A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Should someone who was saved from an overdose say Hagomel?

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
July 14, 2024
Duration
5:25
Lecture code
RGK-1301

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Let's continue with the same topic: someone who gets sick, is saved, and we'll have to say Birkat HaGomel (blessing of thanksgiving). Let's make things a little more complicated. We have somebody who, for example, has an overdose of a drug consumption. It's called Gorem Ra'ah Le'atzmo: He brought on himself the problem. Who asked you to do this? But he did. And now, Baruch Hashem (Blessed is Hashem), after great effort, he gets saved; he's okay. Do you say Birkat HaGomel, or do you say, “Well, you shouldn't have done that”?

Let's continue like a Gemara. If you want to say that he doesn't say it because it was Gorem Ra'ah Le'atzmo, what about somebody who smoked his whole life and then, later in life, gets a very bad diagnosis from a scan of his lungs? Anytime you have a lung cancer. And this man goes through treatments, and, Baruch Hashem, he makes it. He stops smoking. Chazak u'Baruch (Be strong and blessed). Now you say the same thing: “Well, lung cancer. A lot of people smoke; they don't have lung cancer. We don't know. Maybe it's a mix of both.” What about somebody who is extremely overweight, has heart problems, et cetera, and has a heart attack, and, Baruch Hashem, survives? Do they say Birkat HaGomel or not? These are questions that you could continue pushing even more, because then you say that anybody who is diabetic, many times, it has to do with what they eat.

So when do you get to a point where you say, “This was 100% min haShamayim (from Heaven), but for the rest, you should have done something about it”? Say, Gemara meforash (explicit). This means that you can control your health, and if you don't, don't blame it on God. It's on you. Hakol bidei Shamayim (Everything is in Heaven's hands), except that. Mashma (it implies) that's not on God; that's on you. If it's on you, then what? Let's go back to the beginning. Is there such a chiluk (distinction) between what a person would do to himself and what he would not?

There's a teshuva (responsum) from the Chida. In Machazik Beracha, the Chida quotes his father, who says: “Comparing with the cases of the Gemara, the only time a person says is when the problem comes his way without the person intending to have it. It came his way.” This is the shita (approach) of the Chida. Any participation on your part means you brought a problem on yourself; that's your problem. Then don't bring God into that. So don't say, “Thank you, Hashem, for saving you.”

The truth of the matter is, if you think about it, I would think the opposite. I would think that when you brought a problem on yourself and God came and saved you, although you brought the problem on yourself, you should make a double—a double Birkat HaGomel. Because if you brought the problem, it's like, “Okay, God, you brought me the problem for a reason. Now it's time to clean up the problem.” But if you brought the problem, God could tell you, “Hey, Habibi, no, don't get me involved. We said that was not the plan. You brought it on your own.” But God says, “You know what? I'm going to do a chesed, triple chesed, because that was not part of the plan. You messed up the plan. But I'm going to change the plan to save you.” That's a big Birkat HaGomel.

So there's a sefer, Sedeh HaAretz, that says, “Who cares who brought the problem? At the end of the day, God saved you, right?” If He saved you, who cares how you got into the mess? So it's a big machloket (dispute). Normally, you have a safek berachot (doubt about blessings). Hacham Ovadia takes a little bit of a middle position. He says that if it's something a person clearly brought on himself, chas veshalom (God forbid)—somebody tried to commit suicide or somebody had an overdose, things like this—where it's mamash, it's a direct thing, he brings the concept that it's like saying a beracha (blessing) on something that's teref (non-kosher). It's terrible what the person did.

But then you have the natural things that a person is, quote-unquote, controlling or not controlling. A lot of people are overweight and have a good, healthy life, while people who are not overweight have terrible cholesterol and look thin. So it's always unclear; we can't really know. Whenever it's not mamash meforash that he did it, he says to say Birkat HaGomel. But if a person brought a problem mamash on himself, he says not to say Birkat HaGomel.