Baruch Hashem (Blessed is Hashem). We continue with the halachot (Jewish law). We said that you cannot tell your goyah (non-Jewish woman) or goy (non-Jew) to do a melacha (prohibited labor) for you. That's the statement, that's the halacha, and then we'll build around this. But the halacha is time: you're not allowed to ask your goy to do a melacha that you cannot do. So go to your goy and say, "Can you please turn on the light?" Absolutely not. Even if the goy sees that it's dark and turns on the light for you, you're not allowed to have hana'ah (benefit) from that. You cannot read, you cannot have hana'ah, you cannot enjoy that light. Sorry to tell you, but that's the halacha.
Now, the Tur brings the following. The Tur says, so somebody takes with him, whatever, they go into a room, and it's dark, and the goy turns on the light. Since they are together, the goy is turning on the light; the goy needs to get into that room, and he also needs to read. It's mainly for the Yisrael (Jew), so even if the goy turns on the light in the dark and also gets benefit, it's asur (not allowed) to have hana'ah from this light.
The Mishnah Berurah says, "What happens if you send a goy or a goyah to a room, and you say, 'Can you please bring me this wine?'" You say, "Can you bring me the wine which is in that room?" The goy or the goyah goes alone into that room, and they don't see. They go into that room and turn on the light. Now, what are you going to say? They turn on the light; technically speaking, it's for you, because they're only going into that room because they need to bring the wine. But they're going to bring the wine, and that's part of their job. So who is it for, the Yisrael or the goy? The Mishnah Berurah is posek halacha (rules Jewish law): it's too far to say they turned on the light for the Jew. It's true that, at the end, that's what it is; it's super indirect. At the end, of course, that's the main reason, but when they're there and they need the light, it's for them to be able to bring you the bottle of wine. The immediacy of the action is for them, not for you. Therefore, if they leave the light on, or if you come right behind them and say, "Okay, I'm going to stay here now," now you're allowed to use the light, because the light was turned on: "Let's all come," and not "Let's all"—"Let's all go to Yisrael." And we start already with the trick. How can you trick? You like to say, "How do you trick God?" How do you trick in a situation like this to make it that they're lighting the light for themselves, and then you're having hana'ah from that? That then would be mutar (permitted), bediavad (after the fact).

