha, one does not repeat it; lema'aseh, the beracha is not repeated. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas emphasizes that the underlying cheshbon is not simple.
  • This applies to the case where the person had kavanah from the beginning to eat the other foods as well. If he did not initially intend to eat the cucumber and only later changed his mind, he must say Borei peri ha'adama again, even if he had said it earlier on watermelon.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas clarifies that his discussion concerns the case where the person intended from the outset to eat the cucumber, but the safek about the mistaken blessing means that lema'aseh, it is not repeated.