A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joey Haber

Torah Lecture

Divre Hizuk in Times of Despair- Part 1

Lectured by Rabbi Joey Haber

Published
April 6, 2020
Duration
22:53
Lecture code
JH695

The Crisis and the Questions It Raises

  • Rabbi Joey Haber describes how, in only two weeks, life has become almost unimaginable: businesses, learning, schools, and everyday routines have been upended, and the danger is real.
  • He frames the questions people are asking as: What should we think, what should we do, and what should we fix?

What True Bitachon Means

  • Rabbi Joey Haber says many people have misunderstood bitachon. The Chafetz Chaim, commenting on the Gemara in Masechet Berachot, explains that the Yetzer Hara is like a fly sitting “al shnei pitchei halev”—on both sides of the heart.
  • The Chafetz Chaim explains that the Yetzer Hara can pull a person toward evil, but if it cannot persuade someone to do wrong, it may instead persuade that person to do too much good.
  • One example is excessive bitachon: thinking that belief in Hashem means there is nothing one needs to do. The Chafetz Chaim says this is faulty faith.
  • Rabbi Joey Haber stresses that people must believe in God, not act as though they are God: no one can declare the danger insignificant, decide it is overhyped, or know how events will turn out.
  • The Chafetz Chaim illustrates this with the period before the destruction of the Beit HaMikdash: the Navi Yechezkel warned people to get bowls for kneading bread, but they did not listen because they assumed everything would be fine. The Chafetz Chaim says that this was not bitachon, but “playing God.”
  • Rabbi Joey Haber points to the hundreds of people affected in Crown Heights and Boro Park, and recalls seeing a shul with 20 or 30 older members, in their 70s and 80s, while the rabbi was 100. Assuming “we’re going to be fine,” he says, is not faith.
  • He says the danger may be greater for Jewish communities because they gather so often to pray, learn, and celebrate, allowing disease to spread quickly and dangerously.
  • True bitachon means trusting Hashem and following what one is being told to do: staying home, avoiding contact and handshakes, sanitizing, and leaving a place of business when necessary. If doctors advise going home, closing schools, praying and learning from home, or shutting a business temporarily, people should comply rather than tell God how events will unfold.

Responding at Home

  • Rabbi Joey Haber says he told his family that the world had changed medically and that his children could not leave the house, even to go around the corner, unless both parents approved.
  • He cites the Gemara’s instruction during a plague to bring one’s feet and legs inside the home, close the door, and stay there.
  • He says being home also brings emotional challenges: family members may see one another’s anxiety and face a succession of difficulties. Families therefore need structure, fun, and joy, and should make the best of being home.
  • He notes that the Gemara describes a plague in the streets and fear inside, and acknowledges that anxiety at home may feel greater than the apparent anxiety outside. That anxiety must be addressed without abandoning precautions.

Financial Preparedness, Creativity, and Prayer

  • Rabbi Joey Haber identifies finances as a third major change. He describes a travel agent forced to cancel trips for months, a Passover-trip organizer whose year of work is lost, a seller of Broadway and Hamilton tickets with no business, a retail store fearing empty streets or forced early closure, a party planner and makeup artist without events, and a wholesaler receiving order cancellations that could lead to layoffs. Some people have also lost millions of dollars in the stock market within weeks.
  • He says families should prepare financially, drawing on Yaakov Avinu’s response to Esav approaching with 400 men. Yaakov prepared for battle, sent gifts, and prayed.
  • Rabbi Joey Haber interprets “prepared for battle” as preparing for the possibility of loss: Yaakov divided his family in half so that he might salvage the other half if something went wrong. Families should similarly make plan B and, if necessary, plan C—for example, changing summer plans, canceling vacations, buying less clothing, or spending more frugally.
  • He understands Yaakov’s gifts as an act of creativity, and urges businesses to develop new ideas that could sustain or even launch their businesses for the next decade.
  • Examples include restaurants finding ways to bring the dining experience to customers’ homes; stores that did not previously deliver setting up delivery, websites, and deals; and travel agents arranging trips without taking a down payment.
  • The third response is prayer. Rabbi Joey Haber cites the Ramban’s view that prayer is generally rabbinic, except for prayer in a time of pain, prayer be’et tzarah, which the Ramban says is obligatory from the Torah.
  • He explains that prayer in a painful or challenging time is distinct because vulnerability makes people feel weak and unsure where to turn; he says that this can make their prayers especially powerful and lift them up.
  • In response to the medical, emotional, and financial upheaval, he urges people to prepare financially, find creative solutions, and pray with renewed seriousness: obtain the mentioned booklet, say Tehillim as a family every day, and pray well even if they do not normally do so.

What to Fix: Negativity and Social Media

  • Rabbi Joey Haber recalls the brothers of Yosef, when they faced trouble in Egypt and were told to bring their youngest brother, asking one another what Hashem wanted them to understand. They concluded that their difficulties were connected to having sold their brother.
  • He asks what people might need to fix now, noting that the previous financial crisis was in 2008–2009. WhatsApp was created in January 2009, Instagram in October 2010, and Snapchat in September 2011; he says social media has created an unprecedented force on the internet.
  • He warns that Lashon Hara and negativity can now be broadcast to hundreds of people almost instantly. He says people in the community have been shamed online for getting the virus or for holding gatherings where they may have contracted it.
  • Rabbi Joey Haber says he does not know all the circumstances, acknowledges that he himself has made mistakes, and notes that public guidance changed repeatedly: wash hands, elbow instead of greeting, social distancing, no large gatherings, and then no small gatherings. People took different amounts of time to absorb the changing information, and some made mistakes or did not trust the guidance immediately.
  • He says social media should not be used to destroy people’s lives, exclude or include people, or shame them; he describes the resulting harm to the community as devastating.
  • Instead, people can use social media to support others: for example, send a video of dancing at home to someone whose wedding they cannot attend, or show appreciation for pictures from the ceremony. He also suggests minimizing social-media use or, in some areas, getting rid of it.
  • He urges people to call those sitting shiva in empty homes, support people who are sick and recovering, and strengthen those whose lives have been turned upside down rather than shame them online. He defines the problem as not only talking behind someone’s back, but also spreading negativity and vile content.

What to Fix: Rebuilding the Home

  • Rabbi Joey Haber says that being made to stay home is an opportunity to truly live at home: many people are physically there but not emotionally or mentally present.
  • He says many homes in the Jewish community are struggling, with marriages and parent-child relationships not where they need to be, as work, business, learning, teaching, and helping others can take priority over family.
  • He presents this period as a chance to rebuild: spend time with children and with one’s wife individually, learn with sons and daughters, pray together, strengthen family members, and listen to them with the phone turned off.
  • As families clean for Pesach, he suggests examining whether there are things in the home that do not belong there, and calls for rebuilding, strengthening, and energizing the home.

Meeting the Challenge Together

  • Rabbi Joey Haber summarizes the responses as trusting Hashem without claiming to know how He should run the world, making needed changes at home and in business, and fixing negativity and family life.
  • He describes schools adapting quickly, rabbis creating hundreds and thousands of Zoom classes, teachers teaching from home while their children are present, mothers caring for four or five or more children, and fathers adjusting their businesses and home lives.
  • He says children are learning through video conferencing, Zoom, or teleconferencing, and are helping and respecting their parents. He urges the community to respond by praying, learning, growing, changing, improving, becoming more positive and energetic, and supporting one another.
  • He says the community can rise to the challenge not by ignoring Hashem, but by hearing and heeding His call.
  • Rabbi Joey Haber expresses optimism: America came after China, which he says is already getting back on its feet; members of the community who had the virus are already improving; and he hopes that most people affected will be young and recover quickly while elders remain quarantined.
  • He says that if people do what they need to do and trust Hashem, the situation will improve, and expresses hope that in a month or two the community will have shown how it responded, changed, and trusted Him.
Words in this lecture2
Gemaraגמרא
Terms Gemara, the Talmud's discussion of the Mishnah. English: Commentary on the Mishnah
Also written: Gemarah, G'mara, Guemara, gmara
Plural: gemarot, gemaras
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem