A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Not even a cup of water outside the Sukkah? One case

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
October 13, 2022
Duration
2:35
Lecture code
RGK-685

Eating Outside the Sukkah Before the Seudah

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas discusses a halakha in Hilchot Sukkah: bread and Mezonot over a kebeitzah must be eaten inside the sukkah; anything less than that shiur is mutar outside.
  • He notes that Shulchan Aruch brings a chumra, while drinks and other foods—such as salad or steak—may be eaten outside the sukkah, as may less than a shiur of Mezonot or motzi.

After Starting the Seudah in the Sukkah

  • Once a person has started the Seudah inside the sukkah with bread, food eaten outside is considered part of that Seudah and may not be eaten there.
  • For example, someone tending a barbecue during the meal may need to turn the meat or check whether it is ready, but may not taste it outside the sukkah.
  • The rule applies even to a cup of water: after beginning the Seudah inside, one may not drink it outside. Thus, a case in which halakha—not merely chumra—prohibits drinking water or eating a piece of meat outside the sukkah is when it is part of a Seudah already begun inside.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas emphasizes that people may forget this when they go to the kitchen and eat something small. He calls it a frustrating halakha, but says it is important to pay attention: once the Seudah has started inside the sukkah, do not taste anything outside.