A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Pouring hot water in a cup that has drops of water

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
November 2, 2025
Duration
4:36
Lecture code
RGK-1668

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

We once spoke about Pesik Reisha (inevitable consequence); now we’re going to discuss the Halakha (Jewish law) of Pesik Reisha. It’s a very big Machloket (disagreement) among the Rishonim (early authorities): if it’s Pesik Reisha, delo nicha lei, it’s mutar (permitted). We already understood what Pesik Reisha is. You’re pulling the bench because you need it in another place, but as a result, it’s going to make holes everywhere. The Arukh, one of the earlier Rishonim, says, “This is destroying your backyard.” One thing is if it’s your field and you’re interested in planting things, but here you destroy; there were flowers everywhere. So Pesik Reisha, delo nicha lei, mutar. That’s the opinion of the Arukh: since that’s not your intention. You consciously know this is going to happen, so it’s asur (forbidden) as a Pesik Reisha. If lo nicha lei—it bothers him, it’s not good for him—then it’s mutar. Most Rishonim disagree with that: Pesik Reisha, delo nicha lei, asur. However, we could make a very interesting... No, no, hold it, it’s asur min ha-Torah (by Torah law). If it would be Derabbanan (rabbinic), maybe. I’m not going into Derabbanan, I’m going to take a different direction. Let’s say something happens that could happen almost every Shabbat morning. You’re home and you make yourself coffee. You’re drinking your coffee and add a little milk. At this point, it’s a Kli Sheni (secondary vessel); you add a little milk. You finish drinking your coffee, or you’re halfway through it and you get cold. So you know what? I’m going to make myself another coffee. So you empty out your coffee. But there are still drops from the old coffee, and there’s milk in that coffee that is considered raw. Or you rinse it, and now you have fresh water in there—uncooked water. Can you make a coffee directly on top, or do you have to dry the cup? You’re not sure whether it’s water or milk.

The question is that this is coming from a Kli Rishon (primary vessel). It’s called Iruy Kli Rishon (pouring from a primary vessel), not Kli Sheni. Iruy Kli Rishon is Mevashel kedei klipah in Hilchot Yoreh De'ah—Mevashel a little bit. The question is, is it mutar? It’s a three-way Machloket. According to the Rashbam, it’s Kli Sheni. It’s not Mevashel at all. But according to Rabbeinu Tam and Ri, the Ba'alei HaTosafot, it’s Mevashel like Kli Rishon, De'oraita (by Torah law). According to the majority of Rishonim, it’s Bishul (cooking) Derabbanan. It’s not De'oraita; it’s Derabbanan. It’s a three-way Machloket.

That’s one Safek (doubt). The truth of the matter is, you’re not interested in this Bishul. You’re not interested at all in this Bishul. You don’t care about the two drops that are there. Mi ikhpat lecha. If it happens, it’s called Pesik Reisha delo ikhpat lei. The Pesik Reisha doesn’t care about it. But we said, Pesik Reisha delo ikhpat lei or delo nicha lei, it’s asur. Halakha is not like the Arukh. But it’s still a Machloket in the Rishonim. So I make a Safek sfeika (double doubt): Safek, maybe Pesik Reisha delo nicha lei, even De’oraita, is mutar. Safek, it’s asur. And even if you say that it’s asur, maybe Iruy Kli Rishon—having this water fall from a Kli Rishon to a Kli Rishon on top of those drops—is a Machloket: whether it’s mutar or asur, De’oraita or Derabbanan. There’s a Safek sfeika. Safek sfeika, mutar.

And therefore, Hacham Ovadia says, if you want to be Makhmir (stringent) and dry the inside, Tavo alav Beracha, amazing. But if you don’t want to do that, it’s mutar to pour, even on water that was never cooked. It’s not like the first cup on the side. No, no, or milk or water that was never cooked would be mutar, because it’s a Safek sfeika. So even in the Pesik Reisha world, some say lo nicha lei in issur (prohibition) De’oraita. I’m not talking about issur De’oraita; issur De’oraita, you could use it as a tzad safek (a side of doubt). If you have another Safek, it would become mutar, and that would be Halakha in this case.