A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Torah Lecture

When is it allowed to leave in the middle of a meal?

Lectured by Rabbi Gabriel Koskas

Published
February 5, 2023
Duration
4:26
Lecture code
RGK-776

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

This is the same subject that we mentioned yesterday. There was a group of people sitting down to drink. Those who learned Pesachim will remember. And then there's a group, a chatan (groom) or a kallah (bride) passing by. They used to walk from the house of the kallah to the house of the chatan. That would make the chatunah (wedding). So there is a mitzvah (commandment) to accompany the kallah, and they have to interrupt their meal to go. If they left someone at the table, they did not have to say a beracha (blessing) when they came back. They did not have to say Birkat Hamazon when they left, or Hamotzi (blessing over bread) when they came back. But if they did not leave anyone at the table, now they came back to the table and wanted to continue the meal, basically. They all left. They all left. Can they continue? No, says the Gemara. Then they would have to say Birkat Hamazon for what they left, and they would have to say the beracha of Hamotzi again if they wanted to continue the meal. That's what it says.

The Beit Yosef quotes the Kol Bo, who says that from here the medayek (one who infers) asks: Why did they bring the case of a chatan and kallah? Just tell me: There was a group of people, and it was the 4th of July. They observed the 4th of July, with this beautiful firework outside, and they all went to see the firework. And don't worry, there was a zaken (elder) and a choleh (sick person). Mutar (permitted)? No. The medayek says, “You could have just said, ‘They left.’ Who cares what the reason was?” No, every word in the Gemara counts. If they said, “It's because it's a mitzvah”—but not just any mitzvah. A mitzvah overet means if you don't go now, the kallah is not waiting. “Excuse me, kallah, do you want to wait for a couple of minutes? We're going to say Birkat Hamazon.” It's called mitzvah overet. It's going to go.

Or, a more practical case for us: Let's say somebody is eating breakfast next door, and they need a tenth for another minyan (prayer quorum), or whatever the case may be. That's called mitzvah overet. They need one now. You can't have tircha detzibura (burden on the community), or the person didn't pray yet. I don't know, Ma, you make up a case. That's mitzvah overet. It's a very specific kind of mitzvah. That's when it's allowed. But if it's just like that, for a dvar shel reshut (optional matter), asur latzet (forbidden to leave), you're not allowed to leave your seudah (meal).

Indeed, the Beit Yosef discusses this back and forth, but the Rama, at the end of the day, is the Posek halacha (halachic decisor). Clearly, I quote in siman kuf ayin chet (section 178), at the end of seif bet (subsection 2), l'chatchila (ideally) lo ya'akor mikomo b'lo beracha. If you want to leave the table, say Birkat Hamazon. That's it. You say Birkat Hamazon. Then you do whatever you want. L'chatchila, people say, “Oh, I'm going to go and come back,” even if there are people at the table. We make that mistake. Even if there are people at the table, asur. That's only for mitzvah overet that they will matir (permit). Chayshinan shema yishkach milachzor v'le'echol. It's very common. A person had the good intention of coming back, and once you leave, we don't know what happens, right? It could be taking longer than you thought. You come back, you totally forget, et cetera. Mihu l'tzorech mitzvah, if it's for the purpose of mitzvah overet—sorry, mitzvah overet—davka (specifically). So not even a regular mitzvah. It has to be mitzvah overet. A mitzvah that is going to expire if you don't do it right now. Kegon shehigi'a zman tefilah (prayer). It's the time to do the tefilah. Mutar. So the only case you could rely on this leniency is for mitzvah overet. For other things, even a regular mitzvah, you would have to first do Birkat Hamazon, and then you take care of the mitzvah or dvar shel reshut (optional matter) l'chavod (for one's own sake).