A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

The mitzva of Zimun is Derabanan

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
August 2, 2023
Duration
3:24
Lecture code
RGK-941

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

There is a new siman (section) that we're going to start: siman Kuf Tzadi Bet (192), the halachot (laws) of Zimun (invitation to bless). Everyone knows that in the Zimun there are two different categories. Usually, it's three people or ten people: one with the Shem (name) Elokeinu, one without. The Gemara, Masechet (tractate) Berachot, daf (page) Mem Chet (48). Bring source.

Gadlu la'Adonai iti, v'neromemah Shemo yachdav. Gadlu la'Adonai iti means, “Bring gadlut, greatness, to Hashem with me.” Gadlu is plural. It's somebody, one person, iti. He's talking to at least two. And he's saying, bring greatness to Hashem with me. V'neromemah Shemo yachdav: “And let us exalt his name together.” V'chen amar (and so he said), Moshe Rabbeinu said to Gemara. Moshe Rabbeinu also said, Ki Shem Adonai ekra, Havu godel le'Elokeinu. Call the name of Hashem. Let's bring greatness to Elokeinu. It seems that these are Pesukim (verses) from the Torah.

Indeed, the Ra'avad is of the opinion that the Zimun is from the Torah. Is it a Din Min HaTorah or is it deRabbanan? Is it biblical or rabbinic in nature? The Ra'avad says these are Pesukim in the Torah, so this should be a Mitzvah (commandment) from the Torah. However, the majority of Rishonim (early authorities) disagree with the Ra'avad. The Rambam. These Teshuvot Pe'er Hador. The Rashba, the Ra'ah, the Me'iri, and the Shita Mekubetzet. All the great Rishonim disagree with the Ra'avad. They said, “No, this is called Asmachta.” Asmachta means it's not Meforash (explicit) in the Pasuk (verse). It's the support that comes from the Torah. It's hinted in the Torah.

It doesn't say in the Torah, Vayedaber Hashem el Moshe lemor. Daber el B'nei Yisrael v'amarta. Hem ta'asu Zimun (The Lord spoke to Moses, saying; speak to the children of Israel and say, they shall make a Zimun). It doesn't say that. That would be Min HaTorah (from the Torah), or a Derasha (interpretive exposition), one of the Derashot, ShehaTorah nidreshet bahem (that the Torah is expounded through them). That's not the Derech (method) here. There's a Remez (hint). It's mentioned.

But it is mi'deRabbanan, not mi'deOraita (from the Torah). They bring an argument for that. They say that if that were the case, it says in the Pasuk, Nevarech le'Elokeinu she'achalnu mishelo (Let us bless our God, from whose bounty we ate). It says, K'shem Hashem ekra, Havu godel le'Elokeinu. Now we know that there's a distinction between ten people doing the Zimun together and three people doing it together. The ten people bring the name Elokeinu in the equation. Nevarech le'Elokeinu she'achalnu mishelo. And then you answer, Baruch Elokeinu (Blessed is our God). Baruch Elokeinu she'achalnu mishelo (Blessed is our God, from whose bounty we ate). That's only if you have ten people. If you have three people, you just say, Nevarech she'achalnu mishelo (Let us bless from whose bounty we ate), without saying the Shem of Hashem.

Now, if this Pasuk is in the Torah, what distinction? It doesn't say anywhere that you have to have ten people. And if it were the case that you have ten people, then why do you even do it when you have only three people, just without saying the Shem? It makes no sense. When there's a Mitzvah in the Torah, it's not quantified by how many people you have. It's either a yes-or-no question. You don't have different steps and different levels. Therefore, that's a very strong argument for those who are in favor of saying that it is deRabbanan.

There's a middle shita (position): the Kiryat Sefer and some other Poskim (halachic authorities) hold that if you have ten people, it's in the Torah. If you have three people or fewer than ten, it would be mi'deRabbanan. But Chacham Ovadia goes through all the complexity of this subject and concludes that the Mitzvah of the Zimun is a Mitzvah mi'deRabbanan.