linen.
Rabbi Arking has been checking for Shatnez (wool and linen) and raising awareness in the community about Shatnez for many, many years. We want to ask him a few questions and have him show us a little bit, from a practical point of view, how things are done, what has to be checked, how to check, and so on.
I asked, “The first thing I want to ask you is this. I know the Torah says you can’t wear wool and linen; in the words of the Torah, it’s Tzemer u'Pishtim (wool and linen). What exactly is wool? There’s lamb’s wool, merino wool, and cashmere, which is similar and comes from a goat, I think—the hair of a goat instead of the hair of a lamb. What’s included, and what’s not included? Tell us what fibers are included. And the same thing for linen: what about hemp and cotton? They’re all plant-based fibers. Which ones are problematic, and which ones are not?”
He explained, “The Torah tells us not to wear wool and linen. There are many different types of fibers, and even in wool itself there are different types of wool. Cashmere is a type of wool, but it is not going to be forbidden under the Issur (prohibition) of Shatnez. Sheep’s wool is the only wool that is going to be Asur (forbidden) for the Issur of Shatnez. There’s something called mohair, which could come from goats; cashmere comes from Angora goats; and you have llama, rabbit, and different types of wools, but they will not be Asur. When studying it under a microscope and then trying to figure it out, all these different details need to be analyzed carefully, along with the different properties they have. For example, the thickness, the medulla, and the scales each has need to be looked at to determine whether it is actually sheep’s wool or a different type of wool.”
I asked, “And regarding linen, what about other plant fibers like cotton or hemp, or anything else of the sort?”
He replied, “We have to differentiate between linen, ramie, and these different types of fibers. They can actually look pretty similar under the microscope. They can feel a little similar, but they are distinctively different, and that would make a difference as to whether it would be Asur for Shatnez or Mutar (permitted). Any other fiber besides linen—Tzemer or Pishtim, flax, linen—is going to be Asur; anything else will not be Asur.”
I asked, “Now, when I get a hold of a suit, the suit generally says either ‘100% wool’—that’s the most popular fiber used for suits today, I think—or something along those lines. Now, I’m very well aware that not everything in the suit is 100% wool. There are a lot of other layers, linings, and things of the sort that can be made of other fibers. So first of all, can you show us what a suit is made out of, what the different parts of a suit are, and then explain each part of the suit, what it could potentially be made out of, and where we’re likely to have issues?”
He said, “Over here we have a suit jacket. If we look at the label, it tells us the fiber content. Over here, the fabric is 100% wool. The lining is 100% cupro, and the sleeve lining is a combination, a mix of viscose and polyester.”
I started to ask, “So the lining is—”
He continued, “Viscose, polyester—obviously, the man-made rayon. They’re all synthetics.”
I asked, “And all that synthetic material is easy to—”
He replied, “Those are not a problem.”
I said, “That’s not a problem at all. So that would mean that this fabric over here, the body of the suit, is wool, right?”
He replied, “You can look at the weave and see if there’s any unevenness, which could be a symbol for...”
I said, “Okay. But some types of flat fabrics—actually, in general, flat, straight-up fabrics will not have this issue. But when you have plaid and different types of styles on the fabric itself, then, aside from looking at all the secret places, it’s most important to look at the most obvious, which is the fabric itself.”
I continued, “Okay, fine. So the first thing we’ll do: somebody brought a Hugo Boss suit. He said, ‘Rabbi, could you please remove the Shatnez? I know, of course, it’s a suit that has Shatnez.’ I came and looked at it, and before I even looked at the collar, the entire fabric was Shatnez. The entire fabric was intertwined with linen and wool.”
I asked, “Was it labeled as such and he didn’t read the label? Or was it labeled as wool and the label wasn’t accurate?”
He replied, “In this case, he actually did not read the label correctly. There was another person who came with a suit already hemmed the night before Pesach (Passover), and he said, ‘Rabbi, could you check this for Shatnez? I got it from a famous company that requires checking.’ I looked at the inner lapel, inside the suit description: ‘Wool, linen, silk,’ in large, huge words on the inside of the tag, without even reading the label.”
I said, “So first of all, read the label. There are people who come in to you again and haven’t read the label; that would have saved them time, possibly money, and a lot of other things afterward. And after you hem the pants, you’re right. So number one is to read the label. But number two, as we said, even after I read the label, this is 100% wool. That is this fabric over here. Now, this fabric over here is the lining that they were telling me was cupro. Besides this, there are still many fabrics inside the suit, many layers and many parts of the suit that are not on the label, and those potentially could be problematic. True?”
He replied, “Right.”
I asked, “Okay. So now can you show me all the different parts of a suit, what’s in here? After you show us all the different parts, you’ll tell us what each thing potentially could be made out of that would be an issue.”
He said, “We’ll start with the collar, which is the most infamous place to check for Shatnez.”
I said, “Just one second. Before you do that, Rabbi, this right here, this felt that I feel—what fabric is this? Is this also part of the wool, or is this a different fabric?”
He explained, “This is a separate fabric, which is sewn on to give it that shape and that feel, so that it wraps around.”
I said, “This fabric itself is usually felted. It could be made from different types of fibers, or even wool. That’s why, when a person has a linen suit, you still have to look for wool felt, if this is wool.”
He replied, “Right.”
I said, “So this wool felt attached to the linen suit would create a problem.”
He replied, “Right.”
He began, “So actually, the famous—”
I asked, “Okay. So now what’s behind there?”
He explained, “The famous wool suit that they’re always worried about having Shatnez refers to the ones that have felt collars. However, the ones that just have fabric in the back should be checked, but they usually turn out better.”
I asked, “And is the felt itself the problem with those suits, or is it the fiber under the felt?”
He replied, “The felt itself could be just felt, which is sewn on, and under it there could be a different material. That different material could be linen, or it could be some other horsehair or something used as a stiffener to enable it to take the shape of the person. Or the collar itself can have what we call a sandwich collar, which inside can have a piece of linen. That will be the piece we are searching for.”
I said, “I got it. Now, if we just took off this whole piece, would we find more fabric inside?”
He explained, “Sometimes you’ll have suits that just have a felt collar. They usually do have a stiffener to give it that stiffness. Actually, in some ladies’ jackets, they’ll have it without any of that stiffener, so it can sit properly. Let’s open this up and see what’s inside.”
I said, “Okay, so again, in the collar, we have the fabric of the suit. We have the felt in the back, which could be problematic. If the felt is scratched, then sometimes... there could be a fabric behind there. And then under this whole thing, there’s another fabric, as you can see, this white fabric over here, which is obviously not the felt and not the body of the suit.”
He replied, “Correct.”
I said, “Okay. Now we’re going to go to the inside of the suit. This seems to be the pocket, right? Is that true?”
He replied, “Pocket, correct. There’s the pocket. They also want to secure the pocket and make sure it stays on well. As you know, linen is a bast fiber and a very strong fiber, so in places where there might be much pressure, using a linen thread or a linen piece of fabric will give it strength.”
I asked, “So if we look at this over here, we have—”
He explained, “We’ll look at the seams of this pocket, on the inner seams, to see if there’s any such type of telltale sign.”
I said, “Okay. So, just to see all the fabrics involved over here, we have the pocket itself, which is this. Other than that, this over here is clearly something else. You’ll explain to us what that is momentarily. And this is also something else.”
He replied, “Correct. Those are the fabrics that we see over here in the pocket.”
I asked, “As we move up the suit, what do we have here?”
He explained, “This is a seam. Another seam comes to an end right before the pocket, so again, that’s a little pressure point. I just want to say that there’s no linen piece used to strengthen anything at that point. I see that there is some type of fabric, but not a linen fabric. This fabric helps keep that secure. So you have this also over here, this little piece.”
I said, “Okay. So at a pressure point, you have a different fabric. That fabric is not necessarily linen, but it potentially could be linen.”
He replied, “Correct.”
I continued, “Then you have the area under the pocket again, which is a little... It depends what you put in your pocket, where the handkerchiefs are. I’d want to see that it looks pretty safe. Then I would move up toward the shoulder pads. Around the shoulder pads, there’s always a canvas. This canvas is designed to keep it properly in place and hold it stiff enough. This canvas could possibly be linen. That is another point that we look at. Secondly, there are a few layers of canvas, as you can see—one, two, three—that we would have to look at. So if I make my way from the bottom to the top, and I know I’ve made it all the way back to the top collar, I know I’ve gone through all the different layers of what potentially could be sewn in as linen.”
I added, “It’s just a matter of being conscientious about the buttons and how they are sewn on, to see that they look like the regular types of threads. The shine or sheen of linen is obviously a little different from the others, but it’s not necessarily such a common thing for them to sew the buttons, but...”
I asked, “Now, generally they’re sewn with synthetics, right?”
He replied, “Correct.”
I said, “I got it. Okay.”

