It is all about the position, what it means, the name. It is all about the connection He has with the Olamot (worlds). It has nothing to do with the Prophet. It is like saying you are never going to talk to Him, basically. If you can talk about Him, you can talk only about His relationship with someone.
I have to grab a type. Perek Gimel (Chapter Three), Sha'ar Bet (Gate Two), Perek Gimel. Let’s continue a little bit. We had started the Ra'aya Meheimna, in Parashat Bo: “ki lo re'item kol temunah” (for you saw no image), “deha ketiv temunat Hashem yabit” (for it is written, “the image of Hashem he sees”), “de afilu hai temunah lete be'atre, rakad nachit le'amla'cha alayhu, v'yitpachot al biryan, v'tchazelon l'kol chat kifun mar'e v'hezyon v'dimyon d'lehon.”
There is a stira (contradiction) in the pasuk (verse). One pasuk tells you that you did not see any physical aspect to Hashem, but another pasuk says that He has a temunah. Does He have a temunah or not? I don't feel it any moment. What is it? A picture, a picture. Look at that. I think once it’s fine. “Harei katuv” (behold, it is written): “u-temunat Hashem yabit.” Shafirut munazlu en lobim komo.
So again, you have the two perspectives: the Ein Sof (the Infinite) perspective and the Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh perspective. From the Ein Sof perspective, obviously there is no temunah. It does not exist. If you have a temunah, it is something concise. For those learning the daf, it's to pull your hair. These things are very, very, very hard, but this helps a drop, a drop in its place, whatever that is. You do not find any temunah. So in his personal—like we spoke about the Ein Sof—there's nothing.
But when He comes into connection with the world, before forming anything—even a spiritual formation—anything that is created is called a tzura (form). It involves some kind of creation, sometimes a limitation, and therefore we are already talking about part of creation. That is already not the real aspect of Hashem, if you want: angle area. Hashem is unlimited. If it is unlimited, there is no space for something limited. But before He even considered making something, when He was, quote-unquote, alone with nothing, there was no tzura, there was nothing. So anything that has to do with that dimension is not permitted. I do not know what the Lashon (language)—
If you refer to a dimension prior to the Briyah (creation), there is no point in talking about anything. There is no thing. There is nothing. He creates that tzura, that form of Merkavah shel Adam Ha'Elyon (chariot of the supernal human). Mowgli sees that anyway. Yalad sham v'unikra bat tzurahi havayah (existence) Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh. He is mehave something. He is going to have something in order to have the Shem Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh, because you carry time, ayah veveh. You carry something because you have mehave something. He is making something exist.
Once you go into that dimension, there is something that is a tzura, something, even if it is not a physical tzura. It could be a spiritual tzura. Then you can start talking. This is the dimension of Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh. In order for us to understand that, it is above my pay grade. But we will continue with what we have learned so far.
I mean, if you start now, you won't understand anything. How did He communicate with the malachim (angels)? He also needs to do Tzimtzum (contraction) for them. “His nerve is so bright.” The question is, does He also need to do Tzimtzum for them? If He speaks to the malachim, obviously there is a Tzimtzum. There is no such thing as communicating with something if there is nothing.
So His communication also was sinful. Again, how could you have anything, including malachim, if there is nothing to it? Before the Briyah, there was nothing, not temunah. “Temunah had to spread in her world, to have Tzimtzum so she could connect.”
If He spoke to the malachim in the way that He speaks to us, in Tzimtzum, it doesn't matter. It has to be exactly or not in Tzimtzum compared with before the Briyah, before the temunah, before the peshitut (simplicity). If He did it only for us, it was not only for us. He did it also before the Briyah of the Adam, because it was also with the malachim. So what is written here is either inaccurate, or I do not understand, or whatever that may be. It does not jibe; it cannot work. I really do not understand. Maybe you misunderstood, too.
“I do not think he is going to make a mistake.” Of course he did not make a mistake. Maybe you misunderstood. I am trying to understand the way you misunderstood what you said. “I did not misunderstand either.” Of course you did. 100%.
Before that, He did not have any temunah, any tzura, anything like that. And He does have it because, again, He made temunah, He did Tzimtzumim, He did whatever that may be, so we can communicate, connect, whatever. So now He is talking about us. So now He is not talking about you. The briyot (creations) are everything. Malachim are also briyot.
That was my question to begin with: How did He communicate with the malachim? Did He communicate after the Tzimtzum? Obviously, because if there is no Tzimtzum, there are no malachim. “So anything you talk about after asher, that could be in the beginning 50 seconds without the—so.” Briyah includes everything: malachim, everything, whatever is spiritual, whatever is physical, anything, even us, even what we do not understand.
I am not sure I understand what you are getting at, but we have said a thousand times already that nothing is created at the level above the Tzimtzum. Above Tzimtzum, there is no space for anything. Hashem has to give space to something in order for it to exist. So anything—even the highest spiritual neshama (soul), ruach (spirit), Malach Gabriel, Malach Raphael, any malach—cannot exist at the level, at the dimension, of Ein Sof. They cannot exist there. That is obvious.
As Philip commented, perhaps we are all making the same mistake, thinking there was one separation for us and another for the malachim. It is different. Obviously, we are not at the same level. Everything is under the banner of Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh, anything except Ein Sof. As we said maybe two weeks ago, nobody—not even the highest beings, whom we cannot understand—can reach the level of Ein Sof. You could take the neshama of Moshe Rabbeinu (Moses our teacher), which is probably the highest thing; it will never visit that space or being, or whatever you want to call it, in the dimension of Ein Sof. In a place of something—in a place of nothing, sorry—something cannot exist.
In the end, if you call a neshama something, maybe it is not something you can touch, smell, or hear. It is something because there is a Briyah. Once there is a Briyah, you are not in the world of Ein Sof; you are in the world of Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh. Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh seems very inside. There are a ton of levels there, including levels that we will never reach, ever. Nobody will.
We said—I do not remember—that there were 310 Olamot that the tzadikim (righteous people) could visit, quote-unquote. Imagine the highest level: 310, 311, all the way to 365. We do not have any access to it. There was 55 Olamot that nobody ever will ever be able to. And that is still under Ein Sof, because there is something. You talk about the number, the level, something. Something means Tzimtzum. Something means Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh. Nothing is above that. It is a different dimension, something we will never understand.
Even at the highest level, after 7,000 years of whatever is going to happen to us, we will never comprehend it. When they say that our neshamot (souls) are going to come back to the highest level, it is still under—under, under, under. So how does He communicate with malachim? The same way He communicates with us. It has to be through the Tzimtzum, and they are included when you say briyot. It is all briyot. Chochmat ha-malachim (wisdom of the angels) is a different level. It is not with us, but it is still under the same banner. Hashem still had to make space for a malach, for a neshama.
And no, it is not true that we are higher than a malach. We are higher than a malach. The communication of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, the Holy One, blessed be He, with the malachim is more panim el panim (face to face) than with us. We do not have that type of communication. “Who says?” I mean, like, He really does. “Who says?” “I thought it's an old time.” He means to say that they do not have to use a voice to be heard. He does not have a voice. He says, “Call Hashem.” It is not His voice; it is the creation of a voice they make to communicate. It is not us.
That is why they say—remember the shitah (approach) of the Rambam? When a malach and a human communicate, it can't be. Because if it's not the same means of communication, the way we communicate is the way we communicate, by writing, by talking. But with the malach, it doesn't work like this. It's a different channel. So he asks: How can the Torah say that Yaakov spoke to the malach, for example? “Shai Rabbeinu, are you with him too?” It is the Midrash, but it is about pesukim meforashim, explicit verses. It is the same question: If a malach does not communicate by voice, how do you communicate with a malach? It is impossible.
Then the Rambam asks: How could the malach come in the form of a woman? He could, if he wanted to. Hashem can do whatever He wants—not the malach, Hashem. If He does not tell you that the malach appeared like that, you cannot assume it happened that way.
“But we do know because no Rambam disagrees.” “No, Rambam, they always disagree with each other.” “No, it's good to know what they disagree with.” The Rambam’s famous, very controversial statement is that it never happens. But in that story, it did not happen. How can they separate the cases? He does not talk about the Akedah (Binding of Isaac). In the Moreh Nevuchim, the Rambam talks about the story of Yaakov and the malach. So how can the malach—he says the malach and Yaakov fought. What about the Akedah? Exactly: the Ramban, the Abarbanel—how does he separate all the mefarshim (commentators)? They all ask. “But in Akhiyam.” The Rambam brings two examples from the story of Yaakov and Shimshon. Shimshon’s parents, before he was born, had a whole conversation with the malach. So how can you justify the separation between this and that?
The point is that communication with a malach has to be at the malach’s level. The story is supposed to be the story of Yaakov; he does concur that it is okay, that it was right. It was a communication through… He says it never happens, neither one. Whenever there is a malach in the story, the whole thing did not happen. He communicated with the malach spiritually. So there was no fight.
“No, there was a fight.” I understand. Actually, it does not matter if it was a fight; it was a malach. It was nevuah (prophecy). They showed him that story. But if you asked Yaakov, “Did you ever meet that malach? Did you have a conversation with him?” you could have. You could say, “Tell me, Yaakov, did you ever meet that guy, that malach?” He would have to say no; it was not the same. “No, I had a dream.” We say it is not the same. And in the memoir they showed me, it is not the same, X, Y, and Z.
“But what about the gid hanasheh (sinew of the thigh), when I woke up and couldn’t walk?” In the dream, they tell him, since you got hurt in the dream, therefore the gid hanasheh—
Finally, my son realized that he watched The Matrix for a reason. The connection between a malach and a human cannot exist. So you see that the communication is obviously different. It’s the side one Rambam is unbelievable.
It is very interesting because Hashem exists on both dimensions at the same time. If you think about it, when you say you think that today and so on doesn't exist? No, Shalom, exactly. So when you say that before the Briyat HaOlam, creation of the world, Hashem was like this, and after the Briyat HaOlam Hashem is like that because He made the Briyat HaOlam, there is no before and after. After the Briyat HaOlam there is a before and after, maybe even for Hashem. After the Tzimtzum, I want to argue that there is. Why wouldn’t there be? There has to be; otherwise it is a joke. The whole Torah talks about time. Are you going to say there is no time? They create the time. They piplette, of course they create the time based on what they piplette.
Hashem follows time, yes or no? I asked the she'eilah (question) once, the big he created, remember, and he slapped me. That was my first—no, I was not the first one. I was one of them. I said I made him crazy, big rabbi. I told him, Rabbi, no, he slapped me, said we don't ask this question. I said I have a problem. Rosh Hashanah is coming up. The Rambam says Hashem is above time. No, He is above time. Maybe we are not.
We say Hashem is Yoshev al Kisei Din, sits on the Throne of Judgment. I showed him the Rambam. The Rambam said there is no time, no yeshivah (sitting), no amidah (standing), no din (judgment). I mean, there is no din. So I said, “The day before Rosh Hashanah, it is not Yom HaDin (Day of Judgment), right?” “No, the day after Rosh Hashanah, it is not Yom HaDin.” “Why? No, it's Yom HaDin every day? Is it Yom HaDin every day?” You gave a show on this. You said I found the answer. He didn't help me. He slapped me. That is when I thought of quitting. Why? Because he did not know the answer. The question I asked was, “I have a problem. Rosh Hashanah is coming up.”
The question I asked was, “I have a problem. Rosh Hashanah is coming up.” The question is valid; it is very strong. It is not valid for young kids. I was 26. I wanted to argue that there is a confusion between the two things, not in the Lama and the people. It took me years to find that answer. I learned this because the rabbi slapped me across the face. Who is this rabbi? I'm not going to say his name. Call him up and tell him that you're going there. I met the son, came to ask me for help. I said, I'm very upset with you. He came here. What? Yeah. It's a whole story. Did you not let him take revenge? I didn't take revenge. I said, you know, I had a little story with your dad. I told him, he said, I'm going to call my father. I'm going to tell him. He called the father. He said, he doesn't remember any of that. I do. He says, he's very quiet. He doesn't do this. And I said, okay. Maybe I'm beginning to mix up. I'm sure. I was very young, and I did ask the question a little hard. But the question is very strong. With Bono Gela, which I made it up as.
What do we see from it? After the whole iyun (study and analysis), at the end of the day, we must say that in the Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh dimension, you also follow time and space. “Yeah, because Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh is for all of us, our life, right?” “Yes. Our universe.” “Exactly. So He has to follow the time on our level.” “Yes. Maybe on another dimension within Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh there isn’t. I don’t know.” But within our dimension, it is not just for us. When He says it is for us, it makes no sense. It sounds like a circus. It's not for us. It's also for him, meaning he—yes, for us to understand, we explain that the point is, is that it has to be understood that within the Yud-Keh-Vav-Keh there is a space and there is a time.
If we don't say that, and the whole institution of the—where is this space? But no, it goes for some reason. Many do not say that there is space and time, but He goes by it. He goes by it. Otherwise, the whole Torah is not accurate. Is it only the time for Pesach (Passover)? If emet—truth is absolute—you can eat matzah all year. No, there is a time, and Hashem goes by it. There is a day of Yom HaDin and a day that is not Yom HaDin, but that is in our dimension. Hashem goes with it. That is the Chiddush (novel insight) of the Tzimtzum.
However, we cannot comprehend how both dimensions could exist at the same time. After the Briyah you can talk about time, but since before the Briyah you cannot talk about time, that dimension of Ein Sof still exists now. If there is a now—okay. There is no time for Him, for this. But again, it is both. It is like a vector. It is both, because the dimension of instance—you might—I am sure you can’t get both emet. One is more emet than the other. When He’s wearing one, one goes by time and one doesn’t, at the same time. Ein Sof is also now.
The whole charrette is based on this, what I am saying now. I know that Ronen says, “I wouldn’t do now.” At that point, it is very important to understand it. But I think it does, because it's trying to tell you, because at the end of the day we're going to need—we're going to have one question: why do we need to know that? Yeah, it's good to know. What do you mean? I think we know we're never going to reach. He is not sleeping. He is up. He is sleeping. He is checking his eyelids. Why do we need to know? No, it's very important, because why do you need to know that there's an Ein Sof? Anyways, we have nothing to do with it. Why do you switch to French in the middle? Why you don't want to know? Why you want to know that there is a lack? It is not given at all, like a nuclear central that gives energy to the whole world. Okay, let’s say you know it is in there. That is not true. That is not at all what it is. And so it's not that—understand that.
The Nefesh HaChaim in Sha'ar (gate) asks the question: Why would you want to know that? He says, “Normally, I wouldn’t talk about this. The only reason I’m talking about this is because…” He says, “For us, it would be a suit to talk about this.” We said we do not have to go too deep. Look at page Kuf Nun Gimel (153). He says, “Be'emet hayiti mone'a atzmi medaber be'inyan zeh klal” (In truth, I would have restrained myself from speaking about this matter at all). “Ki harishonim zal histiru ha'inyan me'od” (For the early authorities, of blessed memory, concealed the matter greatly). All this is not known. Even the Rishonim (early authorities) don't talk about it. “Ki Moshe tiret diwey kedosh Hashem ha'rokeh achzal.” All these topics were hidden. Nobody spoke about them, and nobody knew about them. People didn't know about it. It was not open.
You saw what we said: you teach a person only if he knows the Mishnah we just started. That is it. Now there are books that talk about this openly, as if we are wiser and understand better. That is who we are. We are not wise, we are not understanding, and we do not have that. We have access. Look at the courage he has. That was good for their time. But now we have to talk about these things. Many days without a teacher.
People are very smart. They think they know and understand, and therefore they go according to their own nitya, their own understandings. All people do is fly according to their understanding, wherever they go. So people talk about this subject: Hashem is everywhere, He’s everything. It is very dangerous to go according to this. There is no makom (place), there is no zman (time). Why pray in a shul? You can pray at home; it is the same Kedushah, holiness. “Oh, there’s more Kedushah.” It is not shul, and so off and so baruch hu, everything is equal. People start doing shtuyot, foolish things. There is no more Torah if you are going to go according to the—You need help with that.
People snap. They become crazy. They go into these subjects; they do not understand, they don’t have a more. They go crazy because you take it—what do you do? He says a person has to be very careful with this. One has to be careful when these people in the middle, they talk like this, they don't understand anything. It's very dangerous to have people like this in the class, because they talk, they hear one thing, yes, one thing, no. This guy, he comes one day, yes, one day, no, and they think they understand. This is not to be taken lightly. You understand a little bit and think you understood. You understood nothing! Chas veshalom, God forbid. No, I'm not joking. This is not a subject to take a little piece whenever you are in the mood to come. If you do not learn this in depth and pay attention at every moment, then it is not for you. Chas veshalom. “Ikachenu libenu. Likbo alanu makhsaba zu. L'atib la'atmenu. L'itnay gam be mizhe makhsaba zu.”
You hear a little piece and say, “I’m going to do this, I’m going to do that.” Are you crazy? You could destroy the Torah completely if you do that. We have not reached that Sha'ar yet. I’m skipping ahead to show you the same point. I should not speak about this. You said, “Why not know the nuclear plant?” We should not be talking about this, but the only reason he is talking about it is that it has become so open. People talk about Kabbalah as if it is a center. “Kabbalah center?” What are you talking about? You have to have a high in life. If not, you become like a blind person going around. It is dangerous; you are going to get run over by a car. It hurts. It's a picnic. He's right, it's a picnic, and you have to pay attention.
This is for generations. Nobody spoke about this, for a reason, because people did not have the chutzpah, audacity, to even think about these things. But now people—he said now people talk about this in a very easy way. We better get our act together. We have to talk about it. You do not teach this. I asked permission to teach this. I said to my rabbi, “I’m afraid to teach. This is a big deal. This is not simple.” It says you are not allowed to teach this in public. You are not allowed. I am not allowed to teach. Maybe I did not understand a quarter of it, so I asked permission.
He said, “Times change. Teach.” Why? Because people need the hadrachah, guidance. Otherwise, their minds go here. Today, people check Google for all the answers. Rabbi Google has everything. So when you say, “Why not?” I’ll show you why not.
For 1700 years they did not talk about it. 1500 years, nobody spoke about this. It was the Ramban who talked about it. A talmid, a student, from the rabbi; one, one; all the Mesorah, tradition, was one person. Rashi must have had one person he spoke to. Maybe Mahzor Vitry was the closest talmid of Rashi, and then this one to another one, and this one to another one. That is it. Nobody knew about this, ever. I think I’m only going to say this: one to one. Ramban is what I said. Hidden Torah. It was a tradition. One Chacham, wise person, to one Talmid, student. They did not have, “Okay, this year I’m going to take care of this guy. Next season I’m going to take care of this guy.” One to one.
Then the Ari HaKadosh, the holy Ari, was the first one who opened it to one person also, and then Avraham Azulai was given permission to publish these things. Avraham mi-Volozhin is saying he became a baraka. It is a very dangerous subject, because if you go deeper, you might say, “Oh no, I’m a higher level.” What’s the higher level? “I understand fully, and I grab and I respect that there's nothing other than—” Tell me why I couldn’t pray in the bathroom. The bathroom is no—it’s not true. At a higher level, there’s no problem. The bathroom is as much the same thing. And guess what? It's true in some perspective, but you're saying you go higher to a higher level, so I'm a higher perspective. I still cannot pray in the bathroom. How is that? Because we do not belong there.
So we need to know. Why? So I know about it. I know about it because I have to know my place. No, it says you should not know about it. I should know to begin with that thing, but if you already know this, I’m only addressing it because people are confusing it, exactly like you. But really, before that—so now you need to make an order. It means that by essence, why know about it? We should not know about it either. No—or yes, but not in between, because then the confusion comes in. Exactly. Unfortunately, it became very popular, and people talk, and people do not know anything. That is what I am saying here: you have to be very, very careful to know exactly how it works, because if you have bits and pieces, you become confused like the other guys. We should have a grant all week.
You said it. We close the parenthesis. No parenthesis, same subject. That's it. It is a hard subject. It is good we do it. I can’t handle more than that.
The only time you’re going to call or any shame for the like, it could only be through a new introduction, the spreading of His light on them. It is a little bit similar to what we said before. It is in the connection. It is not even Hashem. Even if you can’t talk to Him, it is about the connection of Hashem with the Olamot. You talk about that connection. That connection is the Midah (attribute) that you talk about by doing it like this, the Shalom (peace), by doing it like that. It is always in connection to something. When you say you are a peaceful person, or a Shalom-oriented person, why? Because you did Shalom with this guy. It is always in connection with something else.
So when you say Hashem Shalom, why Shalom? Because he did Shalom Bib Romance, for example. It is in connection with something. I am not talking about Him. I can’t talk about Him. I am not allowed to talk about Him. I have nothing with Him personally. It does not work. It is in His connection.
Peshitut Olo. What do you say, like the Peshitut Olo? The parenthesis is the translation in Hebrew from the Aramaic of the Zohar. That is where it is. The Zohar is in Aramaic.
UveTikkunim, e erikh bihinan, piplette. What are Tikkunim? It is another book of the Zohar. You have the regular Tikkunim, the Ayah Me'im, all this stuff. The Shi'ur Komah and the Adam Ha'Elyon, who said the thing before. It is, if you want, the whole humanity in one. Remember that concept? Let’s use Israel as an example. In a deeper dimension of Israel, it means that together we form one. Imagine the whole humanity being one big body. You ask, “How is the health of this body?” So look at the whole car. He says, “Okay, how is the health of the body?” His foot hurts; he’s like this. As is the guy. Why? Because we are all forming one.
That is, if you want, the very simple understanding of Adam Ha'Elyon or Merkavah. We mentioned before: Shuvah Shalah Merkava Shalah Adam Ha'Elyon. That is what it is. You understand what it means? He says in the parenthesis that it is a connection of HaKadosh Baruch Hu with us. Through every evar, limb, it is hard to know which one represents what. I don’t know. It is not that one is in the finger and the other is in the foot. It is more if you take it in a spiritual way. I don’t know how it works. Take all the humans, take all the guys and put one on top of another, and now you have a picture of all of them.
So when you see this, it means that the connection of HaKadosh Baruch Hu with us creates a name of HaKadosh Baruch Hu. It is not a name by itself. It is in its connection with us, because it tells you that when you look at the evar, you see that name, and when you look at that evar, you see that name again, whatever that means. It is too complicated.
Would you say it is parallel to the tefillah, prayer, that we spoke about before? We are doing all this to understand how tefillah works, so obviously it is taking us somewhere. After all these proofs, after all these esoteric, complicated things that he quotes from the Zohar, which we understand only 10% of, what we do see—one thing relevant to us, which is what is really important for us, while the rest we do not understand—is that the only way to relate to a name is through Hashem’s connection to us or to something. That is the ikar, main point.
So when you say, “Baruch Atah Hashem,” Blessed are You, Hashem, you are not even talking to Hashem. He is going to explain why you say Atah, but we are not really talking to that. Or you are, but in His function, in His active function, in something. Because to Hashem you can't even say too highly. It is all about the connection, or the spreading of His presence, His awe into it.
That is the temunah He said: only the temunah of HaKadosh Baruch Hu's temunah in His relationship with us. That means part of the Tzimtzum was from scratch, to have a relationship with somebody. Otherwise, there is no need for that. His presence, His relationship, His connection with something, is what gave birth to the idea of making a world. Otherwise, there is no purpose. And therefore, that is what he says regarding—
In the tefillah, that is the whole perek about what we started saying. When we say, “Baruch Atah Hashem,” it is not about Him. It is about some connection. Baruch Adonai le'olam (Blessed is Adonai forever). Foreign.