A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

Tefilah According To The Approach Of The Nefesh Hachaim #7

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
March 22, 2022
Duration
47:43
Lecture code
RGK-TNH-07

Names, Form, and the Two Perspectives

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas frames the discussion around what a name or position means: it concerns Hashem’s connection with the Olamot, not His essence or the Prophet. Speaking about Hashem in this context means speaking about His relationship with something.
  • In the Ra'aya Meheimna in Parashat Bo, he examines the apparent contradiction between “ki lo re'item kol temunah” (“for you saw no image”) and “temunat Hashem yabit” (“the image of Hashem he sees”).
  • He explains the contradiction through the distinction between Ein Sof and Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh: from the perspective of Ein Sof, there is no temunah or tzura (form).
  • Any tzura, including a spiritual one, entails creation and some limitation. Before the Briyah, there was nothing—not even a spiritual form—so that dimension cannot be described in terms of something.
  • Once Hashem brings something into existence, there is a tzura and a connection to creation. This is the dimension of Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh: Hashem mehave something, bringing it into existence. The form need not be physical.

Tzimtzum, Creation, and the Malachim

  • The discussion raises how Hashem could communicate with malachim if communication requires some form of connection. Rabbi Koskas reasons that malachim, like all created beings, cannot exist in the dimension of Ein Sof; they require Tzimtzum and the making of space for them.
  • He clarifies that Briyah includes everything—malachim, neshamot, other spiritual beings, physical beings, and humanity. Even the highest neshama, including that of Moshe Rabbeinu, cannot exist in Ein Sof.
  • He mentions 310 Olamot that tzadikim could visit, then levels numbered 311 through 365 as beyond our access, as well as 55 Olamot that no one will ever be able to access. These levels still involve “something,” and therefore remain under Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh, not Ein Sof.
  • Even after 7,000 years and whatever future elevation is described for neshamot, they remain far below Ein Sof. The wisdom of malachim is at a different level from ours, but both malachim and people require Hashem to make space for them.
  • Rabbi Koskas rejects the idea that humanity is simply higher than malachim. He says Hashem’s communication with malachim is more panim el panim than His communication with us, while stressing that this does not mean Hashem communicates through an ordinary voice.
  • He discusses the Rambam’s approach to communication between a human and a malach: if they do not communicate through the same means, an ordinary conversation between them cannot take place. The Torah’s accounts of Yaakov speaking with a malach therefore raise a question.
  • The discussion also considers how a malach could appear in a human form, including as a woman. Rabbi Koskas says Hashem can cause such an appearance, but one should not assume that it happened unless the account indicates it.
  • The Rambam’s position is described as famous and controversial. In the Moreh Nevuchim, he discusses Yaakov’s encounter with the malach and the account involving Shimshon’s parents; the class asks how these cases relate to the Akedah and to the interpretations of the Ramban and Abarbanel.
  • Rabbi Koskas explains the encounter with Yaakov as nevuah rather than an ordinary physical meeting: the episode was shown to Yaakov spiritually, so he did not literally meet or converse with the malach as one person meets another. The question about the gid hanasheh is also discussed in connection with what happened in the vision.
  • The Matrix is invoked as an analogy for the difference between a human’s ordinary experience and a spiritual encounter. The larger point is that communication with a malach cannot simply be assumed to work like human communication.

Time, Space, and the Dimensions of Hashem’s Existence

  • Rabbi Koskas considers how Hashem can be beyond time while the Torah describes time-bound events and obligations. He recalls asking a rabbi whether Hashem follows time, especially as Rosh Hashanah approached and the Rambam’s teaching that Hashem is above time seemed to conflict with Yom HaDin.
  • He notes that the Rambam describes Hashem without human conditions such as sitting, standing, or being subject to time; the class discusses how this relates to the language of Hashem sitting on the Throne of Judgment and to the distinction between Yom HaDin and other days.
  • Rabbi Koskas recounts that the rabbi rebuked and slapped him rather than answering. Years later, after meeting the rabbi’s son, he raised the story; the rabbi reportedly did not remember it. Rabbi Koskas allows that he may have remembered it imperfectly or asked the question too forcefully, but maintains that the question was serious.
  • His conclusion is that within the Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh dimension there is time and space, and Hashem relates to them there—not merely as an explanation for human understanding. Otherwise, the Torah’s distinctions in time, such as Pesach and Yom HaDin, would lose their meaning.
  • He leaves open whether other levels within Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh have time in the same way. He says we cannot comprehend how the timeless dimension of Ein Sof and the dimension in which time exists can both be present; Ein Sof remains “now” even though that dimension has no time.

Why These Subjects Require Caution

  • Rabbi Koskas turns to the Nefesh HaChaim, Sha'ar, page 153, and its statement: “Be'emet hayiti mone'a atzmi medaber be'inyan zeh klal”—“In truth, I would have restrained myself from speaking about this matter at all.” He cites the Nefesh HaChaim’s explanation that the early authorities concealed these matters greatly.
  • He stresses that such topics were not ordinarily discussed openly and that studying them requires serious preparation, attention, and guidance. Hearing isolated pieces and drawing one’s own conclusions is dangerous.
  • He warns that people may take the idea that Hashem is everywhere or beyond place and time to mean that all places and practices are equivalent—for example, that praying at home is identical to praying in a shul, or that one could pray in a bathroom. Even if an abstract perspective seems to suggest equivalence, it does not mean that we may disregard the distinctions that apply to us.
  • Rabbi Koskas cautions that partial or casual study can lead people to think they understand when they do not, and can undermine Torah practice. He says the subject should not be approached in fragments or merely when convenient.
  • He explains that he sought permission from his rabbi to teach these matters because he understood that they were not to be taught publicly. The rabbi told him that the times had changed and that he should teach them to provide hadrachah, since people now encounter these ideas openly and may otherwise be misled.
  • He describes the tradition as having been transmitted privately, one chacham to one talmid. He says these subjects were not discussed for 1700 years, and also describes 1500 years in which nobody spoke about them; the Ramban was among those who brought them into discussion.
  • He mentions a chain of transmission associated with Rashi and possibly Mahzor Vitry, then says the Ari HaKadosh was the first to open the material to one person, and that Avraham Azulai received permission to publish it. He emphasizes that public access does not mean that people understand the material.
  • The reason to learn these ideas is not to claim a higher spiritual status, but to know one’s place and avoid confusing an abstract perspective with what one is permitted or required to do in practice.

Hashem’s Names as Expressions of Relationship

  • Returning to the main discussion, Rabbi Koskas says that what can be spoken about is the connection of Hashem with the Olamot: the spreading of His light or presence into them. The subject is the relationship, not Hashem “personally” in His essence.
  • He applies this to attributes such as Shalom: calling someone a peaceful person refers to how that person relates to others. Likewise, speaking of Hashem through a name or attribute refers to His connection with something.
  • He notes that Peshitut Olo is a phrase whose parenthetical wording is a Hebrew translation from the Aramaic of the Zohar. He also explains that the Tikkunim is another book of the Zohar.
  • The discussion refers to Shi'ur Komah, Adam Ha'Elyon, and the Merkavah. Rabbi Koskas gives the simple model of humanity as one body: Israel can be considered collectively as one, and the health or condition of the whole is understood through its parts.
  • He cautions that the body imagery is spiritual, not a literal mapping in which one person corresponds to a finger and another to a foot. It represents the connection of HaKadosh Baruch Hu with us through the whole of humanity.
  • In this framework, the connection of HaKadosh Baruch Hu with us gives rise to a name: the name is not being discussed in isolation, but as it appears through that relationship. The details of how the parts correspond are beyond what Rabbi Koskas claims to understand.

The Implication for Tefilah

  • Rabbi Koskas identifies the central practical point of the complex material: we relate to a name through Hashem’s connection with us or with something in creation.
  • When one says “Baruch Atah Hashem,” one is not speaking about Hashem’s essence. The address is understood in relation to His active function, presence, or connection; Rabbi Koskas says the meaning of “Atah” will be explained further.
  • The temunah discussed earlier is likewise the temunah of HaKadosh Baruch Hu in His relationship with us. Tzimtzum makes that relationship possible; without creating a connection, there would be no purpose in making a world.
  • The chapter on tefillah is therefore concerned with this connection: “Baruch Atah Hashem” and the other language of prayer refer to Hashem as related to creation, not to His essence apart from all relationship.
Words in this lecture1
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem