We continue with what we said yesterday regarding the koach (power) of the Chachamim (sages) to frame a mitzvah (commandment) min HaTorah (from the Torah). It does not mean that because they framed a mitzvah, that mitzvah is no longer min HaTorah. That was the proof several Poskim (halachic authorities) brought regarding Nesi'at Kapayim (priestly hand-raising). For example, we do indeed find this in Tosafot in Masechet Sukkah, and most Rishonim (early authorities) agree with the Shitah (position) of Tosafot, which is the following. Masechet Sukkah tells us in the famous Mishnah about somebody who eats inside the Sukkah (booth). If he eats inside the Sukkah while the table is inside the house, the Gemara tells us—the Mishnah tells us—we are worried that the person is going to eat outside the Sukkah. So there is a Gezerah (decree) of the Chachamim not to eat in such a way. But what happens if the person ate in this fashion? He is sitting inside the Sukkah, and the table is inside the house. Is he Yotzei (fulfills the obligation) the mitzvah of Sukkah or not? Mitzad (from the standpoint of) the mitzvah of Sukkah itself, in the min HaTorah world, if you want, he is for sure Yotzei; he is inside the Sukkah. The Torah does not say anywhere that he is supposed to have the table inside the Sukkah as well. Here he is sitting by the edge of the Sukkah, and the table is outside. Is he Yotzei or not?
Tosafot tells us that since the Chachamim made a Gezerah that a person should not eat in this way, he is supposed to have the table inside the Sukkah as well. Even with respect to his mitzvah min HaTorah, he is not Yotzei. This means that the Chachamim were able again to frame the mitzvah of Sukkah and say that it is going to work only if you are not eating in this way. But if you are by the edge, although you are completely inside the Sukkah, since shulchano betoch habayit (the table is inside the house) and we are afraid that you are going to go out, the Chachamim said, “Don’t do it.” Don’t do it to the extent that if you do do it, you are not Yotzei the mitzvah min HaTorah. It does not mean that the mitzvah of Sukkah is there; rather, it means that there is a Gezerah of the Chachamim. There are situations where they decide that you are not going to be Yotzei, even min HaTorah, because they limited, narrowed down, and slimmed the mitzvah to certain cases, instead of leaving it broadly open to the first original Torah thought. This is the Shitah of most Rishonim: when the Chachamim tell you that there is no mitzvah min HaTorah in this case, there is no mitzvah min HaTorah.
For example, if somebody blows the shofar (ram's horn) on Yom Tov Rishon (first festival day)—for example, on the first day of Rosh Hashanah that falls on Shabbat—and somebody blows the shofar, was he Yotzei the mitzvah min HaTorah? That would be the same discussion. The Nafka mina (practical difference) is: does he say Shehecheyanu on the second day or not, if he said Shehecheyanu on the first day? If you hold that he was Yotzei, then he cannot say Shehecheyanu on the second day. But if he is not Yotzei, like the Shitah of Tosafot, then he was never Yotzei; he was playing with an instrument. The next day, he’s going to be... Ah, but this whole thing was because we are afraid he may carry it to learn from his teacher, et cetera. So therefore we see from here that there is this koach in the Chachamim.
Chacham Ovadia, although he agrees with the first Chiluk (distinction), as I checked yesterday, says in Teshuvot (responsa), in Yabia Omer, “But from here, it’s not exactly the same as before.” Here the Chachamim were afraid; there is a Gezerah. If you eat in such a fashion, you may be pulled outside the Sukkah and eat outside the Sukkah. When there was a chashash (concern) of a Gezerah—that you may not be fulfilling the mitzvah—that is how the authority will conclude. That is when I would say that there is a koach in the Chachamim. But perhaps not for a mitzvah without the chashash, like the kiddush (sanctification) that we said, or like the Nesi'at Kapayim, where you would say that it is limited to this. So he is saying that this is not a full Re'ayah (proof), but it still holds like the first Shitah.
Just to conclude this discussion, the grand, grand, grand majority of Poskim hold, based on the Yerushalmi, the Sifri, and several other sources, that Nesi'at Kapayim holds. Nesi'at Kapayim is min HaTorah, even in this time, even outside of Israel, even outside of the Temple, even outside of everything: the mitzvah of Birkat Kohanim (Priestly Blessing) is the mitzvah min HaTorah.