Today we're going to discuss the halakha (Jewish law) that has to do with yesterday. Yesterday, we discussed the halakha regarding someone who made a mistake. Instead of saying Borei peri ha'etz (Who creates the fruit of the tree), he said Borei peri ha'adama (Who creates the fruit of the ground). We said that, lema'aseh (in practice), it worked.
Now, the she'elah (question) today is this: a person says Borei peri ha'adama on a grape, let's say. It worked. Now he wants to eat a piece of cucumber. Does he say Borei peri ha'adama again or not? What's the question? He just said ha'adama (the ground). When you say that Borei peri ha'adama works for Borei peri ha'etz, does that mean Borei peri ha'adama includes Borei peri ha'etz? And therefore, what is it? It's as if he said Borei peri ha'etz. Or do you say Borei peri ha'adama includes the grape too? You understand the safek (doubt), or not? Because what it really means is: when you said Borei peri ha'adama, is it as if you said Borei peri ha'etz? Or no, you said Borei peri ha'adama, and it covers the grape?
Now, the difference between the two possibilities is this: if Borei peri ha'adama is Borei peri ha'adama and includes the fruits from the trees, then you said Borei peri ha'adama, so the cucumber is covered. But if you say that when you mistakenly say Borei peri ha'adama on a grape, it's as if you said Borei peri ha'etz, which is what you're supposed to say on the grape, then, number one, your Borei peri ha'adama is equivalent to Borei peri ha'etz, especially since your kavanah (intention) was to eat the grape. It's just that, in the world of berachot (blessings), it works. It's as if you said Borei peri ha'etz.
“Oh, it's as if I said Borei peri ha'etz. So now I want to eat cucumber. I didn't say Borei peri ha'adama.” “No, you did say it.” “No, because you told me that Borei peri ha'adama is as if I said Borei peri ha'etz. Do I have to say Borei peri ha'adama again or not?” That's a very big she'elah in the Poskim (halachic authorities). Don't think it's simple at all. It's a very big she'elah in the Poskim.
It's the same she'elah you have in another halakha: Shulchan Aruch says that when you say Shehakol nihya bidvaro (Everything came into being through His word), it covers everything. So if you said Shehakol nihya bidvaro on a piece of cake, bedi'avad (after the fact), it works. Now you want to drink something. Do you say Shehakol (Everything) again or not? It's the same safek. It worked on the bread, on the mezonot (grain foods), because I made a mistake. It's as if I said Borei minei mezonot (Who creates various kinds of nourishment). So I didn't say Shehakol. I said the word Shehakol, but I meant Borei minei mezonot. So now you want to drink Coke. Do you have to say the beracha (blessing) Shehakol or not? That's a big safek in halakha.
Well, as you know, because of safek berachot lehakel, because we have a doubt in halakha, whenever you have a doubt in berachot, you don't say the beracha again. That's why we don't say the beracha again. But don't think it's so pashut (simple). The cheshbon (calculation) is a very interesting cheshbon.
Now, you must have had kavanah to eat other things too, because if you didn't have kavanah to eat the cucumber, then even if you said ha'adama on watermelon and later you're going to eat cucumber—“I didn't want to eat cucumber, but now, you know what? I changed my mind”—you would have to say ha'adama again anyway. So I'm not talking about this. I'm saying you had kavanah from the beginning, but since there's a safek in this halakha, lema'aseh, we don't repeat the beracha. Bechavod (respectfully).