A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

The solution to the candles problem

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
February 12, 2026
Duration
6:23
Lecture code
RGK-1765

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Continuing yesterday's halacha (Jewish law), we asked a simple question: Why do we say a Beracha (blessing) on candle lighting when what really benefits the house, what lets you see and have hana'ah (benefit) on Shabbat, is the electric light, not the candles the woman lights? It's a big question; it's really a big question. We should say a Beracha on candle lighting because that's not what brings the shalom (peace); what brings the Shabbat, the hana'ah of Shabbat, is the electric light.

Let's dig a little deeper. What could be the solution? I would suggest and say: the same way they lit Nerot (candles) 2000 years ago and 200 years ago. They also lit Nerot on Tuesdays, by the way, and on Wednesdays and Thursdays, because that's how they saw; so on Shabbat they lit Nerot. So why don't we do the same today, so we can see with electricity? Let's say the Beracha, lehadlik ner shel Shabbat (To kindle the Shabbat lamp), on the switch: your lady should come to the switch; it's off; lehadlik ner shel Shabbat, boom, and turn on the light. Don't think I'm kidding; that should be how we do it, because that's the equivalent of what they did for 2000 years. But for the past 150 years, we have electricity, and we still light the Nerot of Shabbat. That should be totally wrong, so we should turn on the light and say a Beracha on the light. What's wrong with that? What would be the difference with a Tuesday? On Tuesday, you turn it on whenever you want, and on Erev Shabbat (Shabbat eve), you have to turn it on before Shabbat. That's it. That would be the mitzvah (commandment), just like they did, by the way. That's how they did it because they didn't have electricity, so they lit Nerot Shabbat (Shabbat candles) like they did with Nerot on Tuesdays.

But we're not going to do that. We're not going to do that, and nobody would agree with me, so we go back to the question: What do we do now? Theoretically, that should be the solution to all the problems; that's the equivalent. Continuing to light the Nerot the way we do is very questionable. All the poskim (halachic decisors) ask this question; don't think it's my chidush (novel insight)—every single one of them asks it because it's a problem. Some poskim say there are many answers. I'm not going to go through all the answers. One answer is that it became a minhag (custom) to light the Nerot. You make sounds. It became the minhag to turn on the candles. That's a weak answer, because we don't say Berachot (blessings) on minhagim, so you say Berachot on minhagim, and you have a very simple solution: say the Berachot on the switch. So you say, "Oh, I'm stuck in my minhag." So say the Berachot on the switch and light the Nerot without the Beracha. What's the problem? You want to do minhag? Light the Nerot; you don't have to say Berachot on it. I'm sorry, I disagree with that. Bottom line, it's a big problem. That's really the bottom line.

Some poskim said you have to make sure the lights are off when the woman lights the Shabbat candles. Many other poskim said the lights have to be off when she lights the Shabbat candles, and afterward she can turn on the lights. She should have Kavanah (intention) not to enter Shabbat when she lights the candle. She doesn't need to—we'll discuss that next week—but the bottom line is that she can do that: have Kavanah that she doesn't enter Shabbat right away, and then she turns on the light of the house.

I think that's also not good, because bottom line, that's called cheating. If you're going to go back to the same problem, you know very well that the lights of Shabbat are not going to be the lights that bring light to the seudah (meal). You know that already, before you even do the halacha. Just say, "I'm going to trick the system. I'm going to light when it's off, and in two seconds I'm going to turn on the lights of the house, and that's it." Now, that's not good. You know there's a halacha: if you light when it's still day, you have to make sure that it's going to be on at night. Why? So that you have hana'ah from the light. Here you're doing the opposite: you're going to light when it's still day, and then by the time it's night, "Oh, the electricity is on." So what did you gain by that? Nothing. Even that solution is a problem.

I have one, by the way. If you keep doing it the way you do, many poskim came out okay with that. I'm just digging a little deeper, and I don't like any of the answers. Bottom line, bottom line, bottom line: the only solution that I personally think is great is the following. If you only do the electricity, they say there's no heker, it doesn't look like it's Shabbat at all. Again, we could discuss that, but you're going to light the Nerot Shabbat. The best way to do this is to make sure there's no light on at the time of the Hadlakat Nerot (candle lighting), and the woman should have Kavanah, when she says the Beracha, to include the electric lights in the Beracha. That means like this: she's going to say the Beracha on the Nerot; the lights have to be off, no light. And she's thinking, "I'm going to light the Nerot and the electricity." “Baruch Atah Hashem, Eloheinu Melech ha'olam, lehadlik ner shel Shabbat” (Blessed are You, Hashem, our God, King of the universe, to kindle the Shabbat lamp), then she turns on the Nerot and goes straight to the switch and turns it on. Now her Kavanah, her Beracha, is going on everything. That's fine. It's like saying, "I'm going to light 1,000 Nerot." Perfect. She says the Beracha, and she lights 1,000 Nerot. No problem. All the Nerot are going to be part of the mitzvah. So here she lights the Nerot, whatever she does, two, seven, whatever number you do. She goes straight to the switch and turns it on. But her Kavanah was to include the electricity in the Beracha. With that, we're perfect, because now everything is the Nerot Shabbat. So for me, that's the best solution. Bechavod (respectfully).