A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

The Power Of Restriction Of The Hachamim

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
June 29, 2025
Duration
4:11
Lecture code
RGK-BC-13

The Chachamim’s Power to Frame a Mitzvah

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas continues the discussion of the Chachamim’s power to frame a mitzvah min HaTorah. This does not mean that the mitzvah ceases to be min HaTorah; rather, the Chachamim may define the cases in which it is fulfilled.
  • Tosafot in Masechet Sukkah, whose Shitah is accepted by most Rishonim, discusses someone sitting inside a Sukkah while his table is inside the house. The Gezerah is meant to prevent him from being drawn outside and eating there.
  • From the standpoint of the Torah’s requirements alone, the person is inside the Sukkah, and the Torah does not say that his table must also be inside. Nevertheless, Tosafot says that because of the Chachamim’s Gezerah, he is not Yotzei even the mitzvah min HaTorah.
  • This illustrates that the Chachamim can narrow the cases in which a mitzvah is fulfilled: according to this Shitah, if they say there is no mitzvah min HaTorah in a given case, there is no mitzvah min HaTorah in that case.

The Shofar Example

  • The same question arises if someone blows the shofar on Yom Tov Rishon—for example, on the first day of Rosh Hashanah when it falls on Shabbat: was he Yotzei the mitzvah min HaTorah?
  • The Nafka mina is whether he says Shehecheyanu on the second day. If he was Yotzei on the first day, he cannot say it again; if he was not Yotzei, as in Tosafot’s Shitah, he was not fulfilling the mitzvah but was merely playing an instrument.
  • The restriction exists because of the concern that someone might carry the shofar to learn from his teacher. Rabbi Gabriel Koskas cites this as another illustration of the Chachamim’s power.

Chacham Ovadia’s Qualification

  • In Teshuvot, in Yabia Omer, Chacham Ovadia agrees with the initial distinction but says that the Sukkah case is not exactly the same as the earlier cases.
  • In Sukkah, the Chachamim’s Gezerah addresses a chashash: a person might be drawn outside and eat there. Chacham Ovadia says this example may support the Chachamim’s power where such a concern exists, but it is not necessarily proof for a mitzvah without that chashash, such as the kiddush or Nesi'at Kapayim discussed earlier.
  • He therefore considers this not a complete Re'ayah, while the discussion still follows the first Shitah.

Nesi'at Kapayim

  • Rabbi Gabriel Koskas concludes that the overwhelming majority of Poskim, based on the Yerushalmi, the Sifri, and other sources, hold that Nesi'at Kapayim is min HaTorah.
  • This applies even today, outside Israel, and outside the Temple: Birkat Kohanim remains a mitzvah min HaTorah.