A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joey Haber

Torah Lecture

Does our community have a middle of the road?

Lectured by Rabbi Joey Haber

Published
November 7, 2013
Duration
40:58
Lecture code
JH417

This transcript was auto-generated and polished for readability. While we aim for accuracy, errors may occur. If you notice a mistake, please click to submit corrections.

Welcome, everybody. This morning’s class is dedicated by the Tawel family in memory of Esther Tawel. She passed away this week. What’s interesting is that she passed on the same yard side—or she’s buried on the same yard side—as Aharon Kotler, the rabbi who ended up founding Beth Medrash Govoha, and whose yeshiva went to Kobe, Japan. She and her husband basically took care of the whole yeshiva and made sure it survived through portions of World War II.

It’s an honor to have our class this morning in her memory. Does everyone remember last week’s class? Last week’s class was all nice and positive: how wonderful the community is, and ten reasons why we’re the greatest ever. I’m glad you enjoyed it while it lasted. Our class today is not so negative, but it’s titled “Where Has the Middle Gone?”

I’ve been asked this question many, many times in the past five to ten years: Our community, 30 and 40 and 50 years ago, was basically all the same. We were at about the same level of religion and observance, and we lived in the same areas; we were the same. It seems that what’s happened over the past few decades is that our community has slowly begun to have people who’ve become very observant and people who’ve become very not observant. And you have people who consider themselves just regular, middle-of-the-road, normal people who feel like their group is slowly but surely dwindling away, and they want to know what happened. What happened to the middle?

I’d just like to know if this is something people here have asked about, are curious about, or relate to. Yes? Yes. Yes.

So I’m going to tell you what that means. If our class is on that subject, then if you are very irreligious, this class is not for you because you couldn’t care less. If you’re very, very, very religious and observant and all that, then this class’s official topic is not for you. But hopefully all the thoughts we bring will be very relevant to all of us.

My first question is: Why do we even need a middle? Who cares? Why does it matter so much? A lot of people are becoming more religious; be happy with that, Rabbi. A lot of people are becoming more observant, so why are you still asking to have a middle? “Middle” means, “I’m sort of in the middle. I’m not perfect. There are certain things I don’t do so well.” So why do you even care about there being a middle?

I’d like to explain it as follows. The life of Avraham Avinu has basically come and gone. The life of Yitzchak has come and gone, and now the spotlight, from now to the end of the book of Bereshit, will focus on the life of Yaakov. Yaakov left his father’s house after he received the blessings last week. He goes to sleep in a place, and you all know that he then falls asleep and has a vision of a ladder, with a ladder going up and down, and he sees angels going up and down the ladder.

Here’s my little question about that little dream. The vision was of angels. Angels don’t really need a ladder. Angels don’t need to climb. Angels can fly. So why a ladder? Just show me angels flying up and angels flying down.

The answer is that the message of that dream wasn’t for angels. The message of that dream was for humans, and humans don’t fly. Humans climb one step at a time. What that means is that if we want to have a community in 20 or 30 years from now that is really growing and really religious, we need the middle to be very healthy. Because if there is no middle, there are no people to climb.

What’s happening—and the catastrophe, or the sadness, of this dwindling middle—is not really so much that people are becoming much more observant. That might be true of 20%, but a much larger section of people is becoming less and less observant. And that’s why there’s a major concern. We have some people who are climbing up, and we have way too many people who are crawling down.

So it matters to everybody in this room that the middle is strong. Because if the middle is strong, our community is strong. If our community is strong, we can grow, achieve, change, and improve. But if we’re going down, we’ll just continue, God forbid, that way. This community very much needs a middle, and so we need to understand where it’s going.

I just want to tell you the kinds of questions that people who consider themselves in the middle seem to ask over and over again. “Rabbi, I feel like we’re alone. We care about Shabbat in my house. We don’t use cell phones on Shabbat. My husband likes to pray three times a day. We care about observance. We’re pretty strict with kashrut (kosher dietary observance). Rabbi, is there anybody else like us anymore?”

I have the idea that people ask the question, “Rabbi, is it possible to still be a really good person this way? Or do I have to turn into some, I don’t know, white-shirt, black-suit kind of person”—which I’m wearing right now—“in order to be a good person?”

“Rabbi, how do I make sure that if I am pretty much in the middle, I don’t get caught up and dragged in by the bottom of what’s happening in the community? Or, Rabbi, let me say it a little better. I’m not so afraid for myself, but how do I make sure that the bottom element of our community isn’t pulling my children into it? Because, Rabbi, I’m not ready for Kollel (full-time Torah study). Rabbi, I’m not ready to be very, very perfect in every level of observance. I don’t feel that yet. Does that mean that I should just give up on my kids? Or do I have hope for them, even if we’re only in the middle?”

The biggest question they ask all the time is, “Rabbi, we’re really in the middle. Are there good people for my children to marry who are also in the middle?”

So I’m not going to answer every one of those dilemmas. I know you were hoping, “How do I get my children married?” That’s not today. But what we are going to discuss today is how to deal with it and make sure that, if I am in the middle, that’s healthy; that I’m in the right position to be, and that I’m not in spiritual danger while still being vibrant and very much a member of our community.

We’re going to do so by focusing on that moment of Yaakov Avinu and his vision of the ladder. Yaakov left his father’s house. He stops at a place, finds some stones, puts them underneath his head, closes his eyes, and sees that dream.

My first question is: If you were going to go to sleep in the woods or on a random field, what would you put underneath your head? Say you had no pillow. I think I might put my shirt or a coat there. I might take some leaves or grass. I might even put my arm there. The last option is a rock. So why is that Yaakov Avinu’s choice?

My next question is: Why is this vision of the ladder so critical to Yaakov at this point in his life? And my third and final question is about a very, very, very famous midrash (rabbinic interpretation) on this story. The midrash says that Yaakov Avinu now put down his head to sleep. The past 14 years before that, he had not gone to sleep. For 14 years, Yaakov Avinu studied in the yeshiva of Shem v’Ever after he left his father’s house. He didn’t just leave last week; he actually left 14 years ago. He went to study, and he never went to sleep while he was studying. That doesn’t mean he never closed his eyes, but it means he never went and lay down in a bed to go to sleep for 14 years. This is the first time he’s actually going to sleep. Why is this a critical story? Why is this a critical midrash and a critical message right here at this point in his life?

First, I’d like to explain the ladder. I think the ladder has a very important message. The pasuk (verse) says that the angels were olim veyordim bo (The angels were going up and down in it). One commentary says that you have to look at those words a little better. The words of the pasuk are telling you: How do you make angels rise? How do you make yourself—how do you make things grow around you? How do you make kedushah (holiness) happen when you realize that it’s dependent on you?

It’s bo. It’s in it. It’s in me. It’s not in him. It’s not in her. It’s not in them. I’m not waiting for other people on my block to be like me. I’m not waiting for other people in the community to be like me. I’m not waiting for rabbis to turn this community around. No, no, that’s not what I’m waiting for. I have to understand that the malachim olim veyordim in me (Angels ascending and descending in me). They rise and they fall, and it’s dependent on who I am.

I’ll give you my example of where I understood it and realized it. What really motivated me to give this class was that someone called me on Friday morning. She said, “Rabbi, do you realize how many Halloween parties there were last night? Maybe a dozen,” she says. Then she said, “Rabbi, do you realize how many people wear costumes on Halloween and trick-or-treat?” I said, “Nah.” She said, “Yeah.” Then she started forwarding me pictures of couples with their children, and so on, dressed up and ready to trick-or-treat on Halloween, that people had posted on Instagram.

Do you know who I blame for those pictures? I blame me. I blame me. I’ll tell you why. Because if it were clear from our community and every one of us that that was a bad thing to do, they would not post those pictures. They post those pictures because they believe that, basically, among all of us it’s somewhat acceptable. It’s not that big a deal.

Have you ever seen a picture of someone on Instagram eating pork? Raise your hand if you’ve ever seen it. You know why you never saw it? Because they know that’s absolutely unacceptable. So no one would show it to you. Raise your hand if you saw someone eating a burger on Kippur. You know why you never saw it? Because they know you absolutely wouldn’t accept it.

But those pictures—they know they’ll get 93 likes. They did. Or 120 likes. 120 likes for a cat woman or someone half-dressed or half-not-dressed. Someone used a hashtag. This one I didn’t like so much: “A little partying never killed nobody.” Have you ever heard that before? It’s a song? I didn’t learn it in school. You know what? A little partying did kill somebody. It’s killing your family. That’s what it’s doing.

And the fact that there were dozens and dozens of pictures like that, of people who consider themselves basically normal community members at parties, dressed up—it’s Halloween. You’re Jewish. What are you doing? Am I going to see pictures in a month from now of people with red socks in their house? I didn’t mean that as a joke. Am I going to? I really hope not.

But I don’t get it. We’re Jewish people. Halloween is… Does anyone know what Halloween is? I’m not quite sure. But it’s not like Thanksgiving, which is, you know, thanking and… No, no, no. It’s spirits, ghosts, goblins, whatever that is. It’s not Jewish at all. So why do we all accept it and think it’s not that big a deal to see a picture of it? Why do dozens and dozens of people actually like it?

I don’t know if I should mention this, but... This is not the biggest deal. What I’m going to... I mean, maybe it is. Someone today was texting me. You know how sometimes you’re texting someone and then you want to text somebody else, but you accidentally keep texting the first person? That’s okay. Sometimes it’s not the biggest deal when it’s one friend or another friend. It’s sometimes a little bit of a big deal if the wrong person happens to be a rabbi.

Apparently it was some, I don’t know, trip or something like that the guy was talking about. He was talking about a price of something, and he just put initials. This is a good guy. I shouldn’t say this, but I have to. Something like, “What? Two thousand dollars? WT…” I don’t have to do the last letter. You got the letters? Let someone teach you what this is. I don’t have to tell you everything. So I sent it back. I said, “Was that text meant for me?” The guy sent back, “LOL.” No, not so LOL. Then he tells you, “Oh, Rabbi, oh, Rabbi. It stands for Wednesday, Thursday, Friday.”

I’m just saying that you wouldn’t send something, post something, or publicize something unless you thought the public would accept it or be okay with it. The fact that people are willing to post things on Instagram or Facebook, and post pictures like that, means that we don’t think it’s so bad. So our job is to be one of those angels climbing that ladder. Our job is to be oleh. Our job is to make sure that we are part of that group that’s growing.

Our job is not to sit and talk about the person down the block, or the person who lives here, or the person who lives there. No. Our job is to talk about ourselves.

I’m going to tell you basically this: The only way to be in the middle is to understand that you need to be climbing. Because if you’re not climbing, you’re sinking. It’s as simple as that. The world is so different than it was that if you’re not climbing, you are sinking.

So we need to give you the plan for how to be a climber. I’m not going to tell you how fast to climb. I’m not going to tell you where you’re trying to reach, because that’s up to you. I understand you’re in the middle and you want to be in the middle 20 years from now. I’m not fighting that. But I am saying that you still have to be climbing on that ladder. And here’s how you do it.

When Yaakov wakes up in the morning, he makes a comment: “I realize that this is a holy place. This is not… It’s only the house of God. The place I’m on is a very holy place. This is not anything else but the house of God.” Now, I don’t know if you’re following my wording. That wording to me is pretty strange or unique. I would just say, “I wake up in the morning and realize this is the house of God.” But that’s not what he’s saying. “This is not… It’s only the house…” What is “this is not”? “It’s only.” In those words is a very important message.

Yaakov Avinu, I just told you, studied for 14 years. He stayed in yeshiva for 14 years. I would say that if you’ve done that for 14 years, you are right now a pretty holy, good person. And he comes out and lays his head down on that stone. Remember, he had never spoken to God to this point. He had never had prophecy to this point. This is the first time that he is seeing a direct vision from Hashem.

And he says to himself, “What I’ve been till now is nothing compared to where I am right now.” And zeh, what’s happened the past 14 years is nothing until I got here, where this is really a holy place. What Yaakov Avinu was commenting and saying is, “I can’t believe that after I’m this holy, I still found a place that was holier than me and that was actually uncomfortable for me, that I didn’t exactly know what to do. I’m not used to this.” And zeh, I never saw this before. I never experienced this before. I’m not sure how to handle this. But that’s the way you climb.

The way you climb is if you’re willing to be ready to be in a place that’s even holier than you. Be willing to be uncomfortable. Be willing to be in an environment that is a little religious and maybe even a little more religious, and say, “You know what? I can grow here. I can be happy here,” even though every now and then I feel a little unsure.

If what I’m saying right now sounds vague, I’ll make it very un-vague. I’m going to try to say this right, but I’m going to say it. Over the past 10 or 15 years, many people have started to move out of Brooklyn to the city. Now some of you are going to say, “Oh, here it goes. He’s going to knock the city.” No, that’s not what I’m going to do. I’m going to say it depends why you’re going.

There are some people who are going because, you know what, they got married and they want to be sort of close to the business and maybe have a little independence. There’s a shul (synagogue) there, and there’s some growth there, and there’s Torah and classes. “You know what? I’ll live there for a few years, and then I’ll come back and be very much a part of the community and the growth of the community.” That, I’m not going to say I’m psyched about, but that’s not the biggest deal.

But there are other people who are moving there simply because Brooklyn is too religious. Apparently, I don’t know if you knew, we live in Borough Park. Apparently, for some people, they get very uneasy seeing so many classes, so much growth, or so many rabbis. They’re not frightened of, like, a goblin or a ghost on Thursday night, but they are frightened of a rabbi with a beard on a Friday night. And somehow they can’t—am I speaking Chinese, or am I speaking English? Perfect English? You know this.

I’m telling you that if that’s your mindset, you’re in big trouble. Because if your mindset is to run away from here, don’t think you’re going to run somewhere and be in the middle. No, the message you’re making is very clear: “I’m not interested.” And that’s the message you’re saying, the message your husband is saying, and the message your kids are receiving. “We are a family that’s uninterested. We can’t handle seeing somebody on Shabbat really being in a Shabbat mode. We want to walk in Central Park with our cell phone out. That makes us comfortable.” If that’s where you’re comfortable, then you’re on the ladder and you are flying down. I’m sorry.

Again, it’s not about the city. It’s about the mindset of some of the people who are going. If your mindset is to go for a healthy reason, and even if you plan on staying there for a while, again, I’m not psyched, but if your plan is to stay there for a while and really grow, and you have some real purpose for why you want to be there, I’ll deal with that. But if your purpose is that you’re uncomfortable in Brooklyn and uncomfortable around classes, Torah, and observance, and you need less of that, then I’m telling you you’re in big danger. Yes, I didn’t give this class in the city, if you’re wondering.

You know, I want to explain this a little further. Some people I commented to over Shabbat, “Oh, you know, how many people trick-or-treat?” I got a comment back from a number of people: “Rabbi, let’s be honest. Forty years ago, nobody did it, or everybody did?” Nobody? See, you’re a very religious family. That’s not fair. What? Maybe. What’s the consensus here? This way I can say I took a vote from a room full of people. Forty years ago, did we do it or did we not do it? Yes.

Here’s my thought on that, and here’s my response. First of all, just because we did it forty years ago doesn’t mean it’s now minhag Halab (Aleppo custom). That’s A. And B, forty years ago, when they did it, there was a group of our ancestors—and yes, I believe that probably my grandparents or whatever parents, probably some of them did it. That’s the hint I’m getting. I’m not saying people admit it. Yeah, Joe, I’m just coming to tell you. But that’s the impression I get.

We did it because our parents and grandparents came to this country somewhat unaware of what was happening, basically trying to say, “I want to adapt to a new country.” They really had no yeshivot at that time. Their religious knowledge and education in Torah was very limited. When you come to a foreign country, you’re trying to adapt. Everything is foreign to you. You’re not sure which things to do and which things not to do.

That excuse has been gone for thirty years. We know we’re educated. We’re raised in America, and we know the difference between something that’s an American custom that’s no big deal and an American custom that’s absolutely not for us. We can’t say, “Oh, I didn’t understand it so well.” We have to be willing to be a little more uncomfortable. Be willing to be in an environment that is a little more religious than you. Go to a shul that feels a little more or a little heavy sometimes. It’s not going to kill you. It’ll put you on that ladder, even if your goal is not to fly to the top.

But here’s the key. You have to be willing to have religion in your life, even in a way that maybe you’re not so used to, or even in a way that maybe you’re not so comfortable, or even in a way that’s not so easy. But you have to do it while you’re happy about it. And this is a very important key.

Years ago, many families came from Europe to the United States of America in the early 1900s. There were many, many, many men. In the 1900s, you had to work on Saturday: 1910, 20, 30. Many men would go to work and, by Saturday, lose their job and have to look for another job that was hard to find. Then they’d look again the next week and the next week. Of those people, many of their children remained religious to this day. And of those people, many of their children have absolutely nothing to do with religion today, and their grandchildren are married to non-Jews.

What’s the difference between group A, whose children sort of made it religiously, and group B, whose children didn’t? Both grandparents didn’t work on Shabbat. Both grandparents decided they would lose their job rather than work on Shabbat. What made one group’s children survive and thrive, and the other group’s children totally fall apart?

They asked this question to Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, who was basically the Gadol Hador (greatest of the generation) around that era. He said it basically depended on this. Yes, both groups didn’t work on Shabbat. But the first group came home on a Friday afternoon and said, “We are Shomer Shabbat (Sabbath-observant). We have this beautiful, wonderful, unbelievable Shabbat. I don’t have a job. If I’m losing my job, it’s totally worth it for this gift.”

The second group said a line in Yiddish: “I just lost my job. Es iz shver tzu zein a Yid in America (That means it’s just hard to be Jewish in America today).” And that line has nothing to do with what you did. That line in itself basically told everybody around you, “This is tough. I can’t handle this.”

If we’re going to be willing to add things to our life and grow in our life, and sometimes add things that we’re a little uncomfortable with, we can’t do it like, “Oh, this is so hard, but this is what Hashem wants.” No. It’s got to be, “You know what? In a few weeks or a few months, we’re going to see how worth it and awesome this is for our life.”

What we’d like to do at this point is mention a point that I’ve mentioned dozens of times in classes. We want to continue up that ladder. It means we’re willing to be uncomfortable. We’re willing to know, and we’re going to portray an image of total happiness about it. I now want to convince you why you should be so happy, why it’s so awesome to have Torah in our life even if you’re not looking to fly to the top.

Again, Yaakov Avinu went to the yeshiva for 14 years. Why do I care, and why now? I believe the reason it’s now is that Yaakov Avinu knew he was about to build a family. He’s going to go to the house of Lavan.

Yaakov Avinu realized that he was now about to build a family. He was about to not just be in his father’s protected home. He was about to have children. And he understood that in order to have those children, in order to build that family, he needed to be prepared. So Yaakov Avinu said, before I get married—and by the way, just as a side note, he’s in his 60s at this point—before I get married, I’m going to spend 14 years studying Torah so that I am prepared.

Why in the world does Torah prepare him for the family he’s going to build? I’d like to explain it like this. It’s sort of strange how the rabbis tell us that he learned for 14 years. They don’t just say he learned for 14 years. They say this was the first time he slept. He hadn’t slept for 14 years. Why are you telling it to me in such a roundabout way?

So I’m going to answer the question. I hope I’m clear. Someone forwarded me an email the other day. They said, “I want to just sort of show you the world we’re in right now and how new it sort of is. How is the alphabet taught to kids nowadays? And I don’t think this is real, but you’ll get the idea. How would you teach the ABCs if you wanted to teach them to a four-year-old today in 2013? You teach it like this: A is for Apple. B is for Bluetooth. C is for chat. D is for download. E is for email. F is for Facebook. G is for phone. J is for Java. Laptop. M is for Messenger. We’ll go to the end. T is for Twitter. U is for USB. V is for Vista. W is for Wi-Fi. X is for XP. Y is for YouTube. And Z is for Zorpia? What is that? No idea.”

The point is, you could fill the entire alphabet with words from the world that you use to prepare children for this world. Don’t tell me we’ll teach them more. We’ll give them more technology. We’ll be up with the times. Because you know why? This is what the world looks like today. In 20 years, there’s going to be a whole new ABC.

I’ll tell you the only way you could possibly prepare them to be what you want them to be: give them Torah. If they have Torah in their life, and they have the structure and the values of Torah, the messages of Torah, they’ll be able to handle it. And no, it’s not as simple as that. Just teach them a Gemara and everything’s fine? Of course there’s more to it than that. But if they have the foundation of Torah, everything else you want to teach them is much, much easier. Any message you want to give is so much easier if they have the framework of this book. As things adjust, they’ll be more prepared if they have Torah in their life.

We’re not just doing this because God wants us to. We’re doing this because this is going to make us what we need to be and what we want to be. We’re happy doing this because Shabbat is a gift. And I think this is why the Torah tells it to us now.

Yaakov Avinu is now going to sleep. What’s he sleeping on? A rock. How in the world? The rock represents what Yaakov Avinu’s life is going to be for the next few decades: hard, not easy. And the Torah tells us, “Don’t worry about it.” Because now he’s putting his head down on the rock. For 14 years he prepared himself for this moment, so he can handle it fine. The Torah tells us in a roundabout way because it’s explaining that this is preparing him. Those 14 years made him ready for right now.

I read a statistic, which I mentioned in a class 6 months ago, that the average person by the age of 35 has gone through 14 jobs. 14 jobs. You know what that means, to go through 14 jobs? It means you’re up, you’re down, you’re happy, you’re sad, you’re frustrated, you’re nervous, you have to deal with different people, and there are uneasy people in your life. So many things come at you that the only way to be prepared for them is through the values and morals that Torah gives you.

Yes, Yaakov is going to go to a father-in-law who’s crazy, children who have issues, a daughter who’s going to have problems, and wives with issues. He’s going to deal with 100 issues in his life, and he’s going to prepare himself for 14 years. We’re not doing Torah and growing in Torah for him. I’ve said this a hundred times. We’re growing in Torah for us.

That message needs to permeate your home. It needs to be very clear: “We are a growing home. We’re willing to be uneasy. We’re willing to do things that we’re not used to yet. We’re willing to even do some things that our parents and grandparents didn’t do. They sacrificed, they’re happy about it because we understand how much and how critical it is to our life.”

If that’s the mindset and you’re in the middle, you’ll be very healthy. If that’s the mindset, then we’re ready. We’re on this ladder and we are climbing. We may be slow. We may not be moving that fast. We may not be changing a hundred things. We may simply be sitting together at the Friday night table, and we haven’t changed anything. We’re moving.

We may simply still eat in a non-kosher restaurant but have one less item on the menu. I’m trying to show you how small it could be, but it means we’re willing to be a little uncomfortable because we know what Torah does for us and we know how it’s going to change us.

So this Yaakov Avinu story was not just about a man who randomly took a nap, put his head on a very hard place, and saw a vision of a ladder that told him, “Yaakov, the rise and fall of your family is dependent on you.” Every one of your descendants can climb that ladder if you have the strength and if you’re willing to do what it takes to build them, and he did, and they did.

I’ll end with one little story. It’s a story about a man who climbed a little higher than some people want, or maybe their son climbed a little higher than some people desire. But I will guarantee you this: everybody would love it if their child looked like this.

There was this boy, I believe he was raised in Denver. In Denver 50-some-odd years ago, there were no yeshivot, no day school, nothing, but there was a boy. He was 11, 12 years old. One of the rabbis in the Talmud Torah (Torah school) inspired him enough that the boy spoke at the Friday night table for his parents. His parents were so impressed, and his father said, “Wow, maybe one day you’ll go off to yeshiva.”

Within a year, the boy decided he wanted to go, and he found the yeshiva in Chicago where he was going to study. You can imagine how the parents felt. He was 13 years old and going somewhere far to study. The parents were at the airport, crying with their son, and the father said to the young boy, “I have one request. Can you do me a favor? Can you write me a letter every day?” “Okay, Dad.”

Years later, the father passed away. This boy was sitting shiva (mourning period), went back to Denver to sit shiva, and was reminiscing about that day and that moment, when his parents came to him. He was telling the story about the airport. Someone sitting in front of him said, “Naturally, you did that for a couple of days and then you didn’t do it every day.” He said, “I did it every day for 43 years.” He said, “In fact, here’s the note I was going to send my father the day he passed away.”

The man became basically the leader of a yeshiva somewhere here in New Jersey. He said, “If you’re going to go up, you’re going to be on that ladder, and if you’re on that ladder and you’re going up, you’re safe.”