A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi & Hazan Haim Arking

Torah Lecture

OHR Of The Shore - Shaatnez - Part 2

Lectured by Rabbi & Hazan Haim Arking

Published
December 6, 2024
Duration
9:12
Lecture code
OHRShore-SN-03

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

“In a pair of pants, other than the wool that the pants are made out of, there’s this lining, which seems to be some sort of kind.” “Correct. Okay, what other fabrics are there in this?” “This lining is obviously synthetic. Other than this, what else do we have over here that could potentially cause a problem that we would not find on the label?”

So again, understanding the property of linen—that it’s used to strengthen something—I would look for pressure points where it might be used. One is under the belt loop, which can be pulled at times. So this is obviously a different fabric. This is also fabric that goes around the entire waist, and it should be looked at. As that comes to an end at the tip over here, just by checking in this area, you’ll be able to catch that fabric going around and look to see if there are any other pieces being used as strengtheners for that area.

Another place I would look is in the belt loops, which sometimes have a filling. You see over here that I pull it apart, and there’s a piece of fabric. So it’s not just the outer fabric, which is the 100% wool we mentioned, going around. To keep it in its proper place, there’s actually a piece of fabric inside it, which should be looked at and can be picked apart to see if there’s any potential linen issue.

“Okay, so here we have this jacket from Vineyard Vines. The label is over here. And it says—now, first of all, is that accurate? Here it’s not a smooth fabric. Would the fabric itself have to be looked at?” “Right.” “So once I have like a plaid or a complicated fabric, it can be suspect because there are different colors, there are different textures, and maybe use some quiet place where to pick up something that might be.” “Okay. Meaning, we know there’s wool; we’re just here to make sure there’s no linen in this.” “Correct. So other than that, on a jacket like this, are there any linings or things that can be problematic?”

Overcoats in general have fewer components that are suspect for Shatnez (wool-linen mixture). They don’t have the stiffeners, not necessarily these collars. The fancy dress coats, which are, so to speak, souped-up suits—warm and designed like a suit—should be checked because they could have the same way a regular suit does. But overcoats, and bulky overcoats with soft collars all around, where there’s nothing really in between, have not commonly had Shatnez at all.

“Here we have a raincoat from Norwegian Wool. The five on the label over here: 53% polyester, 43% wool, 4% elastane. Now, in a fabric like this, which includes, once again, 43% wool, would you suspect it of having linings? Does this have to be tested, or is this good to go?”

“Right. Regardless, if there were even one thread of linen in this entire jacket, the entire jacket would be asur (forbidden) if it was mixed with wool. If there’s going to be a mixture where the threads themselves are comprised of these components, then it’s not going to be asur. So if I test one piece and see that it’s a mixture of some wool and some cotton and some of the other things, and that’s what the entire thing is made out of, then I wouldn’t even be concerned with the rest.”

“Right. And you see, it’s pretty obvious just looking at it. Just looking at the texture of the fabric, we see no reason to suspect any linen. Now, on this jacket, are there any linings or anything?” “So this is obviously all synthetic. And once again, there’s a soft collar and no shoulder pads. There’ll be nothing else to look at.” “Right. This is suede, I’m assuming?” “Looks like it.” “Okay, so this jacket also would not be any problem.” “That’s right.”

“Okay, so here we have a few ties. These are actually all from Brooks Brothers. Let’s first read the label, and then we’ll discuss what other fibers are there that are not listed on the label, where they are, and what they might be. This one over here, for example, says 100% linen. So I understand that this fabric right over here that we’re looking at is 100% linen, right?” “Right.”

“Okay. Now we turn the tie over and see a lining over here. This is definitely synthetic and not linen.” “Right.” “So the lining is not listed in the fiber content, once again, but in this case it’s not a problem. Now, other than that, in a tie we generally have another fabric, and that is the interlining inside over here. So tell us what this is and what it potentially can be made out of.”

“Once again, as we said, this is linen. So if we had wool over here, we would have an issue. This inside piece is something that potentially can have wool. There are ties that do have it exclusively in wool. Some of them have it as mixtures of wool.” “Okay.” “And that could… That must be looked at, especially in a linen tie. So if a person is buying a linen tie, the inside must be checked to see that there’s no wool content.”

“Okay, here we have a tie, also from Brooks Brothers. This one is 60% wool and 40% silk. So first of all, the fabric itself is not flat; it’s textured. Would there be anything of concern to look at over here? And second of all, on the layers inside, once again, this is obviously the same synthetic. But on the interlining, which is right over here, would there be any chance of there being any linen in here?”

“Right. It would not be common for interlining to be made out of linen, though you could look at it briefly. Then this fabric itself is something that we take a little closer look at to see if there’s something that may be telltale of linen. But wool ties are generally—right, they’re not problematic.”

“Okay, so here we have a few simpler garments without linings and layers necessarily. Maybe a little bit of them. Now I want you to show us what the fabric of the whole item is, and what other fibers might be there in any lining or anything of the sort. Here we have a cap, and it’s labeled as 100% linen. Is there anything to this other than linen?”

“So you look at it from the outside: ‘Wow, 100% linen, beautiful.’ Open it up. Let’s take a little closer look. Well, there’s something pulling it together. Maybe there’s something that’s going to make it a little soft around the forehead to make it comfortable. And look around to see if there’s anything else suspect for wool.” “Okay. And now the stiffener in here itself, that would be made out of?” “Synthetic.”

“Okay. Now when it comes to socks, we have socks. This, for example, is 65% wool, 33% nylon, 2% spandex. Would there be anything to check over here?” “Socks are really not common to have any linen. They’re not so comfortable.” “So it’s kind of like this?” “And number two, that it’s pretty much like this. It’s like a straightforward fabric. There are no linings over here.” “That’s good. They’re going to catch us. There are no, you know, decorations or different things that could be added on. And therefore would be even though they are Hugo Boss socks.” “Okay.”

“Now there’s a kind and wool blend. Still a straightforward fabric. Something like this scarf, which is labeled as 100% wool: once again, there are no seams or linings or anything of the sort. This just seems to be some filling. So once again, there’s nothing suspect about this. Straightforward. One fabric. One fabric. All wool.”

“Now over here, we’ve got a skirt. This is labeled as 96% wool, 4% elastane. Now over here, are there any other parts? This is simple fabric, right? Straight fabric. And are there any other internal parts?” “There’s no lining that we see over here. There is a piece that’s being used to strengthen it. It does not have any telltale signs. It’s made of linen. So it’s used to strengthen it. So this also would not be an issue.” “Correct.”

“Now in regards to women’s clothing. First of all, women are obligated in Shatnez also, right?” “Of course.” “Okay, so there’s no difference between men and women in that regard. Practically speaking, women’s clothing: are there problems, are there no problems? What’s the story with that?”

“Women’s clothing is not necessarily constructed the same as men’s clothing. The different stiffeners or parts that they put in are not always there in women’s clothing. In a lady’s jacket, which is constructed to go around the shoulders and everything, there are shoulder pads, there is canvas, there’s perhaps something in the collar, right? But that’s worth checking when it is a suit similar to a men’s suit.”