A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Tefilah According To The Approach Of The Nefesh Hachaim #5

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
March 22, 2022
Duration
46:15
Lecture code
RGK-TNH-05

What Baruch Means

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas resumes with the Nefesh HaChaim’s discussion in Perek Bet: Baruch is not praise or the elevation of someone in the way people ordinarily praise one another.
  • He recalls the example involving Rabbi Yishmael: someone repeatedly asks him for a beracha, but Rabbi Yishmael does not respond with one. The discussion distinguishes giving a beracha from offering shevach (praise); asking for lachmanot or for lachayim on people is not itself shevach.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas presents this as the central point: when Baruch means filling, elevating, or bringing more, it refers to adding something. Ribui is increase or multiplication.
  • In expressions such as “U'berach et lachmecha” and “U'berach pri vitnecha,” beracha means an increase in income or children. More generally, when Scripture speaks of beracha directed toward people rather than Hashem, it means an increase, multitude, or abundance—not praise.
  • The Zohar’s language includes le'arika birchan, pouring out blessings. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas discusses the related terms le'arik and lehorik: although they can suggest emptying, here the sense is pouring or bringing down from one place to another, and birchan denotes increase—tosefet ribui.
  • The Raya Mehemna says, “Baruch Atah Hashem,” perusho kemashma'o (“as it sounds”); Rabbi Gabriel Koskas explains this as bringing down. He also discusses “U'le'arika chayim mi'mekora de'chayim” and “Dehamshich u'le'arik chayim mi'mekor chayim”: bringing and pouring life from the source of life. The group questions why the language of “emptying” is used if the intended sense is pouring down; no further resolution is given.
  • He emphasizes that, at this stage, the aim is only to define Baruch. The sources he cites present it as ribui and addition, not Tehillah v'shevach (praise and acclaim). He cautions that one should not assume every cited verse has the same context as the beracha in prayer.

The Problem of Adding to Hashem

  • The definition raises a serious question: if Baruch means adding, how can a person add anything to Hashem, who is Ein Sof and lacks nothing?
  • The discussion considers whether adding to creation could count as adding to Hashem, since creation belongs to Borei Olam. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says this is a matter for careful discussion: in one sense a good deed adds something to creation, but it is not thereby an addition to Hashem as He truly is.
  • He rejects the idea that this can be understood mathematically: adding even a drop to an infinite being is impossible. He warns against speaking as though Hashem were a human companion whose possessions or abilities could be increased.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas stresses that this subject concerns the essence of Hashem and must be approached carefully. He says the introduction to the Sha'arim is Sha'ar Gimel, not Sha'ar Aleph or Sha'ar Bet, because it addresses the distinction between the different facets or “personalities” through which Hashem is discussed and what human beings can never comprehend about Him.

Creation, Change, and “Baby Talk”

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas uses the mashal of air and a physical object: saying that everything is Hashem does not make a book, phone, or other tangible thing cease to be perceived as such within our experience. The same discussion holds that, from the perspective of Ein Sof, nothing exists independently of Hashem.
  • He compares imagining Hashem before creation and after creation to seeing the same thing: from the perspective of Ein Sof, there is no change. But human beings are part of creation and change, so they cannot fully grasp that perspective.
  • From that perspective there is no physical measurement and no time; therefore, even speaking of “before” and “after” is inadequate. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says that these matters exceed human comprehension, since we experience and touch the created world.
  • He describes Hashem’s relating to creation in a lower, humanly accessible dimension as giving creation “space.” His analogy is an adult speaking to a child in language the child can understand: the adult remains an adult, but adapts his speech so that a connection is possible.
  • The grandparent-and-child analogy illustrates the point. A child may call a grandfather great because he gave the child a lollipop; that is true at the child’s level, but it does not describe the grandfather’s greatness as an adult would understand it.
  • In this analogy, Tosefet Beracha is part of the relationship Hashem establishes with people at their level. It is a serious connection, not a joke, but it does not mean that anything is added to Hashem’s essence. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas warns that thinking one has added to Atzmut Baruch Hu is a mistake.
  • He applies this to the pasuk said every morning: Hashem is above any beracha. Without understanding what beracha means, he argues, the pasuk cannot be understood properly in English. He then turns to how one proceeds into the Amidah after considering these ideas.

The Hidden and Revealed Dimensions

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas cites the Zohar’s formulation, “Kudsha Brich Hu satim ve-galya, satim de-kol satimin” (The Holy One is hidden and revealed, hidden of all hidden). The two aspects correspond to the distinction he has been making between what can be addressed at a human level and what remains beyond comprehension.
  • The highest truth, Ein Sof, has no name and cannot be understood. He says this remains beyond comprehension even after 120 years—or 120 million years—and even in relation to Moshe Rabbeinu, the highest neshamot, or the highest malachim.
  • He distinguishes two ways of saying “I didn’t understand”: being wholly disconnected from the subject, and recognizing why one cannot understand it. Anything spiritual is a creation; because creation is outside the world of Ein Sof, it cannot comprehend Ein Sof.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas describes Shai Olamot (310 worlds) of tzadikim as far below that hidden dimension. He also refers to another 55 Olamot of malachei Elyon and malachim kedoshim, which can be understood only under Yud-Kei-Vav-Kei.
  • Yud-Kei-Vav-Kei is already associated with time—Hayah, Hoveh, Veyihyeh (was, is, and will be)—and is far below even what he calls the lowest “level” of Ein Sof. In Ein Sof itself, he says, there is no high or low.
  • The response to the limits of understanding is “Tiku” (let it stand unresolved)—and, as he puts it, not even Tiku: the matter is beyond resolution.

Names and the Limits of Description

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas quotes: “Atzmut Ein Sof Baruch Hu satim mi-kol setimin” (the essence of the Infinite is hidden from all hidden), and “Ve'en lechanoto” (there is no name for Him). He says that, in this dimension, one may not call Him by any name—not even Yud-Kei-Vav-Kei. Even the yud associated with Keter belongs to what can be approached at a human level and does not touch the satim.
  • He reiterates that human beings’ task is “baby talk”: Hashem chose to create a relationship accessible to creation. The grandfather analogy describes a serious connection at the child’s level, not a description of the grandfather’s full reality.
  • He returns to the claim that any name applied to Hashem is inadequate at the level of Ein Sof. His examples are calling Einstein smart according to ordinary standards of Chochmah, or imagining that $1,000 in a bank account would impress Mr. Safra: such descriptions miss the vast difference in scale.
  • At the level of Ein Sof, the more one says, the more inadequate the description becomes. Calling Him good-looking, rich, smart, Gibor, or Nora cannot describe Him. “Ein Sof” itself is not a positive description of the essence; it means that one has no adequate name or description.
  • When someone asks whether people can speak to Ein Sof in prayer, Rabbi Gabriel Koskas answers that prayer is “baby talk.” He describes Hashem as connecting to the world through complex connections by which He influences, gives, and acts. In the examples discussed, people address the particular angel or connection relevant to that moment, not Ein Sof itself.

Ein Sof, Human Understanding, and Connection

  • The discussion considers whether “beginningless” would be more accurate than “endless.” Rabbi Gabriel Koskas says that, from the perspective of Hashem Himself, there is neither beginning nor end, but even saying that is already using human language and limiting what is being described.
  • “Ein Sof” is used mitzad hasagatenu (from our understanding): it conveys, in terms we can grasp, that there is no end to Hashem’s powers. Yet “endless” and “infinite” can suggest something that began and simply does not finish; the lecture acknowledges that this is also inadequate.
  • He says that “beginningless” is even farther from human comprehension. Ein Sof is therefore the closest description available to us, not a full account of the reality it refers to. Leaving the matter blank is not the answer either; people must recognize the limits of their own place and understanding.
  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas invokes the Rambam’s teaching that such matters are not taught publicly but one-on-one. The transition from infinite to finite cannot be understood, yet Hashem made creation and its “space” possible.
  • He argues that this limit should not lead to despair. The analogies of wishing to live on the moon or Mars, or to drive 500 miles an hour, illustrate that people need not be distressed about what is beyond their place or capacity. They should first explore life, relationships, and Torah at their own level rather than lamenting what they cannot access.
  • When someone says this does not sound uplifting because it does not promise continuous personal development, Rabbi Gabriel Koskas agrees: the point is not to imagine oneself progressively reaching Ein Sof. There is already immense depth and connection available at one’s present level.
  • He concludes that Ein Sof is only a highly partial human apprehension of kochotav yitbarach (His blessed powers). It is the furthest description from us that is still connected to us; if it were even slightly farther away, there could be no connection. Even this highest description is effectively a way of naming the unknown, shaped by human limitations rather than a description of Hashem’s essence.
Words in this lecture1
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem