The following halacha (Jewish law) is not political, so nothing personal. I spoke about this years ago, but Hacham Ovadia introduces the concept that, just as you have beracha (blessing) levatala—a beracha that was not necessary, or a beracha that was said incorrectly, etc.—so too you have the concept of amen levatala (amen said in vain). The Gemara discusses when to say amen (so be it), how close the beracha is, amen chatufa (snatched amen), and amen yetoma (orphaned amen). There are a lot of different things regarding amen, but he mainly quotes Rambam, who clarifies everything and basically says that just as there is a beracha levatala, so too there is an amen levatala. Whoever is not careful about that will have to give an account of it, meaning it is very serious. Of course, it is not as well known as a beracha levatala, but according to Rambam, it is the same thing. It is interesting: there is no Shem Hashem (the Name of God), correct? But maybe that is because amen is like a small version of the Shem Hashem. That is the shita (approach) of Rambam. Hacham Ovadia brings it to ma'aseh (practical application). Of course, he is not bringing it; it is just that this is halacha lema'aseh (in practice), and therefore he says one has to be very careful about it.
How does that apply, and why did I say this is not a political halacha? Many times—here is a simple example—everybody knows that when it comes to Rosh Chodesh, our custom is not to say the beracha on the Hallel. The Ashkenazi (of Ashkenaz) custom is to say a beracha on the Hallel of Rosh Chodesh. So the question is: can the Sefaradi (Sephardic Jew) answer amen to the beracha that an Ashkenazi is saying on his Hallel? On one hand, you say, “Look, Hacham Ovadia says you cannot answer amen.” Why? Because just as you have a beracha levatala, so too you have an amen levatala. I am asking: can you say that beracha or not? If the answer to that question is no, I cannot say that beracha, then you should not say amen to that beracha. That is the opinion of Hacham Ovadia. Other poskim (halachic authorities) do not agree. They say that as long as the beracha was said properly—meaning, if that is this person’s custom, this is this person’s way of saying a beracha—then you are saying a beracha; it is not levatala. Levatala would be that he was misplaced; it was not well said. If the Ashkenazi asked, “Do I have to say a beracha?” the answer would be yes. So if he did not say a beracha in vain, then you could say amen to his beracha. Hacham Ovadia disagrees. He says, “No, you do not say amen to a beracha that you would not be able to say.”
Why is that very relevant here? Over the past few days, we have been talking about the beracha of Borei Nefashot on coffee. We said that we do not say the beracha of Borei Nefashot on coffee, mainly because it takes a very long time to drink a coffee. But we saw many different opinions on this. For instance, according to some poskim, that is the derech (way) to drink it. If that is the derech to drink it, then you would have to say Borei Nefashot. We saw the opinion that some people say you have the same amount of time to drink it as you would for a meal, which is four minutes—let’s say, four or five minutes. So if you drink your coffee within four or five minutes, it is still okay. Hacham Ovadia disagrees with that. He disagrees with all the halachot saying that we do not say Borei Nefashot. But at the end of the day, the safek sfeika (double doubt) is to say Borei Nefashot. We do not say Borei Nefashot. But can you use this safek sfeika to answer amen? Hacham Ovadia says, “Yes, you could.” So if somebody says Borei Nefashot, it is not as serious as the beracha levatala itself. We do not say the beracha on coffee. But if somebody did say the beracha on coffee, Hacham Ovadia says that in this case, he would be able to answer amen to his beracha.

