A Yissachar / Zebulun Partnership in Loving Memory of Yishak ben Simcha A"H & Felicia bat Miriam A"H
Rabbi Joey Haber

Torah Lecture

How I Survived The Holidays With My Family

Lectured by Rabbi Joey Haber

Published
October 31, 2011
Duration
37:31
Lecture code
JH331

Holiday Strain and the “One Comment”

  • Rabbi Joey Haber opens by noting that holidays can be beautiful and still bring challenges. The strain is not only the expense, preparation, and work; spending repeated three-day holidays with the same people can also be difficult.
  • A particular discussion, remark, or person can leave a lasting sting. Haber says he often receives calls about family tensions after the holidays, involving spouses, parents, siblings, and in-laws.
  • He is not offering advice such as staying quiet, ignoring the comment, or learning how to respond confidently. His aim is to explore how to become someone who can hear a hurtful remark without being deeply fazed by it.
  • He compares a painfully well-placed comment to the fatal shot that found a tiny opening in a soldier’s bulletproof vehicle and vest. A remark about a family always being late, a child being noisy, other children showing off, or a mother-in-law praising a sister-in-law’s cake can land in just the wrong place.

The Flood, the Tower, and God’s Promise

  • Rabbi Joey Haber turns to Bereshit and Parashat Noach. The Mabul (flood) destroyed the world; later in the parasha, a group builds a tower in an apparent challenge to Hashem. Hashem gives them different languages, and they disperse because they can no longer communicate.
  • He asks why the sin that led to the Mabul brought such a severe punishment, while the tower builders’ sin did not seem to bring a punishment on the same scale.
  • After the flood, Noach and his family leave the teivah (ark) and enter an empty world. Noach plants a vine, grows grapes, and brings a sacrifice. The Pasuk says Hashem smells the sacrifice and says He will no longer curse humanity and the ground because of humanity, “because man is bad from when they’re born.”
  • Haber asks why humanity’s inclination to do wrong should be a reason not to punish it. He also notes Hashem’s promise not to harm all living beings again in a mass punishment like the Mabul.
  • The Pesukim also say that seasons will continue and that “day and night will not rest.” Haber asks why seasons begin at this point and what it means for day and night not to rest. He treats these statements as marking a fundamental change in the world.

Two Worlds: Before and After the Mabul

  • To illustrate how people can misread what they see, Haber tells a story about his children using binoculars from their attic to watch a television in an apartment across the street on Shabbat. When a woman entered the room and shut off the television, the children thought she had noticed them. In fact, she was confronting her own child for staying up late; the television later went back on.
  • His point is that what appears to be happening may actually be something else. He says the Mabul and its aftermath are often misunderstood as simply the destruction of the old world followed by a fresh start.
  • Instead, he describes the world before and after the Mabul as radically different—almost as great a change as Adam’s being removed from Gan Eden into the ordinary world.
  • Before the flood, people lived 800 or 900 years, the weather did not change, and life was, as the rabbis describe it, practically miraculous. Planting seeds could provide food for 40 years.
  • In such a world, Haber argues, someone who sinned at about age 400 could feel there was little reason to worry about consequences, with another 400 years of life still ahead. He compares a 900-year life to being born in the year 1100: a span so long that people might feel free to do whatever they wanted.
  • Haber says Hashem changed how the world worked because that way of life was not working. After the teivah, people had much shorter lives, seasons brought changing conditions and the need to prepare, and work became substantially more demanding. Though there had been some work before, the kind of sustained work familiar today began after the flood.
  • In this changed world, life involves ongoing work and challenges: people must keep facing difficulties, meeting them, and trying to succeed.

The “20-Mile March”

  • Haber introduces an idea from an excerpt of a forthcoming book about businesses that succeeded during turbulent times. The book examined seven companies that performed ten times better than others in their industries.
  • He traces the idea to two groups who set out in 1911 to travel 1,400 miles to the South Pole. They left at the same time, had roughly the same number of good- and bad-weather days, and had no phone, radio, helicopter, or walkie-talkie.
  • One group completed the journey and returned; the other arrived late and all its members died on the return. Haber first says the second group reached the destination 35 days late, then says it got there 34 days later.
  • The key difference, he explains, was the first group’s fixed system: travel 20 miles every day, regardless of weather, mood, or how much farther they could manage.
  • The second group’s effort fluctuated. It covered 40 miles on an exciting first day, rested when it was hot because it was ahead, then varied its daily distances and stopped for several days in freezing weather. Haber says the irregular pace contributed to its failure to get back safely.
  • The lesson is to keep a steady pace in difficult times rather than overexerting when conditions are good and stopping when they are bad.
  • Haber applies the idea to businesses including Intel, Microsoft, and Southwest Airlines. He says Southwest kept to its annual goal even when it could have exceeded it, and did not use difficult years as an excuse to fall short. It pursued the same goal and profits year after year rather than swinging between doing far more and doing less.
  • He applies the same principle to exercise: people may start with long walks, increase the distance, skip a rainy day, and then give up. Successful exercisers, in his view, keep showing up consistently.
  • He gives the example of people he sees on his early-morning route to Shacharit (morning prayer). He sometimes feels proud to be out while it is still dark, then turns a corner and finds the place crowded with people who exercise regularly.
  • Haber connects the principle to the Pasuk in Parashat Noach, “Yom vaLayla lo yishbotu” (“Day and night will not rest”). The same steady persistence, he says, matters in journeys, business, and life.

Consistency as a Way to Withstand Criticism

  • Haber says that a person should have steady goals for raising children, behaving in marriage, and meeting what Hashem expects in religious life, and should work toward those goals every day.
  • A person who knows what their life is about and keeps to that course can be secure and confident. A small comment may not land as deeply because the person knows where they are going and continues their “20-mile march.”
  • This does not mean that insults will never hurt. Haber says the hurt should not last or define the person. The most meaningful insults are often those that feel true—for example, that one’s children are not being raised well, one is unprepared, the family is always late, or one is lazy.
  • If someone is consistent and understands why they are raising their children or living as they do, another person’s failure to understand a particular choice need not shake them. The response is to keep marching.
  • Haber acknowledges that the period after the holidays can feel gloomy: the excitement of summer, Rosh Hashanah, and both parts of Sukkot has passed, the weather is turning cold, and routine resumes. He says successful people are formed not only during holidays, but on ordinary Tuesdays in October or November, through daily consistency.
  • That steadiness, he says, helps a person face a comment at a meal from an in-law, sibling, parent, or spouse without losing sight of what their life is about.

God’s Hiddenness After the Flood

  • Citing Emet L'Yaakov, Haber says that before the flood, Hashem’s presence was much more apparent: the world was picture-perfect, giants lived in it, the Pasuk refers to people who came from heaven (Haber says he does not know exactly what this means), and Hashem communicated with people who were not even prophets.
  • After the flood, with seasons and the natural order in place, Hashem became hidden. The world appeared to operate on its own, and there was no guarantee that an observer would see God’s presence unmistakably.
  • Haber says Hashem made the world this way intentionally. People are born with the excuse that they do not clearly see God; they must search for Him.
  • This makes it harder to keep marching consistently, but Haber’s counsel remains to continue through every kind of condition—hot, cold, or difficult—rather than stopping or getting distracted.

Why the Two Generations’ Sins Differed

  • Haber returns to the question of the Mabul and the tower. Before the flood, people could see Hashem’s presence but disregarded it. He describes them as living as if life were a party with no consequences, committing sins including stealing people, wives, and animals, despite living in a world where God was plainly present.
  • He says their sin was especially grave because they acted this way in the face of God.
  • The tower generation sinned in a different world. Hashem was no longer so evident, and people were uncertain about His presence and actions. Their challenge was one of belief: they sought to find and challenge God without the clarity earlier generations had.
  • Haber explains Hashem’s statement that humanity is “ra mine'urav” (“bad from when they’re born”) as meaning that people in the changed world were somewhat excused because they were born without clearly seeing that God was there. The challenge of belief was harder, but it was not the same as knowingly disregarding God in the earlier world.
  • He interprets “Tzadik tamim haya bedorotav” about Noach as describing the qualities that let him withstand both kinds of challenges: he was a Tzadik who could resist people’s desires, and a complete believer who could remain faithful amid uncertainty.
  • Noach exemplified the “20-mile march”: he persisted in the same direction regardless of what the surrounding generation did or how long building the teivah took. According to the rabbis, he was insulted, abused, and mocked for the 100 years he spent building it, yet kept going.
  • Haber’s answer to the original question is that the two generations faced different challenges in different worlds. The pre-flood generation knowingly pursued its desires despite seeing Hashem; the tower generation struggled with belief when Hashem was hidden. The latter was less culpable, in Haber’s explanation, because people were born into a world where God was less evident.
  • The way to succeed in either world is the same: be like Noach, remain steady, and keep building and marching through ordinary days as well as dramatic ones.

Family Members’ Comments and the Steve Jobs Anecdote

  • Haber stresses that even close relatives may not know what is truly happening in someone’s life. They may not understand how someone is raising their children or directing their life; the person themselves knows their aims and direction.
  • He illustrates how casually people can speak without understanding their own words with a story about Steve Jobs, whom he describes as Apple’s founder and CEO and the creator of products including the iPod, iPhone, MacBook, iPad, and iPad 2. Haber says Jobs had changed several industries and had recently died in his 50s; a biography about him was about to be released.
  • Jobs had been given up for adoption at birth because his unmarried parents placed him for adoption. Later, after becoming Steve Jobs, he searched for his mother and found her. She told him he had a sister, a well-known creative writer, and the siblings developed a good relationship.
  • The siblings researched their father, a Syrian-American man who was not Jewish. Jobs disliked what he learned and chose not to meet him, while his sister still wanted to meet their father. Jobs asked her not to tell their father that she knew or had met Jobs.
  • When the sister found their father, who owned a small restaurant, he told her she had a brother but dismissed him as someone who would never amount to anything. In the same conversation, he recalled owning a large restaurant in Silicon Valley that Steve Jobs used to visit, without realizing he was speaking about his own son.
  • Haber compares this to contradictory family remarks: someone may praise one daughter-in-law’s cake and later praise another for arriving without bringing anything. People may speak without understanding what they are saying.
  • His practical conclusion is to know what one is doing, not be governed by others’ comments, and continue the daily work of one’s life as ordinary days become monotonous.
Words in this lecture2
Bereshitבראשית
1.Books The first book of the Torah, also called Genesis. English: Genesis
2.Terms The opening weekly portion of the Torah.
3. Hebrew for 'in the beginning', the first word of the Torah, as in Bereshit bara Elokim.
Also written: Bereishit, Bereishis, b'reshit, B'reishit, Bereshith, B'reishith, Breshit
Pasukפסוק
Terms Pasuk, a verse. English: Biblical verse
Also written: Passuk, posuk, psuq
Plural: Pesukim, psukim, p'sukim, psuqim, Pesukei, psukeem