A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Should one say Sheheheyanu on a ‘new fish or meat’?

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
September 11, 2024
Duration
2:46
Lecture code
RGK-1346

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Magen Avraham asked a question. Let’s say there’s a new restaurant in town, and they tell you, “This is new meat that you’ve never tried.” Why? I don’t know why, but it’s new meat that you’ve never tried—maybe a different animal, maybe a new cut that they didn’t have. I don’t know. Do you say it or not?

Let’s say they tell you there’s a new variety, a species of fish that you’ve never tried. There is, by the way, such a species. I remember there’s a big lake between Switzerland and France called Lac Léman. This lake has two or three species of fish. In the entire world, this is the only place. I remember trying one of them. It wasn’t especially good, but it was from there. Do you say Shehecheyanu (Who has kept us alive) or not? You have definitely never tried it before.

The Magen Avraham says absolutely not. You only say Shehecheyanu on new fruits and new vegetables. Vegetables—we discussed that already—but new fruits at least. Why? Because we find that it’s not up to you or your experience, but up to the hitchadshut. Only with fruits is there a time when they’re not available at all because it’s not the season, because that’s the way HaKadosh Baruch Hu (The Holy One, blessed be He) made the world. So therefore, there’s a time when you don’t have it. And then, when the new moment comes, you’re able to have it from year to year, from time to time, let’s say. That’s not the case there. It was always there. You didn’t have access to it. It’s your problem. Other people did. You decided. Whatever, you didn’t know.

But it's not based on personal experience when it comes to the consumption of food. Personal experience in other situations—we do have Shehecheyanu. When it comes to the consumption of food, you don’t find the concept of Shehecheyanu unless it is related to the hitchadshut, the renewal of the fruit. Like we discussed just the last time about the etrog (citron). The etrog is always found. That was one of the reasons why you don’t say Shehecheyanu on the consumption of the etrog. Although you didn’t have access to it, it’s there on the tree. The Gemara says that it’s always there.

Therefore, based on the above, says the Magen Avraham, we do not say Shehecheyanu on any new-ish kind of meat or fish or whatever. It’s not gadel min hakarka. It’s not something that grows from the ground.