A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

If the Baal Koreh skipped a pasuk (part 2)

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
November 5, 2019
Duration
3:39
Lecture code
RGK-80

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Yesterday, we spoke about the case of someone who skipped a pasuk (verse) of the parasha on Shabbat morning. For example, even after Musaf (additional prayer service), you take out the Sefer Torah, do one aliyah (call to the Torah) with a Beracha (blessing), and he reads a total of three pesukim. What happens in the next case, where it is the same thing, but they only realize it at mincha (afternoon prayer)? They could look and see, “We missed this pasuk.” So, it is mincha time. Do you add to the parasha in mincha? You are going to read anyway, and you are taking out the Sefer Torah, so you may as well read three pesukim together with the one that you missed and then continue, or not?

A few months ago, we discussed a case of a place that did not have electricity in the morning, so they could not read the Keriat HaTorah (Torah reading) in the morning. Could they read in the afternoon instead of the morning, when the whole kehillah (community) had not heard the Keriat HaTorah in the morning? We brought the story of the Chatam Sofer, who missed the Keriat HaTorah because he was traveling with a group of people. It was a Monday morning, and when he got to his destination in the afternoon, he said, “We have a majority of the minyan (quorum of ten) who did not hear. Let’s take out the Sefer Torah,” and they read the Sefer Torah.

First of all, that case is different because there was the takana of not passing three days without listening to the Keriat HaTorah. If he missed Monday, then the takana would mean that he would hear on Shabbat and on Thursday, which is more than three days. But here, he is going to hear it anyway in the afternoon. That is one Chiluk (distinction).

Second, in the story of the Chatam Sofer, although the Noda BiYehuda agreed that you could do something like this, many Poskim (halachic decisors) disagreed with the Chatam Sofer based on the Rishonim (early authorities). The biggest of them all is the Rambam. The Rambam writes, I quote. According to the Rambam, part of the takana of reading the Keriat HaTorah is Shabbat, Monday, Thursday. We saw the Or Zarua, the Sefer HaEshkol, and other Rishonim, who say that if they missed the Keriat HaTorah, a certain, and Shabbat morning, they should wait until next week. They do not say to do it in the afternoon.

Why? Because you have Rishonim who are going against the Chatam Sofer and the Noda BiYehuda, although they are great, major, major Poskim. But we do not do that because of the Rambam and the other Rishonim, and the Chida and other Poskim who disagree with them. Therefore, there is really no such thing as an afternoon reading to make up for the morning. If somebody missed the Keriat HaTorah—if the whole community missed the Keriat HaTorah on Shabbat morning—they wait for the next week to do it.

So too, in our case, if we missed one pasuk in the Shabbat morning reading, you do not make up for that pasuk on Shabbat afternoon. Shabbat afternoon is a takana bifnei atzma (in its own right), to read the next week’s parasha. The next Shabbat, they would have to read the pasuk that they missed with two pesukim, and then join it into the new parasha of the next week. But they would not do it that Shabbat afternoon. They would have to wait until the next week to reread what they missed.