A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Jewish owned car used as Uber during Shabbat

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
February 25, 2025
Duration
3:40
Lecture code
RGK-1507

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Because...

The last halacha (Jewish law) we saw in Hilchot Shabbat (the laws of Shabbat) was about a brand franchise being leased out to another company that would operate on Shabbat. We discussed that last time. Now we'll discuss somebody who has a car, for example. Someone says, “Let me drive your car on Shabbat, and whatever profit I make, we'll split.” Is that allowed to do on Shabbat? It could be done through different structures, but that idea exists. And is it allowed on Shabbat?

The first thing we have to discuss is what's called Shevitat Kelim (resting of vessels). Do the Kelim—the items a person owns—also have to be resting on Shabbat? Or can Kelim work on Shabbat? It's a machloket (dispute) between Beit Shammai and Beit Hillel. The Torah says that there is an issur (prohibition) against someone's animal working on Shabbat. That's a Gezerat HaKatuv (decree of the verse) in the Pasuk (verse). Does that apply to Kelim as well? I know that the mode of transportation back in the day—let's say, a horse—would be asur (forbidden): a Jew's horse could not work on Shabbat. But a car isn't a horse, although it has horsepower. Beit Shammai say that just as you have Shevitat Behemah (resting of an animal), you also have Shevitat Kelim. Beit Hillel holds that there's no such problem as Shevitat Kelim. The Torah doesn't say that a person's tools, items, or belongings have to rest on Shabbat.

The proof is that your Kelim are allowed to work; you can put them on cruise control beforehand. For example, you have a crockpot. It works on Shabbat; you plug it in beforehand. There's no problem. You can have a machine continue working on Shabbat. There's no problem. With that, we use a lot of the new technology to actually make Shabbat easier, because you can preset a lot of things. I don't want to get into this subject, but there's no problem with Kelim working on Shabbat. So having a person's car working on Shabbat is no problem.

What about the business partnership they had in that case? We already saw yesterday that when it's done in an Arisut mode, Arisut is a partnership where basically the Goy (non-Jew) is in control, and whatever it gives, it gives a percentage to the Jew. The Goy isn't paid per hour, isn't employed by, and isn't a Shaliach (agent) of the Jew. When this is the Derech (customary practice), it is definitely the Derech to do this. Even trucking companies pay their drivers by the mile. It's an incentive to get them to work. If you're going to pay them, I don't know, $150 a day, you don't know where they're going to go. So nobody does that. They pay them for the work. That means there's a partnership in the work: the more work you do, the more we both get. There's no problem with that. It's Mutar (allowed) because it's Arisut, a mode of partnership in which his incentive is to work for himself. He's the one who decides to put in more work because he wants to get more money. It's not a set amount; it depends on the amount of work and the success of his work. So in that case, it would be Mutar from both ends. There's no problem with the Shlichut (agency) to the guy, and there's no problem with the car itself. Therefore, it would be allowed. B'kavod.